Understanding Automation

At Atlantic Derek Thompson has written the best post on the effects of automation on jobs that I’ve seen in a long time. He makes and offers evidence to support the following points:

  1. The U.S. economy is in a productivity recession.
  2. Companies don’t seem to be investing in technology nearly as much as they used to.
  3. Globalization is a much bigger deal than automation for work and wages.
  4. The U.S. economy’s creative-destruction engine is broken.

Or, in other words, there is very little evidence that robots are taking our jobs.

He also cites a fascinating case study:

In the short run, the digitization of retail has created jobs. But it’s replacing in-store salespeople—not easily automated, since who wants a robot clothing assistant?—with warehousing and transportation workers. There are nearly 2 million truck drivers and 300,000 warehouse laborers and stocking clerks in the United States, and there are rather direct efforts underway to make a great number of these jobs obsolete. Amazon has expanded its armada of warehouse robots to more than 40,000, and self-driving cars have the attention of practically every auto and technology company in the world. So, e-commerce has created jobs—ones that are quite vulnerable to automation.

Note, too, that the warehousing and transportation jobs that have been created while eliminating sales clerks are much more organized than the sales clerks ever were, arguing against yet another narrative.

If robots aren’t the job-killers that some are arguing they are, what’s happening? I would argue that the following factors explain practically everything:

  • Globalization
  • Immigration, particularly of low-skilled workers
  • Out-sized expectations of the returns of capital
  • Poorly constructed public policies, particularly of the NIMBY sort
4 comments

A Question About International Agreements

Hearts are palpitating in the news media about President Trump’s apparently imminent announcement of the U. S.’s withdrawal from the Paris climate accord. I have a question. What’s the difference between an international agreement that is unenforceable and with which you don’t intend to comply and withdrawing from the accord?

I’m serious. I really want to know.

11 comments

He’s Dreaming

I read Michael Tomasky’s piece in the New Republic up to this point:

It has been observed that today’s conservative movement, to use the old Leninist vernacular, is a “vanguardist” movement. The word referred to the revolutionary party, the one that was going to make the revolution happen. (Its weak-kneed counterparts were the “spontaneists,” who were going to sit around and wait for it to happen, being alert to the moment.) Some conservatives welcomed the comparison. In Blinded by the Right, David Brock reports that Grover Norquist had a portrait of Lenin in his home.

A movement intent on hastening the revolution develops certain habits of mind. It has enemies, to be sure. But it knows that it’s an embattled minority, so it welcomes new recruits, as long as they agree on some basic principles. That’s why every liberal who abandons liberalism to join the right—from the Irving Kristol neocons of days gone by, to David Mamet and Donald Trump—is joyously embraced. So you’ve finally seen the light! Welcome!

American liberalism is, of necessity, anti-vanguardist.

He’s dreaming. While I’m glad that he’s discovered vanguardism since it explains so much of what’s happening today, American progressivism is nothing if not vanguardist. Unless he plans to excommunicate Hillary Clinton.

1 comment

And With Guaranteed Jobs

Meanwhile, Robert Fellner argues against a guaranteed jobs program:

While a government job would certainly benefit those currently unemployed in the short term, they too stand to lose in the long run.

The longer these workers stay in make-shift jobs, the less opportunity they have to develop skills that have actual value, a harm that compounds over time.

The best thing the government can do to help those struggling to find work is to get out of the way. Repeal cronyist occupational licensing laws that lower wages and reduce employment. Stop imposing a one-size fits all monopoly form of education that is poorly suited for preparing students for today’s rapidly changing and dynamic job market. Repeal and reduce anti-business taxes and regulations so that entrepreneurs can get back to their work of making us all richer.

A government-jobs program would only make worse a problem that is, for the most part, the result of government intervention.

Unmentioned are the distortions caused by intellectual property laws, trading policies, and monetary policies which result in fewer jobs being created than would otherwise be the case and immigration policies which result in wages being lower than would otherwise be the case.

So, if a universal basic income isn’t a viable solution and neither is a guaranteed jobs program, what is?

