The Politics of Health Care Spending

You might be amused, informed, or depressed by this post at Pro-Market on how politics drives the cost of health care in the United States:

Americans spend significantly more on health care than any other country. Why? Economists’ answers to this question (of which there are many) range from opaque pricing to hospital monopolies to “creeping consolidation” to pharmacy benefit managers to medical licensing to Medicare being unable to negotiate drug prices to abusive IP practices by pharmaceutical firms.

Politics is another, seemingly obvious factor. The federal government is responsible for nearly a third of all health care spending, and the health care industry is the biggest spender of lobbying dollars in Washington: as health spending ballooned from $1 trillion in 1996 to $3.4 trillion in 2016, the industry—led by pharmaceutical firms and hospitals—spent nearly $7 billion on lobbying legislators. And as any person who follows the news even a little can tell, health care is one of the most heavily politicized policy issues in the United States today. Thanks to its complicated and impenetrable nature, the American health care system is also replete with so-called pork barrel projects, meant to appease hesitant legislators by providing money or jobs to their districts, thus potentially aiding in their reelection.

Who benefits from the extraordinary degree of politicization of our health care system? Not patients.

What would a less politicized health care system look like? Beats the heck out of me. It’s tempting to suggest that it would be much more centralized, more consolidated but I suspect that such a system would just be politicized in a different way.

3 comments

Captive

At Atlantic Annie Lowrey reviews a book that adds a new culprit to the list of factors reducing growth and increasing income inequality which already includes trade policy, automation, globalization, immigration, and education—regulatory capture:

In their excellent, slim new book, Brink Lindsey and Steven Teles—the former the director of the Open Society Project at the libertarian think tank the Niskanen Center, the latter a political scientist at Johns Hopkins—point to an important and overlooked additional cause. In The Captured Economy: How the Powerful Become Richer, Slow Down Growth, and Increase Inequality, they argue that it is not just that technology and offshoring have wiped away middle-income jobs, but that high-income individuals and big-profit businesses have rewritten the rules of the economy, “capturing” the regulatory system and using it to squeeze out their competition. The result is both greater inequality, and a more sclerotic economy.

What are the consequences of this distortion of the economy?

The result of all this “capture,” they write, is an overpaid white-collar professional class, a bloated financial sector, a lack of affordable housing, the growth of fewer and bigger companies, and a dearth of new startups.

The mechanisms identified by which this operates include zoning, licensing, intellectual property law, and the subsidization of Big Finance. The only key words that I thought were missing in the review were “deadweight loss”.

Anyone who’s ever run a business knows just how true this is and most of these laws and regulations are at the state and local level where they’re nicely ignored.

This review neatly summarizes the things I’ve been writing about here for the last 15 years. If we want a supple, vibrant economy that creates many more new businesses and many more jobs, paving the way for the economy of the future, these are the areas where reform is most needed. The enemies of that future, the beneficiaries of the present system, will fight doggedly to preserve their prerogatives and they hold most of the cards. Not to mention most of the money.

2 comments

The Shoeshine Boy Test

I’m reminded of a 90 year old story. Joe Kennedy, famously rich in the days just before the 1929 stock market crash, is said to have gotten out of the market when his shoeshine boy started giving him stock tips.

Today I’ve seen at least a dozen posts on Bitcoin and I haven’t even been looking for them. If it’s not in bubble stage yet, that’s not far away.

Maybe it means something, maybe it doesn’t. Broadbased economic declines sometimes have the least likely looking beginnings.

7 comments

Pay for the Military We Need

I’m not even going to bother to link to Robert Samuelson’s Washington Post column this morning. He thinks we should be spending a lot more money on our military.

Rather than spending a lot more on our military why not just right-size it? Pay for the military we need to defend the country, not for the military we need to knock down every dictator we don’t like. Or prop up regimes that are inherently unstable and hate us anyway. Our interventions in Iraq, Yemen, and Libya have been disasters. No, we haven’t lost thousands of American lives in Libya or Yemen but that’s not the only yardstick. Thousands of Yemenis and Libyans have died and it hasn’t made us a bit more secure.

5 comments

Can It Happen Here?

There’s a post at The Diplomat on caste discrimination in the United Kingdom that I found informative and distressing:

“One is of the opinion that you leave behind all the trappings of the caste system once you leave India, but perhaps I was naive.”

Saunvedan Aparanti, an Indian student studying in London, has found himself at the center of a heated campaign to introduce caste discrimination legislation in the United Kingdom. Having moved to Britain for university, Aparanti was surprised to find himself at the receiving end of “caste supremacy” from his new flatmates. The caste system he speaks of — and its trappings — is one that the world has, unfortunately, become familiar with. Stories relating to caste violence frequently emerge from some South Asian countries, particularly India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Nepal. Headlines featuring the rape and murder of so-called “lower caste” people, or Dalits, are no longer rare.

