On Target

Every once in a while you stumble across something that just cries out to be passed along. This post fits that description. It’s a journal of somebody’s first five days working at Target. Here’s a snippet:

Things That Happened On My First Day At Target

  • Sold lingerie to an 80 year old woman
  • Sold a bra to the mom of a 16 year old girl who was cringing the entire time
  • Had a very engaging conversation with a three year old boy about colors. We both like blue.
  • Served an old woman who I thought had an impressive mustache, but it was just nose hair

Read the whole thing. Don’t bother clicking through after you get to the post linked above. I don’t even care if it’s a genuine journal or not.

On this Labor Day weekend let’s salute those who work hard doing thankless work. Which is most people.

0 comments

Perspective

To place the report 151,000 increase in the number of jobs in August in a little perspective, here are a few things to consider.

  • The number of jobs created in August 2006 was about 150,000.
  • The U. S. population has grown about 8% since August 2006.
  • The number of live births in the U. S. in August 1998 was around 337,000.
  • 151,000 is around 45% of 337,000.
  • In constant dollars median weekly earnings are about 3% higher today than they were in 2006; in nominal dollars they’re about 20% higher.
  • The category accounting for the largest part of the increase (20%) was food service.
  • Employment in mining declined; employment in manufacturing was unchanged.
  • The average workweek declined slightly.
  • A considerable part of the jobs reported in the monthly employment situation report aren’t actually counted. They’re estimated taking into account a variety of factors including the number of businesses estimated to have started or closed their doors. The size of the adjustments is considerably larger than the total number of jobs reported.
3 comments

Trump’s Immigration Plan

As reported by the Wall Street Journal, Donald Trump’s immigration plan is here. It consists of ten points.

I think that point #1, “We will build a wall along the southern border”, is just a campaign promise and won’t have much effect on immigration, legal or illegal, one way or another.

I think that point #6, “We are going to suspend the issuance of visas to any place where adequate screening cannot occur”, is, sadly, unworkable. In this day of dual (or more) citizenship and other countries (notably Canada) accepting refugees from the Middle East with only the most cursory of screening, the only way to put teeth into it would be to stop issuing visas at all. Obviously, that’s not going to happen.

I think that points 8-10 are long overdue but I’ll believe them when I see them.

Basically, I don’t think any of it means much. Mr. Trump’s continues to view everything as a negotiation and he’s trying to negotiate the terms of his being elected to the presidency. What he will do after being elected is unpredictable.

2 comments

Differences

The difference between a man and a dog is that if you feed a dog and make it prosperous it won’t bite you. And, apparently, dogs can be trained to sit still for an MRI.

0 comments

Just Trying To Be Helpful

I think that Mohammed El-Erian’s op-ed at Bloomberg could stand some corrections. For example:

In addition, the Trans-Pacific Partnership, the trade agreement the U.S. and 11 Asian nations signed in February, seems increasingly unlikely to be ratified, given the limited appetite for any such deals in the U.S. Congress weak merits of the agreement.

We already have “free trade” agreements with most of the countries with which the agreement has been negotiated and all of the major economies other than Japan. No trade agreement with Japan that doesn’t eliminate Japan’s barriers to agricultural imports (which the TPP doesn’t) is worth the paper it’s printed on. Or the bits it’s composed of, as appropriate.

And the title. “The Lure of Protectionism Will Grow” should be “The West Doesn’t Retaliate Against Chinese and Indian Mercantilism”. Or maybe just “West Supine”.

Protectionism keeps descending on the U. S. and falling on China. How does that happen?

1 comment

The Cold Equations

Which do you think is more likely?

  1. The portfolios of Illinois’s public employee retirement funds will grow fast enough to pay the promised benefits.
  2. Illinoisan will pony up enough tax dollars to make up the shortfall.
  3. The state constitution will be amended to allow the legislature to renege on the promises they’ve made to public employees (and they’ll do it).
  4. The Federal Reserve will manage to create enough inflation to inflate the problem away.
  5. The federal government will bail out the state of Illinois’s public employee retirement funds.

