The Great Divide

There are a lot of very interesting facts in David Dayen’s most recent and highly educational post at Fiscal Times. For example, I didn’t know that 30% of new homes sold in 2002 cost $150,000 or less but today only 2% do. Or that one in three houses valued at $100,000 or less are underwater.

What’s even more interesting is his claim that there are actually two U. S. housing markets, one for the rich and one for everybody else.

I’ll throw in a fact of my own. Just about a third of all housing sales are cash sales (nearly half of all housing sales in Florida are for cash). Those cash sales are mostly some combination of flippers, other domestic real estate investors, and foreign buyers.

1 comment

Did America Work?

At Fiscal Times Liz Peek says the heck with making America great again, make America work again:

  • There is no excuse for any American missing his plane because the TSA cannot do its job.
  • There is no excuse for a single veteran to be denied critical care because of long wait times.
  • There is no excuse for the IRS not answering your phone call.
  • There is no excuse for allowing tens of thousands of Central Americans to cross our southern border illegally.

There is no excuse at all for ineptness on such a grand scale.

Okay, I’ll bite. Which of these is closest to the truth?

  1. America never worked.
  2. America has never worked for a lot of people.
  3. Americans have forgotten what working means.
  4. Given enough time any bureaucracy will stop working.
  5. If we were willing to spend the money, we could make everything work beautifully.
  6. Everything is working as designed. It was just designed poorly and to accomplish political goals rather than practical ones.
  7. Other
5 comments

Why We’ll Never End Poverty

Scott Sumner explains some of the reasons that we’ll never end poverty:

1. Because we think of poverty in relative terms.

2. We are very good at noticing subtle differences in status. Make the differences smaller in objective terms, and they’ll still seem just as big in subjective terms. If everyone in my department had a salary within $1000 of each other, then differences of just $50 or $100 would drive people insane.

3. Government quality regulations are set based on average living conditions. Hence societies tend to criminalize poverty. It’s illegal to provide goods and services at Bangladesh levels of quality to Americans. Even SRO apartments have been regulated away; we prefer our poor to be homeless and without medical care, rather than living in substandard housing or getting treated by someone who is not a certified MD.

4. In any society, some people are less competent than others. By no means are all poor people incompetent, but people who are incompetent often end up poor. (I don’t mean ‘incompetetent’ as a pejorative, rather as someone who struggles with the demands of the modern world.) The cynical conservative says that if you completely equalized wealth tomorrow, a year from now there’d be lots of billionaires and lots of homeless people. And unfortunately that’s true.

5. Items 3 and 4 interact in a particularly nasty way. I have a PhD in economics, and yet often feel incompetent when trying to deal with the complexities of government regulations (or private utilities). The regulatory state makes things especially difficult for the poor. Some poor people are in and out of jail for being unable to pay various government fines for violating various regulations.

I have no objection to using the power of the federal government to help people who are genuinely in need. However, we should recognize that the number of people who are needy is dwarfed by the number that are want-y.

Here’s my question. To what degree should the federal government be intervening to help people maintain their lifestyles? I can see legitimate reasons (especially political reasons) that local governments might want to intervene for that reason. I wish there were more general recognition of the degree to which local governments actually make it hard for people to maintain their lifestyles.

But not the federal government. I’m hoping someone can explain the need for federal intervention for people who aren’t homeless, starving, unable to obtain medical care, etc.

1 comment

The Reality of a Universal Basic Income in the U. S.

Over at Bloomberg Megan McArdle gives her reaction to the Swiss rejection of a universal basic income that I wrote about yesterday:

Oh, we weren’t going to get rid of Medicare? Nor Medicaid or Obamacare? And of course we’ll keep providing public schooling, and assistance for disabled children, and…. By the time you’ve started saving programs that obviously can’t be cut without immiserating large chunks of the population who currently rely on the government, what you have is a $2.7 trillion program to substitute for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (welfare), unemployment insurance, Social Security and food stamps — four programs upon which the federal government currently spends about $1.2 trillion.

