The Useful Russians

I want to encourage you to read this briefing at the Foreign Policy Research Institute from Rensselaer Lee and William Severe which proposes that the Russians be encouraged to get involved in the situation with North Korea:

This briefing argues that the United States should attempt to engage Russia as a potential broker of negotiations over North Korea’s nuclear and missile programs. Russia’s ascension to a more prominent role in North Korean affairs is long overdue, and could add some heft to the international community’s negotiating positions vis-à-vis Pyongyang.

The briefing also argues that the policy of economic sanctions on North Korea, while important in pressuring Pyongyang, has proven insufficient in coercing the country to restrain or relinquish its nuclear and missile programs. One reason for this lack of success is North Korea’s skill at evading sanctions via shell companies and Chinese intermediaries. A second reason is that not all parties to the sanctions, most notably the Chinese, have demonstrated the level of commitment required to implement an airtight sanctions regime

If there’s one thing that should be of no concern to us at all, it’s the prospect of Russia becoming too chummy with China. It is of no more concern than would a cobra getting pally with a mongoose. Russia’s involvement might change China’s calculus in determining where their interests lie. It also highlights just how counter-productive fostering a hostile relationship between Russia and the United States is.

6 comments

What’s the Matter With Connecticut?

In his article on Connecticut at Atlantic Derek Thompson lurches uncontrollably into the observations I made about Connecticut’s budget problems several days ago—its tax base is declining:

Despite being the richest state in the country, by per-capita income, Connecticut’s budget is a mess. Its pensions are woefully under-funded. Its deficit is projected to surpass $2 billion, or 12 percent of its total annual tax revenue. Hartford is approaching bankruptcy. Conservatives look at Connecticut and see a liberal dystopia, where high taxes have ruined the economy. Liberals, on the other hand, see a capitalist horror show, where the rich dwell in gilded mansions, ensconced in sylvan culs-de-sac, while nearby towns face rising poverty and bankruptcy. Why is America’s richest state floundering?

The first answer is: Corporations are leaving. Aetna, the insurance giant, is leaving Hartford, where it was founded 150 years ago. In early 2016, General Electric announced that it would move its global headquarters from Fairfield, Connecticut, to Boston.*

The second answer is: People are leaving. It’s rare for any state to actually shrink, but Connecticut’s population has been falling for three straight years. Meanwhile, only Michigan, Ohio, and Mississippi had slower job growth than Connecticut did over the last two decades, according to Jed Kolko, the chief economist at Indeed, a job site.

What I think goes unappreciated in these commentaries about Connecticut is that state’s split personality. Southwestern Connecticut is a sort of bedroom community for wealthy New Yorkers. The rest of the state (especially when you discount New Haven) is very different indeed and it’s that part of the state that is suffering.

The wealthy are much more mobile than the poor and do, indeed, respond to incentives. If you tell them you don’t want them, by raising their taxes for example, they’re polite enough to leave.

And one of the big implications of really great income inequality is that a very few very rich people leaving can make a huge difference in a state’s revenues. It’s like what happens to a company town when the company leaves.

2 comments

O’Reilly on Trump’s War With the Media

Whatever you think of Bill O’Reilly, he’s a smart guy and he’s been around the block a couple of times. Consider these observations of his at The Hill:

There are two levels to the hate-Trump media movement. First, the national press corps largely believes he is not qualified to run the country and his flamboyant personal style offends the media elite who consider him to be a vulgarian.

The second level is pure ideology. Under President Obama, the United States lurched left in a dramatic way. Political correctness became the order of the day, and conservative thinkers were branded racists and bigots simply for opposing liberal policies. The press encouraged that massive deception, and the demonization of selective conservative individuals became acceptable. Groups funded by people like George Soros have actually organized into propaganda hit squads using a sympathetic media to spread their vicious invective.

Here’s his advice to the president:

Tweet facts, Mr. President, not insults. Hammer your opposition with verifiable statements. Do that, and you may ultimately prevail against a press that often abuses its freedom — a media where seeking the truth is becoming obsolete.

I suspect his analysis of the media is just about right. I hold no hope that President Trump will take his advice. What I think is likely to happen is that both Trump and the media will continue what they’ve been doing. And, as in mud rasslin’ with a pig, Trump will like it and the media will get even dirtier. We will permanently assume the situation that prevails in the United Kingdom where news outlets are associated with specific political parties.

