Take National Literacy Percentages With a Grain of Salt

In reference to his unsuccessful run for California governor, Upton Sinclair used to say “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!” Similarly, when bureaucrats’ or politicians’ livelihoods or national prestige are on the line, do not underestimate the ability of bureaucrats to torture statistical findings to produce the desired results.

More than fifty years ago there was a best-selling book, “What Ivan Knows That Johnny Doesn’t”, a comparison of Soviet and American curricula, that engendered a furor here in the States and a push for curriculum reform, shortlived as these pushes invariably are.

That’s the context in which I see the periodic panics about how the test scores of American kids on the PISA exams compare with the scores of kids in other countries, notably China. As reported by Adam Minter at Bloomberg View, China is experiencing a little panic of its own:

In 2009, Shanghai students did so well — beating the world in math, science and reading — that President Barack Obama declared it a “Sputnik moment,” requiring immediate action. A similar panic broke out in 2012. But this year proved to be a surprise. The results from the 2015 tests, released this month, showed Chinese students ranked sixth in math, 10th in science and 27th in reading. What happened?

On one hand, the answer is simple. Instead of merely testing Shanghai’s elite, the 2015 exams included a broader selection of students across China, which dragged down scores. But the results also highlighted an important problem: China’s much-lauded education system remains riven by inequality, with far-reaching consequences for schools, students and, ultimately, the economy.

There is a well-known, widespread, cheap and easy way to improve a performance of a country’s students on international standardized tests: jigger the statistics. Limit who takes the test. Engage in fraud. Teach the test. After all, who will know?

Shenanigans in reporting educational statistics is by no means limited to China. Here in Chicago our city fathers have perfected it.

There is no global, cross-cultural definition of literacy. Each country defines it in its own way and measures it on its own. I do not know that it is still the case but China used to use different definitions of literacy depending on what was referred to as the individual’s “station in life”. A farmer could be deemed literate if he could recognize his name when he saw it. The standards were higher for a factor worker and higher yet for, say, a government worker.

That’s why when I see all of those 99% literacy rates reported by UNESCO, I take them with a grain of salt, especially when they’ve improved dramatically over a very short period of time. One possible reality check is to compare the reported literacy rate with the number of books published annually in a country. In the United States that’s about 304,192, roughly 92 per 100K population. There are more books published in Spain (population 48 million) every year than in the entire Arab world (population 366 million).

0 comments

Know Your Adversary

I found a number of the insights in George Friedman’s latest offering interesting and I wish that more Americans were aware of them. For example, we have a chronic inability to evaluate the actual threat posed by potential adversaries, sometimes underestimating their capabilities:

Before World War II the U.S. massively underestimated the Japanese. In Vietnam, the U.S. underestimated both the resiliency and will of North Vietnam. In Iraq, the U.S. underestimated the response to the destruction of Saddam Hussein’s regime.

sometimes overestimating them:

World War II wrecked the Soviet Union and it would take a long time to recover. The Soviet Union had numerous weapons available, but its training, command structure morale and, above all, logistical system lacked the robustness needed to fight a high-intensity war. The Soviets knew this, which is why despite our conviction of their overwhelming strength, they never attacked. Instead, they conducted psychological operations to undermine our confidence by supporting terrorist groups in Europe in the 1970s and ’80s in an attempt to create pro-Soviet opposition groups around the world. The U.S. never clearly grasped that rather than representing Soviet strength, these operations were designed to hit American confidence. The Soviets were far weaker than imagined, and the Soviets helped us overestimate their strength.

It did not help that the CIA had a vested interest in a Soviet Union more powerful than it actually was and that the CIA systematically overestimated Soviet capabilities over a period of forty years.

His assessment of China should be better understood:

China is a significant power with problems and limits. Its core problem is a significantly weakened economy due to a decline in exports and a troubled financial system. This would be manageable in most countries, but enormous inequality and poverty has made normal adjustments to its new situation difficult. The fear of social unrest has generated a dictatorship that is carrying out an aggressive purge to ensure the party remains stable. People discuss the money China has invested in U.S. government bonds and see it as a strength. In fact, it is a weakness. It represents China’s inability to utilize this money because of an undeveloped economy, and repatriating the money would have massive effects on the yuan and inflation, further undermining China’s economy. No other banking system is large enough to absorb the money and stable enough to guarantee it. There is a significant overestimation of China’s power and a failure to see its weakness.

Militarily, China is far from ready to wage war. The People’s Liberation Army is designed for internal security. China’s geography makes aggressive warfare almost impossible. The Chinese navy does not have an operational carrier battle group. It has ships. But it has never waged intense warfare at sea, and its admirals and staff are untested in battle. Most importantly, the traditions for developing doctrines and coordinating air-sea operations don’t exist.

