The Real Real Story on the Tech Sector

When you read this post at the Progressive Policy Institute expressing their take on the tech boom:

Suppose you were counselling your college-age child about what fields to consider. Where would you tell them to start?

The short answer: Tech and health. Just look at the numbers: Since 2007, when the current tech boom started, employment in computer and mathematical occupations–including software developers and network administrators–has grown by more than 900,000 jobs. Employment in healthcare occupations–including physicians, nurses, skilled medical technicians, and support occupations–has risen by almost 1.9 million jobs. Everything else: Zilch.

I think there are several things you should keep in mind:

  1. The total number of jobs in the U. S. is about 125 million.
  2. The total number of jobs in the tech sector is about 6 million. Nobody really knows how many tech jobs there are outside the tech sector.
  3. Wages in the tech sector have been flat for well over a decade.
  4. The total number of jobs in the healthcare sector is about 20 million. Most of those jobs are relatively low wage jobs—as in many sectors the wage distribution is extremely skewed towards the top 5% of the workers in the sector.
  5. Between 50% and 70% of the revenue in the healthcare sector comes from government in one way or another. If you think that the number of jobs and the median pay for jobs in the sector can both increase indefinitely, please explain to me the dynamics of how that will happen.
4 comments

What the Russians Think About Syria

If you want to know what the Russians think about Syria, this op-ed in The Guardian from Russia’s ambassador to the UK will give you a pretty good idea:

We entered the conflict on 30 September 2015. The western coalition had already been active there for years, dropping bombs and missiles, and supporting the highly-praised “moderate opposition” against the radicals – as they say. And still, Syria was on the edge of collapse. Isis, a byproduct of ham-fisted western social engineering in Iraq, gained new ground, pushing back the Syrian army as well as rival anti-government forces.

They brought the conflict to a new degree of barbarity and cruelty unseen since the days of Nazi Germany. Massacres, public tortures and executions, and a slave trade on an industrial scale were a daily reality in the areas held by Isis – not to mention the destruction of many historic sites and artifacts. And they seemed to be moving in for the kill: preparing to take Damascus and rule the country by right of conquest. The establishment of a terrorist state in Syria would pose a grave threat to Russia and Europe.

A year after Russia sent in its air force, reacting to a request from the legitimate government of Syria, the picture looks different. Isis is in retreat, having lost more than 4,600 square miles of territory and up to 35,000 fighters. The Syrian army and local militia freed 586 towns and villages from Isis. Their leaders – who a year ago promised to bring slaughter and chaos to other regions, including Europe – went remarkably silent.

Read the whole thing. It’s a good deal different from the saber-rattling you’ll read in the New York Times, the Washington Post, or the Wall Street Journal. Is it the whole truth? Unquestionably not. But it’s a different version of the truth than you’ve likely been exposed to.

U. S. policy in Syria is hopelessly muddled. We’ve been simultaneously fighting DAESH and arming it. While seeking peace, we’ve been prolonging war.

0 comments

The Road Forward With Russia

This article at Foreign Policy by Thomas Graham and Matthew Rojansky on how the U. S.-Russian relationship has gone wrong is the best thing on the subject I’ve read in a long time. Here’s a snippet:

The most common U.S. policy responses to Russia — from both Republican and Democratic administrations across three decades — have depended either on the hope that Moscow can be fully defeated or that it can become a friend and fellow democracy. But Russia is not a democracy, nor is it democratizing, and although Russia may be in secular decline, it is a major power on the world stage. The next president needs to accept that Moscow cannot simply be defeated or contained in the emerging multipolar, globalized world order. It must be engaged through a comprehensive balance of cooperation and competition.

The next president will have to persuade Moscow to cooperate where cooperation is needed on things like preventing the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) while limiting room for Russia to maneuver where its interests largely oppose American ones, such as in Syria. And this new U.S. policy must also recognize that tensions with Russia do not divide neatly along the lines of geography or individual issues, and that even shared interests will seldom overlap entirely. The goal should involve constructing a web of interactions, both cooperative and competitive, that yields the most beneficial balance for our national interests. But above all, rather than setting out to defeat or transform Russia, a new U.S. approach should deal with Russia as it really is.

They go on to present six steps for improving the relationship between the two countries:

  1. Understand That It’s Not Just About Putin
  2. Stop Ukraine From Becoming a Frozen Conflict
  3. Have an Honest Talk About Europe
  4. Push for More Arms Control
  5. Work With Russia in Asia
  6. Recognize That Syria Is About More Than Syria

I think that can be distilled into just three principles. First, we need to consider clearly what the U. S. interests are. Germany is not our friend and Russia is not our enemy. The U. S., Germany, and Russia are different countries and sometimes our interests coincide with each of theirs and sometimes they’re different. For the last thirty years we’ve been pushing Germany’s interests even when they aren’t consistent with our own and opposing Russian interests even when they don’t interfere with ours.

Second, a war between the U. S. and Russia isn’t in anybody’s interest. That isn’t idle speculation. Russia is taking the very bellicose words and actions that have come from the United States seriously.

