Thinking Straight (Updated)

There’s an interesting sort of Point/Counterpoint going on at the Washington Post on the subject of income inequality between Scott Winship and Jared Bernstein. There’s plenty in both of their points of view to make your eyes cross.

Scott Winship takes a pretty typical tack of the sort that used to be called “supply side economics”. Inequality isn’t really a problem; the real problem is slow growth:

Are American levels of inequality harmful? Some analysts claim that they hurt middle-class incomes or increase poverty. But child poverty is at an all-time low, and middle-class incomes are also at historic highs. Across developed countries, those with higher inequality have slightly higher middle-class incomes and less poverty.

Others argue — based on mobility measures constructed to look worse when inequality rises — that higher inequality causes lower economic mobility or leads to political inequality. In fact, research claiming that the rich get their way in Congress over other voters has been debunked; in truth, across most issues, rich, middle-class and poor Americans have similar policy preferences. And in the United States, mobility has remained flat while inequality has risen over the past generation. Areas of the United States with more income concentration at the top have no worse mobility than areas with low inequality. The same is true across countries — the best research indicates that low-inequality Sweden is no more mobile than the United States.

Left unstated are what are to me the gravest problems with our present high level of income inequality. The first is that if you subscribe to the beliefs of the Founding Fathers you must believe that a country divided between a very, very wealthy 1% and a much less wealthy 99% (or, even more problematic to my way of thinking, a .1% with more than 20% of the total wealth rather than the 6% they held in 1975), will inevitably lead to tyranny. The temptation to exploit and wealth and power to gain more wealth and power is irresistible. Very high achievers will have much less highly achieving offspring but they will seek to have those offspring maintain their wealth and power without the achievement.

But even more serious to me is that’s just not the sort of country I want to live in. I’m concerned about social inequality following wealth inequality.

But I found Jared Bernstein’s views even more distressing. Here’s an example:

Democrats tend to think in terms of tax and transfer policies, moving resources — money, food, housing services, help with child care or subsidies for low-wage jobs — from the rich to the poor. Such redistribution through the tax code is absolutely called for and has been highly successful in reducing poverty and boosting opportunity. Democrats, including President Obama and Hillary Clinton, have also embraced tax increases on the wealthy: an excellent place to start. But the current set of ideas is too limited. More broad-based tax increases will be necessary just to maintain our current set of inequality-reducing policies as our population ages.

I realize that’s what many Democrats like to think they believe but based on their actions over three generations what do they actually believe? They believe in helping the poor by paying the rich or the nearly rich. Consider how federal money is actually disbursed:

Which of the slices in the pie chart above reflect direct transfer payments to the poor? None of them do. Some small proportion of total Social Security payments goes to the elder poor. That’s about it. The payments in “healthcare spending” go to providers; the payments classified as “education” pay teachers and administrators (in Chicago most teachers and administrators are in the top income quintile). And so on. Unless you think that “interest on the debt” is being paid to the poor.

In other words both political parties now subscribe to something like John Kenneth Galbraith’s memorable description of supply-siders: they want to feed the sparrows by feeding more oats to the horses.

The same pattern is seen at the state and local level. Spending doesn’t go to direct transfer payments to the poor. It goes to healthcare providers, teachers, police officers, firefighters (in Chicago the typical police officer or firefighter earns in the six figures), and grantees who, presumably, help the poor (with very little oversight). The evidence that all of this spending actually helps the poor is weak.

Consequently, I don’t think that increasing union power (one of Mr. Bernstein’s pet reforms) or increasing the taxes paid by the poor (astonishingly enough, one of Mr. Winship’s) will bring income and wealth equality back into a zone that is more consistent with historical levels.

Some of their prescriptions, e.g. Mr. Winship’s desire to reduce the number of low-skilled immigrants and Mr. Bernstein’s desire to negotiate “trade deals that ‘prioritize the interests of workers and communities’ over those of multinational corporations are things I’ve recommended here. I’d do a couple of other things as well.

First, stop subsidizing the rich. If your preferred policies result in more income and wealth for the ultra-rich, pair them with highly targeted Pigouvian taxes.

Second, recognize that size itself is a problem. Big companies hire fewer people per dollar of earnings than small ones and pay much higher salaries to top management, exacerbating income inequality. Stop enacting laws that benefit large companies to the detriment of small ones. Break up large companies that have abused monopoly power.

Most importantly, stop making up airy stories about what you believe in. As Shakespeare put it, suit the action to the word.

Update

Scott Winship, author of one of the pieces cited above, responds in comments to clear up some of misconceptions about what he wrote.

14 comments

Trivia

Rio is almost due south from Reykjavik. A long way south.

