Dave Schuler
June 16, 2017
In his Washington Post column Fareed Zakaria blames identity politics for the growing divide in the United States:
The dangerous aspect of this new form of politics is that identity does not lend itself easily to compromise. When the core divide was economic, you could split the difference. If one side wanted to spend $100 billion and the other wanted to spend zero, there was a number in between. The same is true with tax cuts and welfare policy. But if the core issues are about identity, culture and religion (think of abortion, gay rights, Confederate monuments, immigration, official languages), then compromise seems immoral. American politics is becoming more like Middle Eastern politics, where there is no middle ground between being Sunni or Shiite.
I think he’s got it backwards. When you choose to cast your political positions using the language of rights and morality rather than ways and means, there will be no room for compromise.
Take health care reform, for example. When your position is based on the assertion that everyone has a right to unlimited health care of his or her choosing, it’s very different than when you base your position on the idea that the United States is a wealthy country and can afford to give its citizens certain benefits. The discussion will then be about the size and nature of the benefit rather than entering into an apocalyptic battle of Good versus Evil.
That’s how Social Security and Medicare were enacted into law. Neither is a right. They are both benefits. For the last half century ensuring that the elderly are not penurized in their old age is a value shared by Democrats and Republicans. Discussions are about what that means and how to accomplish it.
Dave Schuler
June 16, 2017
Fellow Illinoisan Mike “Mish” Shedlock has written a diatribe on Illinois’s financial condition. It opens by quoting a letter the state has sent out to roadwork contractors that opens “Dear Contractor” and instructs all contractors to cease work on Illinois roads July 1 because the state can’t pay them. His post opens:
The state of Illinois has not passed a budget for close to three years.
Arguably it’s just as well because Illinois budgets for decades have been nothing but a moth-eaten collection of lies, one time deficits repeated endlessly, and financial wizardry statements designed to disguise Illinois’ real problems: failure to rein in spending coupled with a very business unfriendly environment.
As Illinois’ bond rating careens towards junk, Illinois Unpaid Bills Jumped to $14.3 Billion. Today, the state told contractors to halt roadwork other that required for safety.
He goes on to note that the bonds issued by five of Illinois state institutions of higher learning have junk ratings, that tuition at these institutions and public pensions are soaring, and that Illinois has the worst personal income growth of any of the states.
In a few weeks we’ll get our property tax bills and they are expected to jump, following a substantial jump last year. I had planned to live in my Chicago home until I died but, frankly, I know I won’t be able to afford a 10% increase in my property taxes every year. I don’t know who could but if I can’t the list of those who will be forced to leave Chicago because of its taxes will be large.
Moody’s and S&P have made their views on Illinois’s need to reform clear by downgrading Illinois’s and Chicago’s credit rating repeatedly. Unlike voters here they have the power to make their voices heard.
Dave Schuler
June 16, 2017
Somewhat to my surprise I have a patent pending. I don’t feel free to say too much about it other than it’s a new business method and it relates to warehouse management. Apparently, something I’ve come up with is worthwhile, non-obvious, and original.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
I think that this study, reported at Newser, comparing the effect on the microbiome of eating artisanally produced sourdough bread with eating mass-produced white bread:
The study looked at the gut microbiomes plus clinical measures including cholesterol, blood sugar, fat, and mineral levels in 20 participants prior to its start. The subjects were then randomly assigned to either eat the sourdough or the white bread for one week, then take a two-week break and switch breads. Participants’ gut microbiomes did not appear to be changed based on the bread they ate and researchers found no measurable differences when looking at most markers, but they did find that while half the group had a higher blood glucose response to the white bread, the other half had a higher response to the sourdough. Based on subjects’ microbiomes, researchers could actually predict which half a participant would fall under. “The ‘one-size-fits-all’ diets that are given to the population as a whole, without personalization, are probably not optimal for everyone,” a co-author says, per CBS.
is likely to have some problems. How long does it take to see measurable changes in the composition of gut microbes? Your gut is a living ecosystem. It probably has its own mechanisms to reduce the rate of change. If you knocked out the gut bacteria of the participants at the beginning of the study it would be one thing but that doesn’t seem to be the case.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
I agree with this post by Nathan Lewis at Forbes. Automation isn’t our real problem. Low savings and investment rates are:
Thus, an economy needs a high level of capital investment, to create new, high-productivity, high-wage jobs. This high productivity is practically in the math of capital itself. If you invest a million dollars of capital per person, for example some kind of business that has 100 employees and $100 million of investment, then each person must generate perhaps $100,000 of profit per year to justify the investment. This can only happen with high productivity per person.
