Not the Picture Book Kind

I agree with nearly everything that the author of this article, a parent of a child with autism, has to say:

Because for every boy with autism who manages his high school basketball team, there are 20 boys with autism who smear feces. And for every girl with autism who gets to be on the homecoming court, there are 30 girls with autism who pull out their hair and bite their arms until they bleed. And for every boy with autism who gets to go the prom, there are 50 boys with autism who hit and kick and bite and hurt other people.

This is the autism that no one talks about. This is the autism that no one wants to see.

The one reservation I have is that I hope the author’s prescriptions aren’t construed as letting the classmates of a child with autism assume primary responsibility for the care and support of their classmates with special needs. While it’s good, helpful, and even necessary for children to receive proactive strategies they can use to avoid unpleasant or even harmful developments, that responsibility needs to remain with parents, teachers, and other professionals.

Read the whole thing. It might give you a window or at least a keyhole into the lives of parents of many of the children with autism.

3 comments

Liberal Democratic Government Lost in Turkey

What the heck happened in Turkey? As they’ve been reported the facts are a) a military coup was announced and b) is was suppressed. Everything beyond that seems to be conjecture.

Now there are various claims. For example, it’s being claimed that the Turkish people chose democracy in Turkey. Is that really the case? Or did they choose Erdogan? Maybe they chose democracy in the sense of mobocracy but certainly not in the sense of liberal democratic government since that selection wasn’t on the menu.

It’s also being claimed that the supposed coup was actually a false flag operation that will empower Erdogan to seize more autocratic power than he already has.

Is that the case? Was the attempted military coup an attempt to reinstate Ataturk’s secularist Turkey or an expression of frustration with lack of Islamism? I don’t think we know and possibly never will. Does secularism in Turkey foster liberal democratic government? By all indications Erdogan’s Islamism threatens it.

Whatever has happened I think we can conclude that liberal democratic government lost in Turkey.

2 comments

Star Dust Memories

In a corner of the Mariano’s store at which I occasionally shop, there’s a baby grand piano. On Sundays pianists come and play there. As I waited in the checkout line, today’s pianist began playing the song in the video above.

Me (to the cashier): Do you know what song he’s playing?

Cashier (in her late teens or twenties): No.

Me: That’s Star Dust, Hoagy Carmichael.

The original version of Star Dust, composed in 1927 by Hoagy Carmichael was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1995 and into the National Recording Registry of the Library of Congress in 2004. Considered by many the finest song of the 20th century, it has been beloved by three generations.

But culture is ephemeral now and the young people of today barely know the popular music of last year let alone of the last century. Or if it’s in a Disney cartoon. That suits the corporate owners but not the culture. Poetry and stage plays are practically unknown. The Sound of Music is a movie starring Julia Andrews spinning in a mountain meadow or, worse yet, a television program featuring Carrie Underwood. Camelot is known only from the execrable movie.

Sometimes I wonder why I spend
The lonely nights
Dreaming of a song.
The melody haunts my reverie
And I am once again with you.
When our love was new, and each kiss an inspiration.
But that was long ago, and now my consolation
Is in the stardust of a song.

7 comments

Forum Preview

The Watcher’s Council forum question for this week will be “Is Islam compatible with a free society?” I strongly suspect that my answer will be somewhat different than those of my fellow Watchers.

Of course it is. To the same extent as Christianity or Judaism is.

Islam is inclusive of more diversity of beliefs than Christianity and enormously more than Judaism. Within it is contained variants that are completely compatible with a free society, whatever radical conservatives within Islam and foes of Islam of other confessions might think.

The question is somewhat beside the point. For me the much more important question is whether Wahhabist/Salafist Islam is compatible with a free society and to that question the answer is “No” and, honestly, I think that those who profess the Wahhabist/Salafist versions of Islam would agree with me.

The additional challenge is that the Wahhabist/Salafist variants of Islam are on the rise, largely propelled by the money of Gulf Arabs, not just among the Gulf states but everywhere including the West. Something like three-quarters of all imams in the United States are foreign born, most of those are Saudis, and a distressingly large proportion of those hold to very conservative Wahhabist/Salafist beliefs.

