Working As Designed

Here’s the kernel of the extract from Joseph Stiglitz’s new book posted at The Guardian:

On both sides of the Channel, politics should be directed at understanding the underlying sources of anger; how, in a democracy, the political establishment could have done so little to address the concerns of so many citizens, and figuring out how to do that now: to create within each country, and through cross-border arrangements, a new, more democratic Europe, which sees its goal as improving the wellbeing of ordinary citizens. This can’t be done with the neoliberal ideology that has prevailed for a third of a century and played such an important role in the construction of the euro. And it won’t be done if we confuse ends with means – the euro is not an end in itself, but a means, which, if well managed, might bring greater shared prosperity, but, if not well managed, will lead to lower standards of living for many or possibly the majority of citizens.

and the euro doesn’t do that.

I don’t think that Dr. Stiglitz understands the purposes of the European Union and the euro. The purpose of the European Union was to open markets for German manufacturers and provide subsidies for French farmers. The purpose of the euro was to facilitate those two goals. Poking a stick in the Americans’ collective eye was a plus.

Both are working as designed.

1 comment

Policy or Dogma?

After reading the umpteenth editorial, article, or post about the effects of increasing the minimum wage, I have a question. Is there anything that would convince proponents of an increase in the federal minimum wage that it’s a bad idea?

I’m not an opponent of the idea so much as a skeptic and I can say what would convince me to support increasing the minimum wage to $15/hour: show that the number of jobs did not decline, job growth did not slow, and median income rose. Even shorter: show that the number of people being helped greatly outnumbered the number of people being hurt.

2 comments

The Shorter Version

To save you the trouble of reading Bryan Riley’s post at RealClearPolicy, “Trade With China Is a Net Plus for Americans”, here’s a summary. The number of jobs lost in manufacturing since 1991 has been more than made up by the number of jobs in fast food and hospitality.

10 comments

Second Verse Same As the First

At Bloomberg Luke Kawa notes that despite better-than-expected employment situation reports, the U. S. economy continues to have the problem that has plagued it for decades:

The manifold headwinds on productivity growth (a mass retirement of the most experienced workers, a prolonged period of rising oil prices before a sharp retreat, the slow integration of new innovative technologies into the production process, and above all, soft business investment) means policy rates will stay even lower throughout this cycle than the subdued levels monetary policymakers think they’ll eventually reach over the long haul, according to Bank of America Merrill Lynch analysts.

The problem will persist as long as policymakers continue to fetishize GDP rather than, say, the median income.

He concludes by warning of a recession to come:

A pick-up in capital spending by businesses will presumably foster a commensurate rise in productivity, which would allow even companies without a large deal of pricing power to avoid choosing between pressuring their profit margins or raising costs for their customers.
Otherwise, as the Deutsche Bank team writes, “this could well be a cycle that does indeed die of old age,” with Corporate America electing to cut jobs to maintain profitability and ultimately fostering a downturn in consumer spending.

That’s unlikely to happen with the present crew of managers who are more interested in padding their compensation plans than they are in building businesses. And they’re just pursuing the incentives before them.

2 comments

What’s Really Happening?

I have a number of remarks to make about David Brooks’s most recent NYT column, “The Great Affluence Fallacy”:

In 18th-century America, colonial society and Native American society sat side by side. The former was buddingly commercial; the latter was communal and tribal. As time went by, the settlers from Europe noticed something: No Indians were defecting to join colonial society, but many whites were defecting to live in the Native American one.

This struck them as strange. Colonial society was richer and more advanced. And yet people were voting with their feet the other way.

The colonials occasionally tried to welcome Native American children into their midst, but they couldn’t persuade them to stay. Benjamin Franklin observed the phenomenon in 1753, writing, “When an Indian child has been brought up among us, taught our language and habituated to our customs, yet if he goes to see his relations and make one Indian ramble with them, there is no persuading him ever to return.”

During the wars with the Indians, many European settlers were taken prisoner and held within Indian tribes. After a while, they had plenty of chances to escape and return, and yet they did not. In fact, when they were “rescued,” they fled and hid from their rescuers.

Sometimes the Indians tried to forcibly return the colonials in a prisoner swap, and still the colonials refused to go. In one case, the Shawanese Indians were compelled to tie up some European women in order to ship them back. After they were returned, the women escaped the colonial towns and ran back to the Indians.

Even as late as 1782, the pattern was still going strong. Hector de Crèvecoeur wrote, “Thousands of Europeans are Indians, and we have no examples of even one of those aborigines having from choice become European.”

I first read about this history several months ago in Sebastian Junger’s excellent book “Tribe.” It has haunted me since. It raises the possibility that our culture is built on some fundamental error about what makes people happy and fulfilled.

What I have to say is not so much critiques as observations.

