The Trade Story

Michael Pettis’s account of the story of global trade, recounted here at Bloomberg, is better than most. For example, his explanation of Germany’s behavior and its effect on other European countries:

After a decade of trade deficits and high unemployment, worried leaders in Berlin implemented labor reforms in 2003-05 whose main effect was to weaken wage growth. As unemployment dropped and business profits surged, the reforms also shrunk the share of national income allocated to ordinary households, driving down the consumption share as well.

German businesses, blessed with higher profits, responded unhelpfully. They paid down debt instead of investing the profits, increasing the share of national income devoted to savings. As the growing gap between German savings and investment soon became among the largest in history, so did the German trade surplus. German banks exported the excess savings into other European countries, no longer protected by the interest-rate and currency adjustments proscribed under the rules of the euro. By 2009, after insolvency prevented one European country after another from absorbing any more of the German tsunami of capital outflows, these shifted to countries outside Europe.

Germany’s behavior has not been benign. They’ve solved their own economic problems to the detriment of their trading partners.

However, I find this just puzzling:

As counterintuitive as it may seem, if Trump wants to address the U.S. trade deficit with China, he must focus on the capital account, not the trade account. Instead of imposing tariffs, he should either implement policies that absorb foreign savings more productively into the U.S., say by exploiting historically low interest rates and investing in much-needed infrastructure whose economic benefits are too diffuse to be captured by the private sector.

Why does he think that would happen? It sounds to me as though he’s just expressing a preference for one kind of consumption over another. How is building the 153rd bridge across the Mississippi “more productive”? Particularly on the federal level we don’t pick infrastructure projects based on return on investment but on how much they’re wanted by preferred constituencies, political allies, or donors. I think that if we were picking infrastructure projects based on ROI we’d be greenlighting power grid improvements, which certainly fit his rubric of “economic benefits are too diffuse to be captured by the private sector” over roads, bridges, and better Admiral’s Clubs in airports. But more resilient and secure power grids with enhanced ability to adapt to changing circumstances don’t have the constituencies that those other investments do.

Our problem with infrastructure is different than China’s. We’re a developed country. Our problem is not that we don’t have enough roads and bridges but that we have too many. Comments like that inevitably bring up the civil engineers’ report. Their report says nothing whatever about ROI. It just says we build roads and bridges but don’t maintain them. That’s our political problem and IMO is a direct consequence of state and local officials’ propensity for trying to extract more federal funds for their projects rather than turning to state and local taxes, increasingly dedicated to paying for the pensions of public employees and paying interest on debt rather than infrastructure spending. Relying more on Uncle Sugar won’t change that and IMO building more roads and bridges won’t change global capital flows.

But I think this is correct:

Or his administration should change the way savings imbalances are transmitted into the U.S., for example by taxing capital flows, which the U.S. was doing as recently as the 1960s.

But I’m quite certain that Dr. Pettis knows better than this:

What Trump shouldn’t do is get involved in a tit-for-tat tariff war with China that sidesteps the real sources of the imbalances. In a world in which capital flows overwhelm trade flows, trade imbalances are driven by imbalances in global savings, and the U.S. cannot resolve the former without addressing the latter.

because there’s very little that we can do to control the behavior of the Chinese authorities. They will do what they will do for domestic economic and political reasons without any regard for what we want, need, or do. Our ability to influence their behavior is quite limited.

What we should do is what they would do. Rather than being worried how the Chinese will react we should do what we need to do politically and economically. Being more worried about what Xi might think than we are about ourselves is perverse.

6 comments

The Gold Rush

In just a few sentences in his article at Newsweek Jeremy Gelbart expresses my view of autonomous vehicles pretty succinctly:

Will there be a future where autonomous cars dominate the roads? Yes.

Will this future be in 3 years? No way.

It’s even possible that autonomous vehicles will never “dominate the roads”. It depends on all sorts of things, mostly non-technological.

I honestly don’t think that most people understand all of the hype we’re hearing about autonomous vehicles. In the California Gold Rush of 1849 great fortunes were made but mostly not by the miners. The greatest rewards were reaped by the people who sold tools and supplies to the miners.

I don’t believe that Google or Elon Musk want to be the General Motors of autonomous vehicles. I believe they want to sell the AI technology to the companies that will compete to manufacture autonomous vehicles. And, in Elon Musk’s case at any rate, to secure rents.

0 comments

Improving Infrastructure

While I continue to demur with what I see as a facile interpretation of the report card on U. S. infrastructure produced annually by the American Society of Civil Engineers, I do think that Suneel Kamlani is onto something in his plan for improving U. S. infrastructure at Bloomberg View:

One promising solution is for states or regional economic zones to lead the way by creating their own infrastructure banks, modelled on successful development banks in other countries. The Northeast has taken the first step, with Massachusetts filing bills in January to establish a state infrastructure bank and examine a regional one. This model could be easily replicated across the U.S. to accelerate investment and economic activity.