Then the question is what is to be done? I’ve already expressed my opinions on that subject.

I would welcome the contributions of my readers on this subject so that I may better inform my own views. Please weigh in in the comments.

8 comments

The Attempted Coup in Turkey

As you’re presumably aware members of the Turkish military attempted a coup yesterday but have apparently failed. That appears to be the long and the short of it at this point. This isn’t a news blog; it’s an analysis and commentary blog and I think that analysis and commentary are premature.

The only remark I have is that it reminds me of something I heard once about a movie that pitted the Mafia against vampires. There was no one to root for. You would prefer if both sides lost.

Erdogan is not a good guy and Erdogan’s Turkey is not our friend. They’ve been either in fact or in effect supplying DAESH since the beginning and hampering U. S. efforts to combat terrorism in the region for a lot longer than that.

1 comment

Can We Live With Terrorism?

The New York Times has a forum on whether we can live with terrorism, part of its “Room for Debate” feature. This particular forum was convened in response to the French prime ministers remark after the murders in Nice to the effect that France would need to learn to live with terrorism. The opinions expressed by the contributors to the forum include a call to harden targets, a recommendation to increase the forcefulness of our response to terrorism, a plea to broaden the definition of terrorism to include the actions of states, and an observation on the role of mental illness in domestic terror attacks.

It may or may not surprise you but although I don’t agree much with any of the opinions expressed in the forum I agree most with the views of Liah Greenfeld:

The great majority of “homegrown” or “lone-wolf” terror acts are committed by people with a known history of mental illness, most often depression, which counts social maladjustment and problematic sense of self among its core symptoms. Severely depressed people are often suicidal, they find life unlivable. As a rule, they cannot explain their acute existential discomfort to themselves and may find ideologies hostile to their social environment – the society in which they experience their misery – appealing: such ideologies allow them to rationalize, make sense of the way they feel. Any available ideology justifying their maladjustment would do: Mohamed Lahouaiej Bouhlel might have been inspired by radical Islam, but Micah Johnson, who killed five police officers in Dallas, had a different inspiration.

In a way, such ideologies serve for the mentally ill perpetrators as ready-made delusions, which, as we know also can inspire mass murders. Characteristically, the majority of mass murders, including lone-wolf terrorist acts, in Western countries are committed by people who are willing, in fact plan, to die while carrying them out. These acts offer them a spectacular, memorable, way out – a way of self-affirmation and suicide at once. An association with a great cause – and any ideology presents its cause as great – makes it all the more meaningful for them.

I think it’s premature to conclude that Micah Johnson was mentally ill. He may or may not have been. Not all evil acts are the product of mental illness. That’s a misconception that’s far too common these days. Some evil acts are merely evil, the products of sane minds attempting to realize their objectives.

A couple of points. First, not every violent act, even violent acts that inspire terror, is terrorism. For an act to be terrorism it must have some political or social dimension. The murder of police officers in Dallas was pretty clearly terrorism; the murder of Laquan McDonald by a police officer was not.

Second, the notion of hardening targets is fatuous. It is simply impossible to harden all targets. Are you going to prevent groups of people from assembling because as in Nice they present a target?

And I seen no evidence that a harsher military response short of genocidal extermination, something I neither recommend nor condone, will be effective in reducing let alone eliminating terrorist attacks. There are alternatives even if they’re unpalatable. Bombing because the alternative is distasteful is a grossly immoral course of action.

I think that there’s a productive distinction between domestic terrorism and terrorism of the foreign organized, funded, and led sort (like 9/11). We can go a long way to preventing terrorism of the latter sort just by screening foreigners receiving visas and monitoring them when they’re here much more carefully than we do.

