Education As Politics

You might want to take a look at Isabel Sawhill’s spirited defense of pre-kindergarten public education at RealClearMarkets. Here’s her peroration:

In the end, you can’t make public policy with RCTs [ed. randomized controlled trials] alone. We need to incorporate lessons from neuroscience about the critical changes to the brain that occur in early childhood and the insights of specialists in child development. We need to consider what happens to non-cognitive skills over the longer term. We need to worry about the plight of working mothers, especially single parents, who cannot work without some form of out-of-home care. Providing that care on the cheap may turn out to be penny wise and pound foolish. (A universal child care program in Quebec funded at $5 a day led to worse behavior among the kids in the program.) Of course we need to continuously improve the effectiveness of pre-k through ongoing evaluation. That means weeding out ineffective programs along with improving curriculum, teacher preparation and pay, and better follow-up in the early grades. Good quality pre-k works; bad-quality does not. For the most disadvantaged children, it may require intervening much earlier than age 3 or 4 as the Abecedarian program did — with strikingly good results.

Presumably, we should all agree that effective pre-kindergarten public education is worth funding and supporting but ineffective pre-K isn’t. We live in a world of limited resources. As long as that’s the case we should prioritize what’s effective.

In the case of pre-k there isn’t consensus about what “effective” means. The neurological, social, and psychological development of children has been a subject of intense study for nearly a century. If there’s one guiding star in that study it is that developmentally appropriate education can be effective but programs that are not developmentally appropriate are merely wastes of money.

The structure of public education isn’t determined by educators or scholars. It’s determined by politicians and that frequently means “give the lady what she wants”. Sadly, parents frequently focus inappropriate attention on cognitive skills without taking into account what is known about child development and the vital significance of non-cognitive skills in later success and politicians being what they are go along with the game.

If educators are to have the evidence they need to make their case, more rigorous attention to what is and is not effective is crucial.

3 comments

Why Ukraine But Not Estonia?

As I read George Friedman’s article on the strategic importance of Romania, it occurred to me that there is quite a bit of confusion among Americans about Russia’s objectives, even among extremely well-informed Americans.

I think that Putin’s Russia should be understood as having a hierarchy of values. In rough form these values are:

  1. Russian
  2. Slavic
  3. Orthodox
  4. Traditionally part of Russia

Using that as a gauge it’s pretty easy to discern why the Russians are less concerned about Estonia becoming part of NATO than they are about Ukraine.

Estonia, obviously, is not Russia or Russian. The Estonians are not Slavs. The majority are not Orthodox—most are Lutherans, at least nominally.

Estonia is not traditionally part of Russia or even a possession of Russia’s. It was ceded to Russia by Sweden in the middle of the 18th century and remained part of the Russian Empire until the Estonian War of Independence in 1918. It was re-occupied by the Russians during World War II. The Russians don’t consider Estonian lands to be part of Russia.

Contrast that with Ukraine. Ukraine has been part of Russia for a millennium. Kiev is the foundation of Russia, at least notionally. The Ukrainians are Slavs and they were Orthodox (most are non-religious now). When you couple that with the strategic issues (the port at Sevastopol), Russia’s need to keep Ukraine within the fold becomes clear.

Let’s use that model to evaluate Russian intentions with respect to Romania. Romania is not Russian and has never been Russian. The Romanians aren’t Slavs. They are Orthodox. Nowadays Romania doesn’t have a great deal of strategic significance.

The long and the short of it is that the Romanians probably don’t have a great deal to worry about from the Russians.

6 comments

Why Brits?

I’m not sure what brought this to mind. Maybe it’s the torrent of advertisements for The Huntsman: Winter’s War we’ve been deluged with lately.

Have you noticed how many of the lead characters in American movies and television are Brits, Canadians, Aussies, etc.? I think it’s about half. Take the movie above for example. Of the principal cast Charlize Theron is South African, Emily Blunt is a Brit, Chris Hemsworth is an Aussie, and the only American is Jessica Chastain.

It’s not just costume dramas, either. Comedy is about the only area where you’ll find mostly American casts.

I’ve been thinking about why that might be. Here’s what I’ve come up with:

  1. Casting directors’ standard of beauty leans towards Brits, Canadians, etc.
  2. American casting directors find their accents charming.
  3. American actors and actresses tend towards the method which makes them hard to work with.
  4. Americans are too fat.
  5. There are more venues for honing an actor’s craft in English-speaking countries other than the U. S.
  6. Brits, Canadians, etc. improve the prospects for distribution in English-speaking countries.
  7. They’re cheaper.

It isn’t a new phenomenon. Mary Pickford was Canadian for goodness sake.

8 comments

With Bankers Like These

I have to admit that this post at Bloomberg from former Federal Reserve governor Narayana Kocherlakota made me sad. For example:

What level of government debt can the U.S. sustain? The answer is that it can handle a lot more. What’s much more important is its longer-term ability to reduce the federal budget deficit — and eventually run a surplus.

How can any responsible Fed governor write approvingly about running a surplus? Is the objective to destroy the private economy?