I don’t think that any of those are particularly likely but Illinois either needs one or more of those to happen or a miracle. Writing at MarketWatch Amit Sinha explains why:

The dilemma we face is that we have made future promises and don’t have enough money set aside today to pay them. Therefore someone has to make up the shortfall. Instead of trying to determine who makes up the shortfall, we try to bury our heads in the actuarial sand of high expected returns.

But where can Illinois get the additional $5 billion a year? And where can America get the additional $6 trillion?

Investment returns aren’t going to help:

The Teachers Retirement System assumes that investment returns over the long-term will average 7%. With liabilities of $108 billion, and assets of $41 billion, even if investments return 7% per annum, the hole will only continue to grow (see Illustration below). This is why using investment-return expectations to discount liabilities isn’t appropriate.

But investments don’t return 7% year-in, year-out. For simplicity, let’s assume the long-term horizon to be 10 years. Even if there is one year where returns are negative-20%, this results in an asset value that is over $20 billion lower (see illustration below).

When risk-free rates were around 6%-7%, generating 8%-10% expected returns required minimal risk and complexity. However, with risk-free rates at 2%-3%, generating even 7% is a lot harder. While investment teams at pension funds such as Teachers are extremely capable, high expected returns are forcing them to take on additional risk, either in the form of increased leverage or complex investments.

The graphs in the post tell the story. Read the whole thing.

I think that what’s most likely to happen is some combination of B and C. What should happen is that the pensions of retired Illinois elected officials should be cut first, pensions over $200,000 should be cut second, pensions over $100,000 should be cut third, that double-dipping should be eliminated, that the various jurisdictions that pay the notional employee contribution to pensions should stop, that all present employees should be converted to defined contributions plans with all due haste, and that if that fails taxes should be raised. I think they’ll try to solve the problem by raising taxes first.

1 comment

Kosovo, Failed Semi-State

How do you take an area about the size of Massachusetts, with two warring populations, and that has never been a state in all of its long history into a viable state? You can’t says Aidan Hehir at National Interest:

Yet, despite the hyperbole and the extraordinary scale of the state-building project, Kosovo currently suffers from a crippling array of problems, and bears the hallmarks of a failed state. This could be verified by consulting the Failed State Index but for the fact that—illustrative of its contemporary predicament—Kosovo is not considered a “recognized sovereign state.”

As a consequence of the massive investment of economic and political capital, perpetuating an image of Kosovo as “multiethnic,” “democratic” and “peaceful” has become vital to liberal internationalism’s image. Preserving this image, however, has led to the imposition of a national identity which simply does not equate with the reality on the ground in Kosovo. More damagingly, the determination to artificially contrive a facade of peace and stability within Kosovo has led external actors to tolerate, and at times support, corruption and intimidation perpetrated by Kosovo’s powerful criminal network. Paradoxically, therefore, Kosovo’s people have been forced to endure profoundly illiberal practices orchestrated by the various “internationals” who micromanage the country so as to maintain its image as their success.

Read the whole thing.

At one time or another Kosovo has been run by the Serbians, the Turks, the Austrians, the Bulgarians, and the Romans. What’s the end game here? Kosovo doesn’t have the historic, ethnic, or economic conditions that would make it a viable state. Keep it as a UN protectorate into the indefinite future? Eject the Albanian population and restore Kosovo to Serbia? Eject the Serbian population and federate it with Albania?

11 comments

What’s Going On in Syria?

Speaking of reconciling conflicting data, what in the world is going on in Syria? Either the Syrian government is consolidating its control over Aleppo or it’s about to be ejected from it, either the U. S. is fighting DAESH or aiding it, and either the Turks are our allies or our foes depending upon which sources you read.

Moon of Alabama hints at an interesting explanation. The U. S. is attempting to mollify its various allies in the war against the Syrian regime (Turkey, the Kurds, the “moderate rebels”) and orchestrate a partition of Syria:

The Syrian government was barely alive when Russia intervened just 10 month ago. It has now regained a lot of its land and capabilities. The U.S. and Israeli plans for a divided Syria have been warded. The strategic landscape has been changed. That’s a lot of progress in a quite short time.

