The Insurance Business Is Hard

I’m not quite sure how you argue that this is a success. Of the 23 non-profit member-run insurers that started out offering healthcare insurance through the federal marketplace in 2014, only 8 will continue to do so in OE4, the fourth open enrollment period that begins this fall. From the Washington Post:

The number of insurers carrying out one of the Affordable Care Act’s most idealistic goals continues to plummet, with just eight nonprofit member-run health plans set to take part in the law’s fourth enrollment season this fall.

That’s down from 23 such plans — co-ops, as they are commonly known — that started in 2014. Eleven are still in business, but three in Oregon, Ohio and Connecticut will fold soon because of financial insolvency. Just this month, Oregon’s Health Co-Op and Connecticut’s HealthyCT were ordered to close by their state’s regulators.

For the rest — which all posted annual losses in 2015, according to the National Alliance of State Health Co-ops — survival is Job No. 1. Some co-ops are diversifying to serve larger employers, no longer limiting themselves to their ACA mandate to offer health plans to individuals and small businesses. Others are trying to renegotiate contracts with hospitals and other providers.

My interpretation of that is that the the healthcare insurance business is quite difficult under the restrictions imposed by the Affordable Care Act. It’s hard for experienced, established carriers and it’s that much harder for newcomers.

It won’t be a disaster if no co-ops continue to participate. The for-profit insurance companies will still be there. The open question is what happens if nobody is offering insurance in some of the markets? Nobody really knows.

9 comments

Come for the Graphic, Stay for the Misconceptions

I found the graphic at the top of this post at TCW so charming I started reading the article. I got to one sentence in the middle of the post and just couldn’t get past it.

I’ve written about this in the past. Sometimes I find something so egregiously wrong I just can’t read any farther. Here’s the sentence:

Consumption now is always prioritized over consumption later, which is why interest rates have been positive for centuries.

That’s either wrong or confusingly worded. What is true is that all investment is consuming less now in order to consume more later or, said another way, positive interest rates are offered as incentives. But here’s the problem:

Country Personal Savings Rate
Switzerland 34.8%
United States 4.6%

Get it? The Swiss are consuming so little now it’s threatening Switzerland’s economy now. The Swiss central bank is so desperate it’s imposed a relatively high 1.2% negative rate of interest. Will it work? It’s the first time it’s every been tried. Who knows?

0 comments

Is China’s Past Real or Imagined?

Compare this story at Nature:

Keen to get to the bottom of its people’s ancestry, China has in the past decade stepped up its efforts to uncover evidence of early humans across the country. It is reanalysing old fossil finds and pouring tens of millions of dollars a year into excavations. And the government is setting up a US$1.1-million laboratory at the IVPP to extract and sequence ancient DNA.

The investment comes at a time when palaeoanthropologists across the globe are starting to pay more attention to Asian fossils and how they relate to other early hominins — creatures that are more closely related to humans than to chimps. Finds in China and other parts of Asia have made it clear that a dazzling variety of Homo species once roamed the continent. And they are challenging conventional ideas about the evolutionary history of humanity.

“Many Western scientists tend to see Asian fossils and artefacts through the prism of what was happening in Africa and Europe,” says Wu. Those other continents have historically drawn more attention in studies of human evolution because of the antiquity of fossil finds there, and because they are closer to major palaeoanthropology research institutions, he says. “But it’s increasingly clear that many Asian materials cannot fit into the traditional narrative of human evolution.”

with my observations in an earlier post. I believe you’ll find a connecting thread.

Some additional points:

  • The Peking Man fossils, claimed to be the oldest discovered in China to date, were lost during World War II. Without their being available for study using modern techniques, we can’t honestly say what they were.
  • The Chinese history that has been taught both in China and the West for most of the last millennium is known to have been fabricated by Song dynasty scholars. I’ve written on this subject before.

Searching for a glorious and very ancient past is a time-hallowed pursuit, particularly on the part of upstarts. It’s why the Greeks tried to find a relationship between their own society and ancient Egyptian society, the Romans tried to link their civilization to Greek mythology, and why Americans look to Greek and Roman antecedents rather than to the more obvious Italian humanists who were (horrors!) Papists.

I find China’s national socialist government’s interest in demonstrating how ancient and distinct (and superior!) the Chinese people are concerning, particularly in light of our experience in the last century with a certain European fascist government.

0 comments

China’s Interests

The graphic above illustrates the absurdity of China’s claims in the South China Sea, on which I commented earlier. In the article at CNN from which the graphic was sampled, law prof William Burke-White observed:

To a large degree, international legal efforts to accommodate the rise of China have been based on avoiding direct legal conflict where possible and allowing politics and diplomacy to take their natural course. Had the court accepted the Chinese position on jurisdiction, the conflict between law and power that now arises could have been put off to another day.

