The Cook County “Sweetened Beverages” Tax

Since the “sweetened beverages” tax has gone into effect in Cook County we’ve been absolutely deluged with public service announcements, funded by Michael Bloomberg, trying to convince Chicagoans to appreciate what their betters are doing for them. The tax adds a penny an ounce to the cost of a bottle of pop or, in an exercise in overreach to any beverage whether naturally or artificially sweetened—soda, sports drinks, flavored water, energy drinks, pre-made sweetened coffee and tea with less than 50% milk content, etc. That translates to $.72 a six pack or an additional $2.88 in tax per case.

If my dear local grocery store, Happy Foods, had a fidelity club, I’d be a member. I am a daily shopper and have been for more than 25 years so I am, consequently, a face familiar to the staff at the store.

The other day I was chatting with the store manager and she told me that since the tax went into effect soft drink sales across Cook County have declined by 58% county-wide. Since sales tax applies to soft drink sales in Cook County, that means a loss in sales tax revenue. I don’t know what the net effect on tax revenue might be but I suspect that less net revenue is being collected as a consequence of the tax than was anticipated by the County Board.

Keep in mind that the grocery business is a low margin one. A loss of revenue in an item like soft drinks is no joke for many retailers.

Lest you confuse a reduction in sales with a reduction in the consumption of sweetened drinks, in the same conversation the store manager revealed that she was buying her pop when she visited her daughter who lives in DuPage County where the tax does not apply. I don’t think I know anyone who isn’t doing the same thing.

So not only is the tax regressive its effect on health may be negligible as well. Oh well, you can’t make an omelet without breaking eggs. It would be interesting to know if the members of the Cook County Board were still buying drinks subject to the tax and where they were buying them.

9 comments

The Art of Finding the Second Best Strategy

I don’t read the Weekly Standard much but in this article in it Ike Brannon touches on something very important. Very, very few policies that get enacted into law are actually the best way to accomplish any objective. Take flood policy, for example:

For instance, they observed, the best policy regarding floods would be to simply disallow all construction in a floodplain, or at least forswear any public financial assistance to people who do build there and subsequently have property damaged by a flood.

which the observant reader would notice resembles what I’ve pointed out on the subject. However, it runs afoul of politics:

However, such a promise cannot be kept: the political pressures to help victims will be too great to resist. What’s more, people recognize that reality, so they fail to heed the government warnings and build in the floodplains anyway, which in turn forces the government’s hand by putting it in a situation where it finds itself obligated to provide assistance after a flood.

Oddly, there are no corresponding political pressures not to have victims. The real victors are land developers.

He’s not quite on such solid ground in discussing immigration policy:

The optimal immigration strategy would be to have no illegal immigrants. Jeff Sessions would achieve that by making massive new investments in border enforcement until it is nearly impossible to enter illegally. My way would be to let every immigrant who arrives in the U.S. receive permission to work.

Is that really the objective of immigration policy? And why doesn’t the actual policy respond to the political pressures that flood policy does? There is a consensus that total immigration (legal and illegal) should be at or below its present level. There is no consensus that it should be at or above its present level. And yet that’s where the policy sits.

I think the answer is that there’s good money to be made from bad policy.

It would be nice if we actually were arriving at second best policies or responding to consensus. What actually seems to be happening is that we’re arriving at the least unacceptable policy that generates the most power, influence, and money for those who support it. We’re optimizing the wrong things.

6 comments

Why I’m Not Watching the New Ken Burns Documentary

I just don’t have it in me to watch Ken Burns’s documentary on the Vietnam War. I’m sure it’s a masterful job, interesting, and entertaining, joining narration, first hand recollections, photos, video, and music of the period, etc. but I remember the period too well and it was not a happy time for me.

I was called up but didn’t serve. They rejected me for bad eyes and bad knees.

9 comments

We Are All Pauline Kael Now

James Rogers articulates the Democrats’ gamble pretty well at the Library of Liberty and Law:

Trump is poison for many in the Democratic base. Many have moved from the normal condescension with which Democrats treat Republicans, into pure hatred. They make GOP “Never Trumpers” look like subscribers to American Greatness.

