Things to Come

At RealClearPolitics Sean Trende speculates on the upcoming reapportioning to take place following the 2020 decennial census. What’s likely to happen?

In other words, Florida, Arizona and Texas are “on the bubble” for their 29th, 10th, and 39th seats, while California is close to losing a seat, while Illinois is close to losing a second seat. With some relatively minor changes in population growth patterns, we could easily see one of them fail to win these seats. If one of these states does miss the projection, who could benefit? Seat Nos. 436-440 are projected to be: Montana 2 (436), Alabama 7 (437), California 54 (438), Minnesota 8 (439) and Virginia 12 (440). So we could see Montana gain back the seat that it lost after the 1990 census.

Overall, this represents very little change in the Electoral College. While the apportionment shifts are to states controlled by Republican legislatures (for now), it would probably benefit Democrats overall, as it is pretty difficult to eliminate any more Democratic seats in places like Ohio, Pennsylvania and Michigan, while states like Texas and Florida would probably have to draw at least some Democratic-leaning districts.

As I’ve written before I think we’re already seeing the effects of this in the outcome of the 2016 election. Deep Blue States aren’t quite as blue as they used to be while dark Red States were less red.

People are voting with their feet and those whose lives are most portable are moving first. Larger questions are how will the push and pull factors inducing the movement affect the situation? Who will blink first?

0 comments

Remediating Income Inequality at the State Level

While I agree with Elizabeth McNichol’s observation in her post at RealClearPolicy that state and local tax policies may exacerbate income inequality:

That’s because state policymakers, over the years, have tended to choose tax policies that favor the wealthy over the poor and favor corporations over workers. For example, most states rely heavily on sales taxes, which hit low-income families especially hard because they generally spend (rather than save or invest) most or all of their income.

I have reservations about her proposed remedies, which consist of avoiding cutting income taxes or increasing sales taxes and increasing the top marginal personal income tax rates:

tates can help push back against this trend by using tax policy to reduce inequality instead of worsening it. They can raise taxes on high-income households by boosting their top income tax rate and capping tax breaks for high-income taxpayers. They can also create or expand Earned Income Tax Credits for low- and middle-income workers, raise taxes on inherited wealth, and eliminate costly and ineffective tax breaks for corporations.

At the same time, states should avoid actions — such as cutting income taxes or raising sales taxes — that expand inequality by shifting more of the tax responsibility to lower-income residents. And they should avoid cutting taxes deeply without replacing the lost revenues, which could force drastic cuts in services such as schools, transportation, and public safety, which are the building blocks of shared prosperity.

Sadly, she presents no evidence for the effectiveness of her proposals and there may be a good reason for that: they aren’t particularly effective. If a more steeply graduated state income tax were a remedy for income inequality within the states, as a state’s top marginal tax rates increase you’d expect income inequality to decline. That hasn’t been the case in California, the state with the most highly graduated state income tax. The opposite has happened, if anything, suggesting either that other forces are just too much for tax policy to address or that the main effect of a steeply graduated income tax is to increase the return on investment for rent-seeking. When you add that California’s tax policy has resulted in its revenues becoming mercurial while its expenses are much more predictable, resulting in fiscal instability, it suggests that tax policy is just not a particularly effective tool in social engineering.

A more effective strategy might be to focus attention on the factors that are actually driving income inequality in the state.

6 comments

And The Winner Is…

Illinois! The Chicago Tribune reports that Illinois has lost more residents than any other state for the third consecutive year:

For the third consecutive year, Illinois has lost more residents than any other state, losing 37,508 people in 2016, which puts its population at the lowest it has been in nearly a decade, according to U.S. census data released Tuesday.

Illinois is among just eight states to lose residents, putting its population at 12,801,539 people, its lowest since about 2009. Illinois’ population first began to drop in 2014, when the state lost 11,961 people. That number more than doubled in 2015, with a loss of 28,497 people, and further multiplied in 2016.

If you change your yardstick to domestic outmigration, that is you ignore new immigrants, the state that has lost the largest number of residents is California followed by New York. Illinois still ranks first in domestic outmigration as a percentage of total population. I continue to believe that when the dust has settled and the history of the 2016 election is written, migration from Blue States to Red States will be a major part of that history.

Illinois is a place where people come and stay to work. Very few people live here for the climate or the scenery. Hostility to business and job creation and a generally mercurial government present problems that Illinois needs to change quickly before it’s too late.

It may already be too late. A large proportion of Illinois’s bills are pension payments to public employees who worked when here when Illinois was a bigger state with a bigger, wealthier tax base. A shrinking tax base finds it harder to pay those bills than a growing one would.

