A Specter Is Haunting

A specter is haunting the opinion writers of the United States and its name is “Despair”. From George Will:

Viewing 2016 in retrospect — doing so is unpleasant, but less so than was living through it — the year resembles a china shop after a visit from an especially maladroit bull. Because a law says “the state of California may not sell or display the Battle Flag of the Confederacy . . . or any similar image,” a painting of the 1864 Siege of Atlanta was banned from display at the Fresno County fair. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services churned out a 25-page policy statementabout “the systematic inclusion of families in activities and programs that promote children’s development, learning, and wellness. ” That is, government should provide, as an act of grace — systematic grace — a role for parents in raising their children.

to Fareed Zakaria:

In the West, these two traditions — liberty and law on the one hand, and popular participation on the other — became intertwined, creating what we call liberal democracy. It was noticeable when I wrote the essay, and even clearer now, that in a number of countries — including Hungary, Russia, Turkey, Iraq and the Philippines — the two strands have come apart. Democracy persists (in many cases), but liberty is under siege. In these countries, the rich and varied inner stuffing of liberal democracy is vanishing, leaving just the outer, democratic shell.

What stunned me as this process unfolded was that laws and rules did little to stop this descent. Many countries had adopted fine constitutions, put in place elaborate checks and balances, and followed best practices from the advanced world. But in the end, liberal democracy was eroded anyway. It turns out that what sustains democracy is not simply legal safeguards and rules, but norms and practices — democratic behavior. This culture of liberal democracy is waning in the United States today.

to the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

Turkey and Russia announced Thursday that they have brokered a cease-fire between the Syrian regime and the non-radical opposition, with a peace conference to follow next month in Kazakhstan. This is a vultures’ peace, with the two authoritarian powers and Iran preparing to negotiate over the bloody carcass of Syria as they advance their strategic interests in the Middle East.

the tenor of their commentary has overwhelmingly turned to one of despair.

It is not anger or righteous indignation—those would call one to action and there are no exhortations in their writing.

I’m reminded of Robert Bolt’s words in A Man for All Seasons:

And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned around on you–where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country’s planted thick with laws from coast to coast–man’s laws, not God’s–and if you cut them down…d’you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I’d give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety’s sake.”

or Hosea 8:

They that sow the wind, shall reap the whirlwind.

God bless us every one.

8 comments

Militarization

This piece by Greg Watcher may open some readers’ eyes:

We all understand that the EPA is tasked with enforcing environmental laws. But does it really need a full-blown military-style police force? Congress granted the EPA police powers in 1988, but not with SWAT teams in mind. Even now, the agency says its Criminal Enforcement Program “enforces the nation’s laws by investigating cases, collecting evidence, conducting forensic analyses, and providing legal guidance to assist in the prosecution of criminal conduct that threatens people’s health and the environment.” Well yes, but also by midnight raids with Swat teams and attack dogs, confiscating private property, hauling people off to jail for accidentally spilling a barrel of oil, and other “enforcement” horrors.

During the period covered by the Open the Books report, EPA spent over $3 million on military equipment, including guns and ammo, tanks, drones, helicopters, camouflage, night-vision goggles, and other military hardware. And cops – EPA spent $715 million altogether on its Criminal Enforcement Program. APHIS spent even more – $4.77 million on guns, ammo, and military equipment, as well as the salaries and expenses of 140 cops. At EPA, there are almost 200 of these “Special Agents,” and the agency estimates that each one costs taxpayers $216,000 per year in salary, travel, equipment, training and other expenses.

Other agencies with military-style equipment and cops include the Department of Commerce, Internal Revenue Service, Food and Drug Administration, and the Smithsonian Institution (guards to protect museum artifacts are one thing, but drones, helicopters, and SWAT teams?). The National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Maryland has its own cops with a fleet of Crown Victoria police cars, as do the Bureau of Engraving and Printing, Library of Congress, National Park Service, Forest Service, BLM, Fish and Wildlife Service, Marine Fisheries Service, and even the Government Printing Office.

Or maybe not. Maybe most people think that the Government Printing Office should have its own military.

2 comments

The Best of the Best

This being the turn of the year and all we’re starting to see a lot of “Best of…” lists. The best such list I’ve seen so far is Dan Drezner’s list of the best writing on political economy of 2016 at the Washington Post. It’s recommended reading even if don’t like economists or politicians.

Here’s his summary, located oddly enough at the end of his piece:

The overall tenor of the 2016 Albies is that the Whig theory of history is wrong.