Moreover, since the grant would be, in many cases, less generous than what a lot of people are currently collecting, we will probably have to either top up for those groups, or increase the size of the benefit, until we have a $3 trillion or $4 trillion program to replace $1.2 trillion worth of welfare spending. Even if we tax back the whole benefit from higher earners (which would reintroduce many of the marginal tax problems we were trying to avoid with the UBI in the first place), the dead-weight loss of the additional taxation needed to pay for this program will probably harm economic growth, making the program more expensive still. I’m not a supply-side hawk who thinks that any tax increases will plunge us all back into the dark ages, but running an additional $2 trillion to $3 trillion through government coffers every year might give even some ardent big-government Democrats pause.

These numbers are, of course, specific to the U.S., but the problem is the same in any developed country. Handing out a universal benefit of any size at all will be fantastically expensive. You can make it smaller, of course, but then you don’t get any of the vaunted benefits: It doesn’t prevent the benefit cliffs, doesn’t encourage entrepreneurship, doesn’t lessen the distortions of all the in-kind benefits you’ve left in place.

One of the key points is that the advocates of a UBI are trying to address a problem that we don’t actually have, may never have, and for which there are politically simpler solutions: displacement of workers by automation.

Whatever degree technological unemployment is presently a problem is overwhelmed by any number of other laws, regulations, and other policies we’ve introduced over the years. There are good reasons for some of them, e.g. some environmental regulations. The reasons are less good for others, e.g. occupational licensing requirements for jobs that don’t require much in the way of skills.

Something that’s generally ignored is there’s no law of nature that the proceeds that result from the market distortions that are created by such laws, regulations, and policies need to remain in the hands of those who benefit from them. IMO that should be the first line of recourse: either getting rid of unnecessary regulations or getting rid of the deadweight loss from necessary regulations.

That won’t solve the problems of poverty and unemployment in one, grand master stroke but good stewardship frequently requires boring, detailed work rather than grand master strokes.

4 comments

RIP, Bretagne

The last known surviving 9/11 search and rescue dog has died:

Firefighters and rescue workers lined the sidewalk as her body, draped in an American flag, was carried out. Tears streaked down some faces.

Bretagne, believed to be the last surviving 9/11 Ground Zero search dog, was euthanized Monday.

The golden retriever was 16. Old age had slowed her down, and it was time to put her to sleep.

So, the firefighters at the Cy-Fair Fire Department in Harris County, Texas, lined the path up to the Fairfield Animal Hospital, as her owner, Denise Corliss, walked her in to be put to sleep.

Good dog.

Being a good search and rescue dog requires certain qualities—it’s not something that every dog can do. The first Samoyed to be certified as a search and rescue dog came from the same kennel as our Samoyeds and, consequently, was a distant relative of our dogs. He worked with our friend, Betty, who presently has a littermate of our dog, Nola.

Sixteen is quite a venerable age for a Goldie. She was obviously loved.

2 comments

What Infrastructure?

When people talk about federal infrastructure spending (as Paul Krugman does in many of his columns), I’m always struck by how backwards-thinking their views are.

Imagine if in 1936 FDR had announced major WPA initiatives of restoring telegraph lines and refurbishing the Erie Canal. People would have thought he’d gone mad. And yet the pleas to restore 20th century infrastructure are treated as serious policy prescriptions.

Here are my questions.

  • Do you think that the federal interstate system will be as important over the period of the next 50 years as it was over the last 50?
  • What infrastructure do you think will be most important over the period of the next 50 years?

While I think there’s an argument to be made that we should be restoring sewer systems, from a ways and means standpoint you’re really calling for no strings block grants to be made available to the states. Given the states’ present fiscal situations does that sound like a prudent course of action? Or would any foreseeable amount of money spent that way simply disappear into the maw of the professional class without run-on economic effects?

5 comments

Is HC Hiding Anything?

In his most recent post Michael Ledeen asks “What is Hillary hiding?”:

Like millions of avid news readers, I’ve been trying to sort out the Hillary Clinton scandals. You know, all that stuff about classified material on her “private” server, sensitive national security secrets that have most likely been lifted by hostiles.

