For many people in, let’s say, the left-center quadrant of the American political spectrum — especially those who are not all that eager to confront the fractured and tormented state of the current Democratic Party — Montana and Georgia and 2018 seem(ed) to represent the opening chapters of a comeback narrative, the beginning of a happy ending. If what happened in 2016 was a nonsensical aberration, then maybe there’s a fix right around the corner, and normal, institutional politics can provide it.
First you chip away at Republican triumphalism, and the House majority, with a couple of special-election victories. Then it’s about organizing, recruiting the right candidates for the right seats, registering voters and ringing doorbells, right? Democrats picked up 31 seats in the George W. Bush midterms of 2006 — and will need 24 or so this time — so, hey, it could happen. For that matter, Republicans gained an astounding 63 seats in the Tea Party election of 2010, and many observers have speculated that Trump-revulsion might create that kind of cohesion on the left. So we sweep away Paul Ryan and his sneering goons, give Nancy Pelosi back her speaker’s gavel after eight long years, introduce the articles of impeachment and begin to set America back on the upward-trending path of political normalcy and niceness.
I suspect it’s pointless to list all the things that are wrong with that scenario, because either you agree with me that it’s a delusional fantasy built on seven different varieties of magical thinking or you don’t, and in the latter case I am not likely to convince you.
Maybe just maybe Americans are voting for brutes like Trump and Gianforte despite disliking them and what they do but because they disagree with what the Democrats are offering or can no longer believe them.
A good start might be to reconsider where “center-left” actually is.
I wonder if the facts about the behavior of Millennials will change the minds of those who’ve been busily making predictions about them, as noted by Mark Mills at RealClearEnergy:
Over the past couple of years, the data show travel on America’s roads has been growing at a record pace. By year-end 2016 road travel had hit an all-time high, north of 3.2 trillion vehicle-miles. Gasoline demand has followed apace, also hitting new highs. So much for peak driving.
It’s true that because of the Great Recession driving in the U.S. declined by some by 50 billion vehicle-miles in 2009, and stayed flat for half-dozen years. It was the biggest drop and longest stagnation in road travel in automobile history. But the peak theorists confused the effects of economic deprivation with structural changes in behavior. It turns out that Millennial behavior during the recession—living in the basement rather than driving to work, and biking and sharing rides elsewhere—did not reflect a preferred lifestyle so much as an accommodation to the longest recession and slowest recovery in modern U.S. history.
And Millennials aren’t just driving more now, they’ve started buying cars too. Sales data and surveys show that Millennials exhibit more of a preference for new versus used cars compared to the gen Xers that immediately preceded them, and prefer SUVs and luxury cars rather than econo-boxes and electric vehicles. So much for peak oil demand.
and the same thing is being shown in home-buying and other economic behaviors. Maybe Millennials are just as acquisitive and materialistic as the rest of us after all.
I stumbled across an interesting essay by Washington journalist Robert W. Merry in which he says, “When a man as uncouth and reckless as Trump becomes president by running against the nation’s elites, it’s a strong signal that the elites are the problem.”
Memo to America’s elites: Millions of Americans think you’re the ones who are deplorable. They don’t want to be called bigots because they worry about the effects of illegal immigration on America’s schools and hospitals and more broadly on the nation’s sovereignty and culture.
They don’t want to be seen as heartless because they believe that not everybody getting food stamps deserves them.
They don’t want to be viewed as Muslim-hating bigots because they, like the president, believe that a temporary ban on travel from a few countries — countries that harbor terrorism — is a good idea.
And they’re sick of being portrayed as unsophisticated dolts because they don’t abide by the politically correct ideas that are so popular among the elites at our most prestigious universities.
The question is why do they think that they hold mainstream views? They’re professional, trained observers whose job it is to gather information from outside their own narrow circle. It’s more than simple parochialism or confirmation bias. They’re either lying, stupid, or nuts.
According to the Washington Post, the WHO spends $200 million every year on travel and accommodations. Of course, WHO officials aren’t flying Ryanair and staying at the Motel 6. Instead, they are booking “business-class airplane tickets and rooms in five-star hotels.”