1 comment

How Bayes Changed Our Understanding

Even if you’re not interested in religion, history, statistics, neuropsychology, or epistemology, you might be interested in this explication at Nautilus of the origins of Bayesian statistics.

0 comments

The Scandal Is What’s Considered a Scandal

The story of the pollution of Flint, Michigan’s water supply continues its miserable slog towards being one of the gravest scandals involving official misconduct in American history. The Washington Post reports that four more officials face felony charges in the matter:

Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette filed another round of criminal charges Tuesday in the ongoing water crisis in Flint, the latest action in a nearly year-long investigation to hold accountable those responsible for a disaster that exposed thousands of children to dangerously high lead levels.

Schuette announced felony charges against four people, including two former state-appointed emergency managers who oversaw a disastrous switch of the city’s drinking water source to the Flint River. Darnell Earley, whom Gov. Rick Snyder (R) put in charge of the city’s finances from late 2013 through early 2015, and Gerald Ambrose, who held the emergency manager position through April 2015, could face decades in prison.

Prosecutors allege that the emergency managers conspired with two Flint employees, public works Superintendent Howard Croft and utilities Administrator Daugherty Johnson, to enter into a contract under false pretenses that bound the city to use the river for its drinking water, even though the local water plant was in no condition to properly deliver safe water to residents.

As I began researching this post, I started looking into the history of American political scandals and was appalled at how many sex scandals of little actual lasting significance made the lists of major scandals. In addition to the Flint, Michigan affair here are some of the incidents that I consider the gravest examples of scandal and corruption in American history:

Teapot Dome

In the Teapot Dome bribery scandal which unfolded in 1921 and 1922 the Secretary of the Interior was convicted of taking a bribe relating to government leases in Wyoming.

Crédit Mobilier

A dozen or more Congressmen were implicated in this 1867 railroad bribery case.

Whiskey Ring

110 convictions were made in this case of diversion of tax revenues. That both the Crédit Mobilier and Whiskey Ring scandals took place during Grant’s term of office made his the most scandal-plagued in American history and that was not lost on people at the time.

Operation Greylord

93 people were indicted including 17 judges, 15 of whom were convicted, as a consequence of this investigation of official misconduct and bribery in the Cook County, Illinois judicial system in the 1980s.

Iran-Contra

More than a dozen top Reagan Administration officials were either indicted or received immunity for their testimony in this complicated case of official corruption involving sales of arms to Iran and shuffling the proceeds to aid the U. S.-backed rebels in Nicaragua.

I’m accepting nominations for the greatest examples of official misconduct in U. S. history. To qualify the nominees should not be offenses of a primarily political nature or be sex scandals unless they involved more than a handful of individuals. Things that come to mind include the findings of the Knapp Commission. The New Orleans Police Department, of course, is in a class of its own.

8 comments

The Way Forward

I suspect we’ll see a lot of articles in the coming years like this one at VoxEU, proposing that Ethiopia’s economic development plans might want to consider skipping industrial development and go straight to a post-industrial economy:

A country’s path to middle-income status lies, in large part, through industrialisation. African countries are scrambling to bring industrial firms into the continent. As low-income countries industrialise, more workers will be able to choose between informal self-employment and low-skill manufacturing. What do workers trade off when they make this choice, and what are the long-run impacts? How well do we understand the relative costs and benefits of these types of work?

It seems to me that the opportunities for developing countries are closing rapidly. With China’s manufacturing economy overbuilt as enormously as it is, many sectors capable on their own of supplying the entirety of world demand, how much room is there for more industrial development? With an India full of (more or less) English-speaking and college educated people looking for jobs, what opportunities are there for Ethiopian service providers?

Greece is just full of small companies and entrepeneurs. The problem there is capitalization. Why won’t an Ethiopia that skips the industrialization step succumb to the same problems Greece has?

0 comments

Sometimes a Cigar Is Just a Cigar

There’s an interesting report at BBC on a series of killings in Turkey apparently perpetrated by Russian hitmen. It’s written in a sort of stream of consciousness style so it’s difficult to excerpt. I couldn’t identify the name of the piece’s author but he seems to believe that the Russian government is behind these killings.

He might be right but there are any number of shadowy and nefarious Russian groups these days. Besides the Russian government there’s organized crime, oligarchs, competing Chechen groups, and others who just might have wanted these men dead. Sometimes it’s difficult to tell where one of these groups ends and another begins.

We’ll need to keep our eyes opened for more developments on this story.

