Fog of War

The reports and surmises surrounding the collision of the USS Fitzgerald with the container ship ACX Crystal in the shipping lanes south of Tokyo on Friday night are becoming increasingly bizarre. From the Wall Street Journal:

Some former military and commercial shipping captains speculate that the Fitzgerald may have failed to follow international regulations that require ships to give way to other vessels to their starboard, or right side.

“Unless the destroyer lost steering control, which is unlikely, it should have given right of way to the container ship,” said Yiannis Sgouras, a retired captain of tankers and cargo ships who worked in the world’s busiest trade route from Asia to Europe.

Others caution that there are potentially many other contributing factors to the collision. Tracking data sent by the cargo ship, the ACX Crystal, showed it reversed course around 2:05 a.m. local time, shortly before the time of the collision given by the U.S. Navy of approximately 2:20 a.m.

However, Nippon Yusen K.K . , the Japanese shipping company that operates the 728-foot-long ACX Crystal, has stated that the collision occurred around 1:30 a.m. That discrepancy hasn’t been resolved.

I don’t see how all of that can be true. We’ll need to wait until the facts are clearer before reaching any judgments.

Clausewitz wrote

“War is the realm of uncertainty; three quarters of the factors on which action in war is based are wrapped in a fog of greater or lesser uncertainty. A sensitive and discriminating judgment is called for; a skilled intelligence to scent out the truth.”

Apparently, that dictum applies to more than war.

2 comments

Momos Forever!

There’s a fun article at The Economic Times on the history and development of momos, dumplings that are a staple of Indian street food:

Whether it was invented in Tibet or in Nepal, the Indianisation of the momo is now complete. A food-loving Bengali friend’s only child is named Momo, savvy vendors have inevitably synthesised two extremely popular fastfoods to come up with the tandoori momo, a worthy addition to the expanding fusion genre that includes Chinese chaat, chilli paneer and Szechwan idlis.

I find the author’s suggestion of a Mongolian origin for the dumpling credible. However, it could also be an instance of multiple discovery.

A couple of years ago a restaurant characterizing itself as a “Nepal-Indian” restaurant opened within easy walking distance of my home. In addition to a number of staples of Indian cuisine it offers several different varieties of momos.

2 comments

Working

If you read it as I did, I suspect you’ll find this post at The Fiscal Times simultaneously interesting and depressing. Here’s its main argument:

Gallup defines the 76 million millennials as people born between 1980 and 1996 – now the largest generation in the U.S. And they are from a different planet than, say, baby boomers. Baby boomers like me wanted more than anything in the world to have a family with three kids and to own a home — a job was just a job. Having a family and owning a home was the great American dream.

Millennials, on the other hand, place “my job” equally or even ahead of “my family” as their dream. So, because their life is more focused on work, they need to draw more from their work environment. They have their best friends at work — including best friends who are customers. They want meaningful work and to stay with an organization that helps them grow and develop.

Everything has changed.

What does all of this mean for reversing world productivity trends? It means that we need to transform our workplace cultures. We need to start over.

To summarize Gallup’s analytics from 160 countries on the global workplace, our conclusion is that organizations should change from having command-and-control managers to high-performance coaches.

The change will immediately save massive costs by wiping out the wasteful practice of filling out forms and checking management boxes.

Why “high-performance coaches”? Because millennials demand development over satisfaction. They demand ongoing conversations over annual reviews. They demand strengths-based discussions over weakness-based “gap” discussions that produce zero results.

I think there is no prospect for that whatever, at least not in the near term. Among other reasons I was hired to do just that, provide high-performance coaching, by my present employer. I’m not being allowed to do it because it’s just in too great a conflict with the business’s principles and policies of operation.

The reason I don’t think there’s much prospect for it is generally weak management. Top management is generally there for the wrong reasons, jealous of its prerogatives, and its objectives are opposed to a paradigm change from work as punishment to work as collaboration. Despite being a 21st century business the company I’m working for is the most 19th century company I’ve ever worked for.