I think we’ve lost track of the central question: Why was she so eager to conceal her communications from Congress and the American public? Most of the commentary goes something like “because she wanted to evade discovery.” She dreaded all the FOIAs. But that only leads to the question another time: What did she want to hide, and why?

I think there are only two answers to that question and anything else is a variant of one of those.

The first answer, the one most favorable to Sec. Clinton, is that she wasn’t hiding anything. She is convinced, not without justification, that there are lots of people gunning for her and she’s gun-shy. If you believe that’s the one, true answer, you also necessarily believe that she is very poorly informed, ignorant, arrogant or some of all of the above, and that she was willing to subordinate any better judgment to a single-minded avoidance of scrutiny just to avoid being scrutinized. That’s the view most favorable to her.

The other answer is that the Clinton business plan required her to avoid scrutiny. She knew she was going to be treading a very thin line among doing her job as Secretary of State, evading the law, and dealing in the “pay to play” tactics familiar to any resident of the great state of Illinois. What she planned to do might not have been technically against the law but it was certainly unseemly and many including me would say that it was inescapably corrupt.

To my eye Occam’s Razor demands the second answer but I guess YMMV.

8 comments

Unfair to Banana Republics!

The editors of the Chicago Tribune, reacting to remarks from Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner, muse over the governor’s comparison of Illinois to a “banana republic”:

During the long budget battle in Springfield, many inventive and harsh things have been said by those on each side. But in decrying the financial condition of the state government, Gov. Bruce Rauner took the rhetorical fight to a new level. “The Democrats have spent our state into the toilet for 30 years,” he asserted. “We are like a banana republic.”

No, not a Banana Republic store, part of the clothing chain. The governor was alluding to certain Latin American nations with a longstanding reputation for irresponsible governance.

They do bring up one good point: the Chicago Public Schools’s credit rating is B2, the same as Honduras’s. So we have that going for us.

What we have in common with Guatemala, Honduras, Costa Rica, El Salvador, and Panama are official mismanagement, corruption, and lack of democracy. Illinois is, unfortunately, exceedingly stable.

I think the comparison is patently unfair to the countries of Central America. Historically, they’re one crop countries which have been drastically undercapitalized and ruled for lengthy periods by military dictatorships. Illinois’s problems are completely of our own making.

3 comments

It Does Not Compute

Ed Yardeni says that something does not compute in the latest jobs report:

Payrolls rose just 38,000 during May, the weakest gain since September 2010, and the previous two months were revised downward by 59,000 collectively. However, something just doesn’t add up with these weak numbers.

Here’s his conclusion:

I think that in the worst-case scenario, the latest payrolls suggest that there may be a big skills mismatch between all those unfilled jobs and the available workers to fill them. More likely is that May’s weak report is misleading, though we are disturbed by the downward revisions in the prior two months.

Let me provide another alternative, one that is practically tautological, definitional: the wages being offered for the new jobs on offer are below the market clearing price. There are good reasons for businesses to do that, if only to bolster an argument for importing more H1-B workers.

In order to justify Dr. Yardeni’s hypothesis I think you need to probe a little below the surface of the larger number job openings. I’d like to see what the jobs were and what the employers were offering. Sadly, Dr. Yardeni does not provide any additional information.

2 comments

Forum Question: Who’s to Blame?

The Watcher’s Council Forum question this week was about who’s to blame for the violent protests that took place in San Jose last week. The gist of my answer is that it’s hard to know where to stop in assigning blame. Among the culprits I’d list the large number of “protesters” who obviously intended to exceed the bounds of legitimate protest (unless they typically carry eggs and water balloons with them), the handful of Trump supporters who came prepared for trouble armed with pepper spray, Donald Trump, the police, city officials in San Jose, and American politicians who’ve been reacting to illegal immigration with a wink and a nod for generations.

The forum post at the Watcher’s site is here.

7 comments