The Merry Minuet

Intoleranceofsupporters
The whole world is festering with unhappy souls.
The French hate the Germans, the Germans hate the Poles.
Italians hate Yugoslavs, South Africans hate the Dutch.
And we don’t like anybody very much.

The crowning glory of the post at FiveThirtyEight on the intolerance of Trump supporters is the graph above and this summation:

The nearly unequivocal story is that Trump supporters are no different from others, including Clinton and Sanders supporters.2 The one clear exception is supporters of John Kasich (~7 percent of the sample), who are demonstrably more tolerant than Trump’s. Kasich’s supporters are distinctive because 30 percent of them in this poll are self-identified Democrats, but also because the majority of them (54 percent) will not vote for Trump if he is the nominee – just over a quarter will peel off and vote for Clinton and the other quarter claim they will not vote. Kasich support appears effectively to be a protest against Trump by people who wish a restoration of good democratic order.

The main difference among us is less whether we hate than whom we hate. As you may have noticed just about everything reminds me of a quote, frequently a quote from a movie. I wish I could remember the source of this one: finding someone to hate is just as important as finding someone to love.

11 comments

The Missing Link

There’s an image that goes through my mind frequently these days. At the end of the fabulous Powell-Pressburger movie, The Red Shoes, despite the suicide of the prima ballerina, the ballet goes on. A dancer carries the ballerina’s red shoes around the stage in her place.

The suicide rate in the U. S. has gone up. The Wall Street Journal attempts to explain the possible causes:

There are at least two possible explanations, Dr. Crosby said. One is the economic downturn: Suicide rates have risen historically during difficult economic times, when job prospects diminish. The CDC tied increases in suicides to foreclosures on homes and evictions several years ago, he said.

Secondly, abuse of prescription painkillers, heroin and other lethal drugs has risen over the past decade and a half, he said. The rate of overdose deaths from opioids, including prescription painkillers and heroin, tripled between 2000 and 2014, according to the CDC. Those deaths include suicides.

Other possible factors: Many people don’t seek or have easy access to mental-health services, including some people who have attempted suicide before, Dr. Caine said. Domestic violence, social dislocation, and chronic medical problems also sometimes play a role, he said.

Some researchers say the vexing rise in suicides among the middle-aged may be the result of a baby-boom generation known for suicides in its youth reacting in a familiar way to new troubles in its older years. “As that population has been aging and become middle-aged, there’s probably a cohort effect,” said Christine Moutier, chief medical officer of the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, which funds suicide research.

Something else reported: the increase is particularly notable among middle-aged white women. Unless you think that for some reason the explanations proffered fell particularly heavily on middle-aged white women, that sounds inadequate to me.

As with the dancer carrying the red shoes around the stage, there’s something missing.

16 comments

Prince Rogers Nelson, 1958-2016

Prince has died:

CHANHASSEN, Minn. — Prince, one of the most inventive and influential musicians of modern times with hits including “Little Red Corvette,” ”Let’s Go Crazy” and “When Doves Cry,” was found dead at his home on Thursday in suburban Minneapolis. He was 57.

His publicist, Yvette Noel-Schure, told The Associated Press that the superstar “died at his home this morning at Paisley Park.” The local sheriff said deputies found Prince unresponsive in an elevator late Thursday morning after being summoned to his home, but that first responders couldn’t revive him.

I don’t follow popular music much but, since so many people are repeating their stories about Prince in reaction to his untimely death, I may as well repeat mine.

Actually, it’s my mom’s. A number of years ago, back when people actually met air travelers at the gate, my mom flew from St. Louis to Minneapolis to visit one of my siblings. When she got off the plane she was accompanied by a slight young man. My in-law, who does follow popular music, greeted my mom excitedly: “Do you know who that was?”, referring to the individual she got off the plane with. My mom replied, “Oh, yes. That was the young man in the seat next to me on the plane. We had a lovely conversation. So considerate and polite!”

“It was Prince!” exclaimed my in-law, explaining to my mom who he was since she’d never heard of him.

I wonder what they talked about. Probably not what they had in common which might have been interesting to both of them.

2 comments

Vanguardism Rears Its Ugly Head

Shorter version of Emmett Rensin’s post at Vox.com: the Democratic Party has become elitist. The rest was inevitable. This stuff was all explained a century ago.

When the vanguard of the proletariat is distinct from the proletariat, it will inevitably become increasingly separated from the objectives of the proletariat. Darned proletariat just doesn’t know what’s good for them. Maybe that’s because it always involves being bossed around by the vanguard who get pretty busy flying from international convocation to international convocation in their private jets.