The court’s findings — both that it has the power to decide the case and that China’s claims are illegal — mark the first significant international legal confrontation with a rising China. It is a bold move by the court, one that pits the authority and legitimacy of the legal institutions created by the post-World War II international order against the political and economic might of China. The question now is how both sides will respond. The answer will be more significant than the ruling itself.

Will China accept the legal principles on which the decision is based? These principles are, in fact, in China’s long-term interests, as they offer the best prospect for the avoidance of a military conflict in the region consistent with China’s peaceful rise. China need not accept them openly or publicly, but it can do so through a gradual change in its rhetoric and behavior.

I can’t help but think that Mr. Burke-White imagines a China different from the one that actually exists. The real China is chafing under real and imagined past and present slights. Respect is as real an interest to that China as the Phillippines’s exclusive economic zone is to the Phillippines or freedom of navigation is to the United States. The failure to recognize non-economic interests is a weakness of not just U. S. foreign policy but Western foreign policy more generally.

0 comments

Vital National Interests

Yesterday an arbitration court at The Hague ruled against China’s claims to the South China Sea. See Reuters report. China, as should have been expected, angrily rejected the court’s findings. Today the opinion pages are buzzing.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal noted:

A United Nations tribunal ruled Tuesday that China’s sovereignty claims over the South China Sea, and its aggressive attempts to enforce them, violate international law. This is a necessary rebuke to Beijing, but it comes with no enforcement measures and Chinese leaders have rejected it. So its effect will depend on how China’s neighbors and the United States respond. International norms can’t survive without democracies willing to defend them.

China’s record in the South China Sea belies its promises to pursue a “peaceful rise.” By asserting “indisputable sovereignty” over an area larger than the Mediterranean and encroaching on the territory and rights of others, Beijing has threatened the rules-based order that has given Asia decades of prosperity. Its pillars include freedom of navigation and the peaceful settlement of disputes.

Though the South China Sea is the main economic artery of the world’s most dynamic and populous region, the stakes are even broader. As French defense chief Jean-Yves Le Drian noted recently: “If the law of the sea is not respected today in the China seas, it will be threatened tomorrow in the Arctic, the Mediterranean or elsewhere.” Vladimir Putin and other authoritarians are paying attention.

At the Washington Post scholar Paul Gewirtz remarked:

These are major legal conclusions, but they will produce no immediate resolution to the conflict. Despite being a signatory to the convention, China refused to participate in the arbitration and has denounced the decision as “null and void.” China is clearly wrong. But its sweeping rejection reveals the practical limits of law in this context because the tribunal has no enforcement powers — no police force, no sanctions system, no ability to levy fines.

Another fundamental limit is that the tribunal lacks legal power to resolve underlying and potentially explosive conflicts regarding sovereignty over land features, such as the dangerously contested Scarborough Shoal, and disputes over maritime boundaries. And of course no court’s decision can fully address the core geopolitical issues at stake: China’s enormous new capacities, widespread uncertainty about China’s regional intentions, and whether China and the United States can find terms of coexistence in the Asia-Pacific.

So what is the path forward? The United States and other countries should strongly support the tribunal’s judgment as a binding decision in words and deeds. The United States should criticize China’s statements that it will not comply with the tribunal’s conclusions. And it should continue regular freedom-of-navigation operations, taking advantage of any additional navigation rights produced by the tribunal’s decision.

I agree completely with Mr. Gewirtz’s prescriptions to that point. Then he enters the realm of fantasy:

Instead, the United States should encourage our Filipino allies — with their legal victory in hand — to pursue direct negotiations with China as the best next step in looking for real-world, peaceful solutions. China has long demanded negotiations, so this is the testing hour for China’s good faith.

Neither country should insist on preconditions to such talks. China should not insist that the Philippines renounce the arbitration award, and the Philippines should not insist that China accept the legal rights awarded by the tribunal. Such demands would doom negotiations before they started. The path of negotiations will be uncertain and difficult. But the Philippines’ position will be significantly strengthened by the tribunal’s award. Negotiations should begin with a focus on lowering tensions, looking for trade-offs and pursuing common development projects, even if ultimate questions of sovereignty are temporarily set aside.

I wish that Mr. Gewirtz had elaborated on what he thought the shape of an agreement might be. I think there’s a good reason he didn’t: no agreement is possible. Vital national interests of all three countries are at stake and neither China, the United States, or the Phillippines can or should be expected to negotiate away vital national interests.

How could such negotiations significantly strengthen the Phillippines’s position? Its position is already at its maximum strength. They have a legal settlement in their favor and China’s position could hardly be flimsier. It’s based on Chinese fishermen fishing in those waters. By that standard the United States owns every ocean in the world and the laws of the sea are completely vitiated.