Demoralizing the rabidly anti-Trump portion of the Democratic base means some won’t turn out to vote.

but

In turn, decreased turnout among the Democratic base would mean that the location of the median voter moves to the right. On the other hand, if Democrats become even more extreme, then it moves the party even further away from the median voter, making it easier for GOP candidates to position themselves to win the critical pivotal voter. In either case, this is good news for the Republicans.

To be sure, a more-pure leftwing Democratic Party might articulate a cleaner, less muddled ideological message, and so persuade the respective medians to move left with them.

Much depends on what you think the mythical median American voter believes. If you think that most Americans are farther to the the left than one might gather from the outcomes of, say, Congressional elections, then it’s no gamble at all. It’s a sure thing. If you think, as Mr. Rogers apparently does, in the “moderately center-right median American voter”, then it’s brain dead. The idea that most Americans don’t really care and what’s really important is energizing your base however small it may be is the key idea behind the gamble.

What occurred to me as I read the piece is that whoever you are and whatever you think, you probably can’t tell what most Americans think. We are all Pauline Kael now.

If you’ve heard of Pauline Kael at all, it’s probably in connection with her most famous quote which is that she didn’t understand how Richard Nixon won the 1968 election because she didn’t know anybody who voted for him which, as it turns out, she never said. What she actually said was:

I live in a rather special world. I only know one person who voted for Nixon. Where they are I don’t know. They’re outside my ken. But sometimes when I’m in a theater I can feel them.

which is hardly exculpatory.

Today most of us live in “rather special worlds”. It is more than likely that most of the people we know and with whom we associate whether digitally or in the flesh think pretty much as we do and it is becoming more so, both because the middle is eroding in favor of the extremes and due to assortative mating and patterns of residence.

2 comments

The Old New Left vs. the New New Left

At the Claremont Review of Books Charles Kesler contrasts the New Left of the 1960s of Tom Hayden, Jerry Rubin, and SDS with today’s New Left of antifa and BLM. Here’s a snippet of the article and, I think, its kernel:

The old New Left hated being treated as children by professors and deans who claimed to stand in loco parentis. Nothing offended Tom Hayden more, as he remarked in his 1961 Letter, than American universities’ “endless repressions of free speech and thought, the stifling paternalism that infects the student’s whole perception of what is real and possible and enforces a parent-child relationship until the youth is suddenly transplanted into ‘the world.’” When the Free Speech Movement (FSM) formed at Berkeley in 1964, its analysis of frustrated, alienated students, as Allen J. Matusow writes in his very fine The Unraveling of America: A History of Liberalism in the 1960s (1984), “came straight out of the Port Huron Statement.” “In our free-speech fight,” said one of FSM’s leaders, Mario Savio, “we have come up against what may emerge as the greatest problem of our nation—depersonalized, unresponsive bureaucracy.”

Nowadays, student protestors demand in effect, and sometimes literally, that colleges protect them from adulthood, from humanistic debates and political disagreements. “It is not about creating an intellectual space!” a Yale student shouted in 2015 at Professor Nicholas Christakis, then master of Silliman College, one of Yale’s residential colleges. “It is not! Do you understand that? It’s about creating a home here!” She added, not exactly maturely, “You should not sleep at night. You are disgusting!” At home, apparently, she is always a child.

Authentic or strong individualism seems far from what today’s protestors are seeking. They raise their voices almost always as members of groups, whose relevant identity is more collective than personal: students of color, the marginalized, victims of microaggressions, who seek protection by and from the white power structure, and compensation to boot.

On their own, apart from the group, they often seem emotionally fragile. As another Silliman resident, Jencey Paz, wrote in her Yale Herald article “Hurt at Home,” “I don’t want to debate. I want to talk about my pain.” The journal removed her article from its website after it attracted a lot of unflattering attention—thus confirming Paz’s preferences.

No one would have called Hayden or Jerry Rubin or the other leaders of the old radicals “snowflakes.” They wanted to oppose the macroagressions of a society that, in their view, had lost its way amid racism and the existential threats of the Bomb and the Cold War. They wanted to change society, not retreat from it. What happened to the New Left’s passionate idealism?

