Effective Persuasion

Leave aside whether pelting people with eggs and water balloons, pushing them around, taking their stuff, and beating up on them, as described in this Washington Post report:

SAN JOSE, Calif. —Protests outside a Donald Trump rally in downtown San Jose spun out of control Thursday night when some demonstrators attacked the candidate’s supporters.

Protesters jumped on cars, pelted Trump supporters with eggs and water balloons, snatched signs and stole “Make America Great” hats off supporters’ heads before burning the hats and snapping selfies with the charred remains.

Several people were caught on camera punching Trump supporters. At least one attacker was arrested, according to CNN, although police did not release much information.

is legitimate protest or rioting. Here’s my question: is it effective persuasion? I think if anything it will persuade people who are sitting on the fence to do exactly the opposite of what the “protesters” presumably want.

I also think that if the police don’t start being a bit more pro-active at these rallies things will get much, much uglier very quickly.

20 comments

The Monthly Birth Death Ratio Adjustment Reporting

The news reports, like this one from USA Today, say that the Bureau of Labor Statistics is reporting an increase of just 38,000 jobs in May 2016:

The labor market slowed dramatically in May as employers added 38,000 jobs, raising concerns that a sluggish economy is taking a bigger toll on employment and lowering the odds of a Federal Reserve rate hike this month.

The unemployment rate fell from 5% to 4.7%, lowest since November 2007 the Labor Department said Friday, but that was because nearly 500,000 Americans stopped working or looking for jobs. The paltry employment gains were the smallest in 5 1/2 years.

Economists surveyed by Bloomberg expected 160,000 new jobs, with net gains reduced by 35,000 because of the now-settled Verizon strike. That total thus would have been roughly equivalent to the 200,000-plus additions that have been a staple of the payroll recovery in recent years.

But more forces more significant than the strike dragged down payroll gains last month. Also discouraging: Job growth for March and April was revised down by a total 59,000. March’s tally was revised to 186,000 from 208,000, and April’s, to 123,000 from 160,000.

but that only tells part of the story. The “birth-death ratio”, the adjustment the BLS applies to account for their estimate the impact of businesses started or terminated, is responsible for 224,000 jobs.

So, how many jobs were created or lost in May 2016? We don’t know but depending on how much confidence you have in the birth-death ratio adjustment as many as 190,000 jobs may have been lost.

I think that all of this adds up to a dwindling labor force participation rate. The change in the LFPR since 2007 is undoubtedly a social development as important as the entry of women into the labor force in the the 1970s and 1980s. I suspect there have never been as many idle adults in the United States as there are today.

I can only speculate as to what all of those idle people are doing. If the news here in Chicago is any gauge, they’re drinking, doing drugs, and shooting at each other.

6 comments

O Tempora O Mores

I’ve just read the third story in as many days of people murdering other people in imitation of dystopian graphic novels, TV programs, or movies.

I realize that in a country as large as ours there are bound to be a certain number of maniacs, that we’ve got a 24 hour news cycle, and “if it bleeds it leads”.

But has the world gone mad?

1 comment

Living Beyond Their Means

One passage jumped out at me in this News Hour interview of Neal Gabler conducted by Judy Woodruff. You may recall that when he posted his confessional piece at Atlantic I remarked on it. Here’s the passage:

There’s one statistic that I cite in the piece from a USA Today survey which I think is fascinating. And that survey determined that a middle-class existence in America would cost $130,000.

$130,000 a year is not the middle of anything. It’s more than two standard deviations greater than the median. If people genuinely think that everybody in the United States is going to earn upper middle incomes, there’s a serious problem of expectations.

It hasn’t always been this way. Go back and look at old clips from The Honeymooners or The Life of Riley. They weren’t poor. They were just average families. People have forgotten where the middle actually is.

4 comments

Videos Are Public Records

I can’t help but wonder if this, reported by the Washington Post, is standard practice at the State Department:

The State Department acknowledged Wednesday that someone in its public affairs bureau made a “deliberate” request that several minutes of tape be cut from the video of a 2013 press briefing in which a reporter asked if the administration had lied about secret talks with Iran.

