s Yale economist Ray Fair has documented, people really do vote their pocketbooks: Below-trend GDP growth, rising unemployment or increasing inflation almost always dooms the incumbent party.
That reality has Democrats more scared than Hillary Clinton’s emails or her dismal likeability and trust ratings.
Simply put, the current “recovery†is the weakest on record. GDP growth has been below the long-term trend of 3.1% in all but seven of the last 30 quarters. Fair’s statistical model of election outcomes predicts a Republican victory on that basis alone.
The Democrats are doing their utmost to distract attention from these facts. President Obama continues to brag that his policies rescued the economy from the brink of another Great Depression. As for Clinton, she vacillates between promising to jump-start the economy and defending the Obama administration’s record. Clinton surrogates tell us the economy is a whole lot better than it was when Obama took office, and even better than we think it is.
my reaction was that Democrats really need to make up their minds. If their story of the Great Recession is that it was regular business cycle recession, deeper than other many others but otherwise not particularly different, they need to step up to the reality of the facts that Dr. Schiller lays out. Practically every measure proposed since 2008 has been ordinary Keynesian pump-priming and it’s flopped.
If, on the other hand, the recession was as serious as it was because of excessive indebtedness, a “balance sheet recession”, they should be demanding that President Obama and, presumably, President Clinton if she takes over the Oval Office in January address the specific problems of a balance sheet recession. We should be able to do better than 1% growth.
According to David Breeze in his book Roman Scotland, Frontier Country, the Caledonians appeared to be “doughty fighters†with Roman statesman Dio crediting the “fearsome and dangerous†men with standing their ground over the two-year battle.
Others have suggested that the “guerilla tactics†of the Caledonians were the perfect assault on disciplined Roman fighters.
While I realize that the Scots would like to think they held the Romans at bay, I think there’s another more likely explanation. The Romans couldn’t grow grapes in Scotland which meant that they couldn’t continue their way of life in permanent settlements there.
The Domesday Book of 1087, William the Conqueror’s “great survey” of England and Wales, is an excellent record of the economy there at the time. All of the vineyards listed in Domesday were south of a line running from Ely in Cambridgeshire to Gloucestershire. There was a single lonely Scottish vineyard recorded in the 12th century.
Rome rewarded its generals with land in the newly conquered territories. Places where the Roman lifestyle could not be supported were just not that valuable to them. Rome’s British holdings were its northernmost expansion and the greatest likelihood is that extending farther north into Scotland was just not worthwhile.
Assuming that either Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump is elected president in November and take office in January 2017, next January will see at least one milestone. We will have inaugurated the oldest first-term president in our history.
Under the circumstances does it matter what his or her health is? The prescription medications they’re taking on a regular basis?
My sense is that no one cares but I’ve been wrong so frequently during this cockeyed campaign season I can’t claim to know.
We’d better hope that Tim Kaine (or Mike Pence) is up to the job.
Talks on UN-supervised humanitarian access to Aleppo – where reports yesterday suggested that rebels may have broken the siege, at least temporarily – and other stricken areas are staggering on in New York. They must be given top priority by all governments. Discussions are also taking place about resuming the Geneva peace process. They, too, must gain new impetus, not least through a more constructive, non-judgmental engagement between the US and Russia. Countries such as Iran and Saudi Arabia must face severe consequences if they continue to use Syria to pursue regional agendas. Most of all, the international community must unite in telling Assad to step down. While he remains in power in Damascus, there can be no peace. His departure could finally break the cycle of violence.
I could only wonder how in the world they think that will be accomplished? The alliance of the Syrian government, the Russians, and the Iranians are convinced that they are prevailing on the battlefield. Do they believe the press releases from rebel groups who claim they’ve broken the campaign to retake Aleppo? Why?
Three graphs in Sean Kennedy’s RealClearPolitics post on Chicago’s homicides tell a sad story. The first, reproduced above, shows the homicide rate per hundred thousand by race in 2005, 2010, and 2015. The second illustrates the homicide rate for the same three years by gender. The third illustrates the homicide rate for the same three years by age. The ages most affected by homicides are 15 to 24.
Those graphs can’t be explained by a corrupt or racist police force. They can’t be explained by politics. They can’t be explained by rates of gun ownership.
The homicide rate among whites in Chicago is about that in Belgium.
If present trends continue there will be 40% more homicides in Chicago than there were in 2015. There is a crisis under way. Young black men are killing each other.
That’s not even solely a factor of race. The homicide rate among rural blacks is about the same as among rural whites (with higher rates of gun ownership).
Until we start taking these facts seriously and tailoring our policies accordingly, we won’t be taking the problem seriously.
The editors of the Chicago Tribune, noting that Libertarian Party presidential candidate Gary Johnson is now polling at 13%, call for letting him participate in the presidential debates:
Stein and Johnson won their parties’ nominations in 2012, but that November neither broke the 1 percent threshold. This year, Stein has polled as high as 7 percent. Johnson’s ventures into double digits make him, especially, more than a fringe player. He could become the escape-hatch choice for a lot of people Nov. 8 — if he’s included in the autumn presidential debates. The first is scheduled for Sept. 26. The decision on who is included rests with the private, nonpartisan Commission on Presidential Debates. The group says eligible candidates must appear on enough state ballots to have a mathematical shot at winning the Electoral College vote.
