It counts as progress that the president of the United States now acknowledges that he, not his predecessor, is responsible for the policy of the United States in Syria. Now the question is how Donald Trump will fulfill his responsibility after this week’s horrific chemical weapons attack.
For starters, Trump needs to be careful not to repeat one of his predecessor’s worst mistakes. In 2012, President Barack Obama warned Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad not to cross the “red line” of using chemical weapons — then failed to take action when he did. Trump has amped up Obama’s rhetoric, saying that this week’s attacks “crossed a lot of lines for me.” It was, he said, “beyond a red line.”
Worse, he made these remarks shortly after all but throwing an ultimatum at North Korea to stop its missile and nuclear programs, and putting Iran “on notice” for its missile tests. North Korea and Iran will take their cues from his response in Syria. So will China and Russia.
Now consider those remarks in the context of yesterday’s events, outlined here.
There is a single message to be gleaned from Christopher Balding’s post at Bloomberg View on the discrepancy between what the Chinese authorities are saying about the Chinese banks and what those banks are actually doing. The Chinese authorities are much better at issuing press releases than they are at carrying out reform.
There’s plenty of room for debate over the thesis of Noah Smith’s post at Bloomberg View on Japan’s recovery from its decades-long economic torpor—that Japan can serve as a model for anything but Japan. However, I found something very interesting. Based on the statistics presented in the post by Mr. Smith, over the last six years Japan’s unemployment rate, already very low, has declined even farther while its labor force participation rate has increased.
Especially when you take into account that Japanese industry is even more automated than our own, that’s an effective refutation of the claim by American futurists that there will be a near term end of work—that for the first time in history technological unemployment has become chronic.
It hasn’t happened in Japan. There’s a much better, obvious explanation: Japan organizes its trade very differently than we do. We’re doing things wrong.
Yesterday President Trump ordered an attack by American missiles on a Syrian airport in retaliation for a chemical weapons attack against civilians, apparently by the Syrian governments. At the Washington Post David Ignatius observes:
Trump has now taken a decisive step that Obama resisted, but he still faces a dilemma of how to bring political change to a Syria shattered by six years of civil war. The irony is that Trump faces the same bad military options for pressing the attack in western Syria beyond this initial strike that Obama did.
On Tuesday, Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad launched a horrible chemical weapons attack on innocent civilians. Using a deadly nerve agent, Assad choked out the lives of helpless men, women and children. It was a slow and brutal death for so many. Even beautiful babies were cruelly murdered in this very barbaric attack. No child of God should ever suffer such horror.
Tonight I ordered a targeted military strike on the airfield in Syria from where the chemical attack was launched. It is in this vital national security interest of the United States to prevent and deter the spread and use of deadly chemical weapons. There can be no dispute that Syria used banned chemical weapons, violated its obligations under the Chemical Weapons Convention and ignored the urging of the U.N. Security Council.
Years of previous attempts at changing Assad’s behavior have all failed and failed very dramatically. As a result, the refugee crisis continues to deepen and the region continues to destabilize, threatening the United States and its allies.
Tonight I call on all civilized nations to join us in seeking to end the slaughter and bloodshed in Syria and also to end terrorism of all kinds and all types. We ask for God’s wisdom as we face the challenge of our very troubled world. We pray for the lives of the wounded and for the souls of those who have passed and we hope that as long as America stands for justice, that peace and harmony will in the end prevail.
Good night and God bless America and the entire world. Thank you.
In my opinion and assuming that the information that the Syrian government was responsible for the chemical weapons attack were accurate, the attack was warranted but still rash. To be justified the attack either required UN Security Council sanction or the authorization of Congress.
I don’t think we should rule out the notion of the attack as a bargaining ploy. It would be consistent with Trump’s transactional approach. He has sent a message of something that should be obvious: he’s not Obama. The audience for the message included friends, foes, and rivals including Presidents Putin and Xi, the Iranians, and Kim Jong Un.
As I’ve mentioned before from time to time, it always bugs me when national news media cover Chicago local stories. They invariably get the basics wrong.
Take this article from the Washington Post about Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s novel strategy of portraying political incompetence as a civil rights issue:
Say what you will about Rahm Emanuel, Chicago’s Democratic mayor, but he has been in the thick of just about every major policy and political battle in recent history. Few politicians bring more savvy to whatever the fight may be.
Emanuel’s latest provocative move is to recast the Chicago public schools’ pension-funding woes as a modern-day lawsuit equivalent to Brown v. Board of Education.