0 comments

What’s Wrong With the World

I found Nicholas Pell’s op-ed in the Washington Post proclaiming the gospel that humanity is no better today than it was a century ago hopelessly confused:

Each time progressives invoke the current year, they give up an opportunity to rigorously defend their position and convince others to see their point of view. Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau prompted cheers in November 2015 when he answered a question about why gender parity was important in his administration by saying, “Because it’s 2015.” Similarly, Bustle, reflecting on Donald Trump’s Cabinet appointees, lamented, “It’s 2016 . . . and in this modern age, you might’ve thought we’d come further in terms of equality and diversity than, well, it now looks like we have.” Missing is any argument about why Trump shouldn’t have selected the people he nominated or why diversity is important.

For one thing he repeatedly confuses technological progress with moral progress. You are much more likely to survive a heart attack than you were a century ago. That isn’t a sign of moral progress but of technological progress. Medicine is a technology and technologies build upon the past so it isn’t surprising that a century’s worth of work, development, and enormous investment would yield some results.

Government, too, is a technology but for whatever reason it’s one more resistant to building upon the successes of the past than information technology, automotive technology, or medical technology. If there’s one thing that a life much of which was spent evaluating technology has taught me, it’s that the best technology does not always prevail.

Civilizational morality might be a technology, too, but I see no evidence that personal morality is. Mother Theresa’s notable morality will not make me more moral unless I elect to emulate her.

Besides, I think that Mr. Pell labors in vain. It’s too darned hard to improve on what G. K. Chesterton said on the very subject he attempts to address. Here are some examples:

My attitude toward progress has passed from antagonism to boredom. I have long ceased to argue with people who prefer Thursday to Wednesday because it is Thursday.

Progress is Providence without God. That is, it is a theory that everything has always perpetually gone right by accident. It is a sort of atheistic optimism, based on an everlasting coincidence far more miraculous than a miracle

Progress should mean that we are always changing the world to fit the vision, instead we are always changing the vision.

An imbecile habit has risen in modern controversy of saying that such and such a creed can be held in one age but cannot be held in another. Some dogma was credible in the 12th century, but is not credible in the 20th. You might as well say that a certain philosophy can be believed on Mondays, but cannot be believed on Tuesdays

For those who think that humanity has made aggregate moral progress, you might want to consider a few things. There are more people living in slavery now that at any time in human history. More people were killed in the last century by their own governments than the sum total of those who had been killed in previous centuries. The gap between the richest people and the poorest people is the greatest in human history.

5 comments

Russian Officials Expelled

The editors of the New York Times applaud the Obama Administration’s expulsion of officials in retaliation for Russian hacking of the Democratic National Committee:

His latest response shows real teeth, chiefly in the form of sanctions on Russia’s two leading intelligence services, the F.S.B. and GRU, including four top officers of the military intelligence unit who the White House believes ordered those attacks. Mr. Obama also placed sanctions against a number of other individuals and companies, such as the Special Technology Center, which conducts signal intelligence.

Mr. Obama also expelled 35 Russian intelligence operatives and barred Russian diplomats from using two recreational compounds in the United States. The White House said this action was specifically in response to a two-year pattern of harassment of American diplomats in Russia by Kremlin security personnel.

It will be interesting to see what the next shoe to drop will be. Although this might be it. It’s a Kremlin announcement that they don’t intend to retaliate in kind, gently mocking the Administration for retaliating against children (they implicitly characterize the “recreational compounds” mentioned above as areas for children), and inviting the children of American diplomats in Russia to Kremlin children’s New Year’s parties.

3 comments

The Fungus Among Us

There’s a very good article at Nautilus on how basic research into the biology of chytrids, a particular group of fungi, has proven valuable in understanding mass die-offs of amphibians, bats, and oak trees.

0 comments

Not Taking Up the Gauntlet

I’m disappointed that no one, whether supporter or opponent of the president, took up the gauntlet I threw down the other day. “He either fears his fate too much, etc.”

11 comments

The ACA Succeeded

Contrary to any claims to the contrary, the Affordable Care Act did not fail. It succeeded brilliantly in two ways. The first and most practical way is that under the auspices of the ACA a lot of people received insurance and substantial subsidies who otherwise would not have done so.

The other and probably more lasting way in which the ACA succeeded was that it moved the Overton Window. Of the two guiding principles of the ACA, it is pretty clear that guaranteed issue has become an enduring part of the conversation.

If community rating does as well, it will constitute a rejection of the insurance model as applied to paying for healthcare. I have no idea what will replace it. Nationalizing it is no solution, as I mentioned earlier today.