It hasn’t disappeared entirely, but the theory embraced by today’s campus Left is far different from that of the ’60s New Left. The Port Huron Statement reflected deep intellectual engagement, if not exactly seriousness. Its contemporary influences included Herbert Marcuse’s Eros and Civilization (1955) and C. Wright Mills’s The Power Elite (1956). Marcuse, a student of Martin Heidegger’s, had perhaps the primary philosophical influence on the movement, and along with other writers helped to connect it, however tendentiously, to Freud, Nietzsche, Marx, Hegel, and Rousseau.

The new New Left has no comparable philosophical grounding or intellectual foundation. A widely adopted primer of its thought (used in the Claremont Colleges, for instance), Critical Race Theory: An Introduction (2001) by Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic, now in its third edition, nods in the direction of Antonio Gramsci, Michel Foucault, and Jacques Derrida, but these are dusty portraits on the wall rather than active intellectual interests. The book presumes the truth of an easy-going and politically convenient postmodernism without ever establishing it, or reflecting on the alternative. But that’s what’s so handy about postmodernism, isn’t it? It lets you get on with it—skip past the questions of truth and justice, and get right to the delicious matter of power.

I don’t see the real dichotomy as between the Left and the New Left, the Old New Left and the New New Left, or even the Left and the Right so much as between the self-described “creative class” and LBJ. The “creative class” have at least some claim to elite status; LBJ had none other than that of Napoleon—he had brought himself to power. Fifty years ago as now the LBJs had the power. Their “creative class” myrmidons are mere appendages. The LBJs have created little and will create little other than their own influence, power, and wealth.

Who are they? Household names: Rahm Emanuel, Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump, Nancy Pelosi, Rick Scott, the list goes on.

7 comments

It Isn’t Up to Us

In an op-ed at the Wall Street Journal Michael Dempsey outlines five challenges that confront Iraq in the aftermath of driving DAESH out:

First, the Kurdish independence referendum, originally scheduled for Sept. 25, is threatening to spark a full-blown crisis even before ISIS is defeated on the battlefield. At issue is whether a large chunk of Iraq will eventually break away entirely or redefine its relationship with the central government. Complicating the issue is the inclusion in the vote of disputed territories, including the oil-rich city of Kirkuk, which is held by Kurdish forces but claimed by Baghdad.

On Monday Iraq’s Supreme Court ordered the referendum suspended until it can assess the vote’s legality. United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres is also calling for a delay, as are Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and the Turkish and Iranian governments. Kurdish leader Masoud Barzani has previously hinted that he might delay the referendum until after national elections next April, but only at the price of concessions and assurances about the Kurds’ future status. Whether or not the referendum is held next week, it’s likely to be only the opening act in lengthy negotiations between the parties, and resolving the question in a way that doesn’t undermine Baghdad’s legitimacy and threaten Iraq’s neighbors is critically important.

Second, to ensure that ISIS remains marginalized, Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi must accelerate long-delayed political reconciliation efforts, specifically by easing de-Baathification efforts and providing more local power and job opportunities to Sunni communities. This is a difficult task given the deep divisions over this issue within the Iraqi parliament, but Sunni isolation fueled ISIS’ rise, and progress must be made on this issue soon.

Third, Baghdad must exercise tight control over the thousands of Shiite militia fighters (many of whom participated in Tal Afar’s liberation) and limit their authority in traditional Sunni areas. Mr. Abadi must ensure that the Shiite militias are not allowed to determine unilaterally which populations are allowed to re-enter liberated areas, and that the bulk of reconstruction aid from Baghdad is not distributed only to Shiite communities. The Shiite militias are deeply distrusted by the Sunni populations of Nineveh and Anbar provinces, and they are a potential flashpoint in the delicate Shiite-Sunni relationship.

Fourth, as winter approaches, Baghdad must make progress in improving living conditions throughout the country. ISIS devastated infrastructure in the areas it controlled. The latest U.N. estimate is that some 11 million Iraqis require humanitarian assistance, with more than three million displaced across the country, more than one million living in temporary housing settlements, and more than 200,000 refugees abroad. The critical work of providing food and shelter to displaced Iraqis is a top priority.

