I have an almost uncontrollable urge to provide an interlinear translation to Mohammad El-Erian’s latest contribution to Bloomberg View. For example:
Since the eruption of the global financial crisis in 2008, the Fed has adopted a highly “data dependent†approach to policy making. The fact that the crisis took Fed officials by surprise, together with a recovery process that has been far from usual and coupled with repeated growth/inflation forecasting errors, have undermined the Fed’s understanding of the economy’s behavior and the effectiveness of its analytical models, especially the historically-calibrated ones.
Translation: the FOMC members don’t know what the heck they’re doing. Or
The Fed became a hostage not just to high-frequency economic data (and the unavoidable “noise†that accompanies them, including some large subsequent revisions), but also to markets.
Translation: the FOMC has abandoned the Fed’s dual statutory mandate in favor of the single-minded objective of making the DJIA go up. At least they can measure that on a day by day basis.
Must resist the temptation. Must resist the temptation.
I presume Mr. El-Erian would rather speak for himself and waive consecutive translation, as they say at the UN.
The viewership for the annual telecast of the Academy Awards ceremony has decline for the third consecutive year, says the Hollywood Reporter:
A long and eventful 89th Academy Awards continued the ABC telecast’s recent downward ratings trend.
After initial indicators had Sunday’s lengthy show off from 2016, time-zone adjusted tallies give this year’s Oscars an average 32.9 million viewers. That marks a 4 percent drop in viewership from the prior. Early stats had the show averaging an overnight 22.4 rating among metered market households. (Last year’s outing saw its overnight score, a 23.4 rating, ultimately translate to 34.4 million viewers.) In the key demo of adults 18-49, this year’s show averaged a 9.1 rating — off a more dramatic 14 percent from the 2016 telecast, which averaged a 10.5 rating among the advertiser-favored viewers.
Once upon a time the Academy Awards were the only nationally-televised awards show. Now there are dozens of them. Add the various reality shows which are essentially scripted awards shows orchestrated as weekly television programs and it’s just too much.
During the heyday of the studio system the Academy Awards were used to promote movies. Most Americans including the members of the Academy have never seen this year’s Best Picture winner and in all likelihood never will. What the heck were the Academy members voting for?
If the Oscars get a bump next year, following the snafu over announcing the Best Picture winner it will be the equivalent of gaping at a traffic accident. I doubt that will happen and as the people who remember when the Academy Awards presentation was a unique, glamorous event die off its viewership will continue to decline.
There are plenty of stories receiving inadequate attention these days. One of those is famine created by war, as reported here in the Washington Post:
The world is in the grip of an astonishing and acute crisis: More than 20 million people in South Sudan, Somalia, northern Nigeria and Yemen face starvation in the next six months, according to the United Nations. Nearly 1.4 million children are at “imminent risk” of death. The scale of the hunger epidemic was described last month by U.S.-based researchers as “unprecedented in recent decades.”
Unmentioned in the story: the U. S. is up to its neck in all of the conflicts mentioned above. Special Forces operations have been reported in all of them over the course of the last year. I can’t vouch for the veracity of the reports, of course, but that there are reports is undeniable.
Famine is always political. It’s either a weapon of war, a consequence of war, or a product of indifference.
You might want to read the post at American Affairs by Michael Anton, “America and the Liberal International Order”. Its gist is based on a desire to make the “liberal international order” great again.
Heck, I’d be satisfied if the liberal international order were liberal again. Romanticizing the Middle East or Islam isn’t liberal. Neither is tolerance of China’s bad behavior in pursuit of a buck.
In honor of the 89th Academy Awards ceremony (“the Oscars”) to be televised live tonight, rather than talking about the best Best Pictures I’d rather think about some of the worst—the least deserving winners. Here’s my list:
Cavalcade (1933)
Cavalcade is a sort of 1930s antecedent to Upstairs Downstairs. Maybe it had more reasonance in the aftermath of the Great War. There’s nothing particularly wrong with it but nothing particularly right with it, either. I believe that it suffers when compared with several of the other nominees that year which were 42nd Street, A Farewell to Arms, I Am a Fugitive From a Chain Gang, Lady for a Day, Little Women, The Private Life of Henry VIII, She Done Him Wrong, Smilin’ Through, and State Fair. Most of those are iconic in their way and half of them have been remade; Little Women and State Fair have been remade multiple times. Cavalcade is practically unknown now except among film buffs.