The strategies employed by other OECD countries probably won’t be much of a guide. Our problems are unique. For one thing we’re the only country in the world that shares a 1,500 mile land border with a country where the median income is a quarter what it is here.

16 comments

Was the ACA Too Timid?

In response to that question and assertions by Kevin Drum, at Bloomberg View Megan McArdle answers it in the negative:

I agree that higher subsidies and a stronger mandate would have made Obamacare less of a policy train wreck; we probably wouldn’t be so worried about a death spiral if they had passed. On the other hand, it would have made the program much more of a fiscal train wreck. Kevin suggests that they should have just raised taxes on the rich, but for reference, the total repeal of the Bush tax cuts was projected to raise only about two-thirds of the amount needed. And since they were projected to expire, that was not a source of revenue that Democrats could use to fund Obamacare.

Funding this extra entitlement by tapping the rich would have been, to put it mildly, unpopular with an important part of the Democratic base: urban professionals. They would have, in the course of a few years, seen about 10 percent of their gross income, and a considerably larger fraction of their take-home pay, vanish. Nor would they be excited when politicians came back to them for even more money to pay for little incidentals like our growing entitlement gap.

Nor, as Kevin suggests, could Democrats have simply hand-waved the cost away. Bills have to be scored by the Congressional Budget Office. The Congressional Budget Office would not have scored heartfelt paeans to the economic benefits of broader health coverage (and to the extent that they would have, most of those benefits were already in the score the bill got.) If Democrats had tried to pass a bill that cost $2 trillion over 10 years, the Congressional Budget Office would have scored it as such, and that is the cost that the media would have reported. This — not a tragic surfeit of honesty — is why Democrats didn’t take the-time-honored approach of telling wild lies about what their plans would cost.

The Affordable Care Act is built on certain principles: guaranteed issue (everybody should be able to get insurance) and community rating (people living in the same area and in the same age cohort should pay the same premiums). Either one of those principles can exist within the insurance framework but together they can’t. For a program to be insurance, premiums must be proportional to risk.

Kevin’s strategy rests on some assumptions: that a plan of any cost can be financed by taxing “the rich” and that there is no limit to the political acceptability of such a plan. In her article Megan calls the latter assumption into question.

But there’s another problem. With healthcare costs rising at a multiple of the increase in other costs and, importantly, at a multiple of the increase in incomes, it wouldn’t be a case of increasing taxes once and forget it. It would be increasing taxes again and again and again to finance a hungry healthcare system which I characterized in my last post as “writing providers a blank check”. Can you envision politicians doing that? Me, neither.

3 comments

The Ticking Clock

If J. D. LeDell’s prediction at The Moderate Voice is correct, the incoming Congress may not need to repeal the Affordable Care Act. It may have become inoperative long before then:

In the meantime, if Republicans vote to repeal Obamacare(either right away or at some future effective date) without a replacement ready to implement, Obamacare as we know it will cease to exist no later than January 1, 2017 as every insurance carrier will flee the market.

I think he may mean January 1, 2018 but either way is not particularly good news for the program. Mr. LeDell’s expressed preference is for the federal government to underwrite the entire healthcare insurance market, in full or part.

His diagnosis of the problem, essentially, is that the constraints of the ACA make it impossible for private insurers to make a profit:

What should be done to cure Obamacare’s ills? Quite simply make rates reflect expected health care costs by age. Obamacare mandates that the difference in rates between a 63 year old can be no more than 3 times the rate for a young healthy 20 year old. In actuality, the 63 year old rates should be 10 times that rate for the 20 year old. In fact one of Obamacare’s biggest problems is that a 20 year old can find costs in the regular individual market that are half of Obamacare’s rates while the 63 year old will never ever find a rate as good as he can under Obamacare. Unfortunately, the designers of Obamacare took too much of what makes borrowed community rating practices from HMO’s and modified them without understanding the fundamental differences of the two. You can be sure that the 13 million people covered by non-Obamacare individual health policies are young and healthy since their rates are lower than Obamacare.

which is another way of saying that the ACA requires that healthcare insurance not be insurance. For a plan to be insurance premiums must be proportional to risk.

Once you’ve rejected the idea of healthcare insurance as insurance, keeping the system financially viable is a real challenge. Whether underwritten by the federal government or not, the system must be financially viable. Either we must be prepared to write providers a blank check, costs must be reduced, or rationing imposed. There really is no other alternative.

1 comment