0 comments

A Lack of Judicial Temperament

The editors of the New York Times criticized Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s insinuating herself into the presidential campaign on the side of Hillary Clinton:

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg needs to drop the political punditry and the name-calling.

Three times in the past week, Justice Ginsburg has publicly discussed her view of the presidential race, in the sharpest terms. In an interview with The Times published Sunday, Justice Ginsburg said, “I can’t imagine what the country would be — with Donald Trump as our president,” joking that if her husband were alive, he might have said, “It’s time for us to move to New Zealand.”

adding two more statements of Justice Ginsburg’s to their litany. They followed up with this:

Mr. Trump responded on Tuesday. “I think it’s highly inappropriate that a United States Supreme Court judge gets involved in a political campaign, frankly,” he told The Times. “I couldn’t believe it when I saw it.”

The editors of the Washington Post wrote in a similar vein:

As journalists, we generally favor more openness and disclosure from public figures rather than less. Yet Justice Ginsburg’s off-the-cuff remarks about the campaign fall into that limited category of candor that we can’t admire, because it’s inconsistent with her function in our democratic system.

The editors of the Chicago Tribune declaimed:

If Trump is elected, Ginsburg may be expected to rule on the constitutionality or legality of the policies he pursues. Can anyone assume that she’ll put aside her disdain for him and give them a fair hearing? If President Trump were to lose a case, wouldn’t he have plausible grounds to claim, as he often does, “The system is rigged”?

The Supreme Court commands respect and deference from the citizenry partly because it stands outside of petty politics. When a member of the court strides into that muck, she may help a candidate, but she hurts the cause of justice.

Here’s the scenario I think we should consider. Had Ruth Bader Ginsburg made these statements prior to being appointed to the Supreme Court, she wouldn’t be sitting there now due to her being perceived as lacking judicial temperament. Being appointed a Supreme Court Justice is not a license to abandon being a good judge.

4 comments

Marge Genovera

From the NBC tracking poll the results of which are depicted in the graph above I infer the following:

  • Support for the two candidates is very close.
  • Most of the time it’s within the margin of error. In other words on those occasions, e.g. now, when the two candidates are at their closest, it’s actually possible that Trump is leading.
  • Hillary Clinton barely if ever cracks 50%.

We don’t elect candidates at large. It doesn’t matter whether Hillary Clinton wins California’s or New York’s electoral votes by getting the plurality of the popular vote or 100% of the popular vote. She’ll get the same number of electoral votes either way. The polls to watch to are those in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Florida, Virginia, and a few other states and pay more attention after September than now.

Here’s what NBC News has to say:

Hillary Clinton’s lead over Donald Trump narrowed to 3 points this week after several days of controversy following FBI Director James Comey’s recommendation that no criminal charges be brought against the former secretary of state over her use of a private email server.

While the developments are certainly good news for the Clinton campaign, Comey’s critical statement on Clinton’s handling of the matter was not positive. Clinton’s lead over Trump has deteriorated in the past couple weeks since her lead peaked two weeks ago.

A strong majority of voters (82 percent) agreed that it was inappropriate for Clinton to use a personal email server during her tenure as secretary of state. A smaller majority — 56 percent — also said they disagreed with Comey’s recommendation that Clinton not be prosecuted for use of the server.

It’s still not too late for both parties to select candidates that are fit for office but it will be soon.

10 comments

Healthcare Reform Status Report

Speaking of status reports, Jason Johnson presents a helpful status report on healthcare reform at The Root:

The Affordable Care Act had two main stated goals: The first was to increase the number of Americans who have some form of health coverage, and the second was to make health care more affordable. The first goal has been accomplished. While there are caveats, most private analyses show that about 16 million Americans have gained health care coverage through the ACA. Most of these people are poor, under 30 and minorities. However, on the cost end, the ACA has driven up costs for millions of Americans, a reality that has a disproportionate impact on minority communities, especially when it comes to pharmaceuticals.

and most of those who are newly covered are covered through the expansion of Medicaid. “Medicaid for All” does not seem to have caught on as a campaign slogan but, as I pointed out in 2009, that’s the direction in which we’re pointed.

I’ve also seen renewed calls for the “public option”, including by the president himself yesterday. The argument as I understand it is that in markets in which there is only one insurer the federal government should step in to provide “competition”. How a public insurer that depends on the taxpayer can be characterized reasonably as competition for a private company is unclear to me.