1 comment

The Problems With a Universal Basic Income

At Vox Dylan Mathews comes out in opposition to a Universal Basic Income:

Both the OECD and AEI reports suggest that an immediate cashing out of big social programs to fund a UBI would be kind of a mess. It’d create massive disruption with big winners and losers, and given the scale of change required, it probably isn’t the most effective way of alleviating poverty you could imagine. Indeed, many of the models they consider would lead to poverty going up, not down.

[…]

So basic income and cash advocates would do well to pivot away from the kind of big, disruptive plans modeled in the OECD and AEI papers, and toward negative income taxes, child allowances, and carbon dividends, all of which are more politically feasible and likelier to be implemented in a way that doesn’t hurt low-income people or seniors.

The short version: the experimental programs which replace all assistance programs with a guaranteed income haven’t accomplished the results their proponents had thought they would. They’ve mostly just changed who wins and who loses from the present winners and losers.

Even shorter: jobs still remain the best anti-poverty programs.

2 comments

The Easy Ones

Following up on my last post, I was reminded of an engineering meeting I participated in at a client’s site. The client was a large, Fortune 500 company and the meeting was a status meeting about a new product they were introducing. The product had been installed in a number of beta sites and, frankly, the results had been pretty disastrous. With various modifications and many sleepless nights we had remedied all of the problems as they arose but it was a grueling process.

The Director of Engineering summed up the situation like this: “What worries me is that these are the easy cases. Will the next installations be harder?”

Over the last century and a half or so, the U. S. has had several waves of immigrants. Prior to the American Civil War the wave was composed of the Irish and Germans, particularly Germans from the West Rhine and Westphalia. After the Civil War the wave was composed of more Germans and Scandinavians. Around the turn of the last century the wave of immigrants was composed of Eastern and Southern Europeans.

Our most recent wave of immigrants has mostly been composed of Mexicans, with some people from Central America and the Caribbean.

What I think should trouble us is the likelihood that the people who’ve come here over the last 150 years have been the easy cases—those who would fit in the best, who would be happiest here, who would accept the United States and be assimilated to it and us.

Unlike some I don’t think we should ban immigration or even immigration by Muslims or people from the Middle East or North Africa. I think there are plenty of likely candidates among those groups but we should limit ourselves to accepting the candidates most likely to prosper here. That would mean people with educations, people who are literate, people who speak English, and, especially, people who’ve helped us in the past.

Something to think about is that so far in the investigations of the Boston Marathon bombing something like 10% to 20% of the Chechen refugees who’ve settled here have been implicated in it in one way or another. They either perpetrated, participated in, or were accessories to it before or after the fact. That’s something that should really make us think.

1 comment

The Audience

I disagree with one particular in Heather Mac Donald’s polemic in City Journal on the pundit reactions to the mass murder in Manchester last week. Here’s the passage in question:

No, the terrorists will have failed if they can no longer slaughter children. They don’t care if a terror attack is met with candlelight vigils; they care if border restrictions and law enforcement make it impossible to destroy lives.

I believe that reflects a grave misconception about these acts of terrorist violence, a misconception held by conservatives, libertarians, and progressives alike.

We are not the audience for whatever the perpetrators are trying to accomplish with these atrocities. We and the actual victims are merely set pieces. The audience they’re trying to reach is other Muslims, particularly other Muslim extremists. The audience they’re trying to reach is their own tortured consciences. The audience they’re trying to reach is their God.

What we do, how we react, what we believe doesn’t make a whit of difference to them.

0 comments

The New Blasphemy

At Heterodox Academy Jonathan Haidt enunciates an important rule:

Do not assume that being politically progressive will protect you (as Weinstein and the Christakises found out). Whatever your politics, you are eventually going to say or do something that will be interpreted incorrectly and ungenerously. Your intentions don’t matter (as Dean Spellman found out at CMC.) This is especially true if your university offers students training in the detection of microaggressions.

And the rules will change too rapidly for you to keep up. There is no such thing as sensitive enough.

What is the goal, the end game, of all of this? Stay tuned.

13 comments

Après moi le déluge

I agree with John Kass’s assessment in his Chicago Tribune column. Removing Trump from office will not result in a “return to normalcy”. Things will only get worse:

True, Clinton received about 3 million more votes than Trump. But almost 63 million people voted for the president. And forcing them to their knees in capitulation is not a prescription for unification but a prospect for disaster.

