The Downward Spiral

I see the carnival sideshow that is Chicago city government has caught the attention of the editors of the Washington Post. In a recent editorial they observe:

Chicago’s finance chief quit last week rather than, she said, “compromise my integrity and professional obligations.” On Wednesday, the City Council responded with a remarkable 45-to-5 vote to investigate Mayor Brandon Johnson’s financial stewardship. The review will examine whether the Democrat’s administration made “material or intentional misstatements” about Chicago’s financial condition to investors, aldermen or the public.

Ashlee Gabrysch was Johnson’s third CFO to leave in a year. Jill Jaworski, who had served since 2023, left in January. Her interim replacement, Steven Mahr, lasted less than eight months. Gabrysch made it three months. Before joining City Hall, she was a senior director at Fitch Ratings and its lead analyst covering Chicago and Illinois. When the numbers did not add up, her professional obligation was to say so — and she did.

They touch on it but they don’t provide sufficient context. One rating agency rates Chicago’s bonds as one step above junk; two rate the bonds as two notches above junk. This latest brouhaha is unlikely to increase their confidence. The dust hasn’t settled yet but the next step is a long one. Junk bond status will bar many institutions from holding Chicago’s debt.

One significant thing that both the editors and the commenters in the ensuing thread miss: there is no workable, painfree way to solve Chicago problems. Chicago’s population is the lowest it’s been in a century. Chicago already imposes some of the highest combined sales taxes and among the heaviest property-tax burdens of major American cities. The state bars Chicago from taking any other steps to reduce its financial peril, e.g. imposing an income tax or amending its pension agreements. Higher taxes will cause more people to leave as will a reduction in a city services.

What we face is a downwards spiral from which there is no clear way out.

2 comments… add one
  • CuriousOnlooker Link

    Good thing that Uncle Hakeem and Uncle Chuck are now in a position to help.

    $500 billion dollars to cities and states across the US (the vast majority run by Democrats) can certainly help lower taxes and close budget gaps. A few hundred billion dollars to offload health care costs to medicare/medicaid should reduce costs as well.

  • That highlights the problem. If taxes are raised to cover the spending, it might lower the costs of those not subject to the taxes. If the money is “borrowed”, it will raise prices.

Leave a Comment