The number of insurers participating in the marketplace is shrinking and in most states those continuing to participate are losing money. California is an exception to that pattern for reasons that aren’t clear to me. As the number of insurers continues to dwindle, expect more calls for increased federal subsidies. I can’t justify private insurers dependent on federal subsidies. I think that fully government-provided insurance (perhaps I need to put double-quotes around the word “insurance”—what’s being proposed does not sound like insurance to me but like a benefit) would probably be preferable to public-private hybrids. I can’t honestly tell whether advocates really believe their neoliberal fantasies or whether it’s a mere cynical hat-tip.

4 comments

Part Cherokee

There’s an article at Timeline that presents a very interesting case for why so many white Americans with Southern roots claim to have Cherokee ancestry when it’s just not possible that many people could. Meagan Day suggests it’s a way of asserting genuine Southern identity:

First, let’s look at who claims to be Cherokee: Elizabeth Warren, Johnny Cash, Johnny Depp, Miley Cyrus, and Bill Clinton for starters. Their families are from Oklahoma, Arkansas, Kentucky, Tennessee/Kentucky, and Arkansas again, respectively. White people claiming Cherokee heritage are especially common in the Southeast United States, where the Cherokee lived between 1000 A.D. and the 1838–9 forced relocation known as the Trail of Tears. That makes these claims somewhat plausible, because early on Cherokee people did intermarry with white settlers at an uncommonly high rate compared to other Native American tribes. Still, the number of people claiming Cherokee heritage far outstrips the number of possible descendants from these intermarriages.

Second, let’s look at when white people started to claim Native American heritage in the Southeast. It was in the 1840s or 50s, as the federal challenge to Southern slavery was growing stronger and Civil War loomed on the horizon, that Southerners first started to claim “Cherokee blood.” In the decades prior to the Trail of Tears, Cherokee intermarriage with white settlers had dropped off, as white Southern public opinion had turned against Cherokees. For white people to claim distant Cherokee heritage in 1855 or so had the interesting effect of “legitimating the antiquity of their native-born status as sons or daughters of the South,” as Gregory Smithers writes in Slate. In a crucial moment of swelling Southern pride, pointing out that your family had been here long enough to intermarry with Cherokees was a method of staking a claim to Southern identity. Southern white identity.

I think there’s another possibility. Could it be that a very large number of white Southerners have one or more black ancestors, possibly light-skinned blacks who were passing as whites? Cherokee ancestry would have been a much more socially acceptable way of explaining those family pictures than black ancestry.

7 comments

The Iran Deal

In his column at the Wall Street Journal Bret Stephens provides a status report on our deal with Iran:

“The illegal proliferation-sensitive procurement activities [by Iran] in Germany registered by the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution persisted in 2015 at what is, even by international standards, a quantitatively high level. This holds true in particular with regard to items which can be used in the field of nuclear technology.”

The report also notes “a further increase in the already considerable procurement efforts in connection with Iran’s ambitious missile technology program which could among other things potentially serve to deliver nuclear weapons. Against this backdrop it is safe to expect that Iran will continue its intensive procurement activities in Germany using clandestine methods to achieve its objectives.”

The BfV report arrived days before Germany arrested a Pakistani national, identified as Syed Mustufa H., accused of spying for Iran. It also corroborates another German intelligence report, this one from the intelligence service of North Rhine-Westphalia, that Iran’s nuclear procurement efforts have increased dramatically in recent years, from 48 known attempts in 2010 to 141 in 2015. Seven other German states have reported similar Iranian procurement efforts. This violates Iran’s explicit commitment to go through an official “procurement channel” to purchase nuclear- and missile-related materials.

and

One last detail: In June, the Journal’s Jay Solomon reported that the International Atomic Energy Agency had discovered “traces of man-made uranium” at Iran’s military facility at Parchin. The agency reported this finding in a footnote to a report in December, but the administration made no comment then and now dismisses it as old news. The IAEA is no longer allowed to inspect Parchin, or any other military installation, under the deal.

So let’s recap. Mr. Obama says Iran is honoring the nuclear deal, but German intelligence tells us Tehran is violating it more aggressively than ever. He promised “snapback” sanctions in the event of such violations, but the U.S. is operating as Iran’s trade-promotion agent. He promised “unprecedented” inspections, but we’re not permitted to inspect sites where uranium was found. He promised an eight-year ban on Iran’s testing of ballistic missiles, but Tehran violated that ban immediately and repeatedly with only mild pushback from the West. He promised that the nuclear deal was not about “normalizing” relations with a rogue regime. But he wants it in the WTO.

As a reminder my view of the deal was that

  1. I understood what Iran got out of the deal; I didn’t think we got nearly enough out of the deal.
  2. The deal always made the most sense, paradoxically, if you thought the Iranians were lying and couldn’t be trusted.

It seems to be working out pretty much as you’d expect if my view were correct.

3 comments