12 comments

The Obvious Outcome

At CNN (!) Frida Ghitis is outraged that President Trump appears to want to rule rather than govern:

But whether by design or by impulse, Trump is in practice following the authoritarian playbook. He displays the instincts of a populist autocrat. He didn’t need to read books about Mussolini, study Hugo Chavez’s maneuvers, or become schooled in the tactics of Vladimir Putin. He has shown these things are in his blood.
Indeed, he appears not to want to govern so much as rule.

She seems to have forgotten President Obama’s distaste for the political process and his imperious style of governing, for which his high rate of reversal by the Supreme Court—the highest of any president in the post-war period, frequently in unanimous decisions, serves as adequate documentation.

If you give presidents imperial powers, they will, remarkably, start behaving like emperors. You may even attract would-be emperors to seek the presidency. The solution is to restore the Constitutional balance and have the Congress take back the reins of government which the Constitution gives it.

Related: Congress’s approval rating is lower than Trump’s.

6 comments

Enlarging the Problem

At The Week Harry Kazianis argues that the U. S. should consider the challenge posed by North Korea’s nuclear and ICBM development programs as part of the larger set of problems in the relationship between the United States and China:

It’s time for the United States to stop separating two clear and present dangers in the Asia-Pacific region and lump them together as one problem that must be confronted immediately.

The evidence is overwhelming that a rising and defiant China, and a rogue North Korea — now armed with what appears to be an intercontinental ballistic missile, or ICBM — must become Washington’s top joint foreign policy priority. Everything else — whether it’s the Islamic State, Russia, Iran, or even the horrific Syrian civil war — pales in comparison.

But before we start analyzing the dangers America and its allies face today in Asia and what to do about it, we need to know how we got here.

That makes sense. His proposal to enlarge the U. S. military footprint in the region doesn’t.

If it were up to me, I’d publicly recommend to China that they deal with North Korea and privately tell them that if they don’t we will with deadly consequences for North Korea and costly ones for China and leave it at that. Stop clutching our pearls at every new test but be prepared to act decisively if North Korea actually attacks us or our allies, attempts to blackmail us, or starts selling the technology they’ve developed. Minimalist or even proportional responses will be inadequate in dealing with North Korea. We might also want to advise the South Koreans that they should start digging.

2 comments

Converting CO2 to CO

Here’s an interesting technology. nanotechweb.org reports that researchers have found a way to convert carbon dioxide to carbon monoxide, a useful precursor to hydrocarbons useful as fuel, using available energy and cheap catalysts:

Researchers in Switzerland and Spain have developed a solar-driven electrolyser that converts CO2 to CO using only Earth-abundant elements in place of precious metals. Reducing emissions of CO2 by converting it electrochemically to CO is an attractive prospect due to the potential use of CO as a precursor to fuels and high-value chemicals. The work leads the way to further exploration of Earth-abundant metals that might perform comparably to the rare elements used until now.

The conventional method to convert CO2 to CO uses precious-metal catalysts (gold, silver, palladium) at considerable overpotentials and also requires electrolyte additives. What this research has demonstrated is an innovative, inexpensive and stable alternative using a bifunctional system of SnO2-modified CuO electrodes separated by a bipolar membrane and driven by a solar cell. This newly developed system constitutes a milestone for the catalysis community as it avoids the requirement – until now – of noble metals.

There’s lots of work remaining before a viable product emerges, of course. For one thing the technology must be scaleable. Something that works in the lab isn’t the same thing as something that will work in production. But it’s still an interesting technology.

3 comments

All My Legislators

The ongoing soap opera over Illinois’s budget hasn’t ended with the governor’s veto or the legislature’s likely override of his veto today. CNNMoney reports that the credit agencies may, as I warned, reduce Illinois’s credit rating to junk anyway:

Bruce Rauner, governor of Illinois, left, delivers a budget address in the House Chamber of the State Capitol building in Springfield, Illinois, U.S., on Wednesday, Feb. 18, 2015.

Even if Illinois’ House of Representatives takes action to enact a new budget on Thursday, the state still risks a downgrade in its credit rating to junk, Moody’s Investors Service warned on Wednesday.

