Dystopian Future

The prevailing view among Silicon Valley’s elite enunciated by Gregory Ferenstein at City Journal:

As far as the future of innovation and its impact on ordinary people, the most common answer I received in Silicon Valley was this: over the (very) long run, an increasingly greater share of economic wealth will be generated by a smaller slice of very talented or original people. Everyone else will increasingly subsist on some combination of part-time entrepreneurial “gig work” and government aid. The way the Valley elite see it, everyone can try to be an entrepreneur; some small percentage will achieve wild success and create enough wealth that others can live comfortably. Many tech leaders appear optimistic that this type of economy will provide the vast majority of people with unprecedented prosperity and leisure, though no one quite knows when.

seems to me remarkably naive. I guess I attribute that to how young they are. Even Bill Gates, a relative greybeard among the technological elite, probably has no clear memories of very high marginal personal income tax rates and his dad in all likelihood was not affected by it.

High marginal tax rates don’t prevent people from being rich; they prevent people who aren’t already rich from becoming rich. The rich will do what they always do: avoid, evade, and, when all else fails, flee.

These elites’ preferred outcome works in diametric opposition to their business model, embedding the status quo in amber rather than allowing the highest achievers to rise to the top.

Besides, they’re remarkably innumerate for people in tech. You could tax Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, and Jeff Bezos at 100% and it still wouldn’t realize enough revenue to pay for their vision. For that you need to have high marginal tax rates right down to the top 10% of income earners. Basically, no one in Silicon Valley could afford to live there under those circumstances.

3 comments

There Is No Such Thing As a Permanent Majority

You might want to check out academic Musa al-Gharbi’s post at The Conversation on the recent trends in American politics, particularly the eye-catching graphs about half-way down the page, illustrating Democrats’ loss of vote shares in 18 demographic categories from 2008 to the present. Mr. al-Gharbi explains:

It may be tempting to hold onto the faith in an emerging Democratic majority. Some predict Trump will self-destruct and his followers will be consigned to irrelevance, to the “wrong side of history,” as President Obama often phrased it.

On the one hand, as a social psychologist, I understand this impulse toward comforting thoughts. However, given my background in applied social epistemology, I also know it is imperative for progressives to have a clear-eyed view of the situation at hand.

The Democratic Party is in crisis. Demographics will be unlikely to save them. If anything, the trend seems to be going in the other direction.

and

For instance, there is a common misconception that Trump was ushered into power by old, white, economically disenfranchised men. However, according to the exit polls, Trump actually did worse than Romney among whites and seniors, but outperformed him among blacks, Asians, Hispanics and young people.

While the Democrats lost a lot of support among low-income Americans, I think it would be a mistake to interpret these as Trump’s base. He won a plurality of every income bracket above US$50,000 as well. He also won more non-Christian and nonreligious voters than any Republican since the 2000 election.

Now my explanation for what has happened is somewhat different than Mr. al-Gharbi’s. I think that the Democratic leadership has made some disastrous miscalculations, probably assuming that “wrong side of history” nonsense mentioned above.

Time, particularly political time, is not an arrow. Neither is it a cycle. People respond to events as well as identity.

The American people historically have not been ideological. Pushing the two major political parties towards programmatic parties rather than the “catch-all” parties they’ve always been brings little but misery, clearly illustrated by Gallup’s findings on political identification.

Republicans shouldn’t take any solace in their present ascendancy. The political parties must reform rather than pontificate and the American people respond over time to events.

4 comments

The One Sentence

In reading Daniel Henninger’s most recent column in the Wall Street Journal mostly my eyes just glazed over. I know that he likes Republicans, doesn’t like Democrats, etc.

Except when reading one sentence and this is it:

Which is to say, if the alt-right flirts with white nationalism, the alt-left always conducts politics at the edge of violence, such as the trashing last month of UC Berkeley.

Is that empirically correct? The answer is important.

My impression is that the Tea Party ≠ alt-right and Bernie Bros ≠ alt-left and that the Tea Party movement, at least originally, was a genuine grass-roots movement while there has always been a lot of astroturf in the various left-leaning attempts to replicate the Tea Party’s successes? Is that wrong?

Meanwhile, the other day I was sitting in the waiting area of a tire store and the guy I was sitting next to casually mentioned that his daughter aspired to be a professional demonstrator. I can’t help but feel that’s the political equivalent of the shoeshine boy offering stock tips.

12 comments

Daley for “Stop and Frisk”

In an op-ed in the Chicago Tribune William M. Daley, brother of former Chicago Mayor Richard M. Daley, son of the late Mayor Richard J. Daley, and former Obama Secretary of Transportation, comes out in favor of stricter gun laws in Illinois and, I believe controversially, in favor of “stop and frisk laws”:

Those of us in less crime-prone neighborhoods shake our heads in dismay. But as citizens of Chicago we have an obligation to act with greater outrage and urgency.