And as I’ve pointed out before there appears to be a pattern to the Islamist domestic terrorism of the Boston Marathon bombing or Fort Hood massacre variety. They seem to involve the disaffected children of Muslim immigrants. In my view highly targeted early intervention and counseling should be much more commonplace. I would add that thinking that singling people with special needs out for intervention and counseling is beyond the pale because it singles some people out is its own form of mental illness. I’m recommending counseling because they clearly have special needs.

I’m not entirely sure what the commonality among other domestic terrorists including Timothy McVeigh, Eric Rudolph, and, apparently, Micah Johnson is. The only link I can see is racism. I don’t know what could have been done to prevent their evil acts. Is Dylann Roof a terrorist? I don’t know. He may simply be a mentally ill racist or just plain evil. I don’t have enough information to render a judgment and I don’t care to do the work to find out.

11 comments

Forum Question: Attacks on Police

The Watcher’s Council forum question this week concerned the attacks on police that had occurred last week.

Here was my contribution:

I think there’s a lot of exaggerated fear on all sides.
It is not true that police are being murdered in numbers. Here in Chicago there hasn’t been a police officer killed in the line of duty in five years. Police killings, e.g. Laquan McDonald, simply can’t be attributed to rational fear on the part of police.

It’s also not true that blacks are being murdered in numbers by police. The number of blacks killed by police relative to the number of their arrests for violent crimes is about the same as whites. Black anger of the sort that apparently motivated the murderer in Dallas last Thursday simply can’t be thought of as a righteous response to black men being hunted by the police.

The United States is a country of 320 million people and there are more than a million law enforcement officers. With such a large population and tens or hundreds of thousands of encounters between the police and black men daily, occasional tragic incidents are inevitable. Comparing the United States with, say, Denmark is facetious. Denmark is the size of a good-sized U. S. county. There are thousands of U. S. counties where no police officers or civilians have been murdered in decades.

Why the fear? I think there are several reasons. The power of social media and every phone a video camera mean that these inevitable incidents are made available to a worldwide audience in minutes. The news media pick up these viral accounts and perseverate on them, giving the impression that they’re much more frequent and a much more serious problem than they actually are.

Another contributing factor is political leadership that feels the need to provide a misguided balance in their statements about these unfortunate incidents. IMO if President Obama merely said nothing on the grounds that these incidents are local matters and he shouldn’t insinuate himself into them or supported the police unconditionally we’d all be better off.

The forum post at the Watcher’s site is here.

20 comments

The Exception That Proves the Rule

In his essay “America Is Not A Pure Democracy”, James Huffman recapitulates the facts of the American system. Under the Constitution we are not a “pure democracy” but a representative democracy in which representatives constrained by the limits of the Constitution are elected by votes of eligible electors.

Our present system is no longer one in which ” individual rights would prevail over national (and later state) power”. Over time that system has transmogrified into one under which factions (known as “political parties”) put forward candidates and one of two of the factions’ candidates is inevitably elected. In some jurisdictions, e.g. Chicago, for practical purposes a single faction’s candidate will inevitably be elected. The range of action of these factional representatives is limited not by the Constitution but predominantly by the self-interest of the representatives themselves.

Our present system, while calling itself “democracy”, more closely resembles a hereditary aristocracy than it does the system the Founders imagined.

In his essay Mr. Huffman repeats the conventional claim against “pure democracy”:

Factions and the tyranny of the majority remain threats wherever democracy is unconstrained. Witness the sad fates of Germany under Adolph Hitler, Zimbabwe under Robert Mugabe, the Philippines under Ferdinand Marcos, Venezuela under Hugo Chávez, Bolivia under Evo Morales, and Russia under Vladimir Putin, all democratically elected leaders. The lesson, in the oft-quoted words of Winston Churchill, is that “democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.” As the foregoing examples underscore, democracy can fail with horrific consequences.

There is an exception to that rule: Switzerland. Switzerland’s median adult income is higher than ours (it’s more prosperous) and its Gini coefficient is lower than ours (it’s more equal) and it is for practical purposes a “pure democracy”. Every decision of any importance is subjected to a national referendum. Recently the Swiss have rejected a very high minimum wage (amounting to about $50,000) and a guaranteed annual income.