Though the problems behind the case were made in Illinois, its implications are national. Emanuel’s city isn’t the first U.S. jurisdiction to face brutal trade-offs between the contractual entitlements of unionized teachers and the educational needs of America’s public school kids — most of whom, as of 2014, are “minorities.†And it won’t be the last.
Here’s the part of the article that bugged me:
To be sure, Chicago’s lawsuit expressly disavows attacking the teachers, or their pensions; Emanuel, having endured a 2012 teacher strike, isn’t going there. The defendant is the state government, for allegedly sending a disproportionate share of its annual $10.6 billion in education aid to mostly white school systems outside of Chicago, whose students are 88 percent black, Hispanic or Asian. That’s “separate and unequal,†the lawsuit claims, in violation of state civil rights law.
Chicago’s chronically underfunded teacher pensions are the heart of the matter, however. A state-law requirement to pay into them from city resources accounts for Chicago’s financial desperation. The city owes 13 percent of the schools’ operating budget, or nearly $1,900 a year per student in 2017, for teacher pensions.
Without a quick injection of $215 million, Emanuel has said, Chicago public schools may face drastic service cuts, imperiling the fragile but real progress they have made during his administration.
Almost everything in that section is wrong. Autonomy of the Chicago Public Schools wasn’t forced on it, as the above implies. The CPS demanded it. The graph at the top of this post illustrates the source of the problem. Over a period of years the CPS failed to increase its contributions to its teachers’ pension fund. The fund isn’t chronically underfunded. It’s acutely underfunded and that underfunding was due to political incompetence, misfeasance, and nonfeasance. It’s like taking an ax to somebody and then characterizing it as a chronic health condition.
That’s what the Chicago Teachers Union has been complaining about. There wouldn’t be a problem if their pensions had been funded as they should have been in the first place. It’s too bad they didn’t complain during the six mayoral elections that have taken place over the period illustrated by the graph. Note that the Chicago Public Schools weren’t under City Hall’s control until 1995. Coincidentally, that’s when the Illinois General Assembly turned the keys over to Chicago’s mayor.
There seems to be a lot of Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel in today’s news. First, this article from the Chicago Tribune. Can somebody please explain to me how this isn’t racist on the basis of disparate impact:
Mayor Rahm Emanuel wants Chicago public high school students to show they have a plan for what’s next before they can get a diploma.
Emanuel’s proposal would add one more big item to the graduation checklist for high school seniors: proof they’ve been accepted into college or the military, or a trade or a “gap-year” program. The requirement would also be satisfied if the student has a job or a job offer.
The point, the mayor said, is to get Chicago Public Schools students in all parts of the city to stop seeing high school graduation as an ending and get them to consider what’s next.
“Just like you do with your children, college, post-high school, that is what’s expected,” Emanuel said at a Wednesday morning news conference. “If you change expectations, it’s not hard for kids to adapt.”
This is as fine an example of cargo cult thinking as I’ve ever seen.
Presently, I frequently have reason to spend time at a company in which nearly everybody in the organization below the age of 50 has a masters degree or above. 40 years ago there would have been two differences:
Nearly all of those jobs would have been held by people with no more than a high school diploma.
The country of origin of the people holding the jobs.
The jobs haven’t changed that much. The prerequisites have. If you think that strong-arming Chicago students to pursue higher education or some sort of certification will brighten their futures, think again. It won’t do them a bit of good.
It would be one thing if China were just another middle-of-the-pack nation following international norms to reach ambitious industrial goals. But when the world’s second-largest economy makes by-hook-or-crook mercantilism the animating force of its economic and trade policies, that is a whole different kettle of fish. In addition to stealing intellectual property, forcing competitors to hand over their technologies and thumbing the scales on behalf of its state-owned enterprises, China’s unfair policies include a pattern of flatly denying some foreign firms access to its markets; weaponizing its antitrust laws to extort concessions; and underwriting acquisitions of foreign technology firms. These policies are especially damaging in the absence of a true rule of law or an independent judiciary to constrain Chinese officials.
The previous three U.S. administrations sought dialogue with Chinese leaders in the hope that they would have an epiphany and embrace the one true path of Western, market-based economics. But it should be clear by now that approach has failed miserably. Indeed, rather than reform, China has been doubling down.
Trump is right that China is flouting global trade rules to the detriment of the United States, but adopting a policy of economic nationalism — simply slapping tariffs on foreign goods, for example — will not solve the problem. In fact, it would simultaneously crimp U.S. prospects for growth, leave the global playing field wide open for China to dominate, and alienate allies who would have no choice but to cut flawed deals with the world’s new economic hegemon. But neither is it a viable option to blithely accept Chinese domination of advanced industries.
