What If?

At Forbes Paul Roderick Gregory raises an interesting point. What if Chinese economic growth has been massively overstated over the period of the last 35 years?

The media have largely ignored the alternative estimates of Chinese growth of the Conference Board. These calculations (discussed below) claim that China’s growth has been overstated by some thirty percent over the reform era, that it has averaged around five percent for the past five years, and is little different or lower than the two large Asian Tigers (Taiwan and South Korea) during their thirty years of rapid growth starting in 1960. Alarming is the collapse of total factor productivity (TFP) since 2010, a pattern reminiscent of the USSR during its protracted period of stagnation preceding its collapse.

That would have several implications. First, it would mean there has been no Chinese miracle. Chinese economic growth would actually have been less than Taiwanese or South Korean growth.

Second, it would be consistent with other measures of Chinese economic growth, e.g. container ships in use, oil consumed, etc.

Third, it would suggest that China’s present, lower rate of growth might well persist.

Finally, it should not be lost on us as I’m sure it is not lost on the Chinese authorities that their period of greatest growth was during the period they maintained their strict peg to the dollar.

2 comments

The Elephants in the Room

You might be interested in Aaron David Miller’s interview with Obama Administration special assistant to the president on the National Security Council (NSC), a senior advisor to the president for the counter-ISIL campaign, and the White House coordinator for the Middle East, North Africa, and Persian Gulf region Robert Malley at Foreign Policy:

These days, defending U.S. Middle East policy is no easy matter. And there’s not all that much to feel good about. With less than six months left on his presidential clock, Barack Obama faces the almost certain prospect of leaving the Middle East dramatically worse than it was when he entered office. Still, an honest person would admit that regardless of the Obama administration’s transgressions, the Middle East isn’t primarily a mess of this president’s making. Rather, it is largely the result of a broken, angry, and dysfunctional region in turmoil marked by failed or failing states and leaders and institutions unable to provide the kind of reforms needed to right itself: good, inclusive governance; accountability; transparency; respect for human rights; and gender equality.

As you might expect, Mr. Malley’s remarks are consistently supportive of the president’s policies. There are gaping holes, puzzling lacunae, in Mr. Malley’s comments including President Obama’s drone war, U. S. support for anti-regime rebels in Syria which at the very least has prolonged the conflict and may have sparked it to begin with, actions or omissions that weakened governments in the region, and the administration’s reluctance to support anti-regime demonstrations in Iran. Nearly unmentioned is the U. S. role in destabilizing Libya.

And then there’s the elephant in the room: Afghanistan. The number of American soldiers killed in Afghanistan during President Obama’s term of office has been three times what it was when he took office. Is Afghanistan better off than it was seven and a half years ago? Are we? Europe certainly isn’t. There are more Afghans among the immigrants to Europe than from any country other than Syria. The numbers were declining when the president took office.

2 comments

The Soros Dump

I haven’t remarked on the massive document dump of hacked documents from George Soros and his OSF organization. I suspect that if he weren’t a major political backer of progressive candidates it would be much bigger news than it is. Based on the revelations so far my only observations are:

  1. They support the Russians’ claims about the neo-Nazi coup that removed the Ukrainian government and which we’re supporting.
  2. If you’re casting around for people to prosecute under the Logan Act, George Soros would be a darned good candidate.
13 comments

How to Provide Fiscal Stimulus

The editors of Bloomberg give tepid support to a new fiscal stimulus plan:

Some fresh fiscal stimulus wouldn’t go amiss in the U.S. either. Both presidential candidates are calling for a big new effort on infrastructure. Nobody who’s used the country’s roads or airports needs much convincing. U.S. public debt has risen sharply since 2008, and demographic trends will keep pushing it higher in the longer term — but with long-term interest rates at their current depressed levels, borrowing for public investment has never been more affordable. If the money is spent wisely, it will spur growth, which would help to lighten the projected debt load.

And crucially, in the U.S. as elsewhere, judicious fiscal expansion would take the pressure off monetary policy, allowing central banks to stabilize their balance sheets and normalize interest rates faster than they otherwise could.

There’s no need to build bridges to nowhere, or hire armies of unemployed youth to dig and refill holes in the ground. Where opportunities for productive public investment don’t present themselves, governments can cut taxes instead — especially for the low-paid, who’ll be more apt to spend the windfall and thereby boost aggregate demand. Extra public spending also needs to go hand in hand with heightened oversight, to ensure that the resources don’t leak away as waste or graft. And governments do need to keep an eye on long-term fiscal sustainability, which means avoiding open-ended commitments that will permanently increase public spending.

There is a simple, easily administered strategy for providing fiscal stimulus that doesn’t build useless infrastructure, provide a political slush fund for supporters paid out of the public purse, or go primarily to the richest: a payroll tax holiday. If you’re worried about the fund accounting, the amounts that would have been received could be credited to the trust fund’s account.

