The BBC reports that with characteristic prudence three-quarters of Swiss voters have rejected a universal basic income for Switzerland:
Swiss voters have overwhelmingly rejected a proposal to introduce a guaranteed basic income for all.
Final results from Sunday’s referendum showed that nearly 77% opposed the plan, with only 23% backing it.
The proposal had called for adults to be paid an unconditional monthly income, whether they worked or not.
The supporters camp had suggested a monthly income of 2,500 Swiss francs (£1,755; $2,555) for adults and also SFr625 for each child.
The reasons given by the Swiss for rejecting the proposal reflected a concern that millions of people would flock into Switzerland, drawn by the subsidy. In the context of a million refugees streaming from the miserable countries of West Asia, the Middle East, and North Africa into Europe in 2015 with 2016 on target to exceed that number and the manifest willingness of the migrants to venue shop for the best package of subsidies, the Swiss’s concerns are well-founded. Add to that a desire to remain Swiss, something that even the Dalai Lama has proclaimed justifiable.
Closer to home when I read Charles Murray’s Wall Street Journal op-ed proposing a universal basic income for the United States, I didn’t know whether to file it under “Business and Economics”, “Politics”, or “Humor”, presumably after the fashion of Jonathan Swift’s A Modest Proposal. This is a plan he’s been pushing for a decade. The gist of the plan is that the U. S. would pay a $13,000 basic income to every American, $3,000 of which would earmarked for healthcare insurance and the plan would be paid for by abolishing the Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid programs:
First, my big caveat: A UBI will do the good things I claim only if it replaces all other transfer payments and the bureaucracies that oversee them. If the guaranteed income is an add-on to the existing system, it will be as destructive as its critics fear.
Second, the system has to be designed with certain key features. In my version, every American citizen age 21 and older would get a $13,000 annual grant deposited electronically into a bank account in monthly installments. Three thousand dollars must be used for health insurance (a complicated provision I won’t try to explain here), leaving every adult with $10,000 in disposable annual income for the rest of their lives.
It’s hard to know where to start in critiquing such a plan. I’ll start by pointing out that health insurance for a single person costs about $8,000 per year exclusive of subsidies and his plan presupposes no subsidies. The median apartment rental in the cheapest of the 25 largest metropolitan areas (where about half of Americans live) is $1,300 per month.
It isn’t often that you run into a proposal that makes an assumption and its opposite within the same argument but that seems to be the case for Dr. Murray’s plan. His argument is based on the idea that jobs will become increasingly hard to come by but the only way that many people who are presently unemployed will be able to survive under Dr. Murray’s plan is by getting a job.
Roughly a third of those over the age of 65 live almost entirely on Social Security. Without Social Security, Medicare, or Medicaid or any other form of “safety net” program how the heck does he expect them to survive other than by taking a non-existent job that they wouldn’t be hired for anyway? Or does he expect them to hurry up and die so it will decrease the surplus population?

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.