I have no explanation for why Switzerland has been able to avoid the “evils of faction” of which Madison warned but I think it’s something worth reflecting on.

3 comments

During Good Behavior

The editors of the Wall Street Journal took stock of Justice Ginsburg’s political advocacy over the last month or so:

It’s important to understand how far out of bounds Justice Ginsburg was in her comments to the New York Times. She barged into the presidential race by saying “I can’t imagine what the country would be with Donald Trump as our president,” joking that her late husband would say they should move to New Zealand if he won. The Justice kept it up in an interview on Monday with CNN, calling Mr. Trump “a faker” and wondering “how has he gotten away with not turning over his tax returns?”

Such overt partisanship from a judge should disqualify her from hearing any case related to the presidential election—such as voter ID laws. It would also raise doubts about her fairness in judging executive-branch actions if Mr. Trump becomes President.

Justice Ginsburg further violated judicial norms by lecturing the Senate for not confirming President Obama’s Supreme Court nominee, Merrick Garland. “That’s their job,” she said. “There’s nothing in the Constitution that says the president stops being president in his last year.”

There’s also nothing in the Constitution that says the Senate can’t operate on its own schedule or even that it must vote on a nominee. Judges—especially Justices who are supposed to set a judicial example—are supposed to stay out of such political disputes unless they become controversies that merit adjudication.

going on to catalogue other violations of judicial norms and decorum on Justice Ginsburg’s part.

There are times when being chief justice is no bed of roses and this is one of them. Chief Justice Roberts should direct Justice Ginsburg to undergo physical and psychiatric evaluation to determine her fitness to continue in office. If she refuses he has any number of disciplinary measures within his power to employ, the most severe being to make a formal request of the Congress that she be removed from office, something I think is not yet called for.

Defenses of Justice Ginsburg’s actions have been on a purely partisan basis. There were debates in the Missouri legislature over whether Justice Thomas should be disbarred. Justice Ginsburg’s poor judgment and abandonment of judicial detachment recently are at least at that level.

0 comments

Can Clinton Win in a Change Election?

At the Wall Street Journal James Taranto provides a litany of the bad polling news for the Clinton campaign:

There’s more bad polling news for Mrs. Clinton. A new Quinnipiac swing-state survey finds Trump leading in Florida (42% to 39%) and Pennsylvania (43% to 41%) and tied with Mrs. Clinton in Ohio (41%). Trump does better when Johnson and Stein are included in the question, leading by five points in Florida, six in Pennsylvania and one in Ohio. Other findings:

Voters [in the three states] still say [Mrs.] Clinton is more intelligent than Trump and that she is better prepared to be president. But Clinton has lost her wide lead over Trump for having “higher moral standards.” And Trump widens his lead over Clinton for being more honest and trustworthy.

The Washington Examiner reports a Monmouth poll finds Trump leading Mrs. Clinton 42% to 40% in Iowa, a state Democrats have carried in six of the past seven elections (George W. Bush won in 2004).

Nationwide polls also are trending Trumpward. NBC News/Survey Monkey has Mrs. Clinton’s lead at three points, 47% to 44% narrowing to two points (40% to 38%) in a four-way race. McClatchy gives Mrs. Clinton a 42% to 39% lead, though (in contrast to the other polls) it widens to five points (40% to 35%) in a four-way race.

Note how many of these polling results show the return of our old friend, Marge Genovera. It’s too close to call.

I have been saying all along that this election will hinge on turnout. Will Bernie Sanders’s tepid endorsement encourage his supporters enough to turn out for Sec. Clinton? Will Sec. Clinton’s promises of federal largesse be enough to move them?

As I’ve also been saying all along the polls will be more meaningful after the conventions and the states to watch will be Pennsylvania, Ohio, Florida, and Virginia. For Sec. Clinton to prevail she needs to hold all of the states that President Obama carried in 2012. For Donald Trump to win he needs to turn some of those states his way.

5 comments