12 comments

We’re Living Beyond Our Means

You might recall Neal Gabler from when he replaced Roger Ebert on PBS’s Sneak Previews program when Siskel and Ebert left PBS. He’s a well-known writer, published in various prestigious newspapers and magazines.

Recently, Mr. Gabler garnered a certain amount of attention by confessing in an article for Atlantic that he was living hand to mouth:

Since 2013, the federal reserve board has conducted a survey to “monitor the financial and economic status of American consumers.” Most of the data in the latest survey, frankly, are less than earth-shattering: 49 percent of part-time workers would prefer to work more hours at their current wage; 29 percent of Americans expect to earn a higher income in the coming year; 43 percent of homeowners who have owned their home for at least a year believe its value has increased. But the answer to one question was astonishing. The Fed asked respondents how they would pay for a $400 emergency. The answer: 47 percent of respondents said that either they would cover the expense by borrowing or selling something, or they would not be able to come up with the $400 at all. Four hundred dollars! Who knew?

Well, I knew. I knew because I am in that 47 percent.

Megan McArdle responded at Bloomberg:

Why can so few people seem to save any money? The number of people scraping along from paycheck to paycheck is astonishing; surveys routinely find that somewhere between a third and half of all Americans don’t have the savings to fund ordinary emergencies — a moderately large repair, a month with no income. These are not the kind of astonishing runs of bad luck that no one could realistically expect to cover, like a $100,000 medical bill, or a multi-year illness that makes it impossible to work. They’re just the normal vicissitudes of regular life, and somehow, Americans are unprepared.

These are the questions that Neal Gabler tackles in an article for the Atlantic. The answer he arrives at boils down to: we need to keep up with the Joneses, only our incomes aren’t growing, or even stable in the face of inflation, and meanwhile, access to credit enables us to live, for a while, as if that last part weren’t true. The result is a recipe for disaster. Or at least, for Neal Gabler’s disaster.

Most of the responses have been sympathetic. Many have praised his bravery for stepping forward.

I’m understanding but not particularly sympathetic. As a friend of mine’s mother used to say “You lay in your bed—now make it!”

In the article he acknowledged the choices that he made which—at least from his viewpoint—inevitably led to the situation in which he found himself. Why does he live in New York? (He’s a native Chicagoan.) Why is he a writer? Why did he send his daughters to expensive private universities (Stanford and Emory)? One daughter is in medical school. Another is a clinical social worker. In both of those cases they could well have gone to a school in their state’s public university system and gotten into medical school or graduate school.

I think it’s pretty obvious that he’s hunting for status.

Maybe it takes some courage to reveal that you’ve been living a lie. You know what takes real courage? Living within your means no matter what the neighbors think.

When I was a kid my family followed some simple rules. Live below your means. Don’t pay interest if you can possibly help it. In my second job in which I had to travel a great deal, when I needed a credit card for travel I went to our banker, an old family friend. She was somewhat surprised at my request, blurting out “Your family is a non-credit type family!” A week later I had an American Express Gold Card. Things were different 40 years ago.

But I don’t think that the rules of saving are that much different.

What I think has happened in the United States is that wages haven’t kept up with expenses particularly educational expenses. That blow was cushioned somewhat by the feeling of increasing wealth that people had as their homes gained rapidly in value, especially during the Aughts. It’s not something we experienced here in Chicago but we read the newspapers here in flyover country, too. People learned to extract the unearned equity from their homes.

And they got used to living beyond their means.

In Mr. Gabler’s particular case I also wonder whether he has had the experience of being truly poor?

Meanwhile, I think that Tyler Cowen put it well: we’re not as rich as we thought we were. We need to get our heads around that and start living within our means.

20 comments

The Trump Foreign Policy

I recommend reading Rosa Brooks’s analysis of Donald Trump’s foreign policy at Foreign Policy. Here’s the meat of her analysis:

Trump’s vision of the world — and his conception of statecraft — isn’t one I much like, but it reflects a fairly coherent theory of international relations. It’s realist, transactional, and Machiavellian — and it demands a serious, thoughtful, and nondefensive response.

I can’t imagine circumstances under which I’d vote for Trump but Ms. Brooks offers a very solid explanation of why dismissing him, practically a parlor game among pundits and politicians, is ill-considered:

Every time someone in the Media Elite pokes fun at Donald Trump, it inspires six bad-tempered middle Americans to vote for him. And every time someone in the Media Elite utters a pompous condemnation of Trump’s ignorance and folly, 17 more angry Trump voters are created. If Trump becomes president, guys, it’s gonna be your fault.

