Hollywood, Business As Usual

I don’t want to perseverate on this but there are a few things that need saying. I’ll put them in bullet point form.

  • Nearly all of the actresses who’ve come forward to complain about Harvey Weinstein are in their forties, some in their fifties. They have very little to lose by stepping forward.
  • A notable exception to that is Cara Delevigne who is 25, right in his preferred demographic for victims. Unless you believe that he took a 20 year hiatus, there are dozens, scores, or even hundreds of actresses or aspiring actresses ages 25-40 who haven’t come forward.
  • Everyone in the business knows about the prevalence of sexual harassment and abuse, not just of young actresses but also of young actors, many at first hand.
  • Unindicted co-conspirators include all of the biggest names in the business—Steven Spielberg, George Lucas, Ron Howard, Frank Marshall, the list goes on and on. None of them have anything whatever to lose. Every single one of them knows and elects to remain silent.
  • The Weinstein Co. hasn’t had a hit in two years. In Hollywood years, that’s a lifetime. Do you believe that the story would have come out if they had?

Maybe the dam is about to break but I’m skeptical. I think that after a momentary furor it will be back to business as usual in Hollywood.

Mamas, don’t let your babies grow up to be actors. Perhaps some day a hero will come along and divert a river through the stables but I doubt it. Hollywood is about illusions, about lying. We like our illusions.

1 comment

The California Fires

I don’t have a great deal to say about the fires raging, out of control, in Northern California. It’s a horrendous situation. They say that at least 17 people have lost their lives and at least 2,000 structures have been destroyed. Given the median home price of around $500,000 in the affected counties, expect the costs to run into the billions if not the tens of billions.

If this editorial at the Sacramento Bee is any gauge, expect the cost of living in California to get a lot higher soon.

6 comments

Pure Partisanship

The degree of partisanship in the country is increasing. That’s what Pew Research has found:

Over the past six years, the share of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents saying the government should do more to help the needy, even if it means going deeper into debt, has risen 17 percentage points (from 54% to 71%), while the views of Republicans and Republican leaners have barely changed (25% then, 24% today). However, Republicans’ opinions on this issue had shifted substantially between 2007 and 2011, with the share favoring more aid to the needy falling 20 points (from 45% to 25%).

The result: While there has been a consistent party gap since 1994 on government aid to the poor, the divisions have never been this large. In 2011, about twice as many Democrats as Republicans said the government should do more for the needy (54% vs. 25%). Today, nearly three times as many Democrats as Republicans say this (71% vs. 24%).

Basically, Republicans are becoming more Republican and Democrats more Democratic. The parties continue to change from the “catch all” parties they’ve always been to programmatic parties.

In terms of affiliation the two political parties are just about the same with 29% Republicans and 30% Democrats. 40% of Americans consider themselves neither Republicans nor Democrats.

I don’t believe this divergence can continue indefinitely. Either one party, the other, or both must stop their move away from the other party, there needs to be a new assertion of federalism, or fracture or violence are inevitable.

7 comments

It’s the Subsidies, Stupid

I read Eduardo Porter’s article in the New York Times, “Why Big Cities Thrive, and Smaller Ones Are Being Left Behind” with considerable skepticism:

To prove his point, Mr. Muro compared the 100 largest metropolitan areas in the country, those with populations above 550,000, with the 182 smallest, which have populations ranging from 80,000 to about 215,000. On average, the big ones got out of the recession faster than the small ones.

To get a sense of the future, he selected big and small metropolitan areas only in the 10 states most subjected to economic disruption — as defined by the penetration of automation and job displacement as a result of foreign trade — to tease out the effects of these transformative forces.

The difference in performance widened: Private employment grew almost twice as fast in large metropolitan areas as it did in small ones from the trough of the recession, in 2009, to 2015. Income grew 50 percent faster. And the labor participation rate — the share of the working-age population in the labor force — shrank only half as much.

“Economic transitions work against smaller America,” Mr. Muro told me. “This is a period demanding excruciating transitions.”

How, then, does he explain Pittsburg, Cleveland, Detroit, and Chicago? They are or at least were “big”. All are experiencing the same things he attributes to “small” cities.

IMO he’s looking at the wrong factors. Over the period of the last 15 years New York City has received repeated massive subsidies. The subsidies have taken the form of direct grants, regulations, and propping up its local industries (mostly banking and finance) and have been valued in the trillions of dollars. How would New York have fared if Citibank had been allowed to fail?

