Last week as the City Council prepares to debate Chicago’s budget, Ashlee Gabrysch, the city’s Chief Financial Officer (CFO) resigned. She is the third Chicago CFO to resign in less than a year. Today she explained her reasons in an op-ed in the Chicago Tribune. Here’s her explanation:
I knew the numbers were hard when I took the job. I left because I wouldn’t present them as anything less.
expanding:
Here is the problem: in the budget address and in the press conferecnce afterwards, the mayor said 76% of this year’s budget fix is “structural”, meaning it solves the problem for good, rather than for one year. That’s only true if you leave out the money the city is borrowing to pay legal settlements, about a quarter of the total fix. When I testified, I counted that borrowing. I still do.
and I subscribe fully to the principles she outlines:
- Show in every gap-closing plan how much of the gap is truly fixed for good, using the standard of the Government Finance Officers Association.
- Budget for settlements based upon actuarial analysis.
- Don’t borrow to pay everyday bills, even if we’ve done so in the past.
- Save money for the rainy day that will come.
- Treat every new commitment as a weight on the scale, not a line in a speech.
- Lift the thumb. Let the scale tell the truth.
I think I would have said “Don’t borrow to pay everyday bills, especially since we’ve done so in the past”. Chicago’s history of borrowing for operating expenses isn’t a precedent that justifies continuing the practice. It’s evidence that the practice has failed. And IMO the “rainy day” is already here. Chicago can’t pay its pension obligations or legal settlements without borrowing or raising taxes and repeated tax increases risk driving away the very individuals and businesses on whom the city depends for revenue.
I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if many members of the City Council recognize those principles. I suspect they simply don’t know how to get re-elected if they subscribe to them, which explains a good bit of the fix we’re in.