6 comments

First to Reject Another Rejection (Updated)

On Friday the state of Nevada became the first state [ed. see update below] to reject a single-payer plan. The legislature enacted a curt four-page plan to become active in January 2019, briefly summarized as “Medicaid for all”. Nevada’s governor vetoed it. The Fiscal Times relates:

While praising the Democratic “Medicaid for All” legislation sponsored by Assemblyman Michael Sprinkel, Sandoval said he ultimately concluded that there were too many unanswered questions about how the program would work.

The governor wrote that the bill was “an undeveloped remedy to an undefined problem” and that it hadn’t received proper scrutiny before it was passed in a short time frame.

They go on to elucidate:

However, there were numerous obstacles and stumbling blocks to getting the program up and running by January 2019, the target date for the start-up. The bill required Nevada officials to obtain permission from the Department of Health and Human Services to move ahead with the plan, but with no guarantee, the Trump administration, which favors rolling back Medicaid, would go along with the experiment.

The sketchy bill provided no hint of how much the new program would cost the state and the federal government, or how much the premiums and related copayments might cost – although presumably far less than market rate coverage.

Vermont has already put aside a proposed plan without it ever reaching the legislature. California is presently considering such a plan but that hasn’t assumed the form of a concrete bill yet. There are various other states with such programs in various stages of consideration.

Put on your prediction togs and make some predictions.

  1. How many states will consider single-payer laws?
  2. In how many states will they actually be enacted and signed into law?
  3. In how many states will they be rejected, either by the legislature or the governor?

I think that most of the states, possibly all of them, will bandy around about statewide single-payer programs and one or two of them might actually pass such a law and have it signed by their governors with California and New York being the most likely candidates. I think that such laws will be rejected by nearly all of the states considering them, either failing to pass the legislature or being vetoed by their governors including in some of the most progressive states in the country.

I’ll answer another question, too. I don’t think that rejection by the states will dampen the fervor of those supporting it for a national single-payer system.

I supported a national single-payer system for years (after my experience in Germany). I think it’s an idea whose time has passed. Health care just costs too much now for any such system at any level to be practical. Costs must be forced down and that will be terribly difficult and painful to do. Which is why taking that necessary step will be resisted.

Update

I have been informed that Colorado voters rejected a statewide single-payer plan by 80%.

6 comments

Solar Power Generation

I found the graph above, sampled from Justin Fox’s post at Bloomberg View, very interesting. Note solar energy’s position in the graph. It isn’t there. Mr. Fox remarks:

The chart only included the top five sources of electrical power in the U.S. Perhaps surprisingly, solar power doesn’t make the cut. Even when you include the Energy Information Administration’s estimate of the power generated by rooftop panels and other small-scale solar, it’s still in seventh place behind biomass (burning wood, mainly).

Solar is gaining fast, though, and in a few places, it has already arrived.

He goes on to note that solar is presently California’s second largest method of electrical power generation, probably an overstatement since California imports about a third of its electricity and a lot of that comes from coal.

At the present rate of increase I don’t expect solar to be a significant source of overall U. S. electrical power generation in my lifetime and I may live another couple of decades.

There are a lot of variables to consider. We’re probably past peak subsidy for solar energy. What effect will reduced subsidies have on solar energy? There’s no Moore’s Law for solar cells or batteries. A major breakthrough may be just around the corner or present efficiencies may be as good as it gets for the next century. There’s really no way to tell.

Note that this post doesn’t indicate any particular hostility to solar energy on my part. I’m just trying to put things into perspective.