The industrial Midwest on the other hand has received an ongoing onslaught in the form of the managed trade agreements negotiated over the period of the last 40 years that have picked winners and losers. New York and Los Angeles have been winners. Chicago has been a loser.

That tells us nothing about the benefits of large or small, coastal or central, or much of anything else other than the value of political clout.

4 comments

The Real “Thucydides Trap”

The “Thucydides trap” refers to the notion that war between an established power and an up-and-coming power is inevitable. It derives from Thucydides’s ancient classic, The Peloponnesian War. I’ve been critical of the idea as it pertains to the inevitability of war between the United States and China but there’s a battle between an established power and an up-and-coming power that’s real and going on right now. It’s the battle in the retail space between Wal-Mart and Amazon. Investor’s Business Daily reports:

Wal-Mart, the largest retailer in the world, is showing that an elephant can dance. Besieged by Amazon’s online dominance and ability to deliver goods at super-low prices overnight, has responded to the challenge.

Unlike other brick-and-mortar retailers like JCPenney (JCP), Sears (SHLD) and other former stalwarts that themselves were never able to respond to Wal-Mart’s challenge 30 years ago, the Bentonville, Ark.-based discounting giant has moved aggressively into e-tailing.

Walmart said its e-commerce business is set to expand by 40% next year as it goes toe-to-toe with Amazon. It will boost its online grocery pickup sites by 100% or more in the coming year, while hiring an army of 2,000 “specialists” to keep on top if its burgeoning website.

Last year, Wal-Mart put up $3 billion for Jet.com, an online retailer whose “smart-cart” checkout technology has helped Wal-Mart boost its e-sales by 60%.

This is only part of the future that Wal-Mart is building. Soon, it hopes to keep families’ pantries stocked, just as Wal-Mart stocks its own shelves, using enhanced pickup and delivery and letting customers use their cellphones to do everything from returning goods to ordering.

The only question I have about this is which is the “established power” and which the challenger? It would seem obvious. Despite the hype over Amazon Wal-Mart does five times the amount of retail sales that Amazon does and its earnings on its retail sales are better. Amazon isn’t even among the top five retailers. However, until very recently nearly all of Wal-Mart’s sales were in its brick-and-mortar stores. The retail behemoth is going toe-to-toe with Amazon on its own turf. It’s certainly acting like a challenger.

Don’t count Wal-Mart out.

1 comment

The Micawber Economy

In David Copperfield Charles Dickens’s character Mr. Micawber said

Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen [pounds] nineteen [shillings] and six [pence], result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.

160 years later that’s still the case.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal observe about taxes and the federal deficit:

Spending rose only 3% overall for the year, according to the CBO gnomes. Federal outlays climbed by some $130 billion to $3.982 trillion. Three percent is probably more than most of our readers received in raises, but by federal standards it’s penurious. Some of the big outlays were, as ever, for the three giant entitlements—3% for Social Security, 4% for Medicare, and 2% for Medicaid as the pace of new enrollments slowed under the Affordable Care Act.

The biggest single spending increase was 45% for education thanks to an upward revision of $39 billion in the “estimated net subsidy costs of loans and loan guarantees issued in prior years.” In plainer English, the Obama Administration low-balled the costs of nationalizing student loans. Tens of thousands of borrowers are defaulting on their student debt, and the taxpayer tab is coming due.

Our problem is that national income is rising at less than 2% per year while federal spending is rising at 3% per year. It doesn’t take a lot of math to tell you that’s a problem. There are only a handful of strategies for coping with the matter:

  • We can just issue ourselves credit, i.e. we’ll “borrow”. That’s what we’ll do. That will continue a positive feedback loop reducing economic growth.
  • Extract more income from the private sector. That will reduce private sector economic growth.
  • Cut spending. As you can see when constraining the increase in spending to just a little more than twice the increase in income is considered a great triumph, that’s difficult to do, particularly as we place increased demands on the federal government. How do you cut defense spending when you’re fighting a half dozen different wars and preparing to fight more?

In optimization theory you optimize a process by focusing on the segments of the process where there’s the most to optimize. Health care spending is growing faster than any other budget component. If the Obama Administration had focused, as President Clinton used to say “like a laser beam”, on constraining health care spending, there might have been a chance of controlling federal spending. It elected to increase health care insurance coverage instead.

Increasing marginal tax rates, extremely unlikely when Republicans control the Congress and the White House, won’t necessarily remedy the problem. For that you need to increase the effective tax rates and those have proven even more resistant to increase than the nominal rates.