First, Illinois must require mandatory prison time for illegally carrying a gun in the state. People lawfully owning licensed firearms need not worry. The General Assembly has been studying and preparing to change gun laws while people keep dying. Enough! Act!

In 2006, New York increased its mandatory penalty for carrying a loaded illegal gun to 31/2 years in prison. Many factors affect violence, but one fact is stark: New York City, with a much larger population, had fewer than half as many homicides last year (334) as Chicago did.

Gun laws can and must be justly enforced. NFL standout Plaxico Burress spent nearly two years in prison for carrying an unlicensed handgun (with which he accidentally shot himself in a New York nightclub). He rightly was treated the same as any nonfamous, nonwealthy person.

Second, we must give police wider leeway to stop and search suspects for illegal guns. Many people wrongly believe a federal judge in New York City ruled that stop-and-frisk policies are unconstitutional. In fact, the judge specifically said such tactics can be legal if they don’t amount to racial profiling.

A study of New York City’s stop-and-frisk policy, published last year in a Columbia Public Law Research Paper, concluded that targeted police stops “based on probable cause or (indications) of actual crime” were associated with “significant crime reductions.”

Civil libertarians will cite the recent U.S. Department of Justice report that sharply criticized Chicago police conduct. Those findings will help drive reforms, but they must not prevent us from taking new steps to reduce gun violence.

In many ways his comments repeat the fantasies that Chicago’s politicians have been promoting for years. “If only you got rid of the guns.” You can’t get rid of the guns. Mandatory penalties might put a few more young black men in jail but they won’t make the streets safer—there will be lots more gang members as long as the reasons that young black men join street gangs are not dealt with.

One of the reasons that the streets on the South and West Sides are not safe is that the people who live there don’t trust the police. How can they be expected to trust a police department whose members murder their neighbors in cold blood, torture them, aren’t punished for their crimes, and in any of a thousand other ways violate their rights and break the law?

Here’s my question for Sec. Daley: how will “stop and frisk” laws improve the relationship between the CPD and the people of the South and West Sides? My guess is that they will aggravate an already bad situation.

Remedying the Chicago Police Department is up to the city government and the CPD. Tougher penalties and “stop and frisk” laws won’t do that.

4 comments

Maybe Not Complacency

In his recent column at the Washington Post Robert Samuelson explores Tyler Cowen’s suggestion that “complacency” could explain our present slow economic growth:

We don’t move to new jobs as much as we once did; the cross-state rate of migration is down roughly 50 percent from its 1948-71 average. We don’t form new companies as fast as before; he cites one study estimating that start-ups now represent only 7 percent to 8 percent of firms, down from 12 percent to 13 percent in the 1980s. We increasingly cluster with people “like us” — in class, educational background — by marrying them and living in the same neighborhoods.

In isolation, none of these trends may be crippling, but collectively they undermine the economy’s flexibility and its “dynamism,” says Cowen. If people won’t move for work, some productive jobs will go unfilled. The growing segregation by background and lifestyles reinforces the reluctance to move. The scarcity of start-ups hampers job creation and higher living standards.

There may be some complacency involved but I don’t think that complacency, implicitly defined by Dr. Cowen as “increasingly valuing security and stability”, quite captures what’s happening.

The dictionary definition of “complacency” is:

self-satisfaction especially when accompanied by unawareness of actual dangers or deficiencies “When it comes to safety, complacency can be dangerous”.

and I believe that other explanations are more credible in explaining today’s lack of “dynamism”:

  1. Managers have other alternatives to domestic investment for producing business growth or, at least, preventing business decline including overseas investment and rent-seeking, cf. the GM bail-out.
  2. As I’ve mentioned before, large companies with the clout to get legislation enacted in their favor or engage in “lawfare” to prevent competition can inhibit start-ups.
  3. Inadequate demand can make increased investment look less attractive.
  4. Getting into other lines of business (particularly financial) may be a less risky way of producing business growth than expanding present business lines. It’s hard to imagine Henry Ford letting the auto business founder to become a banker. Or Tom Edison deciding that it made more sense to become a financier than invent the light bulb. Present day managers probably do not have that commitment. A company that was formerly a manufacturer may in effect become a wholesaler today through out-sourcing their manufacturing. And so on.
  5. Multiple career households may make families “stickier” than they used to be. My mother-in-law followed my father-in-law anywhere he needed to go for work. If she’d had a career of her own, particularly one that paid more money or that wasn’t particularly portable, staying put even in the face of his unemployment could just be making the best of a bad situation rather than complacency.
  6. Mortgages that are “underwater”, in which people owe more than than their houses are worth, make people less likely to move for work. The percentage of underwater mortgages tends to be inversely correlated with high unemployment rates particularly in regions where property values aren’t being pushed up by other factors, e.g. the Upper Midwest.
  7. There actually might be some people somewhere who won’t move for work because of high levels of public services where they are, AKA the “Great Vacation” theory of economic turndown, but I think it’s pretty rare.

and any number of other factors. I wouldn’t count those so much as complacency as financial realities.