The recent claim by Iraq’s minister of water resources that the Mosul Dam is no longer in danger is worrisome, especially if it reflects a willingness of the central government to gloss over difficult infrastructure-related challenges. The grouting work performed by an Italian firm to shore up the dam’s foundation was widely viewed as only a temporary solution, and most experts still believe there is the potential for a catastrophic dam breach.

Fifth, Mr. Abadi has to begin preparing for local and national elections. Despite a surge in his popularity following the Iraqi military’s victories against ISIS, he will likely face a significant re-election challenge from, among others, Hadi al-Amiri, a longstanding ally of Iran. Mr. Abadi has been a strong partner for the U.S. in the counter-ISIS campaign, and his re-election offers the best hope for continuing a positive working relationship between Washington and Baghdad, and for balancing Tehran’s growing influence in Iraq.

I think there’s something vitally important for us to keep in mind: it isn’t up to us. We shouldn’t decide Iraq’s fate, whether it continues to exist or under what structure. That must be left to the Iraqis. We should neither support nor impede the Iraqis’ decisions about their own fate.

5 comments

Reach Out

It isn’t often that I agree with every word in an op-ed in a major news outlet but I agree 100% with what Jesuit priest James Martin writes in his Washington Post op-ed:

After a gunman killed 49 people at Pulse, a predominantly gay nightclub in Orlando in 2016, I found myself disappointed that more Catholic leaders did not offer support to the LGBT community. And that the few who did found it difficult to acknowledge that LGBT people specifically had been targeted for murder.

For me, that silence highlighted a certain failure to be compassionate to the LGBT community even in a moment of tragedy. It also revealed that the LGBT community was still largely invisible to some church authorities. In response, I recorded a brief video that was posted on Facebook. It offered some support for the LGBT community during a terribly difficult few weeks.

Not long afterwards, New Ways Ministry, an organization that ministers to and advocates for LGBT Catholics, invited me to accept their Bridge Building Award. Until then, I had never done what you might call formal ministry with LGBT Catholics, besides the counseling that almost every church worker does in his or her ministry. But the Catholic Church’s response to the events in Orlando encouraged me to do so in a more public way. So, with my Jesuit superiors’ permission, I accepted the award and offered a lecture on how to build a “two-way bridge” between LGBT Catholics and the institutional church — that is, the church’s hierarchy and decision-makers. From that talk came the first half of my book, “Building a Bridge: How the Catholic Church and the LGBT Community can Enter into a Relationship of Respect, Compassion, and Sensitivity.”

Now, in the past few weeks, three lectures I was invited to have been canceled, and I have been targeted by some far-right groups whose actions betray a level of homophobia that is hard to fathom. These groups, a kind of Catholic alt-right, are increasingly attempting to substitute themselves for legitimate Church authority by passing judgments on which Catholics are orthodox and which are not. “Heresy” is a word they use as frequently as “and” and “the.”

and I’m appalled that some alleged Catholics should take it on themselves to react in that way. Hating homosexuals is inconsistent with Church teaching. As a Catholic you don’t need to accept every item on a political agenda but you should at least conform to church teaching, honoring the magisterium if nothing else.

7 comments

Putting Your Thumb on the Scale

What’s wrong with this sentence?

A report ordered up by President Trump in March, and produced by officials in July, concluded that refugees had delivered $63 billion more in federal, state and local tax revenue than they had cost in federal benefits through the decade ending in 2014.

I mean as analysis. That’s from a Washington Post editorial in support of the U. S. accepting more refugees.

The answer is that it’s comparing apples and oranges—federal, state, and local revenues vs. federal benefits only. If you really wanted to determine the net cost (or profit) from refugees, you’d compare federal, state, and local revenues with federal, state, and local spending as a result of refugees.

The state and local costs of refugees, immigrants, generally, actually, dwarf the federal costs. There are education expenses, health care expenses, roads and sewers, law enforcement, social services, and thousands of other expense line items large and small to include in the reckoning. I think we can agree that if you consider only the revenues and ignore most of the costs you’ll find a benefit every time. That’s generally not what is thought of as “cost-benefit analysis”.

I’d support changing the mix of immigrants into the United States to include more refugees, giving priority to the people who’d helped us in our wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, and now Syria and their families but I think we’d be better served as a society by reducing the total number of immigrants. Immigrants are presently 14% of the population—the highest in as long as we’ve kept records. I think we need a breather.