To put that figure into perspective, WaPo writes:
Last year, WHO spent about $71 million on AIDS and hepatitis. On malaria, it spent $61 million. And to slow tuberculosis, WHO invested $59 million. Still, some health programs do get exceptional funding — the agency spends about $450 million trying to wipe out polio every year.
In other words, WHO spent more on travel than on fighting AIDS, hepatitis, malaria, and tuberculosis combined. To make matters worse, back in 2011, WHO cut 300 jobs because of budget constraints. Assuming that WHO spent roughly the same amount on travel then as it does now, by eliminating its travel budget, it could not only have saved those 300 jobs, but could have paid each of those people a salary of $666,667.
Thinking of that as waste or corruption is to miss the point. It is more an instantiation of Pournelle’s Law.
Over time the purpose of the organization has transmogrified into a mechanism for continuing the out-sized lifestyles of its bureaucrats. who no longer know any other way of functioning. That’s much more basic than ordinary waste or corruption.
If the United States is growing less willing to act as “the patsy†(Martin Wolf’s term), offering unreciprocated access to its markets for the goods of mercantilist states at the expense of its own producers, and if no other major nation or bloc is willing to be a similar “patsy,†then the kind of parasitic export-oriented strategy pursued by Japan, the Little Tigers, China, and Germany cannot succeed. At the same time, classic import substitution strategies, like the radical renationalization strategy discussed above, are also rejected by the major economic powers, because they seek markets for goods and services beyond their borders to reap the benefits of scale in increasing-returns industries. By default, then, the economic system in a world of multiple great-power blocs is likely to resemble that of the European colonial empires.
If he’s right Metropolis will look increasingly like current events over the coming years. The residents of the Eternal Gardens much more closely resemble Burnham’s “managers” than they do Marx’s “capitalists”.
What I believe the members of this managerial elite who, presumably, think of themselves as the “creative class” fail to take into account human nature. In the fullness of time they will want their children to inherit everything they have despite their children not being nearly as creative and productive as they. Additionally, maintaining their lifestyles will require incomes far beyond what can be sustained which will withdraw ever-farther into the realms of fantasy.
Americans have reason to be pessimistic, if not despairing, about the war in Afghanistan. After eight years of fighting, more than 800 American lives lost and more than 200 billion taxpayer dollars spent, the Afghan government is barely legitimate and barely hanging on in the face of an increasingly powerful Taliban insurgency.
In his speech Tuesday night, President Obama showed considerable political courage by addressing that pessimism and despair head-on. He explained why the United States cannot walk away from the war and outlined an ambitious and high-risk strategy for driving back the Taliban and bolstering the Afghan government so American troops can eventually go home.
For far too long — mostly, but not only, under President George W. Bush — Afghanistan policy has had little direction and no accountability. Mr. Obama started to address those problems at West Point, although the country needs to hear more about how he intends to pay for the war and how he will decide when Afghanistan will be able to stand on its own.
There are now about 8,400 American troops in Afghanistan. Military commanders have asked for reinforcements of up to 5,000 more. Just a modest increase, they argue, a “mini†surge of troops. But 5,000 troops would boost the American commitment by roughly 60 percent, a sizable reinvestment in a conflict that President Barack Obama had promised was drawing to a close.
It is not unusual for American military commanders to ask for more troops and weapons in pursuit of victory. But can they make a decisive difference? How can 3,000 or even 5,000 more American troops ensure victory when the United States at one point had a force of nearly 100,000 in Afghanistan and was unable to defeat the Taliban and stabilize the country? And what would victory look like anyway?
What has changed their minds? The prospects for victory in Afghanistan are no greater than they were eight years ago. Is the the additional 1,200 American lives lost? Is it the additional $600 billion spent? Is it that they’ve learned by experience?
The workdays were long, 12 hours on and 12 hours off, and the work was a constant challenge in terms of the sheer volume of cases and in the complexity and variety of wounds. Out of necessity, we often operated solo, with the assistance of a nurse or medical technician.