So we’ll continue to issue ourselves credit, hoping that there isn’t a flight from the dollar, and reduce our potential for economic growth, wage growth, and employment.

Result misery.

6 comments

My Dad’s Birthday, 2017

My dad was born on October 10, 1914 at 14th & Clark in St. Louis in the apartment above the saloon his family owned. As an adult he was tall and a bit pudgy in a way I’ve never been. His hair was always unruly; his clothes nearly always wrinkled.

He wore two shirts a day and shaved twice a day. He had a piercing, intense gaze, a keen intellect, and a good sense of humor. He loved to travel, loved exotic cuisines, worked harder than anyone else I’ve ever known, and was scrupulously honest. He loved to debate and encouraged it in his children. He spoke German as fluently as a native—learned at school, not at home.

He died rather suddenly at too-young an age. I’ve never gotten over it and I don’t think my siblings, all younger than I, have either.

2 comments

Truth-Telling

In reaction to the unfolding scandal of sexual harassment and abuse surrounding Hollywood mogul Harvey Weinstein and the company that bears his name, former Weinstein Co. employee Jessica Forsythe writes at RealClearMarkets:

I worked for Harvey Weinstein and it’s everything you can imagine, sans any of the presumed glamour. Curse words fly at and around you constantly, threats and bullying are the prized management modus operandi. The turnover is ridiculous and the office environment is as toxic as they come. The strategy for many employees is to throw a blow-out party at the six-month mark to numb themselves for the following six. Once that year lands on their resume, they leave skid marks a la Wile E. Coyote all the way out of Tribeca. I’m sure a special form of cancer is going to come out of 99 Hudson Street specific to the type of stress born there.

The odd thing is, no one makes any money working for Harvey Weinstein. He pays peanuts and pennies to some of the hardest workers in the United States. The whole outfit is run like a cheap insurance agency in outer Queens.

I hope none of this comes as a surprise to anyone but I’m afraid it might. I’ve known that this was what show business was like since I was a child. It has been true for a century and it may be true a century from now.

Sadly, I think that Ms. Forsythe is kidding herself. There will always be “new thing” young starlets hungry for fame and willing to sell their souls not to mention their bodies for it. I trust that the same is true for young male performers as well these days. We aren’t hearing complaints from them. Only from actresses nearing the ends of their Hollywood careers.

13 comments

Caution

I’m preparing to commit political science. The political scientists won’t do it so I’m leaping into the fray. I’m doing an analysis of Illinois’s highly gerrymandered Congressional districts, providing measurements of just how gerrymandered they are, and examining the objectives of gerrymandering for each district.

Those of my readers who are Illinois residents or who otherwise have knowledge of Illinois’s Congressional districts, please contribute your observations in the comments of this post so I can incorporate them in my final results.

6 comments

What Else Would You Expect?

While in his Washington Post column Robert Samuelson laments the sorry state of the U. S. economy:

The spoils society advances.

The “spoils society” is a phrase I coined some years ago to illustrate a basic problem of wealthy societies, including, of course, the United States. After all, our annual gross domestic product is approaching $20 trillion. The problem is that, as societies become richer, so does the temptation for people to advance their economic interests by grabbing someone else’s wealth, as opposed to creating wealth.

We see the resulting redistributive struggles all the time. They’re part of the social fabric: divorcing couples fighting over the marital assets; Congress debating who should — or shouldn’t — get tax cuts or subsidies (say, Social Security); lawyers launching “class action” suits to remedy alleged wrongs; patent “trolls” suing tech companies over possible infringement issues.

What else would you expect? Considerably more money can be made via rent-seeking at lower risk than via entrepeneurship. That’s why the money spent on lobbying is so high. The return on investment is great and it’s an arena in which only the big boys may play. Just as a single example, IMO the balance sheets of pharmaceutical companies more resemble lobbying organizations that do a little research on the side than research organizations that do some lobbying.

Also, we graduate twice as many MBAs annually as we do undergraduate engineers and vastly more than we do individuals with advanced engineering degrees. That points to the rewards of manipulating the financial economy compared to the rewards of making things and creating processes.

But notice the symmetry between Mr. Samuelson’s column and the other two articles to which I’ve linked today. Mr. Ryu and Dr. Summers are arguing in favor of the status quo, the “spoils society” that Mr. Samuelson is complaining about.

11 comments