1 comment

Why Centralize?

Avik Roy’s concern about the latest iteration of health care insurance reform, expressed in his Washington Post op-ed, is that it has the wrong balance between administration by the states and “market-oriented” reforms:

The core idea in the bill is to take the money Obamacare spends on expanding coverage to the uninsured and give it to state governments in the form of block grants. States, in turn, could use these block grants to address the health-care needs of their populations.

It’s an attractive idea, in theory. Let states become laboratories of democracy, with some states using market-based approaches and others using government-centered ones — and then we’ll see who does best at covering the uninsured.

But Cassidy-Graham, in its current form, would put a heavy Washington hand on the federalism steering wheel. The bill would make it relatively easy for blue states to expand the role of single-payer health care, while making it rather difficult for red states to achieve market-oriented reforms. Lawmakers would be wise to revise the law so that it is more evenhanded.

You would think that would attract more progressives to the plan but apparently not. What attraction does a centralized national system hold for progressives? Such a system for the United States would be unprecedented. It wouldn’t be like Canada’s system—Canada’s system is administered by the provinces. Such a system would be an order of magnitude larger than the systems of the United Kingdom, France, or Germany and two orders of magnitude larger than Switzerland’s. Size really does make a difference and my experience has been that size rarely results in greater efficiency.

But I think the notion of market-oriented reforms in health care is illusory as well. Can the problems with our health care system really be remediated with changes on the demand side alone? I’m skeptical. I think that changing the supply side of the health care equation is what’s really needed but that, apparently, is off the table.

1 comment

When Should an Industry Be Nationalized?

Bryce Covert calls for the entire credit bureau industry to be nationalized in an op-ed in the New York Times:

These private institutions hoover up our data, often without our knowledge and consent, and then sell it off to banks, landlords and even prospective employers. The companies rake in some $10 billion in revenue every year. They wield enormous power to ruin our lives — if not through a data breach, then through errors on our credit reports. One in four consumers has an error on his credit report that could affect his scores, yet it can be very difficult to correct the record.

Although they call themselves bureaus, there is nothing governmental about what these private companies do. We let them take on a role that can have outsize consequences. And the free market doesn’t work here, because none of us can refuse to be a part of this system and opt out if we don’t like how we’re being treated. There’s no legal right to ask Equifax to remove your data from its registries or to stop it from getting more in the future.

Why should we continue to allow private companies to make money from us while ignoring our needs? Let’s nationalize Equifax and the other two major credit reporting companies, Experian and TransUnion. We could follow other countries’ example and hand the duty of tracking our financial histories over to a public registry instead of a private profiteer.

I found Ms. Covert’s reasoning mostly incoherent. If revenue, influence on our lives, or a lack of accountability were justifications for nationalizing companies, it seems to me that Google, Facebook, and Apple would be prime candidates for nationalization. What large company wouldn’t satisfy the criteria Ms. Covert is applying?

I agree with her in one particular: I see no reason that we should subsidize the credit bureaus’ business model. There is a ready solution for that: strict liability. Under strict liability it wouldn’t be necessary to demonstrate wrongdoing, intentional harm, or recklessness for a lawsuit to succeed. All you’d need to do is be able to demonstrate injury.

In her zeal for expanding the role of government she does give us one thigh-slapper:

The United States government is, of course, not impervious to data breaches, nor does it have a perfect track record of fending them off. In 2015, it announced that hackers had stolen “sensitive information” on 21.5 million people. But the government is at least accountable to public pressure.

The civil bureaucracy is completely immune from public pressure and, as we have seen over the last eight months, is highly resistant to influence from elected officials. The surest way of making the problem intractable is to nationalize it.

The more you consider it the idea, the worse you realize it is. Credit bureaus’ primary customers are lenders. Any nationalization of credit bureaus would inevitably lead either to additional subsidies for banks, state capitalism at a level we’ve never seen it before, or both. Can anyone reasonably say “the problem with the United States is that we’re not subsidizing banks enough?”

I also see no way of enforcing a ban on collecting data. No, liability is the best recourse.

9 comments