What If?

At least one of Illinois’s big public employee pension funds, the Teachers Retirement System (TRS), which covers all Illinois public school teachers except Chicago’s, claims to be getting more than 8% return on its investments. IMO under present conditions that means as one regular commenter here would put it they’re “climbing the risk ladder”.

Risk means a higher potential for loss and pursuing riskier investments in pursuit of yield means that sometimes you’re going to lose. What happens when the TRS loses some of its risky bets?

7 comments

The Lawlessness of the South China Sea

If you haven’t been following the claims, counterclaims, provocations, and responses going on in the South China Sea, this Washington Post article describes an aspect of what’s going on that you may not have thought about—fishing:

TANMEN, China — In the disputed waters of the South China Sea, fishermen are the wild card.

China is using its vast fishing fleet as the advance guard to press its expansive territorial claims in the South China Sea, experts say. That is not only putting Beijing on a collision course with its Asian neighbors, but also introducing a degree of unpredictability that raises the risks of periodic crises.

In the past few weeks, tensions have flared with Indonesia, Malaysia and Vietnam as Chinese fishermen, often backed up by coast guard vessels, have ventured far from their homeland and close to other nations’ coasts. They are just the latest conflicts in China’s long-running battle to expand its fishing grounds and simultaneously exert its maritime dominance.

There are eight countries and territories that border on the South China Sea: the People’s Republic of China (China), the Republic of China (Taiwan), the Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei, Indonesia, Singapore, and Vietnam. All of these have territorial claims within the South China Sea, many conflicting. With its construction of artificial islands far beyond its shores, China is clearly attempting to finesse the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) to which it is a party. Under the convention, China’s “exclusive economic zone” (EEZ) extends two hundred nautical miles beyond its shores. Extend the shores—extend the EEZ.

The present claims in the South China Sea, both to territorial waters and EEZs, are thorny but manageable. With China’s extending its shores with these artificial islands the conflicting claims become intractable.

China’s aggressive fishing doesn’t stop within its own putative EEZ but extends into the EEZs of other countries. Just last month as reported by CNN, the Argentine coast guard sank a Chinese fishing vessel poaching with a restricted area.

4 comments

Found in Translation

This is sort of off any subject but are there any fans of Asterix the Gaul out there? I’m a great fan.

I’ve read Asterix in both French and English and, remarkably, I think the translations are actually funnier.

5 comments

It’s Not Just a Messaging Problem

Despite its provenance, you might want to take a look at John Ellis’s post at PJMedia, taking fellow conservatives to task for their messaging on the $15 minimum wage:

Sadly, based on much of the rhetoric, it appears that many of my fellow conservatives don’t want fast food workers and their fellow low income workers in other fields to make $15 an hour. Over the last couple of years, many articles have been written attributing moral words like “value” and “worth” to low-income workers – according to a recent Slant News article, “Fast Food Workers Do Not Deserve That $15 an Hour.” Even conservative blogger Matt Walsh penned an article last year titled, “Fast Food Workers: You Do Not Deserve $15 an Hour to Flip Burgers, and That’s Ok.”

To be clear, I’m not necessarily quibbling with the content of Walsh’s article, and I understand the value of “click bait” titles (I mean, scroll up), but I am discomforted by the tone-deaf use of moral language in reference to low-income workers.

I think that’s a start but I think that conservatives’ problems are more serious than messaging problems. In particular, I think their problems and, indeed, the Republican Party’s problems will only deepen if the GOP remains or is even thought of as the party of pain, hardheartedness, and narrow-minded moralization.

5 comments

We Actually Need Two Immigration Policies

If you want to read another episode in Forbes’s propaganda campaign to convince its readers that all immigrants are Sergey Brin, this piece is a pretty good example of the genre.

It tells the story Noubar Areyan who’s started 38 companies in the U. S. I think the story has a moral but the moral has got to be that culture matters. Dr. Areyan is an ethnic Armenian born in Lebanon who emigrated to Canada with his family as a teenager and went to college there.

In all likelihood his family is Christian and the reality is that in Arabic-speaking countries Christians tend to better educated than their Muslim peers. But that’s not the only way that he’s atypical. The percentage of those with college educations and doctoral degrees is pretty low throughout the Arabic-speaking world. Of the immigrant population in the United States 29% have college degrees while 14% of those have doctorates or professional degrees. That’s 4% of the total immigrant population—hardly representative. If you torture the statistics long enough, as is usually done in these articles, you can make that look better.

If you set out to create an immigration policy specifically intended to undermine the economy and social fabric of the United States, it would look a lot like the one we have. Just to hit a few of the high points problems include the strong emphasis on family reunification, diversity visas, and the unfortunate reality that by far the largest number of U. S. immigrants are semi-skilled or unskilled with poor command of English.

The reality is that we need two distinct immigration policies: one for Latin America and the Caribbean (mostly Mexico) and one for the rest of the world. Because of the lack of that distinction the discussion of immigration policy inevitably cross-ruffs between defenses of policies specifically designed for the best qualified immigrants and those that suit the completely unqualified.

4 comments

Field Trip

I was called down to Springfield on business today. It will be a long day. Three and a half hours down, spend the day, three and a half hours back.

It’s been a long time since I’ve spent any time in Springfield. It’s got to have been 35 years. I’ve passed through on the way back and forth from St. Louis but never paused to spend any time. This time around my schedule is very full—no time for sightseeing.