Surely Syria would like to be in a better situation, but its resources are limited and neither Russia nor Iran are willing to go all-in (and risk attacks on their homelands) to recover the last corners of the country. The deal with Turkey will prevent control of the U.S. over significant parts of Syria and the federalization of the country the neocons promote.

The interests of these allies are not reconcilable. They’re not just fighting the Syrian government or DAESH. They’re fighting each other. The task on our plate is not just like herding cats, it’s like herding rabid cats.

A fundamental principle in negotiation is that no agreement is possible when two parties insist on getting all of the same limited resource. The Turks don’t want an independent Kurdistan. The Kurds don’t want to commit resources to anything other than defending their homeland. As in Iraq the “moderate rebels” want a unified Syria with them in control and each faction of the opposition thinks it should be the one in control.

Meanwhile, the Syrian government, the Russians, and the Iranians continue their slow progress.

2 comments

More Equal Than Others

When I read Christopher Ingraham’s Wonkblog piece in the Washington Post:

In 2008, fewer than half of Americans said their life was good enough to be considered “thriving,” according to Gallup. But that’s changed: “The 55.4% who are thriving so far in 2016 is on pace to be the highest recorded in the nine years Gallup and Healthways have tracked it,” according to the report.

Not only that, members of each ethnic or racial group in Gallup’s study feel better about their lives.

I was reminded of two things. The first was this passage from George Orwell’s Animal Farm:

On Sunday mornings Squealer, holding down a long strip of paper with his trotter, would read out to them lists of figures proving that the production of every class of foodstuff had increased by two hundred per cent, three hundred per cent, or five hundred per cent, as the case might be. The animals saw no reason to disbelieve him, especially as they could no longer remember very clearly what conditions had been like before the Rebellion. All the same, there were days when they felt that they would sooner have had less figures and more food.

and the second was my beloved How to Lie With Statistics. One of the niftiest ways of lying with statistics is by selecting your baseline carefully. Gallup didn’t start asking this particular set of questions until 2008 when the country was in the midst of the worst recession since the 1930s. Not only does that mean that comparing 2008 with today is a meaningless comparison, there is no baseline to which it might be compared. As a statistic to promote a partisan line, it’s perfect.

Bryan Caplan, pointing to the same passage from Animal Farm, sees the opposite:

In a totalitarian state, there’s a chasm between daily life and the media. Daily life is awful, but the media trumpets the glory of the status quo.

The West now has a comparable chasm between daily life and the media, but it goes in the opposite direction. Daily life is wonderful: Unless you actively hunt for outliers, you’re surrounded by well-fed, healthy, safe, comfortable people enjoying a cornucopia of amusement. The media, however, uses the vastness of the world to show us non-stop terror, hate, fear, brutality, and poverty – not just in the Third World, but right here at home.

How can you reconcile three things: that most people feel better about their lives than they did eight years ago (at the depth of the recession), that “daily life is wonderful”, and that more than 90% of U. S. counties haven’t recovered seven years after the recession has ended?

Here’s the story I’d tell. Life is wonderful if you’re among that relatively small segment of the population, the topmost 3% of income earners, the upper middle class and the wealthy, and all that you know about anyone who isn’t in that sliver is what you can glean as they empty your dustbin or mow your lawn. Life is better for most of us than it was at the lowest point of the late recession but most people’s lives today aren’t better than they were in 2006. And for the longest of the long-term unemployed or those who expected to enter or remain in the middle class but are only able to barely keep body and soul together, it’s not very good at all.

That’s how I reconcile the manifest anger that’s abroad with the economic statistics. That things aren’t going well is not just bad press.

0 comments

Questions

I’m just full of questions today. For example, what role is there for Barack Obama after he’s left the presidency and assuming Hillary Clinton is elected president?

Also, what are the implications of the total conflation of the personal, the political, and the apparatus of the state for the American system?

2 comments