So what should the Trump administration do? One step would be to resurrect a new and improved version of the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement. Much of the opposition to the TPP was based on a combination of ideology and misinformation, but it is true that the agreement could have been better. Trump should make it his own by adding new protections, such as strong curbs on currency manipulation, and then claim victory. Another step would be to more vigorously prosecute trade cases against China. But doing this would only chip away at the core problem. Neither approach represents a direct challenge to China’s systematic pattern of abuse.
To fundamentally change Chinese government behavior, Trump needs to assemble an alliance of nations that collectively raise the stakes. China won’t willingly abandon its mercantilist policies unless it is compelled to do so by outside pressure that goes beyond the narrow, legalistic limits of the World Trade Organization. This fight will be won or lost not in the tribunals of Geneva, but in the court of global opinion where countries are held accountable for delivering tangible results. That means the Trump administration needs to enlist the international community to pressure China to show by its actions that it can be a responsible player in the global trading system.
This is yet another of the 1,001 op-eds that make the same bad assumption: that it is possible for us by our actions to change the policies of China’s leaders. We can’t. China will continue the patterns of trade abuse I’ve documented here.
It’s long past time to recognize that admitting China to the WTO was an error as was granting the country MFN status. Mr. Atkinson is right. China is an exception. Sadly, there’s no use closing the barn door now.
We need to do what’s good for us and ignore what President Xi thinks of it. If it’s tariffs, it’s tariffs. If it’s embargo, it’s embargo. If it’s let ‘er ride, it’s let ‘er ride.
I do have one question for Mr. Atkinson. What does he think of U. S. technology companies colluding with the Chinese government to suppress the rights of the Chinese people?
A vote on the nomination of Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court of the United States is expected today in the United States Senate. Democrats are expected to oppose it and not enough votes in favor are anticipated to override a filibuster. Republicans are expected to “go nuclear” and change the rules so that he can be confirmed by a simple majority.
What should happen?
Neil Gorsuch is acceptable on his merits and should be confirmed. Democrats should return to the old standard which is that any competent candidate should be confirmed and vote to confirm.
Gorsuch is as good as any candidate Democrats are likely to see from this administration. Democrats should allow him to be confirmed, i.e. should not filibuster.
Republicans should not “go nuclear”. If they don’t have the votes to override they should let the nomination go down.
Republicans should “go nuclear”.
Democrats should oppose the Gorsuch nomination to teach Republicans a lesson. Republicans should not “go nuclear”. Democrats should then return to the old standard.
Judge Gorsuch should withdraw his nomination and a consensus candidate should be put up in his place. Democrats should vote to confirm this consensus candidate. Please name names. Who would be such a consensus candidate?
No consensus candidate is possible.
We should just continue with the present roster of Supreme Court justices until the end of Trump’s first or even second term.
At the New York Times and in commemoration of the centenary of the U. S. entrance into World War I, Michael Kazin muses over whether the U. S. should have entered the war at all:
How would the war have ended if America had not intervened? The carnage might have continued for another year or two until citizens in the warring nations, who were already protesting the endless sacrifices required, forced their leaders to reach a settlement. If the Allies, led by France and Britain, had not won a total victory, there would have been no punitive peace treaty like that completed at Versailles, no stab-in-the-back allegations by resentful Germans, and thus no rise, much less triumph, of Hitler and the Nazis. The next world war, with its 50 million deaths, would probably not have occurred.
I don’t think he dwells enough on the effects our entry into the war had on the United States or the reasons we entered the war.
To have any chance of altering Chinese behavior, Trump needs a stronger and more coherent message. That means, first, identifying and prioritizing a set of clear, reasonable demands — and then pushing them consistently across a broad front.
Trump doesn’t have a plan. He won’t have a plan. Like it or not he just has a utility function.
I think we need a lot less Cold War nostalgia and a lot more attention to American wants and needs. The containment doctrine laid out in the Kennan letter worked. What we’ve been doing for the last 30 years hasn’t been working. It’s resulted in our spending trillions of dollars on foreign wars that have brought us little but dead people and the prospect of many, many more. It has resulted in stagnant real incomes for most Americans, a growing underclass, and a struggling middle class.
China, barely on the map 30 years ago, is now making noises like a geopolitical rival to the United States. It isn’t but it’s making noises like one but that’a subject for another post. Russia has its own nostalgia, it’s different than ours, and it too is making noises like a geopolitical rival.
But I’m game. I challenge the Bloomberg editors to articulate a “coherent message” that results in something other than increasing incomes for the top .1% of income earners and global American hegemony at the point of a gun.