The embarrassing admission by State Department spokesman John Kirby came three weeks after another spokesperson insisted that a “glitch” had caused the gap, discovered only last month by the reporter whose questioning had mysteriously disappeared.

“This wasn’t a technical glitch, this was a deliberate step to excise the video,” Kirby told reporters.

Somebody help me out here. Refresh my memory. Aren’t videos public records and, consequently, subject to Freedom of Information Act requests? And aren’t they records distinct from the written transcripts?

In other words isn’t the State Department’s editing a video to remove an embarrassing segment a violation of the Records Act?

12 comments

Am I a Lukewarmist?

I want to commend a series of posts by Warren Meyer to your attention (hat tip: Megan McArdle). His subject is climate change. Here’s a snippet:

Even when government programs do likely have an impact of CO2, they are seldom managed intelligently. For example, the government subsidizes solar panel installations, presumably to reduce their cost to consumers, but then imposes duties on imported panels to raise their price (indicating that the program has become more of a crony subsidy for US solar panel makers, which is typical of the life-cycle of these types of government interventions). Obama’s coal power plan, also known as his war on coal, will certainly reduce some CO2 from electricity generation but at a very high cost to consumers and industries. Steps like this are taken without any idea of whether this is the lowest cost approach to reducing CO2 production — likely it is not given the arbitrary aspects of the program.

For years I have opposed steps like a Federal carbon tax or cap and trade system because I believe (and still believe) them to be unnecessary given the modest amount of man-made warming I expect over the next century. I would expect to see about one degree C of man-made warming between now and 2100, and believe most of the cries that “we are already seeing catastrophic climate changes” are in fact panics driven by normal natural variation (most supposed trends, say in hurricanes or tornadoes or heat waves, can’t actually be found when one looks at the official data).

But I am exhausted with all the stupid, costly, crony legislation that passes in the name of climate change action. I am convinced there is a better approach that will have more impact on man-made CO2 and simultaneously will benefit the economy vs. our current starting point. So here goes…

I think I’d support his five point plan, particularly if he made one addition: we should end federal highway subsidies. They are, frankly, subsidies to fossil fuel consumption and will remain so for the foreseeable future.

I don’t honestly know where I fit into the spectrum of opinion on global warming and climate change. I may not even be a “lukewarmist” (see Megan’s post for an explanation). I’d just really like to see policy prescriptions that are actually suited to the results their proponents say they want to accomplish.

6 comments

We Was Robbed!

I demand a recount. According to George Mason University’s Mercatus Center, Illinois ranks 47th among the states in the health of its fiscal condition. It falls behind (ahead of?) Puerto Rico, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New Jersey. From the Mercatus Center’s discussion of Illinois:

On the basis of its fiscal solvency in five separate categories, Illinois ranks 47th among the US states and Puerto Rico for its fiscal health. On a cash basis, Illinois has between 0.63 and 1.39 times the cash needed to cover short-term liabilities. Revenues cover 99 percent of expenses, producing a deficit of $40 per capita. On a long-run basis, a net asset ratio of −1.14 indicates that Illinois is reliant on debt financing to cover spending. Liabilities exceed assets by 48 percent, producing a long-term liability per capita of $6,067. Total debt is $35.55 billion. Unfunded pension liabilities are $298.05 billion on a guaranteed-to-be-paid basis, and other postemployment benefits (OPEB) are $34.49 billion. These three liabilities are equal to 61 percent of total state personal income.

Long-run solvency is where Illinois really shines: it’s ranked 49th there (better off only than Puerto Rico and New Jersey).

I would be remiss in not pointing out that Illinois is entering its second year without a budget. If there is no budget, there is no budgetary problem—amiright or amiright?

1 comment

The Ruins of Empire

At Gulf News Francis Matthew argues against a modern Peace of Westphalia for the Middle East:

There is an assumption that the similarity between the Thirty Years’ War in Europe and the current chaos in the Middle East requires the Arab world to find something like the 1648 Peace of Westphalia for itself. The idea is that the rambling chaos of the Protestant and Catholic fighting in the German states mirrors the multiplicity of wars in the Arab world with their increasingly sectarian divisions.