The wounds could be horrific. A common injury was the result of an anti-personnel mine known as the “Bouncing Betty.” When tripped, it fired straight up about three feet before it exploded — usually disemboweling or maiming those unfortunate enough to be within range. It was a horrible weapon. A lot of the surgery we did was on the lower extremity, doing our best to repair eviscerated abdomens and slaughtered lower limbs.
The work was also emotionally challenging. I remember one particular case where a young soldier had been badly injured. Myself, Ray (Capt. Ray Crissy) and Mert (Maj. Merton White) worked on him for hours. We had opened his chest when his heart just stopped beating. We did everything we could to keep him alive, including injecting blood directly into his aorta and massaging his heart.
I still remember the feeling of holding his heart in my hand. We were able to bring him back and I remember joking with him a few days later. He seemed to be doing well and I really thought he was going to make it. But his kidneys ultimately failed and we lost him. Like so many of the GIs, he was nice kid whose life ended way too early.
Read the whole thing. As usual truth is more interesting than fiction.
Today is Memorial Day. In our headlong rush towards long weekends many Americans have forgotten that today is the day on which we recall those who have died in war, particularly those who died in the American Civil War and among those particularly the Union dead. The holiday has its origins in the decoration of the graves of Union soldiers in the years following the war, hence its original name: Decoration Day.
More Americans died in the American Civil War than in all of our other wars combined and that bears remembering.
I wish that the movie channels would show All Quiet on the Western Front, La Grande Illusion, or Platoon rather than D-Day or The Dirty Dozen.
I’ve told the story before but it bears repeating. My wife and I saw Saving Private Ryan in the theater in a matinee during the week. We were the youngest by far in the small audience—most of the people there were in their 70s and 80s. I will never forget that after the picture had ended you could still hear the quiet weeping of the World War II veterans and their wives in attendance. They remembered.
The city’s overall black population has plunged since 2000. At the start of this century it was just over 1 million. Fifteen years later it was 840,188.
The white population also decreased in that time period, though not nearly as dramatically, falling from 907,166 to 874,876.
As a whole, the city went from about 2.9 million residents to 2.7 million in that time, data show.
Blacks fled crime and poverty on the city’s South and West sides. Many moved to nearby suburbs but some, like the white population of the Midwest, have moved south to Georgia, Texas, and Florida.
The city isn’t hollowed out yet but it’s working on it. Chicago’s test will be how it copes with a declining population and tax base while its expenses, many of them incurred when the city was larger, grow or remain the same. So far it has botched the test.
Political scientist Henry Farrell remarks on the changes that may result from President Trump’s meetings with our NATO allies in the Washington Post:
While the public is more familiar with the “special relationship†between Britain and the United States, the German-U.S. relationship has arguably been more important. One of the key purposes of NATO was to embed Germany in an international framework that would prevent it from becoming a threat to European peace as it had been in World War I and World War II. In the words of NATO’s first secretary general, NATO was supposed “to keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down.†Now, Merkel is suggesting that the Americans aren’t really in, and, by extension, Germany and Europe are likely to take on a much more substantial and independent role than they have in the past 70 years.
I’m glad he brought that up. It may be the case that the U. S. is no longer in; it is unquestionably true that Germany is no longer down.
This portion of his op-ed caught my eye:
If the current U.S. administration has decided that it no longer needs to rely on allies as much as in the past, those allies are deciding that they cannot rely on the U.S. anymore and are starting to forge their own arrangements, which will diminish the U.S. ability to influence their actions and decisions.
I wish the professor had cited an instance of the last time that the U. S. influenced Germany’s actions and decisions. I can think of any number of times that our European allies influenced our actions and decisions, cf. our 2011 military intervention in Libya. Has NATO expansion been the U. S. policy or Germany’s? Helmut Kohl, Angela Merkel’s predecessor as German Chancellor, simultaneously communicated to the Russians that NATO would not be expanded and to the Central and Eastern Europeans that it would, so I would say that at best Germany’s role has been complex and at worst mischievous.