Keep in mind, however, that orthodox Keynesian doctrine does not tell us that we can permanently expand aggregate product via fiscal stimulus. And that it calls for money borrowed during a downturn to be repaid during an upswing (something we’ve rarely if ever done).

Also, if you think that the Great Recession was a “balance sheet recession” caused by excessive indebtedness and that’s still our problem, fiscal stimulus will not be an efficient remediation of that.

1 comment

What Does Milwaukee Tell Us?

As you may or may not be aware, there have been violent protests in Milwaukee for the last two nights:

Tension flared again overnight in Milwaukee, with one person shot and a police officer injured in the second night of riots triggered by the fatal shooting of a suspect by an officer.

Police violence against African-Americans has ignited sporadic, sometimes violent protests in the past two years. It also has prompted a national debate over race and policing while fuelling the growth of the Black Lives Matter civil rights movement.

Violence erupted in Milwaukee on Sunday after peaceful vigils by small groups of demonstrators, and police said late that night that they had rescued one shooting victim, who was taken to a hospital. It was not immediately clear if the injured person was a protester.

The violence started when police shot and killed armed suspect Sylville K. Smith when he refused to drop his weapon. The police officer who fired the fatal shot was black as was Mr. Smith. Early indications are that the police acted within the law and department guidelines.

My questions are what should be the policy and what should have happened? If the law or rule becomes that police may never use deadly force, that would seem to me to be likely to have perverse consequences.

3 comments

Going to Ravinia

I attended a performance by Don Henley at Ravinia. He wasn’t bad for an old guy. I hadn’t been to Ravinia for years. The park was full, most of the people being in lawn seating (lawn seating capacity = 15,000).

I found how the performance was structured interesting. It didn’t consist of sets. Henley would perform a couple of numbers then his group would perform a number with his playing backup and maybe backup vocals.

As you might expect there were a lot of wrinklies in the audience but, surprisingly, there were also a lot of kids.

I got stuck out in overflow parking and hiked the two miles or so from there to the park rather than taking the (free) shuttle bus. Judging by the people walking alongside me not too many wrinklies made that particular choice. Sadly, not too many young people made that choice, either.

0 comments

Labor Shortages in the Trades

Here’s an article at Forbes that supports the argument, frequently made by one of the regular commenters here, that it’s just too hard to find skilled workers in the trades in the United States:

Welders, carpenters, HVAC technicians–the U.S. has far too few of them. The shortfall in welders alone runs as high as 240,000, and it will get worse. The American Welding Society predicts it will reach 340,000 by 2024. The average welder is 54 years old, compared with about age 40 for the American workforce as a whole. Young people simply aren’t going into skilled trades like welding.

The shortage of skilled tradespeople amounts to a tragic mismatch. These jobs can pay well. Including overtime, welders can make more than $100,000 a year–and the lack of welders means there’s plenty of overtime. A welder will need a high school diploma or GED equivalent, followed by at least nine months of professional training. Private welding schools run about $16,000, but many junior colleges with a vocational focus offer training for far less. In financial terms the return on investment is terrific. So why aren’t more young people headed into the skilled trades?

The explanations offered include:

  1. Few American high schools offer vocational training.
  2. Flawed conclusions about the value of higher education.

On the latter subject here’s an interesting observation from the op-ed:

The average salary for a lawyer in the U.S. is $135,000, but the median salary isn’t much over $110,000, as most lawyers aren’t partners at Skadden Arps. So a hustling welder can make more than a median lawyer, with far less money invested in education. The welder can be earning money by age 18, the lawyer not until 25.

There’s one more thing that should be added to that. The distribution of incomes among lawyers isn’t normal (in the statistical sense) and not just because the average and median are different. Incomes in the practice of law occur in a bimodal distribution (a curve that looks like the two humps of camel). The farther right of those two humps corresponding to higher incomes consists of lawyers who graduated from top law schools. The peak of that further left hump is around $40,000. “Average” and “median” don’t really mean anything when talking about lawyers’ incomes because there are two of them.

I’d add another factor to the two cited. We’ve had more than a generation of education policy that has over-emphasized academic achievement. Not only is that gender-biased (as mentioned in the op-ed) it ignores the economic realities.

Here’s my proposal: we should only provide subsidies for STEM and vocational training. Young people can still follow their bliss if it leads them to pursue majors in French literature or art history (or interest studies) but that shouldn’t be paid for out of the public purse. That will mean a dramatic change in how the subsidies are paid rather than just how much is paid.

4 comments

The Case for a Lower Corporate Income Tax

An op-ed by Kevin A. Hassett and Aparna Mathur in the Wall Street Journal makes an argument you may not have heard of for cutting the corporate income tax:

Our empirical analysis, which used data we gathered on international tax rates and manufacturing wages in 72 countries over 22 years, confirmed that the corporate tax is for the most part paid by workers.