16 comments

Don’t Forget India

In Xander Snyder’s post at Geopolitical Futures after assessing the likelihood of a recession in the U. S. he turns to considering the likely impact of an American economic downturn on our major trading partners. Here’s a sample of his remarks:

When the next recession comes – and it will – the United States should be able to weather the storm. Even if the contraction is particularly bad, say, 3 percent over the year, and is followed by a long period of deleveraging in which borrowers spend more time paying debt than investing, the country’s diverse economy and relative independence from exports will mitigate the effects of the recession. Times will be tough, but they won’t threaten Washington’s position atop the global order.

The same cannot be said for countries that need the United States to be economically healthy enough to buy their exports. One such country is Germany, which in 2016 exported 107 billion euros’ ($119 billion) worth of goods to the United States, accounting for 8.8 percent of its total exports and 3.4 percent of its gross domestic product.
Germany exports nearly as much (101.4 billion euros’ worth) to France and only a little less (86 billion euros’ worth) to the United Kingdom, two countries that have their fair share of problems too. France is struggling with stagnant growth, high unemployment and regional economic disparities. The United Kingdom’s economic future is likewise uncertain as it prepares for negotiations to leave the EU.

China depends even more heavily on the health of the U.S. economy than does Germany. Roughly 20 percent of Chinese GDP is generated by exports, nearly 22 percent of which go to the United States. In other words, 4 percent of its entire GDP rests in the hands of U.S. consumers. The government has imposed restrictions on its real estate market, which has begun to push home and development prices down. Since a large portion of the Chinese economy depends on its real estate market, Beijing must walk a fine line between growth and a real estate bubble. If its largest trading partner buys fewer goods, that line becomes even finer

I noticed that he hadn’t mentioned India, probably because its American imports and exports are relatively small, but I thought it might be worthwhile to remedy that omission. The following information was drawn from VCCircle, Trading Economics, the CIA Factbook, and Bloomberg.

Exports comprise about 19% of the Indian economy and a considerable portion of its exports are in the form of software and IT-related services and remittances and somewhat more than half of that can be attributed to the United States. All in all exports to the U. S. and remittances from the U. S. account for 5-7% of the total Indian economy.

That’s a tiny amount of the U. S. economy. In other words like Germany or China we are much more important to them than they are to us and an economic turndown here will have serious consequences for the Indian economy. What those consequences are depend on what you think would happen in the event of a recession here. If you think that our imports of services from India would decline sharply, the impact on India could be quite severe. If you that our imports of services from India would increase as corporations sought to cut costs, a recession here could help the Indian economy.

There’s some reason to believe that a recession here wouldn’t have much effect on India’s economy one way or the other. That graph at the top of the page is somewhat misleading. When you consider Indian service exports taking into account the exchange rate between the dollar and the rupee and inflation, most of the 7% year-on-year increase that India saw in 2016 vanishes and, indeed, they have been pretty flat for the last decade.

3 comments

The Real Economy

At RealClearPolicy Mark Mills explains the importance of manufacturing to the U. S. economy:

A dollar added to the GDP by a factory generates a spillover economic benefit some three-fold greater than a dollar added by a car or food service. This well-established phenomenon is what economists call a “multiplier effect.” It means that policies directed at boosting manufacturing’s 12 percent of the economy are as impactful as an equal boost to 40 percent of the rest of the economy.

Of course, none of that matters if we have, in fact, entered a post-industrial era wherein making “stuff” is yesterday’s news. The Internet and now the “gig” economy have emboldened a worldview that has been fashionable ever since 1973, when Harvard sociologist Daniel Bell published “The Coming of Post-Industrial Society.” According to the post-industrialists, the denouement has finally arrived. In response, policymakers, they argue, shouldn’t try to rescue American factories but, instead, think in hospice terms: offer those displaced by the new high-tech economy handouts, whether in the form of welfare or a guaranteed minimum income — packaged of course with counseling.

He goes on to show that properly considered manufacturing remains the largest employer in the country and should remain so.

The eloi imagine a self-congratulatory future in which manufacturing does not exist. But it continues to exist underground, maintained by the bestial Morlocks on whom the eloi depend for their very existence. Someone should write a book about that.