Trump voters didn’t create the divided nation. The elites divided it over time, through economic dislocation and abandonment of the working class, and a mad push for endless wars in which soldiers returned to find no jobs or economic future.

Now America is reaping what the elites have sown.

Months and months before the presidential election, I began thinking of Trump not as a cause of American disruption but a symptom of it. And as much as I don’t like quoting myself, here is something from March 2016:

“It’s obvious the American political system is breaking down. It’s been crumbling for some time now, and the establishment elite know it and they’re properly frightened. Donald Trump, the vulgarian at their gates, is a symptom, not a cause. Hillary Clinton and husband Bill are both cause and effect.”

The establishment pushed the wars and free trade and their partners in the corporate-government matrix agreed to the sending off of capital (and jobs) to foreign lands.

For all the talk of partisanship, Democrats and Republicans were the two horns on the head of the goat.

There is no national consensus on the way forward but profound disagreement, particularly between those have power and those who don’t. Removing Trump as president even if it were to prove necessary or possible wouldn’t resolve that.

I don’t know that anything will.

7 comments

Intensity

In her Washington Post column Katrina vanden Heuvel, reacting to the highly publicized failures to win congressional districts in Montana, Kansas, and Georgia, points out where progressives have made gains:

In the 9th state assembly district of Long Island, Christine Pellegrino — a schoolteacher, union activist, Bernie Sanders delegate and Working Families Party Democrat — dispatched her Republican opponent by a stunning 58 percent to 42 percent. As Newsday reported, this is usually a district where Democrats hardly compete. Trump swamped Hillary Clinton here by 23 percentage points. The veteran Republican state legislator who held the seat was reelected by a 37-point margin over a Democratic challenger. But when he stepped down, Pellegrino — a first-time candidate — swept to victory.

In New Hampshire, Edith DesMarais pulled a similar upset in a state legislative race. “Republicans should absolutely be concerned,” William F.B. O’Reilly, a Republican partner in the November Team, a political consulting firm, told the New York Times. “Two Republican canaries died in the coal mine yesterday.”

Progressive candidates are rising in Democratic primaries in Democratic areas as well. In the primary for Philadelphia district attorney, civil rights attorney Larry Krasner, who has defended Occupy Philadelphia and Black Lives Matter protesters, won on a platform calling for an end to mass incarceration, police reform and more. Supported by Sanders and a range of progressive groups, his candidacy was also bolstered by the money of George Soros. “This changes the game across the country,” William Cobb of the American Civil Liberties Union told Philadelphia Magazine.

In the Democratic primary for mayor in Jackson, Miss., victory went to Chokwe Antar Lumumba, running on a bold program calling for a “people’s administration” that would feature police reform and a locally grounded, cooperative strategy for economic development. Lumumba marched in solidarity with black auto-plant workers at the March on Mississippi with Sanders and the UAW and helped to found the Mississippi Human Rights Collective that led efforts to remove the Confederate insignia from the state’s flag. His victory was one of many for progressives in Democratic primaries.

These examples illustrate exactly what I wrote about back in November. In deep Blue States and/or in deep Blue areas of Red States, erstwhile Sanders supporters are duking it out DNC-type Democrats for control of the Democratic Party. IMO this is cheerful:

These candidates are not your standard Democrats. Like Sanders, they are campaigning for bold change. They pledge an end to corruption. They support aggressive public action for working people — $15 minimum wage, investment in infrastructure, renewal of public education and making public college tuition free. This is now increasingly reflected at the national level as well, with Democratic legislators coming out for a $15 minimum wage, a major infrastructure jobs agenda and progressive tax reform.

but grossly premature. As I’ve been pointing out for some time, the challenge for Democrats is to win more seats and governors’ mansions, not to unseat incumbent Democrats. That’s just a continuation of the trend we’ve seen over the last several decades—the increased polarization of elected officials in Red States vs. those in Blue States.

Will these newcomers retain their energy and idealism through multiple terms, re-elected time after time to safe seats? Or, like the incumbents they replace, will they inevitably see themselves as entitled to their offices by virtue of their magnificent hearts and mysteriously become wealthy in office while the ideals they espoused languish? Time will tell.

0 comments