Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
Seeking Alpha’s recent story on Tesla is highly critical:
What this above analysis tells us is that the opex is accelerating more rapidly than the installed base – even for existing products. Combined with anemic sales, we have accelerated cash burn, worse than expected operating cash flow and free cash flow. The need for cash has become direr.
We continue to highlight that Tesla does not have a sustainable business model and is completely dependent on capital infusions for survival.
The management narrative is increasingly fantastic and not credible.
All it takes is a dislocation in capital markets to have Tesla spiraling towards a disaster. The chances of bankruptcy remain significant.
The prevailing narrative about Tesla is of a fantastically innovative company on the cusp of revolutionizing the automobile industry. I’m skeptical. I think it’s more like a rent-seeking con man trying to coax more money out of credulous investors. Could it be both?
Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
I’m inclined to agree with the conclusion Mark Bowden reaches in his piece in Atlantic on possible responses to North Korean provocations. He lists the options as
- Prevention, i.e. preemptive attack
- Turning the screws, i.e. punishing NK short of war
- Decapitation, i.e. assassinating key members of the regime
- Acceptance
although I’d phrase it a bit differently. Read the whole thing.
What I’d say is that doing nothing is sometimes the best option. In the absence of an actual attack or serious threat, we should do nothing about North Korea. No threats. No saber-rattling. No ratcheting up of sanctions. Just ignore them.
However, if a North Korean missile is sold to another state or non-state actor or if North Korea actually attacks us or one of our allies, the situation would be very different.
Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
I disagree with Neil Irwin’s interpretation, expressed here at his Upshot feature, of the discrepancy between the various confidence indices and the performance of the economy:
After Donald J. Trump won the presidential election, Americans’ optimism about the economic future soared. But midway through the year, that optimism has not translated into concrete economic gains.
This seeming contradiction exposes a reality about the role of psychology in economics — or more specifically, how psychology is connected only loosely to actual growth. It will take more than feelings to fix the sluggishness that has been evident in the United States and other major economies for years. Confidence isn’t some magic elixir for the economy: Businesses will hire and invest only when they see concrete evidence of demand for their products, and consumers intensify their spending only when their incomes justify it.
What I believe the discrepancy illustrates is just how far separated the financial economy has become from the real economy and that CEO confidence levels in particular are nearly entirely predicated on the financial economy—which makes sense when you recognize that’s where most of their pay comes from.
As to his claim about businesses hiring and investing, etc. it would be nice to think that but that isn’t the case, either. There’s been plenty of consumer spending (if you like nominal PCE better that’s here). Domestic hiring and investing have lagged anyway. In a globalized world with lots of domestic retail overcapacity more spending doesn’t translate into domestic hiring and investing.
Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
The editors of the Chicago Tribune remark on the tax increase and budget:
Ask yourselves, House members: Would this tax increase create jobs here? Grow Illinois’ economy? Stop our young people from taking their careers to Texas, Florida, Colorado, California …
Some of you voted for another tax increase on the notorious night of 1/11/11. Remember all those promises from Democratic leaders? Remember how they designed it to be temporary? Remember how they later tried to blame Rauner for, um, letting their temporary tax hike expire? That increase took $31 billion from taxpayers and hurt Illinois’ job climate. The legislators who supported the hike of 1/11/11 had to own that vote.
So, House members, if you’ve delivered solutions — on property taxes, on pensions, on work comp, on government bloat in Illinois — then maybe you should vote to override Rauner’s veto.
Because if you can boast of real reforms, you’ll have an answer when all those taxpaying constituents look you in the eye and ask: “A 32-percent price increase — for what?”
The editors know very well that the legislature has no interest in reform. Reforms bring them nothing but pain. Tax increases on the other hand keep the party going just a little longer.
Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
The editors of the Wall Street Journal weigh in on Illinois’s budget:
In Illinois, Democrats spent the long weekend coaxing Republican legislators to join their suicide pact to raise taxes to plug a $6 billion deficit and pay down a $15 billion backlog of bills. And don’t forget the $130 billion unfunded pension liability—none of which will be solved by the $5 billion tax hike. GOP Governor Bruce Rauner vetoed the bill on Tuesday but may be overridden.
After credit-rating agencies threatened to downgrade the state debt to junk, Mr. Rauner proposed raising the state’s income tax to 4.95% from 3.75% and the corporate income rate to 9.5% from 7.75% for four years. In return he asked for a property tax freeze and modest reforms to workers compensation. Yet Mr. Rauner already signed off on a huge property tax hike in Chicago—homeowner bills have increased by a quarter in two years—to pay for teacher pensions.
But Illinois’s legislature refused to compromise. Now the budget they’ve enacted, no doubt overriding the governor’s veto, barely scratches the surface of Illinois’s problems. What’s the source of those problems?
Anemic revenue and economic growth can’t keep up with entitlement spending. The state’s GDP has ticked up by a mere 0.8% annually over the last four years compared to 2% nationwide and 1.4% in the Great Lakes region. Since 2010 more than 520,000 Illinois residents on net have fled to other states. (See the nearby chart for some state comparisons.)
The editorial goes on to consider Connecticut’s and New Jersey’s similar problems. Of course, there are some differences. Connecticut is the richest state in the Union on a per capita basis and both Connecticut and New Jersey are growing rather than contracting as Illinois is.
Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
Looks like David Ignatius, augur of the conventional Washington wisdom, has come around to the point I made three years ago. From his recent Washington Post column:
Russian-American cooperation on Syria faces a huge obstacle right now. It would legitimize a Russian regime that invaded Ukraine and meddled in U.S. and European elections, in addition to its intervention in Syria. Putin’s very name is toxic in Congress and the U.S. media these days, and Trump is blasted for even considering compromise.
Against these negatives, there’s only one positive argument: Working with Russia may be the only way to reduce the level of violence in Syria and to create a foundation for a calmer, more decentralized nation that can eventually recover from its tragic war.
It might also give Washington a seat at the table in discussing Syria’s future, something it won’t have under present circumstances.
Being able to change course and take a new stance more cooperative with the Syrian government depends on the hierarchy of values. As long as regime change in Syria and poking a stick in Russia’s collective eye are more important than Syrian lives, it’s out of the question.
You can’t make an omelet without breaking eggs. Syrian eggs, of course. Okay, Washington, where’s the omelet?
Dave Schuler
July 5, 2017
Well, so much for the fierce urgency of now. As expected, yesterday Illinois Gov. Rauner vetoed the tax increase and the budget, the Senate quickly moved to override his veto, and the Illinois House adjourned without taking action. The Associated Press has the latest:
The Illinois House has adjourned without taking action on budget veto overrides that awaits it. There was not a quorum present to conduct business on the Fourth of July holiday.
The House didn’t convene until late Tuesday because the focus of the state’s two-year budget crisis was on the Senate.
The Senate approved a budget package that spends $36 billion on the strength of a $5 billion increase in the income tax. Rauner vetoed the package, but the Senate quickly voted to override, sending the legislation to the House.
Chicago Democratic House Speaker Michael Madigan of Chicago said shortly after the Senate action that there would be no House activity Tuesday, but he did not explain why and his spokesman couldn’t say.
Only 54 members answered the House quorum call. That prohibited lawmakers from taking action.
If I were the ratings agencies, I would examine the budget closely to determine if it actually resolved Illinois’s fiscal problems which I suspect it does not. If they were to find that it doesn’t, they should cut Illinois’s credit rating to junk.
What’s going on now is political posturing. The legislature has had three years to resolve the problem. They’re just running out the clock, hoping to have a more accommodating governor next year.
To put the tax increase into perspective, Illinois realized about $33.7 billion in revenues last year of which 47% was from the personal income tax. Increasing the tax by a third would realize roughly an additional $5 billion, assuming no run-on effects. Illinois has about $16 billion in overdue bills.
Dave Schuler
July 4, 2017
As predicted the Illinois Senate voted to approve the one-third tax hike in the personal income tax and as predicted Gov. Rauner has vetoed it. Politico reports:
Attempting to avoid becoming the first state ever to see its bond rating downgraded to “junk†status, the Illinois legislature on Tuesday sent Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner a $36 billion spending plan in a dramatic showdown that culminated in an extraordinary Fourth of July vote.
Rauner, who called the legislature into a special session to pass a budget, quickly vetoed the measure, citing its permanent income tax increase; the governor, who is attempting to salvage his precarious 2018 reelection prospects, has sought a temporary tax hike and a property tax freeze.
The Illinois Senate already voted to override the veto and the House is expected to follow suit Tuesday afternoon, setting up stability for the state as markets reopen Wednesday.
One of the lawmakers had this to say about the measure:
“We are in a moment in time,†state Sen. Toi Hutchinson, among the Democratic leaders in negotiations said on Tuesday. “We are faced today with the fierce urgency of now.â€
It’s been three years since Illinois has had a budget. The legislators didn’t even bother meeting about the budget until June of this year. Under those circumstances “now” has a way of sneaking up on you.
The Democrats wanted a tax hike and, presuming the House votes to override the governor’s veto as is expected, they’ll get it. The last time the personal income tax was this high they did nothing to straighten out the state’s finances. It’s hard to believe they’ll do any better this time around.
What’s easier to believe is that Ilinois’s higher taxes will drive more people and businesses out of the state. Illinois is not California. We don’t have mountains or ocean or a benign climate to attract people. Illinois’s tax base is falling and its expenses aren’t. The state legislature needs to come to terms with that reality.
Dave Schuler
July 4, 2017
Dave Schuler
July 4, 2017
Our pals, the North Koreans, have tested a missile that apparently flew 600 miles before crashing into the Sea of Japan. CNN reports:
(CNN)North Korea claims to have conducted its first successful test of a long-range missile that it says can “reach anywhere in the world.”
Tuesday morning’s missile test, which was conducted on the orders of the country’s leader, Kim Jong Un, reached a height of 2,802 kilometers (1,741 miles), according to state broadcaster Korea Central Television (KCTV).
That’s the highest altitude ever reached by a North Korean missile, and puts the US on notice that Pyongyang could potentially hit the US mainland.
That puts the missile within striking distance of most of Japan’s population centers (and China’s). Here’s a handy table that lists the distances between Pyongyang and major world cities. Anchorage is 3,737 miles from Pyongyang. Honolulu 4,600. San Francisco 5,605.
My graver concern is that North Korea might decide to become one-stop shopping for anybody with money and a grudge. Hey, that DVD collection doesn’t buy itself.