One Month Out

We are one month away from the midterm elections and I wanted to put my marker down on what I think is going to happen there. The good news for Democrats is that I think that they will take control of the House and, narrowly, the Senate. When the dust has settled I expect Democrats to hold about between 218 and 230 seats in the House and 51 seats in the Senate.

The bad news for Democrats is that it will not be a “wave election” and their majorities will be small and fractious. I define a “wave” as 20 or more House seats.

As evidence for that view I would suggest reading Bryan Bennett’s post at Ruy Teixeira and Michael Bahareen’s Substack. The short version is that the Democratic “brand advantage” is sufficiently low that they are unlikely to overperform it but rather to underperform it. From the linked Substack:

The x-axis is “relative brand advantage” (RBA), which calculates how much higher or lower favorability for the Democratic Party is compared to the Republican Party. For example, in 2006, the average net favorability of the Democratic Party was net +13 and the average net favorability of the Republican Party was net -9; thus, the RBA for Democrats was +22. In 2018, the average net favorability of the Democratic Party was net +1 and the average net favorability of the Republican Party was net -16; thus, the RBA for Democrats was +17. In Q3 of 2026, the average net favorability of the Democratic Party is net -13 and the average net favorability of the Republican Party is net -17; thus, the relative brand advantage for Democrats is just +4. This post does not dwell on the deterioration of the Democratic Party brand, of which I’ve also written about extensively and expressed many concerns about, but I will say this: despite having a narrow RBA, favorability of the Democratic Party dropping by a net 26 points over the last two decades is deeply problematic and should not be overlooked.

and

When charted this way, Democrats have tended to underperform or equal their RBA in the generic ballot—and, ultimately, in the actual election results.

In others words an extraordinary presidency may produce an ordinary midterm correction.

The greater question is how will the Democrats use their new majorities? Specifically, will they devote their efforts to “fighting Trump”, will they focus on tiny minorities, or will they do their best to help ordinary Americans? I’m hoping it will be the last but I’m concerned the Democratic leadership will not be able to subdue or even resist their most extreme subfactions.

4 comments… add one
  • CuriousOnlooker Link

    If your election results pan out, I would predict at least 3 impeachment trials in the next Congress.

    When one steps back, to date Trump’s second term has a “Hollywood sequel” feel to it; the plot feels similar, but with bigger budget, bigger effects.

    So we have to beat the number of impeachments from the first term.

  • Charlie Musick Link

    Looking at the partisan breakdown of the early vote, the best case for Republicans would be an electorate that is D+3 ( 36%D, 33%R and 31%I). My best guess is an electorate that is 37%D, 32%R and 31%I.

    Based on polling crosstabs, I would expect the Democrats to win by a 97-3 margin among Democrats, lose Republicans by a 4-96 margin, and win Independents by a 59-41 margin. Doing the math with a D+5 electorate, that shows them winning the generic ballot by 11%. This would give Democrats about 235-240 seats in the House.

    With this margin, Democrats carry 53 seats in the Senate with three close races in Kansas, Nebraska (Rep against Independent) and South Carolina.

    There will be massive turnover in state legislatures as well.

    This is not what I want, but it is what I expect based on polling and early vote turnout. It’s a wave year.

  • Bob Sykes Link

    Trump’s complete betrayal of his MAGA base, lying to them about ending the Ukraine war immediately and preventing any new war, has made him deservedly toxic both to his own base and to most Americans of either party. His open subservience to Netanyahu and the other Israeli genocidal lunatics has even further discredited him. He has no leadership authority left, and occupies the Presidency by mere inertia.

    The Congressional Republicans own embrace of Trump’s madness discredits them also as any sort of governing party. They have earned a massive loss of seats, but I fear you are correct. The Democrats also are complicit in Trump’s and the Republican’s crimes, and cannot establish an identity separate from their “opponents.”

    The Democrat leadership, inherently weak and complicit with Trump, will not be able to control their own lunatic fringe, and we in for two years of grandstanding and posturing and chaos in both domestic and foreign affairs.

    We, and the World, are still marching down the road to another World War (this time with nukes) and another Great Depression. Both the Evil Party minions and the Stupid Party minions will be flabbergasted when they wake up in the Hell they are building.

  • steve Link

    It doesnt matter. Trump wont sign much of anything and the filibuster still exists. My concern would be that the one thing they might agree on is a budget. Trump might sign if he gets the big defense budget he wants and the Dems increase non-defense spending.

    Steve

Leave a Comment