China could destroy Taiwan but would face grave challenges in invading Taiwan for reasons further explicated by Mr. Friedman.

This is vital:

China is substantially weaker than it looks; China knows this and is doing what it can to appear stronger and more menacing than it is to set the stage for a political solution to its problems.

I don’t honestly think that tells the entire story. China is the Rodney Dangerfield of major powers. It wants respect.

Additionally, there are yardsticks other than “existential threat”. Absent its nuclear arsenal Russia poses little military threat to us. That shouldn’t be construed as meaning that Russia is impotent. It has an imposing, highly capable military—one of the few in the world at what our military experts refer to as “C-1 readiness”. In rough terms that means the ability to maintain intensive operations over a protracted period. Turkey, for example, is not at C-1 readiness. None of our NATO allies, with the possible exceptions of the United Kingdom and France, are. I consider that a bug. U. S. policy has considered it a feature.

Russia has the ability to project substantial force outside its borders in its immediate neighborhood without resorting to nuclear weapons. That makes it a regional superpower. Does China have that ability? Do we know? Do the Chinese know? I assume they do but sometimes I wonder.

2 comments

Zsa Zsa Gabor, 1917-2016

Before the Kardashians there were the Gabor sisters. The middle, longest surviving, and probably most famous of the sisters, Zsa Zsa, has died. From Variety:

Zsa Zsa Gabor, whose 60-year career of playing herself helped paved the way for today’s celebrity-obsessed culture, has died. She was 99.

Publicist Ed Lozzi confirmed to Variety that Gabor died Sunday in her Bel Air mansion. She had been on life support for the last five years, and according to TMZ, which first reported the news, she died of a heart attack.

While Gabor had multiple acting credits, her greatest performance was playing herself: She was famous for her accented English (calling everyone “darling,” which came out “dah-link”), eccentric name, offscreen antics (including a 1989 incident in which she slapped a Beverly Hills cop) and one-liners about her jewels, nine marriages and ex-husbands. Despite her glamorous image, her life, especially in later years, was marred by battles between her much-younger husband Frederic Prinz von Anhalt and her daughter.

Her best screen role was probably in 1952’s Moulin Rouge and her most memorable, some would say unfortunately so, in 1958’s Queen of Outer Space.

She wasn’t really an actress. She wasn’t really a great beauty, either. She was glamorous and glamor is artifice. Her talents were self-promotion and artifice and her spiritual offspring today are many.

1 comment

Russia’s Ambassador to Turkey Assassinated (Breaking)

Update

Reuters is reporting that the shooter was an off-duty police officer:

ANKARA (Reuters) – The gunman who shot the Russian ambassador to Turkey in an attack at an art gallery on Monday was an off-duty police officer who worked in the Turkish capital, two security sources told Reuters.

Even worse.

Update 2

The assassination is starting to be blamed on the same Gülenists who were blamed for the coup attempt back in July:

Meanwhile, pro-government journalists in Turkey are beginning to suggest that the assassin was affiliated with the Islamist movement of exiled cleric Fethullah Gülen, who is widely blamed in the country for orchestrating last July’s abortive coup. (He lives in the Poconos of Pennsylvania and Turkey is seeking his extradition from the United States.)

Tens of thousands of Turkish officials and public employees have been arrested in a sweeping national dragnet following the failed putsch, although Altintas does not appear to have been one of them.

Ankara’s mayor, too, has suggested that Gülenists were ultimately behind the assassination.

You’ll also see characterizations that what happened in July wasn’t a failed coup but a successful purge.

Original post

In a dangerous turn of events the Russian Federation’s ambassador to Turkey has been assassinated in Ankara, Turkey’s capital. The Mirror reports:

Russia’s ambassador to Turkey has been assassinated in front of terrified witnesses allegedly in retaliation for the crisis in Aleppo.

The gunman reportedly shouted “Allahu Akbar” and said in Turkish “We die in Aleppo, you die here” during the shooting which left Ambassador Andrei Karlov dead.

The attacker was fatally shot by police after wounding Mr Karlov and at least three others, according to state TV.

Mr Karlov was delivering a speech at an art gallery in the capital of Ankara when the gunman fired a shot into the air and then shot the ambassador in a suspected radical Islamic attack, the Hurriyet newspaper reported.

This is potentially disastrous. I’ll follow up as more information becomes available.

Other links

Wall Street Journal
CBS News
Washington Post

All of the above tell materially the same story.