Johnson expects to be on the ballot in every state. To meet a second requirement, though, he’ll need to stretch: Candidates must hit an average 15 percent support level in five national polls. A new Fox News poll has Johnson at 12 percent, but in the latest CNN poll he fell from 13 percent to 9 percent amid the hoopla of the Republican and Democratic conventions. A RealClearPolitics average has him at 7 percent. He has time to raise his game. The commission won’t start looking at numbers until after Labor Day.
There’s no way to wish magic on a candidate. It happens or it doesn’t. But there’s a practical side to the equation. Johnson tells us his biggest hurdle to reaching 15 percent is that many pollsters focus on the Clinton-Trump matchup and exclude Johnson or include him in a secondary question that gets ignored by the media and public. If the polls acknowledged that 2016 is a not a two-way race, he says, “I’d be at 20 percent overnight.”
Johnson, in other words, is caught in an election cycle Catch-22: To get acknowledged by pollsters, he needs higher numbers, but he won’t get higher numbers until the pollsters acknowledge him. Something needs to give, and we think it should be the pollsters, who can see better than anyone the dissatisfaction with the major party candidates.
The last third-party candidate to participate in the debates was Ross Perot, who in 1992 won 19 percent of the popular vote against Bill Clinton and George Bush. Perot made a splash criticizing NAFTA, describing the “giant sucking sound” of jobs going to Mexico. Trump and Hillary Clinton both play to jobs fears, going after trade deals while hammering each other over fitness for office.
We have no illusions about Johnson’s chances to break through the clutter of ugliness and negativity. Third-party candidates don’t get a lot of traction for a reason: They don’t win elections. But in a year when the public is sick of politics as usual, Johnson would bring a set of ideas to the debate stage a lot of people may like.
In this funhouse mirror presidential campaign, the head-to-head contest pits an establishment Democrat against a neopopulist blowhard. Gary Johnson is much, much more like the moderate Republicans previously nominated by the GOP than the provocateur Donald Trump. If that’s not an epitome of the campaign I don’t know what is.
If he can focus almost exclusively on the economy for the next three months, the answer to your question is yes, he can win this race. If you look over the 50, 60, 70 years, presidents and parties in power don’t get re-elected when you have 1% economic growth.
I don’t think such exercises are worthwhile, whether you’re talking about analyzing Mr. Trump’s economic plan, foreign policy plan, or anything else he proposes. He’s just floating trial balloons. They’re no more meaningful as serious policy proposals than the presidents’ wish lists in State of the Union messages have become.
I want to consider a different question. Why should the United States have a higher corporate income tax rate than other OECD countries? Our higher tax rate makes tax rate arbitrage a viable business plan. Is that in our interests?
I started thinking about the income and buying power per dollar matter in the post I wrote a little while ago and something about the statistics being reported troubled me. I began noodling around and here’s what I came up with.
Take Nebraska, for instance, one of the states single out in the article I used as the jumping-off point for the post. If my back-of-the-envelope calculations are correct, one-sixth of all of the income in the state goes to just a single individual: Warren Buffett. That translates into per capita income in Nebraska about $7,000 lower than the figure in the article. Per capita income in California (the state to which Nebraska is compared) isn’t nearly as dependent on the income of the richest individual in California (Mark Zuckerberg) because California has a much larger population, Mark Zuckerberg’s annual income isn’t as high, and, frankly, contrary to the information in the Tax Foundation post, personal incomes are higher in California than in Nebraska.
My point isn’t that the Tax Foundation is deliberately misrepresenting the data, that Nebraska is a hellhole, or that California is the Earthly Paradise. I don’t think any of those things are true. My point is that when income is distributed the way it is with a very small number of individuals receiving extremely large incomes it has a distorting effect on certain aggregate statistics, e.g. per capita income, average income, and they’re useless in determining policy.
I think that distortion and the incomes are worth considering. My emphasis in remediation isn’t on the tax code. For most proposing solutions the effectiveness of the tax code as a tool for curbing huge incomes is an article of faith but I see little evidence of that effectiveness.
I think that most people who are enormously wealthy are experts at gaming the system. They exploit some aspect of the law and become hugely wealthy as a consequence. Reducing the opportunities for such exploits is a gigantic game of Whac-A-Mole but life itself is a gigantic game of Whac-A-Mole.
Branko Milanovic’s new book Global Inequality: A New Approach for the Age of Globalization provides some vital insights, looking at the big winners and losers in terms of income over the two decades from 1988 to 2008. Among the big winners were the global 1%, the world’s plutocrats, but also the middle class in newly emerging economies. Among the big losers – those who gained little or nothing – were those at the bottom and the middle and working classes in the advanced countries. Globalization is not the only reason, but it is one of the reasons.