Third, it’s legitimate for Russia to have interests different from ours, just as it’s legitimate for Liechtenstein or Spain to have interests different from ours. That’s what it means to live in a Westphalian order rather than an American empire. We can’t dictate to the other countries of the world what’s in their interests.

8 comments

Mosul Is Doomed

If the editors of the New York Times are right about this:

There is a lot riding on a victory against ISIS — for the civilians suffering under the terrorists’ rule; for Mr. Abadi, Iraq’s embattled leader; and for Mr. Obama, whose regional credibility has been damaged by his decision not to intervene directly in Syria. But retaking Mosul may be the easier part of an operation whose ultimate success will depend on putting in place effective long-term plans for maintaining stability and rebuilding a shattered city.

then the people of Mosul are doomed. If there’s a common thread running through American foreign policy of the last several decades it’s the failure of long-range planning. Overthrowing the governments of Afghanistan and Iraq and then boogying out isn’t carrying out a long-range plan. It’s a failure of long-range planning, whether in the planning itself or the execution. The Iraqi government has shown no ability to look beyond its immediate political goals.

Here’s what I think will happen in Mosul. If the Iraqi military can maintain force cohesion, something that has eluded them in the past, it can take the city with U. S. air support. If DAESH in turn anticipates that will be the case, it will withdraw the greater part of its force from the city before the Iraqi army arrives, leaving partisans, IEDs, and booby traps behind to harass the Iraqi and U. S. efforts.

The Iraqi government will initiate a program of ethnic and sectarian cleansing in the name of rooting out DAESH remnants. Prior to DAESH’s occupation of the city it was a mostly Sunni and Christian city. Presumably, the historic Christian churches of Mosul have been destroyed and the Iraqi government will move to Shi’itize the city. That’s likely to be carried out without being covered by the U. S. media.

If the Iraqi military cannot maintain force cohesion, it will be defeated and that will be a tremendous propaganda victory for DAESH both against the Iraqi government and the U. S. In this case I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if the Iraqi military engaged in just the sort of tactics that the New York Times is presently decrying with respect to Aleppo. The difference will be that, while the deaths of civilians in Aleppo will be war crimes, the deaths of civilians in Mosul, if we hear of them at all, will be collateral damage in the fight against DAESH.

5 comments

Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar

I’ve mentioned before that while I drive I’ve been listening to old radio programs. It’s less soporofic than listening to classical music (or even jazz) and a lot less stressful than listening to the news. I’ll probably maintain the practice at least through the election. Maybe longer.

I went through every extant episode of I Love a Mystery and its sibling, I Love Adventure (not nearly as good), Have Gun Will Travel (the only example of a TV program that was adapted for radio in the U. S.), Frontier Gentleman, and a good chunk of Gunsmoke. There’s no doubt in my mind that Gunsmoke is the greatest of all episodic radio dramas (as opposed to anthologies like Suspense or serials like I Love a Mystery).

Your Truly, Johnny Dollar was the longest-lived radio detective program. It ran from 1949 right to the end of radio drama in the 1960s.

It’s a member of the subgenre created by Carroll John Daly, developed by Dashiell Hammett (creator of Sam Spade and the Continental Op), and perfected by Raymond Chandler—hardboiled detective. There were other hardboiled detective programs on the radio, e.g. The Adventures of Sam Spade, The Adventures of Philip Marlowe, but none were as durable.

Dick Powell cut the original audition tape for the program back in 1949 and over the years Johnny Dollar was voiced by a number of actors including Edmond O’Brien and John Lund. In 1955 the program went on hiatus, retooled and recast with Bob Baily voicing Johnny Dollar, and returned in October of that year as a fifteen minute daily program (it had been a half hour weekly program, each program a self-contained story) with the five daily programs making up a single story.

And it was terrific.

Most of the stories were set in the United States but some were set in other countries including Mexico and Morocco. The show was produced in Hollywood and they hired some of the best voice talent available at the time including Virginia Gregg and John Dehner. Here’s a representative program:

The entire archive of YTJD programs can be found at the Internet Archive. The “Chesapeake Fraud Matter” was broadcast in October 1955. You can freely download them and write them to your own CD for use in the car.

5 comments

Polling the Readership

Do any of my readers still think that Donald Trump will be elected president?

I never have. You can propose all sort of explanations for why that might be but the bottom line is that he won’t be elected. However, I want to know what the rest of you think.

23 comments

In Re Medical Licensing

As Alexander Woollcott said, everything I really like to do it illegal, immoral, or fattening. That seems to be true for the solutions to policy problems proposed by pundits as well. At least that’s what I thought when I read this post at RealClearMarkets from academic Edward Timmons on the adverse effects of restrictive medical licensing on the supply of physicians. Here’s an example of an proposal that’s immoral:

Many wonder if the looming shortage of physicians can be fixed, and the answer is undoubtedly so, but how? Allowing and recruiting foreign-trained physicians from abroad would be a good start.

As anyone who’s been to a hospital or group medical practice recently could attest, “foreign-trained physicians” doesn’t mean we’re recruiting physicians from the United Kingdom, France, or Germany or any other rich country. It means we’re recruiting them from poor countries.