Among emerging markets, this was often called a “bicycle economy:†you had to keep pedaling or it would fall over. Mechanization of agriculture and transport would generate millions of rural unemployed migrating to cities in search of a new way of life. Without a high level of capital investment and job creation, the situation could become politically explosive. Asia’s leaders knew they had to keep on pedaling. During their best growth years, Asian countries often had savings rates and capital investment in excess of 20%–sometimes, in excess of 30%.
China, however, beat them all, with sustained rates of savings and investment on the order of 50%, an astonishing result not only because of the high number, but that it was achieved on such a gigantic scale, with a population 300 times larger than Singapore. With such a tsunami of capital, it was probably inevitable that much of it would be squandered and stolen. But, it didn’t matter – China could piffle away 10% of GDP, a figure the U.S. hasn’t seen in generations, and the remaining 40% would still have been better than anyone else had ever achieved.
Our low rates of saving and business investment don’t just produce the stagnation in productivity we’re seeing. They also exacerbate our balance of trade and are a factor in increasing income inequality.
Rather than perseverating on “robots stealing our jobs”, a problem which, while we may have it some day we don’t have now, we should focus much more attention on the problems we actually have now especially since the solutions are so obvious.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
I love this suggestion from Carl Cannon, articulated at RealClearPolitics. Play the charity baseball game on Thursday as scheduled. However:
Here’s a modest idea. Instead of Democrats competing against Republicans, how about choosing up sides the way American kids do on the schoolyard? Each team captain would pick a player, in order, and they must alternate picks, one Republican, then one Democrat. Don’t play against the other party, play with them—for this one night.
The Congress used to be a very collegial place. It should be a very collegial place in public as well as in private. Casting the disagreements between Democrats and Republicans as the Final Battle between good and evil may garner a few votes in your district or encourage some highly partisan donors from outside your district to contribute to your re-election campaign but it isn’t doing or facilitating the doing of the people’s business.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
The editors of the Washington Post weigh in on the maltreatment of American Otto Warmbier by the North Koreans:
Now it appears that Mr. Warmbier may have been gravely ill for much or all of that time. His parents told The Post that North Korean representatives suddenly informed U.S. officials last week that the student was in a coma. He was said to have lost consciousness after contracting botulism and taking a sleeping pill — an account that strains credulity.
and recommends sketchily-defined “sanctions” against the regime:
The United States should also move quickly to step up sanctions on the regime of Kim Jong Un, which has been racing to develop missiles that can reach the United States with a nuclear warhead. A new report by the research group C4ADS shows that by cracking down on a relatively small number of interlinked Chinese companies and individuals, the pressure on Pyongyang could be greatly increased. According to the Wall Street Journal, the Trump administration has asked China to act against some 10 entities; if Beijing does not respond promptly, the United States should act unilaterally.
I have sympathy for Mr. Warmbier and his parents on a purely human basis. However, the reality is that much of the world is a cruel, harsh place and North Korea is distinctively so. The State Department already warns Americans that they shouldn’t travel to North Korea. When they do so, they’re on their own.
We already have about as much in the way of sanctions against North Korea as we can and until and unless we’re willing to risk whatever relationship we presently have with China any American who does what Mr. Warmbier did can expect to get what he got.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
At Japan Times Yoichi Funabashi crafts a strategy for Japan reacting to an increasingly bumptious China:
First, maintain and strengthen our commitment to an open and liberal international order. For that purpose, reform the World Trade Organization. In the near future, even the U.S. will come to find it difficult to restrain an all-too-powerful China. If the U.S. ignores the WTO, an even more powerful China is certain to ignore the WTO as well. The WTO must overhaul its guidelines concerning subsidies, industrial policy and cyberspace. Moreover, both Japan and the U.S. must learn to make better use of the WTO.