This:

For a government’s debt to be sustainable in the long run, it must grow no faster than total economic output (as measured by, say, gross domestic product). So if the interest rate on government debt is 5 percent per year, and GDP grows at 4 percent per year, the government must run a surplus large enough to cover 1 percentage point of its interest cost if it wants to keep its ratio of debt to GDP stable. (Both my interest rate and growth rate figures are nominal — that is, I’m not netting inflation out of either.)

is closer to the mark.

But with this:

None of this suggests that the U.S. government doesn’t have a budget problem. But the issue is the deficit, not the debt.

it’s a return to the depressing. The issue is neither the deficit nor the debt but how they relate to economic growth.

0 comments

The Debt

In a pre-Tax Day jeremiad at Time, James Grant whined about the size of the national debt. A lot of the attention has been focused on the misleading graphic on the righthand side of the article, boldly proclaiming that each and every American owes about $43,000 in debt.

More important is this outline:

The Federal Reserve is the government’s Monopoly-money machine. It sets some interest rates and influences many others. It materializes dollars. It regulates–now regiments–the nation’s banks. It pulls levers to make the stock market go up.

Congress is the source of the Fed’s power. The Constitution is the source of Congress’s power. The parchment enjoins Congress to coin money and regulate the value thereof. The founders viewed money as a scale or yardstick, something that measures value. The Fed views money as a magic wand, something that creates value.

Dollars aren’t so much minted these days. Rather, they issue from the Fed’s computers in billowing digital clouds. The cost of producing them is only the energy expended on tapping the keys. The Fed emits these electronic greenbacks to attempt to control the course of economic events. It’s a heaven-sent monetary system for a big-spending government.

We can keep that up as long as the demand for dollars holds. As of this writing that’s holding and will continue to do so as long as China, Japan, South Korea, etc. continue to hold massive electronic accounts full of dollars—their strategy for maintaining permanent trade surpluses with us.

Whether we should be sacrificing the real economy—the part of the economy that makes things you can actually touch—to the financial economy is another question entirely.

0 comments

Keep Your Enemies Closer

The hottest article of today is probably Paul Sperry’s New York Post article outlining Saudi involvement with the attacks on 9/11:

In its report on the still-censored “28 pages” implicating the Saudi government in 9/11, “60 Minutes” last weekend said the Saudi role in the attacks has been “soft-pedaled” to protect America’s delicate alliance with the oil-rich kingdom.

That’s quite an understatement.

Actually, the kingdom’s involvement was deliberately covered up at the highest levels of our government. And the coverup goes beyond locking up 28 pages of the Saudi report in a vault in the US Capitol basement. Investigations were throttled. Co-conspirators were let off the hook.

Read it and gnash your teeth. I suspect it’s a surprise to almost no one.

I think there are two factors that underpin our government’s stance. The first is a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of aristocracies. In an aristocracy the aristocrats are the government. There is no wall of separation or daylight between the two. Under the Westphalian order when a state is an aristocracy and one or more of the aristocrats engages in what is obviously an act of war against another state, it’s an act of war, not ordinary street crime. Basically, we’ve been at war with Saudi Arabia for some time, we just have refused to acknowledge it.

The second is even more troubling. Okay. So the Saudis participated in act of war against the United States. So what? That is to say, what recourse do we have? We could go to war against Saudi Arabia, running the risk that, since the Sauds are the custodians of the Muslim holy sites, it could foment a war of all Muslims against the United States.

We could try to bring down the Saud family covertly by one means or another. To be replaced by whom or what? There is no good alternative.

My own view is that we should have been fulminating to pry the Muslim holy sites away from the Sauds long since but a) we’re just not that sort of people; and b) the process would require more guile and more time than we have. The Brits could have done it. We can’t.

What does that leave us with? Well, there’s the legal system which is what’s presently being discussed. Hypothetically, allowing the lawsuits to proceed could cause them real pain.

We’ve tried to corral their activities in the world banking system. That isn’t really sufficient.

My own view is that from 9/11 forward we should have arranged it that the only place that was safe for any member of the Saud family of any age, gender, or rank would have been their homeland. There would be just too many accidents elsewhere.

29 comments

Happy Day Before Tax Day

I don’t think that Haley Sweetland Edwards, writing at Time, really understands how the tax system works. She concentrates too much on the backend spending component:

Tax Day has a reputation for doom and gloom, but for most of us, there’s a silver lining: the promise of a little extra scratch.

Almost 77 percent of Americans will receive a tax refund this year, averaging about $2,798 per person, according to the most recent IRS statistics. Between April 2015 and April 2016, the IRS divvied out a grand total of $228.78 billion in money back.

So what’s that large cash infusion do for the overall economy? So far, the answer is unclear.

“I don’t think we really know,” said Roberton Williams, a tax expert at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center at the Urban Institute. “When you have people waiting to make this big purchase and then saying, ‘Now that I have this money I’m going to go out and buy that big TV set or that washing machine,’ that’s certainly a direct stimulus.” Consumer spending represents about 70 percent of the U.S. GDP.

