Novelist Chigozie Obioma’s op-ed at Foreign Policy is a grab-bag of truths, half-truths, and balderdash. In the “truth” category is this:
Nigeria, the most populous black nation on Earth, is on the brink of collapse. The machineries that make a nation exist, let alone succeed, have all eroded. One might argue that the nation’s creation by self-seeking white imperialists engendered its failure from the beginning, as I did in my recent novel. But this is only a part of the cause. A culture of incompetence, endemic corruption, dignified ineptitude, and, chief among all, destructive selfishness and greed has played a major role in its unravelling. The same, sadly, can be said for most other African nations. States like Zimbabwe, Cameroon, and Equatorial Guinea are farcical democracies ruled by men who exclusively cater to their interests and those of their clipped circles.
and that’s barely scratching the surface. The Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and the Republic of the Congo are in very rough shape.
I wonder what he thinks of Botswana which seems to be a success story would seem to be the exception that proves the rule. My assessment is that in the final analysis whether you’re talking about Nigeria or Russia or Ukraine or Botswana or the United States institutions matter.
I would place the blame he casts on non-blacks for the problems of sub-Saharan African countries in the category of half-truths, see this:
The Arabs enslaved tribes and nations and then colonized and evangelized them. Then came the Europeans, who, persuaded the Africans were of an inferior race, divided up the continent over lunch in Berlin in 1884. They carted off a large population of its people — sometimes leaving entire villages almost empty — and brought those who remained on the continent under their rule. So complete was the transformation that no black nation retained its ancestral nationhood, national language, or national identity. And today we often hear of how China or India or some other nation is “taking over†Africa economically.
and this
One might argue that the nation’s creation by self-seeking white imperialists engendered its failure from the beginning, as I did in my recent novel.
They are half-truths for any number of reasons. The Arabs and the Europeans certainly didn’t help and I agree that they wrought enormous harm. But he fails to recognize that slavery existed in sub-Saharan Africa before Europeans began transporting slaves and probably before Arab contact there as well and the slavery was a consequence of disunity and war. It was disunity and war that created the openings for Arab and European invaders—they didn’t arise ex nihilo and they’re still dragging sub-Saharan Africa down.
But in my opinion this is balderdash:
Black elites should allow for self-criticism and soul-searching and for the restoration of the Pan-Africanist movement with an eye toward building sustainable black nations. We must come to realize that to a great extent the fate of the black man in America is inextricably linked to that of his brother in Africa. Although largely unacknowledged in American political discourse, Jim Crow ended in part because of the African Independent movements.
relying on post hoc propter hoc reasoning. The abolition of slavery, then Jim Crow, and then the slow process of creating a single society rather than two, a process still incomplete, was the work of American whites and American blacks almost completely without contact with sub-Saharan Africans.
In what category should the following assertion be placed?
Black elites and activists across the world have adopted a culture of verbal tyranny in which they shut down any effort to reason or criticize us or black-majority nations by labeling such attempts as “racism†or “hate speech.†Thus, one can be certain that any suggestions that our race may indeed need to do something to remedy our situation will not be aired — not by the terrified people of other races. And anyone within our race who makes such a suggestion will be deemed weak and pandering or a sellout, as U.S. President Barack Obama has been repeatedly called.