Companies That Create Jobs and Companies That Don’t

I hope people take Howard Gold’s most recent post at MarketWatch to heart. In it he quotes liberally from business prof Gerald Davis about job creation in the United States:

It’s Labor Day weekend, and despite unemployment under 5% and nearly 15 million private-sector jobs created since February 2010, nobody’s celebrating.

Workforce participation is stuck near historic lows, six million people are part-timers but want to work full time, and wage growth remains subdued.

Both presidential candidates have talked a good game about jobs and the economy, but neither addresses the real problem. The U.S. job-creation machine—once the envy of the world—is broken, because American corporations cannot create steady, well-paying jobs here in the USA while also providing maximal returns to their investors, who are really in charge.

The basic message is that publicly held companies are not our friends and that the nature of large enterprises has changed. They are too narrowly focused maximizing share value and too little on building businesses.

He mentions lots of possible causes for the change including the growth in the role of institutional investors, corporate raiders, globalization, and the Internet. He does not mention the change in tax rules which incentivized companies to increase executive compensation in the form of stock options which coincided with a lot of the transition. Somehow that seems like more than a coincidence to me.

4 comments

All Subsidies Are Stupid

but gas subsidies are among the worst. That’s the message of this editorial from Bloomberg:

Nations from the U.S. to the U.K. to Russia continue to spend billions on tax breaks and other subsidies for the production of oil, gas and coal. Japan, South Korea and China support massive fossil-fuel projects outside their borders. For years, many countries — including some of the world’s biggest energy producers — have also used subsidies to lower gasoline and diesel prices, supposedly to help the poor.

The sums involved are huge. The International Energy Agency estimates that countries spent $493 billion on consumption subsidies for fossil fuels in 2014. The U.K.’s Overseas Development Institute suggests G-20 countries alone devoted an additional $450 billion to producer supports that year.

Of the fuel subsidies the very worst are consumption subsidies. The worst offenders, as reported here (Excel), is basically a list of the usual suspects:

Country Subsidy
(billion $)
Iran 82.2
Saudi Arabia 60.9
Russia 40.2
India 39.7
China 31.1
Venezuela 27.1
Egypt 24.5
Iraq 22.2
United Arab Emirates 21.8
Indonesia 21.3
Mexico 15.9

Consumer subsidies aren’t the only kind. China, Japan, and South Korea in particular also devote tens of billions to subsidizing oil exploration outside their countries.

Lest we be too complacent in the U. S. fuel subsidies tend to take the form of subsidies to companies (oil companies, auto manufacturers) and road building.

It’s astonishing to me that there is as much of a bipartisan consensus in support of this particular form of corporate welfare in the U. S. as there is. It resists the usual ideological stereotyping.

Both parties should oppose these fuel subsidies, each for their own particular reasons. And yet somehow they keep trundling along, a seemingly permanent part of our fiscal profligacy.

3 comments

Weren’t the 50s Great?

At the Washington Post Jared Berstein calls for a revitalization of unions and union power:

Damon Silvers, director of policy for the AFL-CIO, notes that the extent of union membership is partly a function of big, lasting shocks to the system, both positive and negative. The 1936 Flint sit-down strike against General Motors represented a turning point in the legitimacy and growth of the United Auto Workers, for example. Conversely, President Ronald Reagan’s firing of 11,000 air-traffic controllers whose union, PATCO, was on strike signaled a level of unbridled conservative opposition that persists to this day.

What could precipitate a positive shock that could lastingly reverse the negative trend in union density? Silvers and other to whom I posed this question had the same answer: centralized bargaining. Especially given the depth of opposition and the existence of the “gig economy” (where the “workplace” hardly exists), organizing one establishment at a time is a recipe for further stagnation. As EPI’s president, Larry Mishel, put it, “We need a design where people have collective bargaining rights as restaurant workers, as opposed to one where they gain those rights one restaurant at a time.”

Maybe I’m not being fair to Mr. Bernstein but his whole column struck me as “cargo cult” thinking. Labor unions were strong in the 1950s because labor unions function by limiting membership and labor was already relatively scarce in the 1950s. Additionally, large, centralized manufacturing without notable foreign competition, e.g. the American auto industry of the 1950s, lends itself to unionization. We don’t have any of those conditions now. Attempting to compete with overseas manufacturing is pushing wages down here.

If you want to increase wages for jobs that can’t be moved overseas, e.g. truckers and restaurant workers, limit the number of people competing for those jobs. Half a century ago fast food jobs were jobs for teenagers, trying to earn a little money to buy a car or go to college. Now they’re jobs for adults who are not only trying to support families on them, they’re trying to send remittances home on top of that. Unionization is no solution for raising the wages of people without skills or limited command of English. There are plenty more where they came from.

0 comments

Predictions of Labor Scarcity Are Premature

In his column at the Washington Post, Robert Samuelson sees the beginning of a new period of labor scarcity:

The good news is that U.S. workers may be retrieving some of their lost bargaining power. The supply-and-demand dynamics for labor look more favorable. As the recovery has continued, the unemployed pool has shrunk. In August, the jobless rate was 4.9 percent, down from a peak of 10 percent. In addition, the retirement of baby boomers reinforces the competition for good workers, exerting upward pressure on wages and giving workers more choice.