Izvestiya

Lots of quotes of reactions from Russian and foreign sources. Being updated on a minute to minute basis.

Pravda

Utro

Gazeta

Gazeta has more pictures if you’re into that sort of thing. They’re also updating on a minute by minute basis.

KP

Biographical info on Amb. Karlov in addition to the news story. Also being updated on a minute by minute basis.

22 comments

The 4GW Presidency

I’ve mentioned this before but not in connection with President-Elect Trump’s appointments. I don’t have strong feelings one way or another about his cabinet appointments to date but one idea I’ve been noodling over is that they may be another illustration of an approach to being president quite similar to the strategy he employed in his successful campaign: get into your opponents’ heads and control the discourse. This article at Forbes suggests that the bruited appointment of CNBC’s Larry Kudlow as the chairman of his Council of Economic Advisors supports that hypothesis.

1 comment

Whoever Has Ears Let Them Hear

At the Washington Examiner Salena Zito, who has been offering some of the most insightful observations about Donald Trump and his successful presidential campaign, makes this remark, sure to make many Clinton supporters fume:

Here is a shocker: I’d estimate based on my reporting that this election was baked before the debates, before the “Access Hollywood” tapes, before the hacked emails and before anyone took the time to actually notice, listen and understand just how upended the American voter is.

Pollsters will likely become apoplectic over my conclusion. That’s OK, they deal with numbers and could likely argue with great big gobs of data that I’m wrong; while I am not in the business of predicting, I am in the business of listening to people.

It was there in plain sight for everyone to see if they wanted to; it is clear that they did not and that is a bias towards him and prejudice towards the people that needs to be corrected.

If that’s the case, none of the explanations that have been serially proffered for Hillary Clinton’s election loss are relevant let alone explanatory. It wasn’t just the campaign; it was the candidate—who should have been expected to run precisely the sort of campaign she ran.

2 comments

This Time Was Different

Michael Barone lists some of the ways in which the political rules changed in 2016:

  1. Money doesn’t seem to matter so much any more.
  2. TV spots don’t matter so much any more, either.
  3. Celebrities don’t count.
  4. Outrageous statements aren’t disqualifying.
  5. Polling and big data don’t automatically generate the right moves.
  6. Not being able to understand how the opposition thinks is huuuugely dangerous.

He’s just scratching the surface. How could he have missed the most trumpeted difference in this cycle:

  • The truth doesn’t matter much any more.

Or this one:

  • Political experience doesn’t matter any more.

But for my money the biggie is

  • Professional campaign consultants are useless.

I think that’s the source of a lot of the angst.

7 comments

Provocations by Foreign Governments (Updated)

Given the outrage over Russia’s hacking of the DNC, I’m surprised at how muted the reaction has been to the incident of China’s seizing a U. S. drone. The New York Times reports:

BEIJING — Only a day before a small Chinese boat sidled up to a United States Navy research vessel in waters off the Philippines and audaciously seized an underwater drone from American sailors, the commander of United States military operations in the region told an audience in Australia that America had a winning military formula.

“Capability times resolve times signaling equals deterrence,” Adm. Harry B. Harris Jr. told a blue-chip crowd of diplomats and analysts at the prestigious Lowy Institute in Sydney, the leading city in America’s closest ally in the region.

In the eyes of America’s friends in Asia, the brazen maneuver to launch an operation against an American Navy vessel in international waters in the South China Sea about 50 miles from the Philippines, another close American ally, has raised questions about one of the admiral’s crucial words. It was also seen by some as a taunt to President-elect Donald J. Trump, who has challenged the One China policy on Taiwan and has vowed to deal forcefully with Beijing in trade and other issues.

“The weak link is the resolve, and the Chinese are testing that, as well as baiting Trump,” said Euan Graham, the director of international security at the Lowy Institute. “Capability, yes. Signaling, yes, with sending F-22 fighter jets to Australia. But the very muted response means the equation falls down on resolve.”

The administration has certainly not handled the situation as I would have, proof positive that you wouldn’t want me as president.

I can’t help but wonder if the action wasn’t China’s response to Donald Trump’s accepting the congratulatory phone call from Taiwan’s president.

Update

For more background on the incident see this piece by Gordon Chang at the Daily Beast:

The seizure is only the latest act in a course of belligerent conduct spanning this century. The most notorious incident involved the clipping of the wing of a U.S. Navy EP-3 over the South China Sea on April 1, 2001 by a reckless Chinese pilot. After the stricken American plane landed on the Chinese island of Hainan, Beijing imprisoned the crew for 11 days and stripped the plane of its sensitive electronic equipment. Chinese leaders, for no apparent reason, required the craft to be chopped up so that it could not be flown away.
In September 2002, China’s media claimed a Chinese fishing boat intentionally rammed the Bowditch in the Yellow Sea to disable its sonar. The incident—there may have been no ramming but there was dangerous harassment of the Bowditch—occurred in international water.
In March 2009, Chinese craft tried to sever the towed sonar array from the USNS Impeccable in international water in the South China Sea. The Victorious, Impeccable’s sister ship, was subject to extreme harassment in March and May 2009.

