The Real Question About China

I think I agree with Noah Smith’s most recent Substack post on China. Unfortunately, I can’t read the whole thing because part of it is paywalled. Here’s a snippet:

Anyway, I still think building up an anti-China economic juggernaut would be a great thing to do, and I still think the U.S. would benefit from closer economic integration with its friends and allies. But I think the election of Trump shows why this strategy probably isn’t going to work. The United States is simply too internally divided to engage in the sort of far-seeing, purposeful, smart kind of international competition that we pursued so effectively in the 20th century. Americans care more about fighting other Americans than about fighting the Chinese, and that state of affairs will persist for a while.

I would phrase it a little differently. I don’t think we should worry about China—it will defeat itself. We should be more concerned about our defeating ourselves.

We shouldn’t be dependent on China for the things we use in our military or the things used to make the stuff our military uses. That part can be managed. Companies in which China plays an indispensable role anywhere in their supply chains or their vendors’ supply chains shouldn’t be eligible to bid on defense contracts. That’s harder than it sounds but the reality is that having a second supplier that is not Chinese is not really a second supplier in the context of just-in-time (JIT) inventory and manufacturing.

We shouldn’t be dependent on China for consumer goods, either. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t buy Chinese goods. It means China shouldn’t be in a position to create widespread shortages or sharp price increases simply by withholding them or the materials we or our other trading partners use to make them. Recent experience should have taught us how quickly even temporary increases in consumer prices have political consequences.

None of that requires economic isolation from China. It requires ensuring that trade with China does not become dependence on China.

I have little problem with being more dependent on Canada or Mexico. Indeed, I think our economies should be more closely integrated. That will be harder still.

Do what we’re good at and let China do what it’s good at. Let China be China and the U. S. be the U. S.

9 comments… add one
  • TastyBits Link

    I am sure I will be schooled by somebody, but my hands are working, for now. So, I’ll keep my roll going.

    To be fully independent means no raw materials can be sourced from China. I am somewhat more lax on the US only policy. I think any defensive treaty ally should be qualified, but we should have a plan for a second and third source. We probably would not want Poland as the sole source in a war with Russia, but assuming they could provide quality parts, they should be acceptable.

    For those confused, Turkey is an ally. Israel is not. Japan and S. Korea are allies. Taiwan is not.

    For consumer products, I would apply strict liability, and if the manufacturers could not be touched, the burden would fall on the importers, distributors, and sellers. No tariffs would be needed, and because property laws would be upheld, libertarians (free-traders) would be thrilled.

    Goods from countries with reciprocal laws would naturally be favored. No muss, no fuss.

    Since these would be mostly countries with similar labor, environmental, etc. laws, there would not be as much of an economic advantage. Europe may be more expensive, but Japan may be less expensive. It would mostly balance out, and a small trade deficit is not a problem. Well, except politicians trying to fund a ballooning national debt.

  • Drew Link

    “We shouldn’t be dependent on China for the things we use in our military or the things used to make the stuff our military uses. That part can be managed.” AND “Companies in which China plays an indispensable role anywhere in their supply chains or their vendors’ supply chains shouldn’t be eligible to bid on defense contracts. That’s harder than it sounds.”

    You bet it is. It can be managed, but there are a number of tensions. I’ll give you a real live example; it involves a company we looked at acquiring.

    Tungsten is a strategic material. The carbide is used in many machining applications, its hardness makes it excellent for missile warheads, and alloyed in superalloys (aircraft turbine blades) and you get strength at high temperature. There are other applications. The problem is that China overwhelmingly controls the base ore and it can, and has, withheld supply. Further, as an extractive industry the environuts found it too icky, here and in other places like Europe and Australia. Fortunately, a decent percentage of the need is currently recovered from scrap, and Europe and Australia and the western US do have mines and reserves if we could invest.

    But the tensions. Environuts, commodity price swings, ores not economically located near refinement and finishing. It would take political leadership and serious people to forge the political will. And lets face it, its more sexy for a politician to tell people free beer rather than “tungsten in every pot.”

    But we do have some serious people around. Despite great criticism Trump understands to not be beholden to the economic or strategic whims of adversaries. (And I note that I have been criticized here for the notion of making financial investments – and not control positions – in strategically important industries.” The company I referenced in pp2 actually received about a $500MM capital injection for the purpose of gearing up its extractive (vs finishing) capabilities. That was spearheaded by Pete Hegseth, and a certain DJT. Its a start. Democrats were not pleased.

    I won’t go on and on about consumer goods. Sure we should have more integrated efforts with Canada and Mexico, and trade with China. But the self serving mercantilist policies of countries feeding on the American consumer has hollowed our manufacturing base. Its shameful.

  • Bob Sykes Link

    The grim reality is that the Chinese political and economic structure has significant advantages. And just shut up about our so-called but fake democracy.

    First, China has a unitary government that can and does make and implement decisions. The American federal system and its separation of powers means that just about any Presidential policy can be vetoed at the state or local level, by another branch (Judiciary being the most rogue), and even by independent agencies in the Executive branch itself.