Next, we can advance the regional integration and liberalization of trade and investment in the Asia-Pacific region by spreading the standards agreed on in the Trans-Pacific Partnership deal surrounding norms and rules. Japan must assist with the regional integration of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations members and the construction of a regional architecture that includes India and adheres to the principles of an “open and liberal international order.â€
Finally, Japan can use the momentum of the current economic dialogue with the U.S. as a form of “gaiatsu†(foreign pressure) for promoting domestic structural reforms — the “third arrow†of Abenomics. After all, we should not forget that utilizing gaiatsu to achieve reform and liberalization has long been a Japanese specialty.
I think this is a sure instance of too little, too late. The Chinese very clearly view multi-lateral trade agreements in general and the World Trade Organization in particular in a strictly instrumental fashion. They’ll enforce them when doing so furthers their goals and ignore them otherwise. The reality is that China doesn’t have the civil infrastructure, in particular the robust system of civil law, to live up to the obligations it assumed when it joined the WTO and it certainly has neither the inclination nor the ability to enforce intellectual property law, the U. S.’s key trade goal (foolishly in my opinion). You can’t fight Chinese mercantilism with trade organizations of which China is a member.
As far as the TPP goes, the U. S. simply can’t tolerate two major economies pursuing mercantilist policies against it let alone four or more of them. China, Japan, and Germany are forcing the U. S. into a more mercantilist direction for reasons of political if not economic survival.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
The editors of the Wall Street Journal are complaining about the management shakeups at Uber:
Uber said Tuesday that CEO Travis Kalanick will take an indefinite leave from the company he built, a day after chief business officer Emil Michael stepped down. The moves followed a unanimous vote by Uber’s board—which consists of private investors—to adopt reforms to its “workplace culture.†The San Francisco-based startup enlisted former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder’s law firm Covington & Burling after several women complained that Uber executives ignored sexual-harassment allegations.
Workplace culture often flows from the top, and the internal analysis seeks to correct lapses in executive judgment. In 2014 Mr. Michael floated a plan to dig up details about the private lives of journalists critical of the company. Earlier this year Mr. Kalanick was caught on camera berating a driver.
Yet Uber would never have achieved what it has if not for Mr. Kalanick’s hard-charging attitude. The company has had to break through regulatory barriers backed by the taxi lobby in city after city, and it didn’t do that by bowing at the first sign of resistance. Uber’s innovation has greatly improved the lives of millions of urban travelers, and that breakthough has in turn invited competitors like Lyft, Via and Gett. There’s no guarantee that Uber will emerge as the Facebook of this pack.
Let’s go to the box scores. Uber requires regulatory intervention simply to exist. You can argue whether the regulations should have existed in the first place but that’s a fact. And it’s not a “growing pain”. That Uber’s corporate culture is malignant isn’t a growing pain, either, unless you assume that sexual harrassment is the only way a start-up can operate. Not growing pains, either.
Add that none of the ride-sharing companies is operating at a profit. That sounds to me more like failure of business model than growing pains. Maybe “disruption”, the Silicon Valley shibboleth du jour, just isn’t as great a strategy as the geniuses think it is. Keep in mind that Amazon, the paradigm of disruption as a business model, just doesn’t make much money in retail. They’re making a fortune because they created a brand new product category.
Could it possibly be that innovation is more important than disruption as a business model and that innovators and disrupters are different sorts of people? Don’t tell the editors of the WSJ that. They’re hoping for a big IPO.
Dave Schuler
June 15, 2017
The editors of the Wall Street Journal respond to the shooting responsibly as well:
Politically motivated attempts at mass murder aren’t common but they do happen and too often they’re exploited for partisan ends. The good news is that on Wednesday most political leaders rose to higher ground.
President Trump offered gracious condolences to the wounded, praise for the officers, and a call to national unity. Speaker Paul Ryan and Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi united to denounce the attack, and Mr. Sanders disavowed and denounced Hodgkinson. Mr. Ryan said the baseball game will go on as scheduled—to a thunderous ovation.
These are divisive political times, when verbal abuse and physical harassment are all too frequent against political opponents. The duty of political leaders and the rest of us is to keep the divisions in the perspective of our shared values of free debate and democratic consent. One way to contribute to a better political climate would be to stop claiming as a reflex that victory by the opposing party is illegitimate, and another would be to stop portraying political assassination as entertainment.
This places them in contrast with the editors of the New York Times and Washington Post who did not.