Why Do Americans Feel No Better Off?

Nominal hourly earnings: +0.4%
Consumer prices: +0.4%
Real hourly earnings: unchanged

Why do Americans feel no better off?

I think the reasons are multi-factorial but there’s one factor that should be considered. The metrics being used to chart earnings and prices don’t mean what we think they do. Here’s an example.

I would suggest that the Consumer Price Index no longer comports with what most people must spend to maintain their standard of living. In particular it doesn’t keep track of housing, taxes, or healthcare in the way that most people experience them. Those costs either aren’t reflected in the CPI at all or aren’t reflected in the way households actually experience them. Home prices have risen more than five-fold (551%) since 1980. Total taxes paid (federal, state, and local) have fluctuated over the period from 25.6% of GDP in 1980 to 28% of GDP in 2022 before falling to 25.6% of GDP again in 2024. Healthcare spending has risen from less than 9% of GDP in 1980 to 18% of GDP today. Payment for pharmaceuticals has increased 24-fold over the period.

Those aren’t weighted appropriately in the CPI. That’s why people don’t feel better off. They can see how much they spend on the drugs prescribed to them have increased in price every time they go to the drug store. They don’t see how their incomes have risen (about 400% over the period).

And then there’s the dry, mathematical reality that averages conceal as much as they reveal. Without knowing how earnings and expenditures are distributed, an average tells us remarkably little about the circumstances of individual Americans.

The problem isn’t necessarily that the government is measuring inflation incorrectly. It’s that we’re using measures of inflation and earnings to tell Americans how prosperous they are while ignoring much of what determines whether they can afford the lives they want to lead.

0 comments… add one

Leave a Comment