10 comments

Why We Miss Moderates

At RealClearPolitics former Indiana Gov. Evan Bayh calls for ending the “vicious cycle” that lead to the shootings in Alexandria yesterday:

American democracy is supposed to be a competition of ideas. Elected officials are supposed to have spirited debates. As the saying goes, “politics ain’t beanbag.” But whatever their disagreements, an indelible comity once existed across the partisan divide. Fellowship did not end at the partisan edge.

In an age of increasingly heated debate—in an era defined too often by rhetorical vitriol—the Congressional Baseball Game was one of the few remaining respites. Each spring, colleagues who might otherwise be prone to excoriate one another on the floor of the House or Senate have met for a friendly game of balls and strikes. Their disagreements were never resolved in the course of nine innings. Members were unlikely to see eye-to-eye on a big vote simply because a Democratic second baseman chatted amiably for a moment with the Republican who’d hit a double. But for the few hours when they were engaged in America’s honored pastime, the stain of partisanship was overcome with a feeling of goodwill.

Now even that is tarnished.

Here’s his prescription:

The shooting in Alexandria shouldn’t become fodder for political talking points. It’s a personal tragedy for Rep. Steve Scalise, the other victims and their families. Of course, Americans’ foremost liberty is the freedom of speech. Even the most ardently held views have a right to be expressed. But some level of civility and proportion is important. No one should shout “fire” in a crowded theater and be surprised by the ensuing chaos. No one should strike a match near dry tinder and be surprised at the ensuing flames.

We all need to redouble our efforts to find the common humanity beneath every political disagreement. In the end, no matter how wrongheaded you may believe the other side to be, we all want America to thrive. We all want a better future for our children. We’re all invested in one another’s success.

Let’s hear more reconciliation in our political debate. Let’s rethink our propensity to make every disagreement apocalyptic. Let’s resist the temptation to infer the worst motives to our adversaries. In the end, the American values that unite us are much stronger than those tearing us apart. Let’s remember that. And even amid a horrible tragedy, let’s celebrate and defend the great blessings of American democracy. As Martin Luther King, Jr. once observed: “We may have arrived on these shores in different ships, but we’re all in the same boat now.”

As Plato noted, moderation is the virtue that makes republican government possible.

And that’s why we miss moderates.

3 comments

Fear of Muslims

Something that needs to be understood is that Russia and China face much greater risks from Islamist terrorism than we do. Either country has more Muslims than we do, their native Muslim populations are much more conservative and radical than ours, and both countries border states in which violent radical Islamist terrorism is commonplace. Both countries have resorted to extreme measures to suppress their native Muslim populations. The editors of the Wall Street Journal comment on some of China’s latest measures:

It’s Ramadan, and Beijing is again restricting the peaceful practice of Islam in its western territory of Xinjiang. This year government employees are required to ensure that friends and family aren’t fasting or otherwise observing the Muslim holy month. Under the “Together in Five Things” campaign, cadres are even living in the homes of the Uighur minority, according to the World Uyghur Congress.

This escalation may be due to the arrival of Chen Quanguo, who took over as Xinjiang’s Communist Party secretary in August after running Tibet for five years. He has introduced the system of “grid-style social management” he pioneered in Tibet that allows the government to closely monitor households.

According to state media, Xinjiang’s security budget increased 19.3% in 2016 to more than $4.4 billion, and 30,000 new officers were hired. In February Mr. Chen described security as “grim” and urged the People’s Armed Police to “bury the corpses of terrorists and terror gangs in the vast sea of the people’s war.” So much for winning hearts and minds.

New “Regulations on Anti-Extremism” that came into effect in April outlawed veils or “abnormal” beards. Parents can’t give children “overly religious” names such as Muhammad or encourage them to follow the Muslim faith. All Xinjiang residents were forced to turn in their passports late last year and must give a DNA sample when they apply for a new one.