Other forces push in the same direction. Immigration seems likely to abate. The huge influx of women into the paid labor market seems to have crested. All this shifts the bargaining advantage to workers. It is unlikely to be offset by the advent of more robots, another trend that has been hyped.

I think that’s tremendously premature. If labor had become scarce, you would expect a sharp increase in wages. As the graph at the top of the post illustrates the increase in the median wage continues to be below what it was in middle of the Great Recession and remains significantly below what it was in the late 1990s. For real household income to return to what it was in 2007 we’d need a decade of wage growth at present rates.

Might we be entering a new period of labor scarcity? For that to happen immigration would need to slow. Given that the brief period of net zero immigration from Mexico has ended, immigration is proceeding at the rate of about 1 million per year, and there’s considerable pressure to increase the number of legal immigrants, that seems unlikely.

1 comment

Why Do We Have Laws?

The editors of the New York Times reject jail time for illegal immigrants, apparently regardless of what other laws they have broken:

The Obama administration has spent years endorsing and enacting smart criminal-justice reforms, including pushing back against decades of useless, degrading imprisonment of nonviolent and petty offenders. But there is one huge area where it seems immune to enlightenment: immigration enforcement.

Immigration and Customs Enforcement, known as ICE, takes about 300,000 immigrants a year into detention; the daily population averaged about 28,000 in fiscal 2015. About 63 percent of detainees are held in private prisons under contract with Homeland Security.

[…]

There are ways to enforce the law without mistreating a population that fits no definition of a criminal threat. The job of dismantling the prison network Mr. Obama built will pass on to Hillary Clinton, if she is elected. If it’s Donald Trump, who wants to make immigration enforcement the federal government’s overriding priority, then private incarceration, industry profits and human suffering will go through the roof.

The woman whom they cite as an example has violated at least two laws—our immigration law and the law against theft—and, given how the law is enforced these days, probably many, many more.

Law falls into two broad classifications: malum in se, things that are inherently wrong like murder, rape, and theft, and malum prohibitum, regulatory infractions. Arguably, immigration laws are malum prohibitum although there’s also an argument they’re malum in se.

However, few would argue that theft is anything but malum in se.

The editors of the NYT seem to be dividing laws in a novel way: laws against things that pose a “criminal threat” and laws that don’t. The remedy for laws that pose no criminal threat is repeal, not failing to enforce them. The real problem the editors have revealed is that Los Angeles has declared itself a “sanctuary city”.

There is a question I would like to ask the editors. Why do we have laws? I think that the criminal code represents the minimum standard of conduct we expect. If conduct is below the minimum acceptable, we shouldn’t accept it and “don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time.” What do the editors think?

2 comments

Dowd Looks at the Bright Side

At the Wall Street Journal Matthew Dowd assesses the record-breaking negatives of the presidential campaign—mainly that neither major party candidate is liked or trusted—and concludes:

This election will, though, accelerate the United States toward more political disruption. And that is likely to contribute to the search for independent candidates locally and at the state level who can speak to Americans’ hopes and dreams and get the job done. After Election Day, leaders who put country over party and integrity over service of self will have a great opportunity to grasp the levers of office.

I find that incredibly optimistic. Duverger’s Law, the rule of thumb that suggests that winner take all systems like ours tend to evolve into systems with two major parties that oppose each other rather than a number of smaller parties, suggests otherwise. The Democrats and the Republicans have a stranglehold on the electoral process that they are unlikely to release.

Indeed, I think it’s more likely that Americans will continue the process that has been going on for some time now, realizing that the political process is incapable of producing good, trustworthy candidates who are willing to address the many problems facing us in ways that help anyone other than their donors and themselves. That won’t result in a search for “independent candidates” but will further de-legitimize government and, probably, the law.

4 comments

The Signs

When I looked at the tattoos adorning the face of a man who “gunned down” a police officer in New Mexico:

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. – A police officer who authorities say attempted to chase down a 38-year-old man with three active arrest warrants was fatally shot by the suspect Friday after an exchange of gunfire in a southern New Mexico town.

The suspect, Joseph Moreno, also was killed in the morning shootout near a trailer park in Alamogordo, police said at a news conference. The desert town of about 31,000 people is home to the White Sands National Monument and Holloman Air Force Base.

Police identified the slain officer as Clint Corvinus, a four-year veteran who graduated from high school in Alamogordo. Authorities said he is survived by his parents, girlfriend and an 8-year-old daughter.

my immediate reaction was that it was Santa Muerte stuff. “Santa Muerte”, literally “Saint Death” is a Mexican religious cult. It’s closely identified with criminality and has been adopted in particular by the drug cartels.

It saddens me to see it making its way north of the border. Here in Chicago there are programs specifically targeted at fighting it.

