The venerable Macy’s and Sears retail chains are struggling. Sears may not last the year. Why? In his Washington Post column Robert Samuelson ponders the question. Here’s his answer:
We have two systems to do one job. Companies have to support the old as well as the new technology. People no longer buy everything in stores, but stores are still necessary. (In 2016, e-commerce totaled about 8 percent of retail sales.) Still, the loss of sales makes brick-and-mortar stores less productive, and their loss of productivity offsets some or all of the gains from digital technologies.
This is, I think, the basic explanation of what’s happening at Macy’s and Sears. They have to invest in the new technology, even as the value of the old technology erodes. The effect is compounded because they’ve been slow to shut marginal stores. There’s always the hope that these stores will bounce back and avoid large losses.
I don’t believe his explanation holds water and it certainly doesn’t explain why Amazon is opening brick and mortar locations.
I think the problem is that Macy’s and Sears are poorly managed. That’s what my experience as a vendor of Sears albeit many years ago tells me. That Sears, the company cut its teeth on catalogue sales, couldn’t figure out that a new kind of catalogue sales had become important, leaving an opening for the upstart Amazon suggests that.
Online is not their only competition. They’re also competing with scads of specialty stores.
Half the time when I go to a brick and mortar retail store I’m told that they don’t have what I’m looking for in stock but I can get it online. To me that doesn’t suggest that they’ve got a technology problem (they’ve already done the investment) but that they’re having an identity crisis.
Brick and mortar stores can compete based on service, based on price, or because you can get what you want now. If they can’t do any of those, they’ll lose, not just to online but to other retail competitors.
Keep in mind that Amazon doesn’t make any money in retail sales, either. The company is making its money providing web services, the infrastructure it built to support its retail operation.
Here’s another explanation: maybe ordinary people, the kind that Sears used to consider its customer base, just don’t buy as much as they used to because they don’t have the money. Retail sales increase when people buy Ferraris, sable coats, and 120 inch 4K flatscreen TVs, too. But you don’t need a lot of physical locations to do that. Just a few very carefully placed.