Other measures include antiterror drills, shows of force by the security services and the installation of satellite tracking devices in cars. Mandatory activities for students are deliberately scheduled on Fridays to prevent them from attending mosque services, and rewards are offered for reporting men who wear a beard or women who wear a veil.

Control over the Uighur population goes far beyond religion. The use of their native language is discouraged in schools, and economic opportunities are limited. The best jobs go to Han Chinese settlers, who are given incentives to move to Xinjiang. Peaceful dissent is not tolerated. The Uighurs’ most articulate spokesman, Minzu University Professor Ilham Tohti, was sentenced to life in prison in 2014 for promoting separatism.

A number of real world experiments are going on. China is testing whether levels of suppression that would be impossible and, more importantly, rejected here will be effective in eliminating whatever threat their native Muslim population poses. The Chinese authorities have the advantage that they simply don’t give a damn about anyone but the Han Chinese.

We, too, are being tested. If the reports above are correct, they are in clear contravention of international accords to which China is a signatory. In typically Chinese fashion, their willingness to enter into international accords has almost no relationship to what their conduct.

Ours is a test of values. Do we really believe in the freedoms we claim to? Or in the international order? I can make no predictions about the outcome of China’s test. I would bet a shiny new dime that we will fail our test.

2 comments

The Problem Is Us

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Korean history prof Andrei Lankov makes a saddening claim to the effect that nothing short of war will cause the Kim regime to give up its nuclear weapons program:

The Trump administration, which seems to rank North Korea high among its foreign policy problems, is choosing the hard line, but with a twist: Trump hopes to cajole China into joining him in a really tough sanctions regime. The issue was discussed during the Trump-Xi Jinping summit in April: The administration has apparently indicated its willingness to reconsider some of the United States’ anti-Chinese policies — including on difficult trade issues — if China “fully cooperates” in getting tough on North Korea.

The administration’s assumption is that Chinese sanctions would push North Korea to the brink of an economic disaster and thus prompt the leaders in Pyongyang to reconsider their nuclear ambitions. Given that China controls about 90 percent of North Korea’s foreign trade and also provides the country with vital aid, including shipments of subsidized fuel, the expectations seem reasonable.

The problem is, however, that Beijing has valid reasons not to be too harsh on Pyongyang. While Chinese leaders do not like North Korea’s nuclear program, they are afraid that truly comprehensive sanctions might, indeed, push North Korea to the brink of economic collapse, which would be followed by political disintegration. From their point of view, North Korea in a state of civil war would be a greater threat than the nuclear-armed but relatively stable North Korea that exists now. Even worse, a crisis in North Korea might result in a German-style reunification of the country under Seoul’s control — that is, the emergence of a united, democratic and nationalistic Korean state that would probably be an ally of the United States. This is not an outcome that would be welcomed in Beijing.

While I completely acknowledge Dr. Lankov’s authority on North Korea and even China, I think he’s got it wrong. The Chinese are making a completely rational calculation. As long as a collapse of the Kim regime would be worse for China’s ruling elite than the alternative, where the wheel meets the road they’re content to allow the regime to do whatever it cares to. They have no particular attachment to the Kims. The relationship is purely instrumental.

However, if the stakes were changed, their calculation would change, too. The problem here is us. As long as our present relationship with China such as it is is more important to us than preventing an attack on U. S. cities by North Korea or preventing North Korea becoming the nuclear weapons vendor of choice for every madman with money, the Kim regime will continue its headlong rush to develop ICBMs armed with nuclear warheads. There are any number of levers we could pull ranging from our present relatively phlegmatic stance to much more aggressive moves.

In other words while I think Dr. Lankov is correct in his conclusion I think he’s wrong about the mechanics. The question is not one for the North Koreans or Chinese. They’re responding rationally to the incentives before them. It’s up to us to change those incentives. I don’t think we will. I think we’d rather put Honolulu, San Francisco, or Seattle at risk.

7 comments