I want to endorse the goals outlined in Alana Semuels’s piece at Atlantic:
There was a time, half a century ago, when what was good for many American corporations tended to also be good for America. Companies invested in their workers and new technologies, and as a result, they prospered and their employees did too.
Now, a growing group of business leaders is worried that companies are too concerned with short-term profits, focused only on making money for shareholders. As a result, they’re not investing in their workers, in research, or in technology—short-term costs that would reduce profits temporarily. And this, the business leaders say, may be creating long-term problems for the nation.
“Too many CEOs play the quarterly game and manage their businesses accordingly,†Paul Polman, the CEO of the British-Dutch conglomerate Unilever, told me. “But many of the world’s challenges can not be addressed with a quarterly mindset.â€
despite any reservations about the specific policy changes she outlines. We need to align the incentives we put in place with national objectives. This conclusion, however, worries me a bit:
Perhaps most compelling of the American Prosperity Project recommendations are those that companies can undertake on their own. After all, Congress has been and will likely be locked in gridlock going forward, and it’s doubtful it will take up bills that address corporate taxation or tax incentives in the new session. So instead there are recommendations in the report that individual companies can implement, if they truly want to put an end to short-termism. They include giving enhanced shareholder voting rights to investors who hang onto stocks for the long term, and voting on executive pay in a longer time frame so that executives’ incentives aren’t aligned with the need to post big quarterly gains. They also include discouraging short-term earnings guidance so that companies can focus more on the long term. Companies can, after all, refuse to issue earnings guidance, and only share financial information when they issue quarterly reports and other financial statements.
Years ago when I was working for a Fortune 500 company, my boss said something to me that has stayed with me to the effect that if he looked beyond the next quarter the quarter after that there would be another guy sitting at his desk who was focusing on the next quarter rather than the longer term.
Off-hand some of the reforms we need to consider include:
- Reverse the Clinton era reforms to the treatment of stock options as executive compensation that incentivized short term thinking and put the gap between top management pay and ordinary worker pay on steroids.
- Stop incentivizing companies to invest overseas.
- Provide greater incentives for companies to invest here at home.
- Change the H-1B and L-1 visa programs so that businesses can bring in the workers they need without using importing workers as leverage to reduce wages.
The economic story of the last fifteen or so years hasn’t been a shortfall in consumer spending or government spending but not enough business investment and importing too much. We need policies beyond cuts in the top marginal rates of the personal income tax.