    One example of policy gridlock is our electrical generation system, in which total generating capacity is slowly declining as coal, nuclear, hydro, and even gas are slowly retired without adequate replacement. The solar and wind projects supposed to replace them are themselves tied up in regulatory and NIMBY Hell. Viz the NY offshore wind farm fiasco.

    There is also the issue of crony capitalism, in which elected and appointed officials grease the rails for favored corporations in exchange for bribes. The Pentagon procurement offices are especially prone to such abuses, hence our hollow military.

    The Communist Party of China has no such impediments. When it decides something is in the national interest (e. g., high resolution computer chips), it sets up a regulatory environment to facilitate the activity, and it directs the financial institutions to fund it. But, the Party does not choose the companies that will provide the products or services. That part is almost classical capitalism.

    A good example is Chinese real estate. Everyone thought there was too much speculative and wasteful investment in Chinese real estate, and the Party agreed, and ordered financial institutions to redirect loans from real estate to manufacturing. Real estate markets collapsed; Western leaders rejoiced in evident Communist failure; and Chinese policy succeeded, further fueling China’s huge and rapidly growing industrial base.

    Another is high resolution computer chips, where China is freeing itself from dependence on ASML and TSMC technologies.

    China has ten times as many engineers and scientists as we do and maybe as much as 100 times our freely allocatable resources. Any time we seek to isolate them, they simply replace imports with local manufacture.

    China has been slowly reducing its exposure to the US. There is a steady, slow selloff of US Treasuries (Japan is also doing this.), and a redirection of exports to the Global South. The US now accounts for only a few to several percent of Chinese exports, about equal to one year’s economic growth.

    So, I think the US is stuck. It does not and cannot control its economically dependency on China. China will decide what those are.

  • Drew Link

    Tasty –

    I like reducing dependance on China, but I think its a process. Perhaps better, to use my tungsten example, would be to buy Chinese when we can while developing alternatives. Working out past mistakes can take time and requires some patience. But nothing starts if our electorate is just intent on voting themselves the Treasury, and politicians respond accordingly.

    Bob – I know you are a China-file. But they have problems brewing, including a demographic one bigger than ours. I don’t think you would like living there.

    More generally, to Dave’s AI queries a couple posts ago. All it would take to destroy this irresponsible position taken by certain AI execs and opportunistic Dem politicians and their hysteria is to tell the public “OK, AI and data centers are bad, so eliminate your TV and music streaming, your Instagram and Facebook, and your Google searches.” Hysteria over water and electricity would vanish pretty quickly. (As I suspect it will after the midterms.

    There is always a market for doom. But Florida is not 2/3 under water Al Gore, millions have not starved to death, the polar bears and reefs are not dead, the waves from the Atlantic Ocean are not lapping at the foot of my mountain home in GA, COVID didn’t wipe out half the planet………………………….and AI isn’t going to have robots eating people. But the motivations for control and self interest go as far back as the regulation of the railroads……………….by rail barons.

  • steve Link

    The only tungsten mine I can find is the one in Kazakstan, the one that will benefit Trump and Lutnick’s sons. There was a $500 million investment into 7 companies, several of which were actually battery recycling efforts.

    So first, I still think it’s a bad idea for the US owning, even partially, private companies. Its hard to believe that at some point someone in government doesnt decide to help manage and if the company loses money I thin its more likely we see a bailout. Give them grants or loans to minimize risk. Second, I would oppose the US investing to own companies where the kids of POTUS are invested. There are something like 20 minerals for which we are dependent on imports. Have to wonder what the motivation was for this big investment in tungsten in a country in the Russian sphere of influence.

    I dont actually know and cant find a source for how many of the critical minerals needed for defense could be minded in the US. Of those that could be at what cost? As to Trump’s efforts other than the money going to his sons/Kazakstan I dont see that much difference between him and the dems. Let’s not forget that he cut the efforts to improve battery production and chip production.

    Steve

  • Steve:

    There are tungsten mines on every continent except Antarctica. In Asia (but not in China) for example the Núi Pháo mine in Vietnam. There are lots of them in Russia. There are small-scale mines in Bolivia and probably lots of places where there could be more. There are mines in Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo. The Mittersill mine in Austria is a significant tungsten operation. Almost anywhere that granite intrudes into limestone.

  • STEVE Link

    Dave- Sure. Then why choose to invest $1.6 billion in one that is right next door to both Russia and China? In case of conflict it would be fairly easy for either of those two to shut the mine down. After all we are supposedly doing this for national security reasons. l It’s either stupidity, corruption or both.

    Steve

  • I think you’re mistaking my point. Tungsten isn’t that rare. There are known deposits in Canada, the United States, and Mexico. There are also old mines that still have tungsten but are presently in disuse. We choose to buy tungsten from China for price, political (NIMBY), and regulatory reasons.

  • steve Link

    No, I get that. You miss my point. Of all the places we could have invested Trump chose a mine next to Russia and China when we are doing this due to national security risks. that just happened to be a mine that his sons (and Lutnick’s IIRC) have financial interests.

    Steve

Leave a Comment