2 comments

Footnote on Illinois Healthcare Exchanges

Following up on a comment on an earlier post and based on the information here (Excel spreadsheet), if all of the insurance carriers that have announced or threatened to withdraw from offering plans in Illinois on the healthcare exchanges (Aetna, BCBS, Humana, Land of Lincoln), none of Illinois’s counties will have no insurance carriers but 27 will have only one. They are:

Alexander
Clay
Franklin
Gallatin
Hamilton
Hardin
Jackson
Jefferson
Johnson
Lake
Lawrence
Madison
Marion
Massac
McDonough
McHenry
Monroe
Perry
Pope
Pulaski
Saline
Schuyler
St. Clair
Union
Wayne
White
Williamson

Most of those counties are small and rural but two (Lake and McHenry) are essentially suburban Chicago and one (St. Clair) is essentially suburban St. Louis.

Update

Jefferson and Johnson Counties added per comments.

4 comments

Is That What We’re Seeing Now?

Michael Barone points out something:

If you keep telling “whites” (a category not considered useful when I started analyzing election data, since almost all voters were “white” then) or white Christians that they are headed to minority status, they are going to start voting like members of a self-conscious minority group. Arguably they already have.

If that’s a change from the past, it would certainly explain why this election cycle has seemed so puzzling to me.

6 comments

An Astonishing Claim

You might want to read this op-ed in USA Today. Self-described “female, practicing Muslim human rights activist” writes something that may strike many readers like a bolt out of the blue:

There, I said it: Donald Trump is right.* With an asterisk.

Before we get to that asterisk, you may be asking yourself: Why is a female, practicing Muslim human rights activist like myself saying what many in Trump’s own party cannot bring themselves to say?

Because Trump is right. About certain things. Certain things about radical Islam, which I have been calling to the world’s attention for the past 20 years.

And I am not just saying this because like Trump, I too proposed “a moratorium on immigration from Muslim countries for a set period till matters here settle down.” A year before he did.

There’s an old wisecrack that even a stopped clock is right twice a day. I hope that Donald Trump’s blowhardiness and arseholiness doesn’t cover his occasional commonsensical proposal with slime but I fear that’s the case.

The op-ed also might at least raise a few questions about who will vote for Trump and who won’t. See also this post at National Interest by Peter Navarro.

5 comments

Are the Riots Democrats’ Fault?

In an op-ed at The Hill the sheriff of Milwaukee County lays the blame for the riots in his jurisdiction firmly at the feet of Democrats:

Here are the facts: Milwaukee is run by progressive Democrats. Their decades-long Democrat regime has done nothing to reduce these urban pathologies, in fact, their strategies have exacerbated the situation by expanding the welfare state.

That things have not improved and in fact worsened in the American ghetto after eight years of Barack Obama is remarkable only to those who have not been paying attention to our nation’s cities.

There’s only one answer, which is for the citizens of America to expose and heap scorn on this lying and dangerous triad of big government, liberal mainstream media, and the lost souls of the urban ghettos both these institutions feed upon for their power.

First and foremost the rioters are to blame for the riots. A man being killed by police is no justification for looting a liquor store. Or burning the cars of people who had nothing to do with the killing.

If Democrats who haven’t lived up to their promises don’t share the blame, who should be held responsible? In Chicago the mayors have been Democrats for four generations and the City Council is overwhelmingly Democrats. In Illinois the state legislature has enough votes to override any gubernatorial veto. When the legislature has a year-long logjam, who’s to blame?

7 comments

How Should We Help the Poorest Children of Single Mothers?

The analysis by the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities of the first decade of “welfare reform”, 1995-2005 leaves me severely conflicted:

Average incomes fell significantly among the poorest children in single-mother families in the first decade after enactment of the 1996 welfare law, reflecting a large drop in cash assistance through the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) block grant. These findings provide further evidence that supports the growing agreement among researchers that TANF’s record has been mixed. Since the welfare law’s enactment, the overall poverty rate for single-parent families has fallen — though many other factors besides TANF influenced this trend — but the poorest families and children have become worse off. Previous analyses have found that the share of children in “deep poverty,” with incomes below half of the poverty line, climbed during the welfare law’s first decade.

What should the policy be? When you subsidize something you get more of it. Do we want to subsidize indigence and families headed by single mothers? If all of the studies of the effects of immigration on incomes agree on one thing it’s that unrestricted immigration of low-skilled individual reduces incomes among the lowest income earners, especially the previous cohort of immigrants without skills. Did welfare reform cause the declines in income or was that a consequence of unrestricted immigration of immigrants without skills? Was welfare reform itself a response to that immigration?

What’s the best way to help the poorest children of single mothers?

1 comment

When Do You Start Making Contingency Plans?

At Forbes Seth Chandler suggests, in reaction to the news that Aetna is ending its operations under the Affordable Care Act in the majority of markets in which they’re presently operating, that we should be figuring out what we should do when some markets have no ACA insurance carriers:

People joked for a while about how insurers were pulling out of Obamacare markets so fast we might end up with areas in which there were no insurers at all. It’s no joke anymore: with Aetna’s massive withdrawal yesterday from the Affordable Care Act marketplace, Pinal County, Arizona, the third most populated county in that state, currently has no insurers selling policies on the Exchange.

and

The answer to the question posed in the title of this article is “Yes.” It would be far more productive to acknowledge what had been painfully obvious to many and what is likely now painfully obvious to those just dumped by Aetna. When you see the rapid contraction of the marketplace, when you see gross premiums increasing by more than 20%, and when you yourself are calling for the federal government to spend considerably more on Obamacare, it is time to admit that the existing Obamacare spaceship is passing the event horizon of the adverse selection black hole.