The Democratic-controlled House on Thursday will attempt to overturn Republican Governor Bruce Rauner’s vetoes of spending and tax increase measures aimed at ending the state’s unprecedented two-year budget impasse.

Moody’s said it placed Illinois’ Baa3 rating, which is one step above the junk level, on review for a possible downgrade.

The $36 billion fiscal 2018 budget and $5 billion income tax increase passed by lawmakers over the extended Fourth of July holiday weekend, may fall short in addressing the state’s financial woes, particularly its huge unfunded pension liability and $15 billion unpaid bill backlog, according to Moody’s.

“On both those fronts, it’s not yet clear if the legislation being enacted will have a substantial and clear positive effect,” said Moody’s analyst Ted Hampton.

The legislators decided that the very smallest step they could take to head off junk status was to enact a budget, even one that fell short of the reform that Illinois needs, to reassure the ratings agencies that the state wouldn’t default immediately. That may not have been enough.

Meanwhile, I’m surprised at the narrow focus that the editors of the Wall Street Journal have taken:

Credit-rating agencies are now backing off their threat to downgrade Illinois debt to junk status after the state’s Democratic Senate with GOP support overrode Governor Bruce Rauner’s veto of a tax increase this weekend. But bondholders beware: Politicians will happily throw them over as easily as Republicans dumped their reform principles.

The three major rating agencies— Moody’s , S&P and Fitch—are constructive in highlighting fiscal deficits, but they often underestimate credit risk. Downgrades are lagging indicators of fiscal and economic stress. Puerto Rico’s debt wasn’t slashed to junk until 2014—seven years into a decade-long recession and after politicians had borrowed tens of billions to tape up structural deficits. And as they demonstrated again in Illinois, credit raters don’t much care how deficits are closed. Tax increases are fine, even desirable, if spending cuts are too politically difficult.

Earlier this year the big three credit raters cut Illinois’s rating to just above junk and warned the state would lose its investment grade if politicians didn’t pass a budget reducing its $15 billion backlog of bills. While the yield on Illinois’s 10-year general obligation bonds is 4.4%, servicing its debt is twice as expensive as for highly rated governments—and watch out if interest rates rise.

What surprises me is that they don’t point out that there’s a big difference between near-junk and junk status. Many institutions have governance rules which require them to put money only in securities that are investment grade. Junk status narrows the pool of possible purchasers of Illinois’s debt.

The additional drag that higher costs of debt servicing would place on Illinois’s budget isn’t the only consideration; whether Illinois can refinance its debt at all is a much more serious concern.

4 comments

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

Gettysburg – A Fourth Of July Long Ago 

 WoW! Forum: Trump’s Tweets – Effective Communication Or National Embarrassment? 
 

 
0 comments

The Unveiling

My wife’s project for this summer was to have our backyard re-landscaped. She was tired of our having a pond three inches deep over much of it whenever it rained.

We had it regraded and resodded and had them neaten up our beds and put in some new planting.

BTW, on the left of the shed we’ve got tomatoes and peppers planted. On the right side of the shed is my herb garden.

12 comments

Communicating Science Is Hard

This article at the New York Times, which attempts to explain the developments in thinking about the origins of our species, Homo sapiens sapiens, and how it’s related to other subspecies of the same species, Homo sapiens neanderthalensis (Neanderthals) and Homo sapiens denisova (Denisovans), would be a lot clearer if it explained some of the controversies in classification.

Are we, the Neanderthals, and the Denisovans different subspecies of the same species? Or are we different species, i.e. the proper nomenclature is Homo sapiens, Homo neanderthalensis, and Homo denisova? Consider this paragraph:

The expert consensus now is that Homo sapiens evolved at least 300,000 years ago in Africa. Only much later — roughly 70,000 years ago — did a small group of Africans establish themselves on other continents, giving rise to other populations of people today.

It makes no sense unless you assume the second nomenclature. However, if my understanding is correct, that’s not the way the wind is blowing. Present thinking is trending towards considering us, Neanderthals, and Denisovans as members of the same species rather than three different species.

All of this illustrates why communicating science is hard. Not only is the terminology itself difficult (and in another language) but the understanding changes over time.

1 comment