In most of those countries medical education is paid for in whole or part out of tax dollars. In other words the poor (people in the physician-sending countries) are being taxed so that the rich (us) can see doctors more easily. Pursuing that as a policy is immoral on its face.

It also highlights something else that I think is too little appreciated. The incomes of physicians in general or internal medicine (rather than other specialties) are much closer together in OECD countries than those of specialists. There’s a good reason for that. It’s easier, quicker, and cheaper for a foreign-trained physician to become licensed as an internist in the United States than it is in other specialties. Since all of the rich countries of the OECD are in competition for foreign-trained physicians, that means that at least to some degrees internists are a commodity and there’s a competitive global market for them and that has meant that the prices for these workers have tended to converge.

Dr. Timmons’s proposal for overcoming the effects of the laws governing medical licensing is to relax the law:

The problem with this, however, is that current regulations have created sizeable barriers to opportunity, making it very difficult for foreign-educated physicians to enter the U.S. job market. The main culprit, it appears, is an overly convoluted and lengthy process that foreign educated physicians are required to follow in order to practice in the U.S.

Additionally, non-physicians – both foreign and domestic – should be granted more autonomy and a broader scope of practice. Currently, most states allow physician assistants and nurse practitioners to prescribe controlled substances and physical therapists to see patients without physician referrals. Several additional states allow nurse practitioners to prescribe without physician supervision.

Dr. Timmons ignores the risks in his proposals. Among the risks is fraud. Although most states have laws against misrepresentation, it’s quite difficult to enforce. If India can’t enforce its own laws governing misrepresentation, how are U. S. institutions expected to screen Indian-trained practitioners?

Other risks include diminished levels of care, increased levels of medical mistakes, reduced levels of representation among physicians belonging to domestic minority groups, and increased costs of healthcare around the world (other than in the United States).

There are several alternative proposals that might be considered. The first and most obvious is to increase the sizes and/or numbers of U. S. medical schools. If the number of domestic grads had just kept pace with their numbers in 1960 (when a prominent report highly influential in the enacting of Medicare/Medicaid warned of an impending physician shortage—such warnings are endemic in the U. S.), we’d be graduating about 20% more doctors annually than we are.

The main bottleneck to this is medical residencies and the main barrier is cost. U. S. medical schools are expensive although most Americans aren’t aware of it every single medical residency in the U. S. is subsidized by the Medicare system to the tune of about $80,000 per resident per year (paid to the institution not the resident). To increase the number of grads, Medicare would need to raise its spending caps, which would require Congressional approval.

As an aside I’ve always believed that if anarcho-capitalists understood how our healthcare system actually functioned it would be much harder for them to decry the horrors of socialized medicine with a straight face. Our healthcare system is plenty socialized but its socialized in the peculiar way that programs tend to be in the United States in which costs are socialized and profits are privatized.

Even more practical would be to redraw the line between science and art in the practice of medicine. The art of medicine should be practiced by living, breathing human doctors (and our system of medical education changed appropriately) while much more of the science of medicine should be performed by machines than is presently the case.

The greatest potential for automation replacing human workers isn’t in automating the tasks performed by people working for minimum wage but in healthcare. It will take two forms. One is in the form of expert systems that will do what human diagnosticians do now but will do it more reliably at less cost. The other way is in medical recordkeeping.

Although its presently being done to some degree we’re in the infancy of the Internet of Things as it applies to medical technology. Imagine if every measuring device, every stethoscope, every sphygmomanometer, every syringe were recording data and those data were recorded automatically. If you’ve ever watched your physician struggle with the computer system in her practice or his hospital, you’ll see the potential for improvement.

7 comments

Art

The distinction between the fine arts and the practical arts is mostly sexist and classist.

Most of the poetry of today worthy of the name are song lyrics.

1 comment

Luke Cage

I just finished watching Luke Cage, the straight-to-streaming TV series that Netflix dropped a week or so ago.

Marvel began publishing the Luke Cage character long after my comic book days were over—in the early 1970s. My understanding is that it’s rooted in the blaxploitation films of that time so Luke Cage is cut from the same cloth as Shaft, Slaughter, and the other characters of the genre. Except he’s a superhero, with the soap opera overlay of Marvel comics.

I liked Luke Cage. If I were to rank the Marvel-Netflix collaborations, from first to last I’d say Daredevil (season 1), Luke Cage, Daredevil (season 2), and Jessica Jones. That’s not to say that Jessica Jones wasn’t pretty good.

0 comments

What I’ve Been Doing

This week has been a pretty busy one for me. I was taking another class. Four days, 35 hours, very difficult material. Capped by a four hour exam. I did better on the exam than I anticipated—not quite as well as the most prepared students in the class but better than most and well enough to demonstrate a reasonable command of the material. Basically, that’s the story of my life. I don’t have the level of expertise that the specialists in the field do but almost. I’m the second best at everything. A generalist. A better cook than anyone who isn’t a full time professional chef; a better musician than anyone who isn’t a full time professional musician; and so on.

Not that the world values that.

That’s the last class I anticipate taking for a while.

3 comments