4 comments

Missed By That Much

If President Obama thinks that “failing to plan for the day after” in his ill-conceived war on Libya was the worst mistake of his presidency as reported by CNN, he doesn’t understand the nature of his mistake.

4 comments

Why There’s a Tech Slowdown

There’s an article at the MIT Technology Review, yet another one spurred by Robert J. Gordon’s book, The Rise and Fall of American Growth, on the stalling growth in American productivity:

Growth since 1970? “Simultaneously dazzling and disappointing.” Think the PC and the Internet are important? Compare them with the dramatic decline in infant mortality, or the effect that indoor plumbing had on living conditions. And the explosion of inventions and resulting economic progress that happened during the special century are unlikely to be seen again, Gordon argues in a new book, The Rise and Fall of American Growth. Life at the beginning of the 100-year period was characterized by “household drudgery, darkness, isolation, and early death,” he writes. By 1970, American lives had totally changed. “The economic revolution of 1870 to 1970 was unique in human history, unrepeatable because so many of its achievements could happen only once,” he writes.

The book attempts to directly refute the views of those Gordon calls “techno optimists,” who think we’re in the midst of great digital innovations that will redefine our economy and sharply improve the way we live. Nonsense, he says. Just look at the economic data; there is no evidence that such a transformation is occurring.

Let me suggest in bullet form a few operating thoughts for consideration:

  • We’ve picked the low-hanging fruit.
  • There have been very few basic technological discoveries since 1940. Practically everything has been an elaboration on existing technology. That is very unlike the period 1870-1940.
  • Improvements in productivity don’t come out of nowhere. They’re the result of investment.
  • Investment and consumption are not identical.
  • Investment comes in two forms: business investment and government investment. There have been shortfalls in both for at least 15 years.
  • World War II resulted in an enormous amount of investment in technological development.
  • So did the computer revolution.
  • There is no reason to believe that technological development proceeds linearly with respect to investment. Twice as much investment doesn’t necessarily produce twice as much development. It may take ten times as much investment to produce the next major technological breakthroughs.

I’d also point out that the federal government’s track record with mass engineering projects, e.g. the space program, is pretty good in terms of being an investment rather than consumption. Dream no small dreams.

5 comments

Keep Your Eyes on Retail Employment

Over the last couple of years one of the brightest spots, if that’s the right word for it, in the employment picture has been retail. Only three states have had a net decline in retail employment, as noted by Jed Graham in Investor’s Business Daily: North Dakota, Massachusetts, and Connecticut. Of those two—Massachusetts and Connecticut—have recently enacted increases in the state minimum wage.

I think it’s premature to try to draw a causal relationship between the two but I do think it bears watching.

1 comment

Illinois’s Pride of Place

Over at his place Walter Russell Mead has a very nice essay, something of a cri de coeur on the failure of either political party to come up with practical solutions for the problems that are already at hand:

Just because deep blue Democrats prefer sentiment over analysis and let their allegiance to vested interests trump their concern for the poor is no excuse for Republicans to treat the students of Chicago State with indifference. It’s fine to say “hold the line on taxes and starve the beast”—and there are times when this is necessary. But doing that alone is not a plan for better governance. Illinois’ budget woes are a direct result of years of terrible decisions and the absence of serious planning at both state and local levels. And the chief victims of this neglect of duty are poor people—those who depend most on government for services.

Where are the plans for a revitalization of Illinois and Chicago? Where are the proposals for changes in the way Illinois is administered, its higher ed system organized, its pension burdens managed and rationalized? How will the built-in cost structures that make cities like Chicago so difficult to operate in be reduced? How will the costs of interacting with the regulatory state be reined in, and the process simplified for businesses and homeowners? How will the miserably failing school systems of Chicago and other communities be revived, and labor relations in the school system detoxified? And, among these larger questions, how will the students at Chicago State finish their coursework and get their degrees?

To understand both the voter frustration and the political polarization of the country, it’s necessary to see how neither party is offering real solutions for these problems. The Democrats just keep looking for new funds to pour into the sinkhole; Republicans hope to starve the beast to force a crisis. Neither agenda will do much for Illinois. Democrats’ proposals stave off present pain at the cost of making the inevitable day of reckoning that much worse. Republicans bring on Armageddon now without any idea of what comes after. Voters are right to hold both approaches in disdain. They are right to be contemptuous of the party machines and the think tank apparatchiks who can’t come up with anything better. Until one or both parties develops workable approaches to the serious problems the country faces, politics is going to remain open to demagogues and con artists.

The post is headed with side by side pictures of Bruce Rauner, Illinois’s present Republican governor, and Pat Quinn, his Democratic predecessor. It’s nice to know that Illinois can always serve as an object lesson. At least we’re good for something.

We’ve already admitted that we have a problem but it’s not clear to me there’s much agreement on what the problem is. Democrats seem to feel that the problem is that the state doesn’t have enough revenue. Republicans’ preferred strategies tend to favor promoting economic growth. My own view is that there is no amount of revenue that will ever be enough as long as the state’s revenue needs are growing faster than the state’s economy is.

We should settle on whether we’re taking a retrospective approach or a “day forward” approach to solving the state’s problems. It’s going to be darned hard to put the past off limits since we’re still living with the repercussions of past decisions. The state’s constitution doesn’t allow us to just roll back all of the bad decisions of the last 30 years.

I also think that Republicans should start thinking in terms of a transition plan rather than a revolution.

7 comments