There are several barriers to adopting measured, considered reforms to the law. The emphasis by Republicans has not been on reform but on “repeal and replace” and to that end they’ve voted six times to repeal the ACA in its entirety since it was shoved down their throats in 2010. However, there have been scores of attempts to amend the law or repeal portions of it, nearly all of which have been opposed by Democrats for whom the ACA has become a sacred cow.

Additionally, there are both Republicans and Democrats who believe that the ACA’s becoming inoperative through the attrition of carriers facilitates their own, preferred solution whether that’s repealing the ACA in its entirety or replacing it with a single-payer plan. They can’t both be right but the belief alone in effect bronzes the ACA.

My own view is that dispassionately debating contingency plans in the event of a major fraction of counties having no insurance carriers or only one under the ACA would finding the best, most acceptable solution to the plan. Governing by crisis rarely results in the most effective policy.

8 comments

Fixing Highways

I had a little problem with Noah Smith’s remarks at Bloomberg on rebuilding America’s highways:

When we calculate the social return on infrastructure, we have to think about the cost of doing nothing. If the U.S. never repairs its roads and bridges and ports, its world-class transportation network will decay until it is no longer usable. It’s worth remembering that there is no country in the world that has a private transportation network with anywhere near the quality of the mostly government-funded U.S. system — if Uncle Sam doesn’t fix the roads, we just won’t have nearly as many roads. So the government’s return on infrastructure investment includes the sizable benefit of maintaining the network we now enjoy.

The problem with his analysis is that Uncle Sam is the least significant player in the funding and spending on highway construction. Consider the pie charts above, courtesy of the Federal Highway Administration.

As you can see two thirds of the funding and almost 99% of the spending on highways is at the state and local level. That’s sensible. The federal government does not retain vast numbers of inspectors in Washington, combing the country to determine what should be maintained an dispatching money to address the most urgent needs. Which highways are built or rebuilt are decided politically, almost entirely at the local level.

The reason that highways are in disrepair is that the states have priorities and highways are way down on the list. The greater priorities as measured by what state and local governments are actually doing are paying current and past public employees and providing healthcare for the poor.

Federalizing highway spending would either require a vast transfer of power from state and local governments to the federal government or vastly increased federal spending on highways—much, much larger than anything that Paul Krugman has ever proposed. And highway construction would become even more political and even less in touch with the priorities of real people than it is today.

My own belief is that our infrastructure spending needs to start taking issues like projected use and life expectancy much more into account. It’s hard to estimate the life expectancy of a road—a lot depends on variable issues like climate, soil, traffic, the type of traffic, and so on. Let’s use a 30 year average life expectancy as a rule of thumb.

Will that highway you want to build still be useful, not usable but useful, in 30 years? I think there are foreseeable changes coming along which suggest that it won’t be. These include fuel costs, autonomous vehicles, and patterns of residence.

IMO we’d be a lot better off if we thought of vital infrastructure spending priorities in terms of sewers and power grids than in terms of roads and bridges. They aren’t as glamorous and you can’t make the same rosy predictions of employment and wage growth but they’re more likely to be useful over their productive lives.

8 comments

The Internet of Big Things

Popular Science reports that a Nicaraguan volcano is being connected to the Internet:

Currently, a team of people are in Nicaragua, installing over 80 sensors along the side of the volcano. “The main sensors we are connecting will be gas sensors and also atmospheric sensors,” says Guillermo Caravantes, a volcanologist on the project. The gas sensors will be looking at hydrogen sulfide and carbon dioxide being emitted from the volcano, which can tell geologists more about the composition of the lava. Other sensors will measure atmospheric pressure, humidity, and temperature, and the movement of the magma inside the volcano. Seismometers that measure movement and gravity data will be enclosed in an airtight box the size of a lunchbox.
“This is very uncommon for volcanos. It happens in a few. In a few you have lots of sensors, where you have lots of money. All of them [the sensors] are very expensive in general, and most countries do not have the resources to keep and monitor them really well,” Caravantes says. “This project goes well beyond that and it tries to democratize this idea of having early warning systems from every volcano.”

[…]

Eventually, Cossman says, there will be an online portal that will let people around the world check in on the volcano, seeing it’s status. But many people aren’t volcanologists. It will still be up to local officials and the government of Nicaragua to issue warnings and interpret the data that comes in, in the event that an eruption is imminent. Of course, being able to predict eruptions definitively is still a goal that remains out of reach for volcanologists.

0 comments