How would it work? Taking the Northeast as an example, states from Massachusetts to Maryland could create a jointly owned entity capable of financing critical projects, including those that cross borders. Each state would contribute part of the initial equity, which could then be leveraged with private debt to invest in revenue-producing projects. The equity could be boosted through annual contributions from state transportation budgets — or from other sources — with every new dollar having a multiplier effect.

The federal government could even kick into those “banks”. As Mr. Kamlani notes, the plan has several benefits: projects could be funded on a portfolio basis, because of the greater diversity of their operations these “banks” might be attractive investment opportunities for pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, etc., and it’s a model that has been shown to work.

Best of all from my standpoint it would allow attention to be paid to projects that might not seem significant to an administrator sitting in Washington, DC but might be of obvious importance to somebody in Hanover, Delaware.

2 comments

A Better Border Adjustment Tariff

At Bloomberg View Ted Halstead proposes what appears to me to be a much better border adjustment tariff than the one proposed by the Trump Administration:

China is several times less energy-efficient than the U.S., emitting far more greenhouse gases per unit of economic output. Whether the industry is steel, cement, clothing or electronics, this amounts to an implicit subsidy for dirty production in China, at the expense of U.S.-based manufacturers. The way to level the playing field is to penalize China’s carbon intensity.

The Trump administration has instead based its trade strategy on the outdated notion that China is a currency manipulator. These days, the renminbi is, if anything, overvalued, not undervalued. The White House has also toyed with the idea of a border adjustment tariff as proposed by House Republicans. America’s retailers are fiercely opposed, however, and this proposal would probably run afoul of World Trade Organization rules.

The shrewd play for Trump would be to pivot to a border carbon-adjustment policy, something that would benefit most American companies and be compatible with WTO rules. It would tax the carbon contents of imports from all countries whose environmental standards are weaker than American ones, and rebate any carbon fees paid by U.S. companies on the products they export to those countries. This would enhance our terms of trade and substantially reduce the U.S. trade deficit with China.

To do that while remaining within World Trade Organization rules, we’d need to impose a carbon tax here. That could be done on a Pigouvian basis. The federal government is spending a lot to keep the trade in oil flowing. We’re keeping the sea lanes open, for example. And the trillions we’ve spent on military expeditions in the Middle East haven’t strictly been for humanitarian reasons, believe it or not.

Such a move would also provide a different way of thinking about our trade relationships with other countries not limited to China but particularly in the case of China. The list of possible border adjustment tariffs isn’t limited to carbon. There are clean air and water regulations, labor regulations, safety regulations, and any number of others.

Do we support safe workplaces just here in the United States or everywhere? Twenty years ago most rare earth elements used in the semiconductor and other industries were produced here. Now they’re produced in China. The reason that those industries and the jobs they supported pulled up stakes was due to air and water regulations. Rare earth refining operations can be damaging to the environment.

Do we just oppose environmental damage here in the United States or do we oppose it everywhere?

1 comment

From Comments

This comment is so good I’ve promoted it from comments to the front page. Referring to the revelations about the “unmasking” of the names of Trump Administration officials by Susan Rice in classified reports:

This whole situation is extremely troubling for a number of reasons:

  • You have an incoming/new administration with what appear to be at least uncomfortably close ties to one of America’s primary strategic adversaries. The extent and consequence of these ties isn’t yet known.
  • You have the outgoing administration possibly using the quite powerful tools of the intelligence community in order to damage a domestic political opponent. We don’t know the extent and consequences of that either.
  • In all this, we have factions in the government and especially the always anonymous government officials who will gladly compromise US intelligence collection of foreign adversaries through selective leaks of information, sources and methods for partisan purposes. The vast majority of these leaks clearly come from upper tier political appointees.
  • We have the legions of myopic, blinkered partisans with their selective outrage based solely on partisan scorekeeping and not first principles.
  • We have a completely ineffective Congress, a powerful Executive that is only held back by the courts which are under increasing political pressure.
  • Finally, we have a public that is divided, is ignorant on the details of most of these issues and is kept ignorant by media outlets that selectively filter and spin information to serve various agendas. Amid all this are the various weekly “outrages” that are either manufactured or lack any importance, but serve as distractions or useful political tools for purposes like character assassination. These outrages are quickly forgotten as others rise to replace them in the great circle of life called social media and the 24/7 news cycle.

None of this, on it’s face, is good. It’s evidence we are either in a political crisis or on the cusp of one. We can monitor the building pressure but we cannot predict the spark. In the thread on Venezuela I thought about taking issue with [ed. another commenter’s] comment about how we aren’t in a position to sneer about other countries, but on second thought I think he’s right.

A crisis is often necessary to bring needed change in the face of sclerotic governance, but there’s no guarantee that we won’t auger in like Venezuela is doing.