3 comments

Bad Advice

If this is the quality of the advice that Hillary Clinton is receiving, as reported at The Hill:

The press has badgered Clinton’s running mate Tim Kaine and other top surrogates, Vice President Biden among them, about Clinton’s whereabouts and why she has kept such a low profile with the election only two months away.

“I don’t think anyone can tell her story as well as she can, so she needs to be out there telling it,” said Democrat Nina Turner, a former top spokesperson for Bernie Sanders. “You have to face the voters if you want them to vote for you. You have to be out there talking to them and engaging with them and having real conversations and dialogue.”

she shouldn’t be taking it. That might be good advice for Bernie Sanders but it’s lousy advice for Hillary Clinton. Her best strategy is a “Rose Garden strategy”, maintain a low profile. The more she appears in public the worse she does. She needs controlled environments and minimum visibility.

10 comments

Does Greater Trade In Beef With Japan Advance U. S. Interests?

At the Wall Street Journal Bill Horan calls for ratification of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement to help American beef producers:

If TPP passes, annual farm exports will increase by $7.2 billion in the next 15 years, according to estimates by the U.S. International Trade Commission. The benefits would spread across American agriculture, but here are a few of the biggest bumps: $721 million in new deliveries of fruits, vegetables and nuts to Vietnam; $840 million in new beef exports to Japan; $1.2 billion in new dairy sales to Canada.

Like the United States Japanese agriculture has a byzantine maze of tariffs, price supports, income subsidies, and quotas. Present Japanese agricultural policy is summarized here. The agricultural reforms to which Japan has agreed are outlined here.

There are several things that should be apparent from scrutinizing the links above. The first is that the TPP is not free trade. It is a change in the structure of managed trade. Dragooning Ricardian trade theory to support the TPP is either outright ignorant or deliberate misdirection.

I suspect that Mr. Horan’s estimate of the likely increase in U. S. beef exports to Japan that would result from the TPP are overly optimistic. Present U. S. beef exports to Japan are still lower than they were prior to the SBE scare—some increase is to be expected in the ordinary course of events simply due to the easing of restrictions imposed after the scare. Nothing in the TPP would protect U. S. producers from another politically-motivated scare like the one of a dozen years ago.

Additionally, Japan’s population is actually declining and is expected to do so for the foreseeable future. Unless the per capita consumption of imported beef is expected to rise (something I find unlikely), while Japan will remain an important market it’s unlikely to be a growth market.

Note, too, that very few of the reforms to Japanese agricultural policy take place immediately. Most are phased in slowly and will occur when President Obama is safely out of office if ever. U. S. tariffs and quotas on light trucks on the other hand will be removed immediately.

The TPP picks winners and losers. Beef producers might be winners. Truck manufacturers will be losers.

I don’t know how to assess the benefit that the TPP might provide to U. S. ranchers. There are more than a half million of them. Most U. S. feed lot operations, slaughter facilities, and packing operations are controlled by just four companies: Tyson, Cargill, JBS, and National Beef Packing. They account for nearly 90% of the market and they will definitely benefit. All are substantial political donors. I leave it to the interested reader to analyze the political impact of the TPP.

Beef production is a major source of methane emissions (2.2% of the total—equivalent to about 24 million autos). And that’s just in volume of emissions. The impact of those emissions is probably greater since methane is a bigger problem than carbon dioxide.

I do not know how you reconcile the Obama Administration’s agonistic remarks about global warming (Barack Obama, John Kerry) with wanting more beef production.

More generally, does increasing beef exports to Japan further U. S. interests? I can see how it’s in Cargill’s interests. I don’t think the case is nearly so strong that it’s in U. S. interests.

2 comments

Inevitable Strangeness

At RealClearPolitics Seth Cropsey, musing over whether naval conflict with China is inevitable, assesses U. S. policy with respect to China:

U.S. policy toward China has failed spectacularly. China’s actions show that it sees us as a strategic competitor. We have chosen to see China as a large market that can be cajoled into joining us as a defender of international security and economic stability. U.S. policy makers hoped that the large volume of trade between China and the U.S. and the accompanying economic progress in the former would remold Chinese rulers to look, think, and act more like us. The evidence does not support this roseate hope.

He is skeptical of the Obama Administration’s “strategic patience” and recommends “active diplomacy”:

China does not respect international law. Japan and the U.S. do. American policy has done nothing to resolve this fundamental difference, and the possibility increases daily that the growing weight of opposed interests could lead to accidents or actual hostilities. The U.S. should change its policy toward China so that instead of persuading its leaders to be more like us, our objective is to convince China through diplomacy, military strength, and increased presence, that a conflict with us is not in their interest.

To what end? The harm has already been done and it will take more than diplomacy and visibility to undo it.

Military conflict is inevitable with the Chinese as long as the Chinese believe it is and China’s military authorities have made it abundantly clear that they believe it is and that they can prevail in any conflict.

The United States’s situation is unique. Because of the peculiar qualities of that situation we should never issue threats, particularly idle threats. We should merely act consistently with our interests.

What are our interests in the Western Pacific and what actions would further those interests?

3 comments