3 comments

Dealmakers vs. Chess Players

The meat of Uri Friedman’s piece at Atlantic speculating on the incipient Trump foreign policy is this paragraph:

During Trump’s presidency, transactional thinking—the freewheeling pursuit of deals—could become the organizing principle of the administration’s foreign policy, rather than one element of it, as in past administrations. Previously unthinkable bargaining chips—including, apparently, a vulnerable island of 23 million people in the Taiwan Strait—could come into play. The question of what is negotiable, and what isn’t, will be a persistent source of uncertainty. Is America’s commitment to the most peripheral members of the NATO military alliance a tradable asset? What about U.S. security commitments to countries like Japan and South Korea? Developments that initially seem like one thing (a phone call suggesting closer U.S. relations with Taiwan) could turn out to be another (an opening gambit in complex U.S. negotiations with China). Trump and his team may prove to be masterful negotiators on behalf of U.S. interests. Or they may prove to be dangerous or incompetent ones. As Dominic Tierney points out, Trump has so far signaled that he will fulfill Putin’s desires in Syria and Ukraine in exchange for the mere possibility of improved relations with Russia—pretty weak stuff from a guy who claims to drive a hard bargain.

U. S. foreign policy has always vacillated among competing interests—mercantile interests, idealistic (some would say ideological) interests, populist interests. For most of American history mercantile interests have dominated our relations with other countries and I don’t think we should be surprised if a Trump administration puts the hands of Hamiltonians (realist pragmatic mercantilists) at the tiller for the first time in twenty-five years. At this point it’s too early to tell.

4 comments

China’s Debt

The unfolding scandal surrounding the Chinese brokerage Sealand Securities, reported here at Financial Times and widely underreported here in the States, is refocusing attention on the sheer unfathomably massive scale of China’s debt. The editors of the Wall Street Journal remark:

Government interference had pushed China’s bond market into bubble territory over the past two years. Beijing encouraged companies to issue bonds to reduce their reliance on bank lending, while prodding others to buy them. The authorities also rescued troubled companies to prevent them from defaulting, which has led to a fundamental mispricing of risk that will make the correction all the more painful.

As always, the bursting of a bubble reveals who was swimming naked. Last week, brokerage Sealand Securities defaulted on a bond-financing transaction allegedly made by a rogue employee. Rumors are also circulating that investors are pulling their money out of funds holding bonds. Firms that used high leverage to deliver promised returns now face margin calls.

The larger question is whether China’s real economy is itself a bubble. According to official figures, bank lending and social financing are growing at roughly double the rate of GDP. Total debt now stands at 260% of gross domestic product, up from 154% in 2008. That doesn’t count the trillions of dollars in loans that banks have classified as “investment receivables” and other such dodges.

I’ve seen estimates that China is borrowing $6 to get each additional $1 of GDP. It’s hard to see how that could continue indefinitely.

When you divvy Chinese debt into its component parts there’s individual debt, corporate debt, and government debt including the debt of local governments. Nominally, the preponderance of the debt is corporate debt. However, to an extent that is illusory. Many of China’s largest companies are state-owned enterprises and, unsurprisingly, they’re the largest borrowers, too. Since China’s banks are state-owned, that means that most of that debt is the government borrowing from the government. Some of that debt is resurfacing in California in the form of cash-only purchases of multi-million dollar homes but that’s a subject for another post.

So the Chinese government is borrowing from the Chinese government and an increasingly large proportion of the borrowing is going to service past loans owned to the government by the government. The PBoC then releases more money to provide liquidity. Welcome to the wonderful world of fiat currencies.

Can it go on forever? The Chinese are in the midst of a fascinating experiment. We’ll know the results soon.

2 comments

What Do CEOs and Generals Do?

As I read Tyler Cowen’s musings at Bloomberg View on President-Elect Trump’s appointments:

In addition to expertise, an appointee may be picked for some of these reasons:

  • Ability to command the interest of the public in policy change
  • Ability to influence Congress
  • Ability to think outside the usual Washington “boxes”
  • Ability to reach and motivate the president when necessary

The unusual backgrounds of many Trump appointees make more sense by these standards. For instance, Trump does not seem to be detail focused or policy oriented, as Obama has been. It’s therefore more important that he can rely on advisers to direct his attention. That means nominating candidates who have credibility with him and who can speak his language, rather than eggheads. Those same individuals might be relatively effective taking their cases to the broader public, even if they don’t have experience working the levers of Washington.

it occurred to me that it’s too bad that more people don’t know what generals and big company CEOs actually do. In addition to having substantial managerial expertise, possibly more than anything else they’re politicians accustomed to working through large, complex organizations. The image that some journalists seem to have of generals or corporate CEOs commanding legions of myrmidons into action with imperious sweeps of their hands is a figment of their imaginations.

Re-purposing Tolstoy’s remark, all large organizations are the same. Small organizations are all small in their own way.

11 comments