24 comments

The Venezuelan Limbo

How bad could things get in Venezuela? At RealClearWorld Allison Fedirka speculates:

The most likely scenario is a combination approach in which public unrest is the major engine driving the transformative process. As options for legal resolution – such as elections – become less likely and daily quality of life deteriorates, public unrest will intensify. Regardless of how these forces combine, they exist and are converging to a point of rupture this year, which will result in the breaking point for Maduro and his government. For the first time in nearly two decades, the United States and others in the region will have the opportunity to reset relations with Venezuela.

I don’t think I’d be so quick to dismiss the Venezuelans’ ability to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. Their track record has been pretty solid lately.

7 comments

Changing Times

At RealClearWorld Robert Zaretsky provides a briefing on the French presidential election. His thesis is that there’s a dramatic change going on in French politics:

The second debate on April 4, unlike the first debate, will include all 11 presidential candidates. Despite the enlarged cast, all eyes will be on three candidates — Le Pen, Melenchon, and Macron — none representing one of France’s traditional political parties. Regardless how the debate, and the first round, sorts itself out, politics as usual in France will be the great loser.

1 comment

Housing Vouchers

There’s an interesting article on the effectiveness of housing vouchers at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities you might be interested in. Here’s a snippet:

Rigorous research shows that vouchers — which enable families to rent decent, modest, private-market housing for about 30 percent of their income — sharply reduce the frequency with which low-income families move and the share of such families that live in overcrowded housing, doubled up with other families, in shelters, or on the streets (see chart).

That’s the sort of policy that should be able to garner bipartisan support.

1 comment

Is There a Future for NATO?

Not the North Atlantic Treaty Organization although there’s some doubt about whether there’s a future for that, either. The other NATO. The National Association of Theater Owners. Movie theaters are having a bad time. Here’s what happened at their most recent convention as reported at The Verge:

Studio after studio touted their box office achievements. Executives couldn’t stop dropping superlatives, describing how the business was “thriving.” NATO chairman John D. Loeks went so far as to call reports about various threats to the industry “fake news.” But the truth is the industry is facing challenges, something that only Disney’s executive vice president of theatrical distribution, Dave Hollis, really had the courage to acknowledge directly.

“Even though we’ve had these gains in overall box office, we can also see that attendance has been more or less flat,” Hollis said during a Tuesday state of the union presentation. He stressed that while ticket prices have largely masked the problem, attendance simply isn’t growing, with the exponential uptick in internet usage and other activities a likely culprit. “This is disruption personified,” he said, to a near-silent industry crowd.

It didn’t help that a week before the show, Variety reported that six of the seven Hollywood studios were in active negotiations to release their films for home viewing less than three weeks after they hit theaters. Historically, the theatrical release window has been sacrosanct. It’s the amount of time movies play in theaters — and only in theaters — before rolling out to video on demand, Blu-ray, streaming services, and the other various options on a staggered schedule. Right now that window is largely standardized around 90 days (some players offer films a couple of weeks earlier through electronic services), with theater owners taking the position that a shortened window could irrevocably harm their business, if not sink it entirely.

You’d think they’d be used to it by now. The first time the movie business was dirupted was nearly 70 years ago, that time by television. In the 1930s and 40s you could go to a movie theater, see an A movie, a news reel, a cartoon, maybe a short subject or serial, and then a B movie. A whole evening’s entertainment for a very reasonable price.

Television killed the news reels, short subjects, serials, and Bs. Or, more precisely, television coopted them. The B movies of 70 or 80 years ago are what television is.

Back in the early 50s the studios struck back with Cinemascope, Panavision, 3D, even Smell-O-Vision and Percepto!, offering experiences that television couldn’t replicate. Yet. Today’s home theaters offer viewing experiences very much like those of actual movie theaters. Everything except the social aspects.

I don’t think that offering dinner or booze will help much. You’ve probably got Jack Daniels or Bacardi at home and can mix your drinks to your own tastes. Streaming and early streaming release may be the last straw for movie theaters.

Unless moviemakers can come up with something new to attract viewers into their theaters, movie theaters themselves may be as obsolete as the Mighty Wurlitzer.

3 comments

I Treat a Sick Human Being

You might be interested in this article at the New Yorker on the application of machine learning to medical diagnostics. As should surprise no one it’s an excellent application of neural networks.

Medicine is where the real potential for efficiencies from automation resides. Not fast food. Artificial intelligence can apply machines to things that machines are good at while allowing human doctors to interact with their flesh and blood patients.

Potential problem: we don’t select physicians for these skills.

The title of this post is from a modern rendering of the Hippocratic Oath written by Louis Lasagna, Academic Dean of the School of Medicine at Tufts University in 1965:

I will remember that I do not treat a fever chart, a cancerous growth, but a sick human being, whose illness may affect the person’s family and economic stability. My responsibility includes these related problems, if I am to care adequately for the sick.

8 comments