21 comments

Forum Question: Russia and China

The Watcher’s Council Forum question this week was about our relationship with Russia and China: “China And Russia – Enemies or Potential Partners?”. There’s an interesting diversity of opinion among the Council members on this question.

As I think I’ve made clear I think that we’ve bungled our relations with Russia for the least three administrations. Those in Washington who are committed to ensuring that Russia is the enemy of the United States certainly seem to have gotten their way.

The situation with China is quite different. I think it’s people in Beijing who are committed to the two countries being enemies.

This week’s Forum is posted here.

9 comments

Three Charged in Connection With Lead in Flint Water

Two state employees and the city employee have been charged with criminal conduct in the matter of the the contamination of Flint, Michigan water with lead reports CNN:

(CNN) — The man who supervised Flint’s water treatment plant has been charged, along with two state environmental officials, in connection with the Michigan city’s water crisis.
Mike Glasgow, a former supervisor at the Flint treatment plant who now serves as the city’s utilities administrator, is charged with tampering with evidence and willful neglect of duty as a public officer, according to court records.

The other two are Stephen Busch and Mike Prysby of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality.
Prysby, who still works with the department, stands charged with two counts of misconduct in office, tampering with evidence, conspiracy to tamper with evidence, and two violations of the Safe Water Drinking Act (one a monitoring violation, one a treatment violation). Busch, who is on unpaid administrative leave with the department, faces the same charges minus one of the misconduct in office counts.

The punishment really does not seem to fit the crime:

If convicted on all counts, Glasgow could face up to five years in prison and $6,000 in fines, Prysby could face up to 20 years in prison and more than $35,000 in fines and Busch could face a maximum of 15 years in prison and more than $25,000 in fines. The state code also says that Prysby and Busch could face additional fines up to $5,000 a day for each day they were in violation of the Safe Water Drinking Act.

Michigan’s Attorney General has provided a Clouseauan remark:

Criminal accusations announced Wednesday against two state workers and a Flint city employee “are only the beginning,” Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette said, promising more charges will be filed.

Schuette declined to name possible additional targets of the ongoing criminal investigation. “There are no targets, and nobody’s ruled out,” he told reporters

I suspect everyone and I suspect no one.

I can only speculate on what the inevitable civil suits will look like.

2 comments

Hegemony

One of the powers of the hegemon is the ability to set the agenda.

Considering only President Obama and the current presidential aspirants, who is setting the agenda?

5 comments

The Strategy

I’ve been arguing for some time that Rahm Emanuel’s strategy for Chicago was to support policies that would attract people with earnings in the upper quintiles while not doing much that would retain people from the lower quintiles. You can see it in his support for various project usually articulated as “making Chicago a world-class city”, closing and consolidating neighborhood schools, particularly in poorer neighborhoods, and opening magnet schools.

In an article at City Journal, Aaron Renn, perhaps without recognizing itt, makes a pretty darned good case that’s been the policy for some time now:

The idea was to portray Chicago as a “global city,” and it was successful, to judge from the responses in the national media. As Millennium Park opened (a few years late) in the mid-2000s, The Economist celebrated Chicago as “a city buzzing with life, humming with prosperity, sparkling with new buildings, new sculptures, new parks, and generally exuding vitality.” The Washington Post dubbed Chicago “the Milan of the Midwest.” Newsweek added, “From a music scene powered by the underground footwork energy of juke to adventurous three-star restaurants, high-stepping fashion, and hot artists, Chicago is not only ‘the city that works,’ in Mayor Daley’s slogan, but also an exciting, excited city in which all these glittery worlds shine.”

going right back to Richie Daley’s tenure as mayor. Key problems with all of these amenities are that they were financed with borrowed money and by and large rich people don’t live here. They live in Hinsdale, Winnetka, Kenilworth, Lake Forest, and points beyond and, since the city depends for revenue on sales taxes and property taxes, they don’t contribute a lot to revenue. That leaves Chicago with a declining population of people with lower incomes paying for a spending spree on things that they don’t really need.

Rahm Emanuel has the additional problem that he grew up in an affluent family, is affluent himself, and in his job as Democratic fund-raiser has spent his life surrounded by the wealthy. It wouldn’t be too surprising if under the circumstances he identifies with the wealthy and has no real sense of the problems facing most Chicagoans.

2 comments