The danger with this parallel is that any comparison across almost 400 years and different continents is bound to be a bit stretched. But it also misses the point that the treaties of Westphalia were largely about how independent states behaved with each other, while the issue in many Arab countries today is how a varied population can find an inclusive relationship with a central national government.

What “central national government” is that? In many of the countries of the Middle East there are no central national governments to speak of and some that were have collapsed and show signs of splintering farther.

I think that he misses the point completely. What we’re seeing in the Middle East is people squabbling over the ruins of a multi-ethnic, multi-confessional empire. There are no traditions of the preservation of minority rights other than those secured by a now-nonexistent imperial sovereign.

I don’t dare to prescribe how the peoples and countries of the Middle East should order their affairs. I only know that for us to order our affairs with them their countries need to have responsible authorities. Absent that our only recourse will be to defend ourselves against the ongoing chaos.

0 comments

The Decline of Internationalism

In a recent essay George Friedman touches on a point I’ve made here from time to time. Worries about a rising tide of fascism, either here in the United States or in Europe, are overblown and rely on a bad definition of “fascism”:

Recently, there have been a number of articles and statements asserting that fascism is rising in Europe, and that Donald Trump is an American example of fascism. This is a misrepresentation of a very real phenomenon. The nation-state is reasserting itself as the primary vehicle of political life. Multinational institutions like the European Union and multilateral trade treaties are being challenged because they are seen by some as not being in the national interest. The charge of a rise in fascism derives from a profound misunderstanding of what fascism is. It is also an attempt to discredit the resurgence of nationalism and to defend the multinational systems that have dominated the West since World War II.

Read the whole thing. I don’t think that nationalism is re-emerging so much as that internationalism is falling on its face.

The reality is that people in different countries have different values and there’s nothing wrong with that. The missionary fervor to spread your own culture is more a problem than a solution.

12 comments

Think Small!

I found this article at chinadialogue on rural eCommerce thought-provoking:

In 2015, a slump in the market for red dates (known in Chinese as jujubes) became big news in China. In Yonghe County, over 40 million jin (20,000 tonnes) of dates were harvested, but only half were sold around Chinese New Year, the county’s busiest shopping period.

Upon hearing the news, Liu Dongdong, a Yonghe native and then university graduate working at a building and decorating firm in the provincial capital of Taiyuan, thought of Taobao, China’s eBay with around 500 million users.

What if people could sell the remaining dates online? Instead of farmers waiting for customers to find them, they could deliver directly to customers’ homes. Liu Dongdong returned home that night with dreams of opening his own online business.

A major impediment, of course, is the lack of rural Internet. In the U. S. rural Internet penetration is around 42%. In China it’s less than 30% and, based on the statistics cited in the article, rural broadband penetration might be as low as 1%.

Another big problem is likely to be literacy. Not just computer literacy but literacy literacy. You’ve got to take China’s official literacy figures of more than 95% with a grain of salt. They define literacy differently for different people, depending on their “station in life”. For rural farmers, the ability to recognize a handful of characters might be enough. Sounds like a real opportunity for the computer-savvy.

But imagine if, rather than being (sometimes literally) herded into big cities, rural Chinese people could earn decent incomes through eCommerce. China’s “ghost cities” which bank on continuing migration from the countryside could remain uninhabited. China’s rural population remains in the hundred of billions. There are more rural Chinese than there Americans living anywhere.

Increasing a rural Chinese family’s income to $1,500 per person from $500 per person per year would do more to make China prosperous than increasing the incomes of China’s educated urban elite to European standards.

The real story here might be networks. In the 19th century the meaningful networks were the railway system, the telegraph lines, and canals. In the 20th century we had highways and telephone lines. I strongly suspect that the most important networks in the 21st century will be telecommunications networks and the power grid.

If you want to make worthwhile investments in infrastructure, think networks. That’s as true for the United States as for China.

Also, consider the implications of unmanned drone aircraft, from tiny on up, guided by a nationwide wireless system, carrying products from rural areas to far away customers.

0 comments