Out of Africa (1985)
I guess I just don’t get Out of Africa. I think you could have made just about as good a picture by taking a camera out to the veldt, turning it on, and walking away. Its competitors included the actual best picture, The Color Purple, and Witness.
Dances With Wolves (1990)
I’m sure that there must be fans of Dances With Wolves out there but I found everything about it wooden—direction, acting, and the screenplay which I found almost intolerably patronizing. If you are attracted to this subject matter, watch the 1931 version of The Squaw Man, a better picture in practically every way with a wonderful, touching performance by Lupe Velez.
Keep in mind that Good Fellas and Ghost were among DWW’s competitors.
It’s easy to come up with the best Best Pictures. Which winners of the Best Picture Academy Award do you think are least deserving or worst?
As you listen to the flood of predictions about economic growth being made by the Trump Administration and its supporters, I thought the graph above might be a helpful tonic.
There’s a good post on the politics of immigration policy at The Week by Damon Linker. Here’s a snippet:
Many liberals argue that refugees are among the most vulnerable people on Earth and so must be welcomed with open arms. That forcing undocumented immigrants to leave the country is gratuitously cruel, violates their rights, and so justifies municipalities flouting federal law by turning themselves into “sanctuary cities.” That banning entry to refugees or immigrants not yet within the United States can violate their due process rights under the U.S. Constitution. And that the desire to restrict immigration is invariably an expression of xenophobia, racism, and other forms of irrational animus and so morally (and perhaps constitutionally) indefensible.
All of these claims are, at bottom, expressions of a fundamentally anti-political humanitarian ideology that is unlikely to fare well in the next presidential election. Democrats desperately need to confront the vulnerabilities of this position and stake out a more defensible and pragmatic one if they hope to push back against Trump’s populist-nationalist message in upcoming years.
Many Americans believe that their constitution presumes or appeals to certain timeless, universal moral truths that apply to all human beings. But the U.S. Constitution itself — like the constitutions, fundamental laws, and commonly affirmed norms and rules of all political communities — is nonetheless instantiated in a particular place, rooted in a particular tradition. It also pertains and applies only to people who are members of the political community known as the United States of America.
Those who are members of this community are known as American citizens. They get a say in what laws get passed and how they get enforced. Those who are not members of this community — who are not citizens — don’t get such a say. The community is perfectly within its rights to decide which and how many of these outsiders will be allowed to visit the country, how long they will be allowed to stay, when they will need to go, and how many, if any, will be permitted to join the community permanently by becoming citizens.
When you stake out your position based on transcendent moral truths rather than on cost-benefit analysis, there’s no room for compromise. What is the resolution of a difference of opinion where there’s no room for compromise? The only peaceful resolution I can see is divorce.
I see that George Will has caught wise to a point I’ve made here many times. You can’t judge the scale and reach of the federal government from the number of federal employees. There are about as many federal employees today as there were 50 years ago. However:
Since 1960, the number of state and local government employees has tripled to more than 18 million, a growth driven by federal money: Between the early 1960s and early 2010s, the inflation-adjusted value of federal grants for the states increased more than tenfold. For example, the EPA has fewer than 20,000 employees, but 90 percent of EPA programs are completely administered by thousands of state government employees, largely funded by Washington.
A quarter of the federal budget is administered by the fewer than 5,000 employees of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) — and by the states, at least half of whose administrative costs are paid by CMS. Various federal crime and homeland security bills help fund local police departments. “By conservative estimates,†DiIulio writes, “there are about 3 million state and local government workers†— about 50 percent more than the number of federal workers — “funded via federal grants and contracts.â€
Then there are for-profit contractors, used, DiIulio says, “by every federal department, bureau and agency.†For almost a decade, the Defense Department’s full-time equivalent of 700,000 to 800,000 civilian workers have been supplemented by the full-time equivalent of 620,000 to 770,000 for-profit contract employees. “During the first Gulf War in 1991,†DiIulio says, “American soldiers outnumbered private contractors in the region by about 60-to-1; but, by 2006, there were nearly as many private contractors as soldiers in Iraq — about 100,000 contract employees, not counting subcontractor employees, versus 140,000 troops.†Today, the government spends more (about $350 billion) on defense contractors than on all official federal bureaucrats ($250 billion).