3 comments

The Speech Last Night

Yes, I watched President Trump’s speech last night. I thought that as a piece of rhetoric is was better than most of the breed. I thought that the organizational device he used throughout the speech, first saying what his administration had done with respect to some topic, then outlining the principles guiding the actions, was effective. I also noticed a variety of rhetorical devices including anaphora, hyperphora, juxtaposition, and appeal to emotion that were used effectively. Whoever wrote the speech knew what he or she was doing or at least had some exposure to the genre.

As I generally do I also watched part of the speech on Youtube with the sound off. President Trump has a much flatter affect than I anticipated. That probably serves him well in negotiations.

That’s all I have to say.

6 comments

Take the Over

The LA Times reports that a state-level single payer health insurance system is being pitched for the state of California:

With President Trump now vowing to put forward a replacement for the Affordable Care Act in March, some California politicians and healthcare advocates are once again promoting the idea of a state-run “single-payer” system that operates like Medicare.

Backers say the uncertainty surrounding Trump’s promise to repeal Obamacare presents California with a chance to rethink how healthcare is delivered to its 39 million residents.

“Why wouldn’t we take this as an opportunity to create what we want in California?” Dr. Mitch Katz, head of L.A. County’s health department, said at a conference in December. He mentioned a single-payer system as a possible solution.

Maybe we should start a pool. When will California adopt its own single-payer system?

I also wonder what the actuarial assumptions would be for the viability of such a system.

13 comments

Maybe Not So Rare

At RealClearLife they report on a medical condition they characterize as “extremely rare”:

Scientists are finding one woman’s case particularly memorable.

As The Guardian reports, 51-year-old Jill Price was the first person in history to be diagnosed with “superior autobiographical memory,” and is one of just a handful of individuals known in the world who suffer from it. What exactly does that mean? She’s remembered everything—dates, situations, and other parts of life’s minutia—since 1980.

Where she was, who she was with, what was playing on the television — it’s all burned into her memory.

The only surprising thing to me in this is that they’re calling it “extremely rare”. I think it’s just underdiagnosed.

8 comments

February Blood

Chicago’s homicide rate for the year-to-date is running higher than last year’s, probably facilitated by the warmer than usual weather in February. Last year’s homicide rate here was nearing the highest on record, the previous record having been set 25 years ago.

For those of you who envision a future world without work, these homicides are taking place in a handful of neighborhoods where the unemployment rate for young men in the target demographic for gangs is running upwards of 50%. Income isn’t the only factor. If work did not exist, we would be forced to invent it.

3 comments

Dying Is Easy; Comedy Is Hard

For comedy writing it’s hard to beat Jaap de Hoop Scheffer and Hans Binnendijk’s advice to the European members of NATO at the RAND Blog:

Europe can deliver its portion of this bargain in three ways. First, it needs to demonstrate the value of its existing military contribution to the alliance. A Trump visit to the new British aircraft carrier, to be armed with American F-35s, would help to dramatize existing contributions.

Second, Europe needs a bold initiative on burden sharing. This is not an issue for Trump alone; a broad consensus exists among defense thinkers on both sides of the Atlantic that Europe has been a free rider for too long. Trump has just been bold enough to raise the stakes.

Europe should commit to reaching its agreed goal of spending 2 percent of its gross domestic product on defense in five years rather than 10. That would give Trump some bragging rights during his term in office.

In addition, Europe might use this additional defense spending to make a few highly visible purchases of U.S. defense equipment. Germany might buy more cargo and reconnaissance aircraft. The Netherlands might buy more F-35s. Poland might invest more in U.S.-made air defense. NATO itself might lease U.S. forward-deployed defense equipment. And so on.

Remember the value that Trump placed on his successful effort to prevent Carrier from moving a small air-conditioning plant to Mexico? Symbolism will be important here.

And third, NATO as an institution could play a larger role in global operations against militants’ attacks. This initiative would address much of the reason Trump called the alliance “obsolete.”

Allow me to react to each of those numbered items in turn.

  1. Yes, emphasizing that the Anglosphere should go it alone is an excellent way to highlight the Continent’s intentions.
  2. Do they really believe that’s politically possible? European countries have pressures, too, and as I read the tea leaves building up their militaries won’t do anything about the pressures they’re under. Besides, we know with a confidence based on experience that any investment in equipment which France, Germany, or Italy, the major economies among our Continental NATO allies, will be willing to make will be backdoor subsidies to their own economies rather than to ours. Those economies aren’t doing too well right about now.
  3. With what? Having credible forces takes time and our European NATO allies have neglected theirs for a decade at least. There are only two European NATO members whose forces are at the highest level of readiness: the United Kingdom and France and they’re just about at the limits of their abilities already. Under the circumstances for NATO to “play a larger role in global operations” means greater American commitments rather than greater European commitments. How will that play in Peoria?
2 comments