First, I think that any generalization about the relations between European settlers and the descendants of pre-Columbian Americans (called “Indians” in the remainder of my remarks) is suspect. They remind me of nothing so much as the old joke about the drunk searching for his lost keys under a lamppost rather than in the darkness of the stoop where he dropped them because the light was better there. Previous to about 1900, the records just aren’t good enough to support generalizations. Instead what you’ll get are judgments colored with political bias.

The Indians were divided into nations. Lumping these nations together and drawing broad conclusions is too reductive. The Creek, Choctaw, and Cherokee tended to adopt European manners to a greater degree than, say, the Huron or Erie.

Second, I don’t think the wall dividing the descendants of the European settlers from Indians is quite as high or solid as Mr. Brooks apparently does. By the 18th century interactions between the settlers and the Indians had been going on for 200 years—eight generations. Let’s consider a single example.

When Columbus’s ships sighted land in the western hemisphere, as well as we can determine the horse had been extinct in the Americas for millennia. By 1700 the horse was an important part of the culture of the Indians in western North America. That means that by 1700 even in the far reaches of the West, the Indians had already adopted European manners to some degree.

Note, too, that the cross-pollination of cultures went both ways. By 1700 Americans had adopted Indian agricultural practices, ways of war, governmental structures, and, possibly, religious beliefs. If white Americans considered the Indians “savages”, so, too, did the Europeans consider white Americans.

Until the 20th century most Americans lived in small, rural, agrarian communities which were much more, well, community-oriented than cities in the 18th century let alone the 20th century. To whatever degree whites were impelled to join the Indians, I suspect it was more to find wives than because they hankered after a way of life that wasn’t as different from the one they’d left as Mr. Brooks seems to believe. Other than, possibly, it was less work. Any number of anthropological studies have found that hunter-gatherer-horticulturists spend less time working than agriculturists do.

Third, I think Mr. Brooks’s observations about millennials are suspect. That life in the United States of the late 20th and early 21st centuries is isolating has been noted frequently. That’s what the book Bowling Alone is about. Millennials have grown up in an environment of great isolation but also one of great choice. With 150 varieties of toothpaste and as many kinds of juice they could have what suited them. Or play The Little Mermaid for the 500th time.

I would also note that it’s a lot easier to be skeptical of or even hostile to affluence when you’re living in your parents’ basement.

My observation of businesses that consist largely of millennials is that they are not so much an attempt at building a community as they are like a gathering of Facebook friends. A self-selecting group of people who share common experiences, attitudes, and beliefs while heretics and non-conformists are driven out—unfriended. More The Midwich Cuckoos than Our Daily Bread.

Finally, I don’t much care if millennials find groups with diverse attitudes and beliefs uncomfortable so long as they allow me the same discretion.

0 comments

Repeal the FELRTCA

If even half of the account of the Food and Drug Administration review of the muscular dystrophy drug eteplirsen recounted by the editors of the Wall Street Journal is true, serious disciplinary action is required:

Ten of 12 boys with Duchenne muscular dystrophy walk after four years of treatment on eteplirsen, which produces the protein dystrophin. FDA has pushed off approval for the first-in-class treatment, asking for more time or even months-long delays blamed on snow. In June FDA asked the drug’s sponsor, Sarepta Therapeutics, for readouts from a continuing trial, which the company said it would provide shortly. Since then, radio silence from the FDA.

It’s no secret that the drug’s detractors are career employees in the neurology division, two of whom opposed approval at a public FDA meeting in April: Eric Bastings, deputy director of the division; and Ronald Farkas, a clinical team leader. The pair say the drug doesn’t produce “enough” dystrophin, or maybe any dystrophin, depending on which day you ask. Janet Woodcock, head of the drug evaluation center, can overrule the department and the recommendations of an advisory panel.

The question is whether someone in the division is holding up an approval by Dr. Woodcock with what is known as a differing-professional-opinions proceeding, which is an agency process for handling scientific disputes. According to FDA manuals, this involves a panel review that can take weeks or more, and an appeals channel can escalate to FDA Commissioner Robert Califf. This is the only logical explanation for the continuing delay, as FDA could have rejected the drug already if the data were junk. (An FDA spokesman declined comment.)

The Federal Employees Liability Reform and Tort Compensation Act of 1988 provides an absolute shield to federal employees from civil suit whether they are doing their jobs properly or not, whether they are breaking the law or not, and whether they are acting within the discretion authorized in their official duties or not. We should return to the earlier, more limited common law standard under which officials were only shielded if they were carrying out their duties and acting within their authorized discretion. Agencies should not defend employees who are malfeasant, misfeasant, or nonfeasant.

We deserve public employees who are carrying out the people’s business in a fair, unbiased, and timely manner. That is even more urgent as the boundaries of government power expand.