Mr. Chang is more belligerent about the incident than I am if anything.

Update 2

The editors of the Wall Street Journal echo the observation I made above about the incident:

Some think the theft is a response to Donald Trump’s decision to take a congratulatory call from Taiwan’s President. But the People’s Liberation Army has pulled these stunts before. In April 2001, a PLA pilot tried a dangerous intercept with a U.S. spy plane in international airspace. He misjudged the distance, losing his own life and causing the U.S. plane to make an emergency landing in China. Beijing released the crew and plane after a 10-day standoff.

but see it as part of China’s ongoing testing of American resolve:

China’s behavior shows its intention to intimidate its neighbors and establish hegemony in East Asia. In recent weeks the PLA air force has flown practice bombing missions, with fighter escorts, near the Japanese island of Okinawa and around Taiwan. The Japanese air force scrambled to intercept Chinese planes 571 times last year, up from 96 in 2010. Recently China has deployed military forces on disputed shoals in the South China Sea, contradicting President Xi Jinping’s promise to Mr. Obama.

China objects to U.S. Navy and Air Force transits near these shoals. The Obama Administration promised to carry out such missions regularly but then restricted the Pentagon to a handful. That sent a message that the U.S. can be intimidated from exercising its rights.

The incident in 2001 was transparently intended to test President Bush. I’m generally wary of the “resolve” argument as applied to foreign policy. I don’t think there is such a thing as abstracted resolve. There are, however, specific responses to specific developments. From my vantage point criticizing a lack of resolve relies on the fantasy that if we were only just determined enough, darn it, all of our foreign policy problems would evaporate, ultimately just another word for militarism.

My general impression is that for whatever reason the Chinese military does not particularly respect the United States or the U. S. military. We haven’t really given them any reason to do so. China’s foreign policy objectives clearly include asserting its imagined rightful place in the world and tweaking the U. S. is their way of puffing themselves up.

6 comments

Do As I Say

When I read the headline on this New York Times story, “Preaching the Gospel of Diversity, but Not Following It”, I clicked over to see whether it was about the Republicans or the Democrats. Imagine my surprise when it turned out to be about the New York Times:

ONLY two of the 20-plus reporters who covered the presidential campaign for The New York Times were black. None were Latino or Asian. That’s less diversity than you’ll find in Donald Trump’s cabinet thus far. Of The Times’s newly named White House team, all six are white, as is most everyone in the Washington bureau.

Traveling to other departments, Metro has only three Latinos among its 42 reporters, in a city with the second largest Hispanic population in the country. Sports has one Asian man, two Hispanics and no African-Americans among its 21 reporters, yet blacks are plentiful among the teams they cover and the audience they serve. In the Styles section, every writer is white, while American culture is anything but.

The executive editor, Dean Baquet, is African-American. The other editors on his masthead are white. The staff with the most diversity? The news assistants, who mostly do administrative jobs and get paid the least.

I wish the story had more about the backgrounds of the people who were hired by the NYT. My guess is that the pool of candidates from which the NYT draws its reporters, editors, etc. is a pretty rarified one. I’m guessing they don’t recruit a lot of cub reporters from Central Park East High School.

3 comments

Being Unemployed Is Hard

In August my erstwhile employer “cut me loose” to use the euphemism they employed. It didn’t make sense. I had generated a considerable amount of net revenue for my employer during my tenure. I had excelled at everything I did. I had been something of a rainmaker. I was well-liked. I attribute my termination to a combination of bad management, company politics, and bigotry (not mine).

After a week I updated my resume and uploaded it to a variety of job sites. Then I enrolled in and took a couple of courses, got a couple of new credentials. Updated my resume accordingly and began to field job offers.

This month I’ve begun working part time and will begin working full-time after the first of the year. Now that I know how the game is played these days, I’ll continue to update my resume and interview for new positions.

I went without work for about four months, the longest such period of my adult life. It was stressful and nerve-wracking.

For me being unemployed wasn’t a complete disaster. I save ferociously and assuming I remained in good health I could continue without a reduction in lifestyle for years.

I can only imagine what people who are in more difficult straits or have been unemployed longer are going through. Keep that in mind.

13 comments