This result was controversial at first, and appropriately so. Scientific and economic progress flows from attempts to question and replicate. There has since been a profusion of research that confirms that workers suffer when corporate tax rates are higher.

In other words if you believe that wages should be higher for ordinary people you should also believe that we should reduce our corporate tax rates or eliminate the corporate income tax altogether. What is the likely prospect for the next four years?

Leaders from both parties have proposed lowering America’s 35% corporate tax rate, the highest in the developed world. President Obama has called for cutting it to 28% (25% for manufacturers), while Donald Trump proposes 15%. Hillary Clinton is the outlier. To the detriment of her working-class supporters, she has failed to back even a minor cut to corporate taxes.

1 comment

Mitigating the Risk

The editors of the Washington Post correctly identify the risk:

The behavior depicted in the latest emails does not appear to have significantly harmed the conduct of U.S. diplomacy, distracted from Ms. Clinton’s performance or even, given the evidence available, been particularly frequent. It certainly is not enough to launch a criminal investigation. As political scandals go, this is middling, at best.

But it suggests that some donors to the Clinton Foundation may have seen their gifts as means to buy access — and it points to much bigger potential problems. Should Ms. Clinton win in November, she will bring to the Oval Office a web of connections and potential conflicts of interest, developed over decades in private, public and, in the case of her family’s philanthropic work, quasi-public activities. As secretary, she pledged to keep her official world and her family’s foundation separate, and she failed to keep them separate enough. Such sloppiness would not be acceptable in the White House.

but fail to identify any control. What would provide a control over the new Clinton White House’s continuing blurring of public and private? Fear of impeachment? Really?

1 comment

Theory and Practice

I agree wholeheartedly with Steve Verdon’s full-throated defense of free trade and specialization in his post at Outside the Beltway:

I do not get Donald Trump’s (or anyone else’s like Bernie Sanders) argument for protectionism/mercantilism. I do not understand why trade between nations is viewed a fundamentally different than trade between states in the U.S. or even between individuals and firms. To quote Don Boudreaux, I have been running a trade deficit with my grocery store ever since I started shopping for groceries. I always buy from them, but they in turn never buy anything from me. Clearly using the “logic” of these neo-mercantilists I must clearly be worse off with this arrangement. In fact, I would be so much better off if I would stop going to the grocery store and instead produce all the stuff I buy at the grocery store myself. Let me see, I’ll need some cows, some pigs. I’ll have to grow wheat and corn, I’ll need quite a bit more land too….oh yes, this will make me so much more better off. And I can spend all of my time doing this, so I’d better quit my job too.
Some might say, but it is different when it is another country. I’m still waiting for a good explanation of that one. How is it different? They aren’t Americans? So? Why should that matter? That Americans might lose their job? Okay. So what you are saying is that we should keep these people employed at a job that could be done with less cost. How is that different than welfare? It is no less a transfer of some of my income to those workers than if it were a literal cash transfer. Is that it? Are Trump and the neo-mercantilists espousing nothing more than workfare? Keeping people employed at a job that is actually more costly? That is a recipe for economic prosperity? I don’t think so.

However, as Yogi Berra put it in theory there’s no difference between theory and practice; in practice there is.

We don’t have free trade between the United States and any other country. NAFTA and the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement are mammoth managed trade agreements, not free trade. You can write a free trade agreement on the back of an envelope. The length alone of these agreements should tell you that they’re not instruments of free trade but carefully constructed to pick winners and losers which is not free trade. They remind me of Adam Smith’s famous remark:

People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.

We don’t even have free trade between the states. Every one of the hundreds of thousands of pages of laws and regulations each state has enacted and which vary from state to state is a barrier to free trade.

In an environment of free trade there would be no restrictions on immigration, no occupational licensing, no subsidies or special tax break paid to businesses, no patents, no copyrights, no tariffs, no statements of country of manufacture, no certificates of need, and no quotas. There would either be a uniform system of laws and regulations or none at all.

Clearly, that’s not the world we live in and I think there are good arguments why we shouldn’t want to live in such a world. But each of those barriers alters the structure of supply and demand, incentivizes investments in some industries while discouraging investment in others, and generally distorts the market.

In David Ricardo’s work on trade there were natural limits to how much one nation could buy from another. In today’s world there are no such limits.

One more point: the United States will not be able to specialize in consumption while other countries specialize in production. It just doesn’t work that way.

As a result of all of the foregoing you can’t justify, for example, the TPP on the basis of free trade. You’ve got to make a reasoned value judgment based upon its net results. Is it of great enough benefit to enough people to justify? Or is it just of substantial benefit to a relative handful of people while hurting a lot more?

19 comments