But when people save that money or pour it into repaying their debts? “That’s a much less direct stimulus on the economy,” he said.

The reason that this answer is inadequate is that the money was withdrawn from the private economy via the mechanism of automatic payroll deductions (or estimated tax installment payments) to begin with. Those taxes reduce economic activity before they encourage it. The question that she’s actually addressing appears to be whether higher taxes would be good or bad for the private economy. The issue that is, unfortunately, so rarely addressed is that of deadweight loss and when you take that into account the answer is much clearer.

But even once you’ve identified the question she’s actually addressing the issue is more complicated even than she’s suggesting. There is evidence that too large a debt overhang inhibits economic growth, too. So paying off that credit card balance or paying off more of the principle on that mortgage may or may not be a bad thing. There’s no way to tell a priori.

Just to recap my views on taxes, budgets, and economic growth, I think that

  1. The federal government’s spending more than it takes in is probably benign as long as the growth in aggregate product is greater than the deficit.
  2. With the deficit running at more than 3% of the economy while the growth rate lags at below 2%, that’s not the case.
  3. If you’re going to run a deficit, use it to make investments.
  4. Consumption is not the same as investment.
  5. Borrowing to pay operating expenses is a bad idea even if you’re the federal government. It’s even worse when you’re Chicago.

We can probably keep getting away with our profligate ways as long as the dollar is the world’s reserve currency. We can’t rely on that forever so it might be a good idea to start making better habits.

Even with all of that said, you can’t ignore deadweight loss. It wasn’t stupidity or a universal longing for freedom that killed the Soviet Union or that’s causing China trouble now. It was deadweight loss. Which is just another way of saying that bad decisions made over a long enough period of time have a way of coming back to bite you in the butt.

5 comments

How Many Things?

This article in New York Magazine on using trans-cranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of autism really reminds me of one those pictures you used to see in the newspaper captioned “How Many Things Can You Find Wrong With This Picture?”

1 comment

Tertium Non Datur

This post was motivated by something in comments:

We have always been way too ready to use the military. Look at the list of US military interventions. If the neocons had been in charge, we would likely have been at war with Iran, and have troops on the ground in Libya. Syria too, or maybe just two out of three as even they might realize we can overcommit our troops.

First, I think the case that we’re too willing to use military force is difficult to make prior to about 1990. As the comment suggests, look at the list of instances of our refraining to use military force up to that time. It certainly doesn’t characterize our behavior prior to 1941. The urge to “give war a chance” is a relatively recent one and one more a product of internationalism or Wilsonianism (variously construed) than of warmongering. “Always” is not synonymous with “as long as I can remember”.

With respect to Libya, which course of action would have been most consistent with American interests?

  1. Don’t intervene.
  2. Remove Qaddafi, place enough troops in the country to maintain order.
  3. Remove Qaddafi and let the chips fall where they may.

I think it’s #1 and I think that what was actually done was an expression of moral cowardice. That’s the problem with our leaders today. Neither willing to take the political heat for not intervening if it’s not in our interest to do so nor willing to take the political heat when war proves difficult and messy.

12 comments

Orientalism, Rationalism, and Romanticism

In a paper considering how religious DAESH recruits actually are at Brookings based on captured documents, Andrew Lebovich attributes the notion that violent radicals are motivated by a desire to return to Shariah law to Orientalism. Sadly, “Orientalism” is a catch-all phrase which just means people who aren’t Muslims or, maybe, aren’t Arabs studying Islam or Arabs. When it meant a highly romanticized approach to studying Islam and Arabs, that may have had some value. When it refers to rationalism and empiricism applied to studying Islam and Arabs, it has none.

While I agree with Mr. Lebovich that DAESH recruits are more likely to be motivated by some personal notion of Islam rather than a scholarly view:

For ISIS recruits, a weak knowledge of the Shariah could mean many things. It could and does sometimes mean genuine ignorance of even basic religious precepts, but not always. People join militant movements for a variety of intersecting regions, including
belief, politics, economics, and more. Limited knowledge of an area of Islam traditionally left to dedicated experts says little about the contours of individual religious belief; if anything, it reflects our own projections onto others about modernity and education.

I don’t think that he really appreciates the contours of the situation. The reason that most imams in the United States and Europe are foreign-born and frequently Gulf Arabs is that local Muslim populations don’t have a good enough grasp of classical Arabic to do the job, given the emphasis on the Qur’an and haditha in the original language. Since so many of these imams have been funded by people encouraging Salafism and have been inculcated in very conservative views of Islam it is hardly surprising when these views inform their teaching.

Many of the practices and teachings of DAESH aren’t Qur’anic. “Islam” has been confused with “the way we do things around here”.

That practices like honor killings, female genital mutilation, and the abuse of Christians and Jews persist in the Muslim world aren’t signs of Islam’s strength but of its weakness. It’s under the same pressures as Christianity, Judaism, and Hinduism are and DAESH is one of the institutional responses to those pressures.

3 comments