Finally, “employment in the tax-exempt or independent sector more than doubled between 1977 and 2012 to more than 11 million.†Approximately a third of the revenues to nonprofits (e.g., Planned Parenthood) flow in one way or another from government. “If,†DiIulio calculates, “only one-fifth of the 11 million nonprofit sector employees owe their jobs to federal or intergovernmental grant, contract or fee funding, that’s 2.2 million workers†— slightly more than the official federal workforce.
To which add the estimated 7.5 million for-profit contractors. Plus the conservative estimate of 3 million federally funded employees of state and local governments. To this total of more than 12 million add the approximately 2 million federal employees. This 14 million is about 10 million more than the estimated 4 million federal employees and contractors during the Eisenhower administration.
So, today’s government is indeed big (3.5 times bigger than 5½ decades ago), but dispersed to disguise its size. This government is, DiIulio says, “both debt-financed and proxy-administered.â€
If anything that understates the situation. Upwards of half the entire healthcare sector—more than one sixth of the economy—is paid for by the federal government. In effect half of the millions of workers in the healthcare sector are government workers.
After the French left Vietnam in 1954 and the country was partitioned, Dwight D. Eisenhower and, after him, John F. Kennedy sent billions in aid and advisers to support the South Vietnamese government under Ngo Dinh Diem. His weak regime needed the money to ward off the Communist insurgency of the Vietcong, a guerrilla force aided by the north’s Ho Chi Minh, who had designs to reunify Vietnam. It was an outcome the Americans couldn’t accept: According to the so-called domino theory, a Communist victory in Vietnam would inevitably snowball across the region.
And yet Vietnam remained a trouble spot that continued to fester. With the tacit backing of the Kennedy administration, a military coup occurred on Nov. 1, 1963, resulting in Diem’s assassination.
It was a move about which Johnson had deep misgivings. “I don’t believe assassination is ever justified,†he said later. “They were ruthless people. Ho Chi Minh was. But I mean it was ruthless of the United States government, with our boasted list of freedoms, to condone assassination because you don’t approve of a political philosophy.†Still, after Kennedy’s assassination, Johnson dived into Vietnam immediately. “Those first few days,†he remembered, “Vietnam was on top of the agenda, before the visiting heads of state got home from the funeral.â€
It’s easy enough to explain. He was minimizing personal downside risk. If he had “lost Vietnam” he would have paid for it at the polls. He made the cynical calculation to escalate the U. S. involvement, presumably under the mistaken impression that the war could be won quickly and at little cost.
As it turned out it cost him another term as president and his reputation, still in tatters with the Democratic Party, and cost more than 50,000 young Americans including many of my friends and acquaintances their lives and many more their health and youth.
When this story first came out it gave me a certain amount of blackhearted amusement. I was a bit surprised to see it make national news. The editors of the Wall Street Journal remark on the state of Wisconsin’s crackdown on Irish butter:
We all know how unpopular President Trump has made himself in Mexico (see nearby). But Wisconsin state regulators seem determined to outdo him by making themselves as unpopular in Ireland by banning state grocery stores from selling one of the Emerald Isle’s most popular (and tasty) products: Kerrygold butter.
Never mind that Wisconsinites have been buying Kerrygold for years with no problems. Or that it remains legal in the 49 other states. Badger State bureaucrats, trying to protect the state dairy industry, are suddenly enforcing a 1970 law that requires all butter sold in the state to go through a complicated evaluation by a state panel. This is the same state that once banned margarine because it was a competitive threat to local dairies.
Kerrygold is a premium butter made from the milk of free-roaming, grass-fed cows. But as a result of the ban, Kerrygold-loving Wisconsinites have been forced to make butter runs across the state border, bringing back suitcases stuffed with the import. In Ireland, meanwhile, the ban is leading to headlines such as this in the Irish Mirror: “Shopkeepers in Wisconsin could face JAIL if they sell Kerrygold butter.â€
Let me put that into a little perspective for you. Dairy farming and related businesses account for about 25% of Wisconsin’s economy, 10% of the jobs in the state, and a substantial chunk of labor income. Nearly 50% of the state’s land is devoted to dairy-farming.
Needless to say dairy farmers and particularly the dairy industry wield a lot of clout with the state legislature in Wisconsin. A couple of years back I took a cheesemaking class. The teacher of the class was a long-time professional cheesemaker and noted rather sadly that in Wisconsin (where the class was taught) it was easier to buy cocaine than it was to buy raw milk—preferred for cheesemaking. He claimed that there were industry narcs routinely driving up and down rural Wisconsin roads looking for people selling small quantities of raw milk for cheesemaking to turn them in to the state authorities.