4 comments

Delta’s Missed Opportunity

My reaction on hearing about Delta’s woes, reported here at USA Today:

Delta’s flight woes from a computer glitch carried over into a second day Tuesday, escalating to the point where CEO Ed Bastian issued his second apology in as many days.

“This isn’t the quality of service, the reliability that you’ve come to expect from Delta Air Lines,” Bastian said in a statement posted to the airline’s website at 4 p.m. ET. “We’re very sorry, I’m personally very sorry.”

Bastian’s apology came as Delta’s schedule was riddled with delays and cancellations for the second day in a row. The airline said it canceled about 530 flights as of 12:30 p.m. ET on Tuesday. Additionally, another 950 flights were delayed at of 4:50 p.m. ET, according to flight-tracking service FlightAware. Combined, that mean close to 1 out of every 4 Delta flights had either been delayed or canceled as of early afternoon. Delta operates about 6,000 flights a day.

Tuesday’s woes follow a Monday that saw Delta cancel 1,000 flights and delay nearly 3,000 others. The carrier’s computer system went down early Monday morning after a power outage at the company’s Atlanta headquarters.

was that I’d really like to see Delta’s business continuity and disaster recovery plan. It looks to me as though it could use some updating.

Delta is a publicly-traded company and as such it’s subject to the requirements of Sarbanes-Oxley. One of the Sarb-Ox requirements is that its top management are obligated to certify that they understand the risks under which the company operates and I don’t see how they could possibly do that without having developed an effective BC-DR plan. They very clearly don’t have one which means they’re out of compliance.

Too bad the Justice Department doesn’t enforce the law any more.

Real life opportunities to test your BC-DR plan don’t come along every day (thankfully). Delta had an opportunity to try out its BC-DR plan and shine. Whoops.

4 comments

Cult of Personality

I agree with the editors of Bloomberg: Donald Trump does not have a plan for the economy. He has a posture.

An even better formulation was stated in comments here. A vote for Trump isn’t a vote for a policy. It’s a vote for Trump.

No, thank you.

We want something else.

16 comments

Democracy’s Failures

At RealClearPolitics Michael Barone presents two explanations for why liberal democracy seems to be falling all over its own feet lately:

One answer is that success breeds failure. As the economic journalist Robert Samuelson has argued, the apparent success of 1960s Keynesian pump-priming led to the 1970s stagflation, and the apparent success of 1980s and 1990s central bankers led to the 2007-2008 crash.

Another is that elites remain preoccupied with problems that have long been solved. Angela Merkel, raised in East Germany, naturally abhors walls. But the Berlin Wall came down in 1989, 27 years ago. Eurocrats believe the EU prevents another war between France and Germany. The last one ended in 1945, 71 years ago.

That second explanation is my explanation for the antipathy towards Russia among American elites. It’s a bad habit.

Highly successful people are strongly predisposed to keep doing the things that brought them success in the past. Old Cold Warriors never die; apparently they don’t even fade away.

Is liberal democracy really failing? I’m reminded of a couple of famous quotes. The first is from Winston Churchill to the effect that democracy is the worst form of government except for all of the others.

The other is a riff on something written by G. K. Chesterton. It is not that liberal democracy has been tried and found wanting but that it has been found inconvenient to would-be autocrats and not been tried.

3 comments

Optimize Where There’s Something to Optimize

This story from Japan, reported by NDTV, highlights a point I’ve made in the past:

TOKYO: Japanese doctors have for the first time used artificial intelligence (AI) to detect a type of leukemia, which helped to save a patient’s life as the disease had gone undetected using conventional methods.

The University of Tokyo’s Institute of Medical Science has successfully employed the new method of diagnosis, which includes a computer programme capable of analysing a huge volume of medical data, Arinobu Tojo, a member of the medical team, told Efe news on Friday.

The system, named Watson and jointly developed by the US’ IBM and other firms, concluded that the patient concerned suffered from a rare type of leukemia after the patient’s genetic information was compared with 20 million clinical oncology studies.

The patient, a 60-year-old woman, was initially diagnosed with acute myeloid leukemia, which she was unsuccessfully treated for with several different anti-cancer drugs, leaving doctors confounded, Tojo said.

Consequently, the medical team decided to use the Watson system, which, on analysing the data available, concluded the patient suffered from another form of leukemia and recommended a different treatment which was successful.

The conventional method of diagnosis for different types of leukemia is based on an evaluation by a team of medical specialists after studying the genetic information of patients as well as the clinical studies available; an enormous task owing to the huge amount of data to be gone through.

Expert systems that do just this sort of thing should be cheap, widespread and part of the standard of care. That’s not the case because of shortcomings of the technology but because of U. S. regulation and the opposition of physicians.

Human doctors should do more of what human doctors do best. Let machines do what they do best. Medical practice and education will need to change accordingly.

0 comments