France’s Conundrum

As I have said before it is not my custom to comment on the politics of countries other than my own. That is why I have refrained from remarking on the riots presently roiling France. That has not stopped the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

It’s easy to scoff at French rioting as its national pastime, but what’s unfolding now is different. France is approaching its most serious crisis in decades, and the disorder in the streets may be only the start.

Ostensibly the destructive rioting of the past few days is a student protest against underfunded schools. If you believe that, we have a pont over the Seine to sell you. The riots have been encouraged by politicians on the left, as Dominic Green recently reported on the Journal’s Free Expression newsletter.

Labor-union comrades of Jean-Luc Mélenchon, leader of La France Insoumise (“Indomitable France”), stoked the protests that quickly became riots. Mr. Mélenchon—think Bernie Sanders with a Gallic accent—visited the barricades. It feels like a display of left-wing muscle-flexing before next year’s presidential election, in which Mr. Mélenchon will be a candidate.

The violence obscures the related crisis engulfing public finances. France doesn’t have more money to spend on schools because it doesn’t have more money to spend on anything.

It is on the subject raised in the last paragraph of that quote I want to focus. According the American authorities, France has the highest military readiness of any country in Europe as the U. S. reckons such things. France’s present government spending is more than half of France’s GDP. Here is how it spends the money:

As the editors point out France’s taxes and borrowing are high while its tax revenues rise slowly. They summarize the situation succinctly: every incremental tax euro goes to pensions and health care. Neither of the two major candidates running for president of France supports reducing France’s pension or health care spending. If France increases its borrowing, it will further impede its growth.

Where will the money to increase France’s spending on education come from? The French don’t want to reduce pension or health care spending and France cannot reduce military spending without reducing its readiness and that should be discouraged. France’s conundrum is that it bears the costs of previous decisions to increase the public debt and, as I have said before, there are no mulligans in public life.

5 comments… add one
  • CuriousOnlooker Link

    There’s a couple of deus ex machina.

    First is radical life extension breakthroughs (in particular an extension in health span), reducing healthcare costs and increasing revenue from more years working.

    More “realistically”; there is “Uncle Friedrich” / “Aunt Ursala” / “Aunt Christine”. The EU could implement a European-wide pension plan that assumes the various national retirement liabilities that is funded by a EU wide income/payroll tax. This would a subsidy by the Germans/Nordics taxpayers to French pensioners, but in turn the EU gets real fiscal and taxation powers, and pensions would create a direct tie between each person in an EU member state with Brussels. Fantasical, but US had a debt deal once with the compromise of 1790 involving the assumption of state debts and Canada modified its constitution in the 1950 so its federal government could create a federal old age security act (until then a provincial responsbility).

  • Those are interesting possibilities, complicated by the French retirement age. Melenchón has been pressing to raise it while Le Pen has made a retirement age of 60 as a key plank in her platform.

  • steve Link

    Retirement age is now 64. It could help a bit if increased to 66-67. It is disappointing in some ways that so many countries spend so freely on their old people but seem to resent spending on their young. Look at all the pushback against federal student loans. They largely get paid back, especially before covid, so we have paid out fairly little for those loans. There is constant effort to eliminate these loans yet Medicare and SS are staunchly defended. Old people vote, and vote their self interests.

    Steve

  • That’s a little cleaner than the reality, steve. In France the legal minimum age runs from 62 years and 9 months (people born in 1964 and early 1965) up to 64 (those born in 1969 or later)

  • CuriousOnlooker Link

    Getting old is expansive.

    Through I will note on the bright side for France is that its trade and current accounts is roughly balanced — so an adjustment on who consumes is sufficient vs an adjustment in how much to consume like Greece or Spain 15 years ago.

    France’s tax rates is so high that they likely are on the other side of the Laffer curve — a reduction in tax rates may actually increase revenue.

Leave a Comment