I certainly hope that this problem isn’t being brought here. I’ve never seen it but I doubt I would even recognize it or know that it was going on. We have enough problems as it is without importing more.

However, as I’ve pointed out before, immigrants tend to bring their social and political ideas with them. That’s why New York and Chicago have machine politics and why 19th century progressivism became a political force in the Upper Midwest. We presently have as many immigrants as a percentage of the population as at any time in our history. It would be amazing if we weren’t importing entirely new social and political issues right along with them.

2 comments

Backing the Wrong Horse

An op-ed in the LA Times from Max Abrahms and John Glaser points out how wrong U. S. pundits left and right were about Syria and DAESH. Here’s the kernel of the op-ed:

The notion that Assad “won’t fight” Islamic State was always wrong. The notion that “defeating Islamic State also requires defeating Bashar Assad” was, likewise, always wrong. By now it should be obvious that the Syrian Arab Army has played a role in degrading Islamic State in Syria — not alone, of course, but with Russian and Iranian partners, not to mention the impressive U.S.-led coalition. In marked contrast to pundit expectations, the group’s demise was inversely related to Assad’s power. Islamic State’s fortunes decreased as his influence in the country increased.

Equally contrary to analyst predictions, the group imploded right after external support for the “moderate” rebels dried up. The weakening of the rebels was a major setback for Islamic State because Assad could finally focus his firepower on the group. Fewer weapon shipments into the theater, moreover, meant fewer arms fell into the hands of Salafi jihadists.

which, if you will recall, is what I’ve been saying all along.

I don’t think that Assad is a good guy. The issue is one of priorities and IMO stability in Syria was a higher priority than ousting Assad. Additionally, under no circumstance should we support violent radical Islamists and that’s exactly what we were doing.

The question is why were we doing what we did? I don’t agree with Pat Lang that we were just doing the Israelis’ bidding. It’s possible that we were doing the Saudis’ bidding. Neither of those is a good course of action.

The most benign explanation is that we are naive and were trying to do the right thing. I hope that’s the case.

1 comment

The Richest Cities

John Cochrane has a very good post explaining why the cities that are prospering the most haven’t grown in population:

Lots of people in a democracy vote their interest, despite their professed ideology. There is plenty of hypocrisy on all sides. People of achingly progressive sensibilities vote for housing policies that keep the unwashed out, drive up long commutes, carbon emissions, and inequality. My neighborhood is full of these charming signs:

(the sign, in graphic form, reads “No matter where you are from, we’re glad you’re our neighbor.”)

If I were not polite, I would add a sticker that says, “as long as you have the $3 million bucks it takes to live here. If not, get out.” (Many of the same houses also have signs protesting a local school expansion, which might, well, attract people.)

This is in stark contrast with the boomtowns of the 19th century. When the economy was booming, the cities grew, too.

The converse, however, is not true. Cities that aren’t prospering are shrinking.

Today the cities that are growing are not those where wages are rising rapidly. They are those that allow growth.

2 comments

The Origin of the Species

I’ve read a number of articles today about the new paleontological findings in Asia and Australia and what they mean for theories of the origin of the human species. I have a few observations.

First, we have a very great need for a new, rigorous definition of “species”. The conventional definition of species is that members of the same species may interbreed and produce fertile offspring.

Using that definition the statement that modern humans (Homo sapiens sapiens) have some percentage of Neanderthal or Denisovan DNA is gibberish unless Neanderthals and Denisovans aren’t different species from ours at all but members of different subspecies of the same species. In other words Homo sapiens neanderthalensis not Homo neanderthalensis.

This stuff is all pretty controversial because of its bad history. Its discussion was first broached more than a century ago by a bunch of German racists desperate to prove the primacy of white Europeans. I don’t believe that at all but it makes just touching on the subject hard.

The most recent results have cast some doubt on the notion that modern humans originated in sub-Saharan Africa. The problem: the oldest fossil remains of modern humans aren’t from sub-Saharan Africa at all but from Morocco.

My opinion for more than 50 years has been that

  1. Our genus Homo originated in sub-Saharan Africa.
  2. Its possible that there are no species other than ours in the genus.
  3. Neanderthal, erectus (Peking Man, Java Man), and other variants are all members of the same species as we are.
  4. Our species is a lot older than has been thought.
  5. While it might have originated in sub-Saharan Africa, Asia is actually just as good a candidate.

so I’m pretty gratified with the recent findings since they tend to confirm what I’ve been saying all along.

Now if only some evidence confirming my views on language families is found…

5 comments

A Second American Civil War?

I agree with Omar El Akkad’s concern about the possibility of a second American Civil War, expressed in his op-ed in the Globe and Mail but there’s a lot to disagree with in the piece as well, beginning with this statement in the caption, presumably from the editors:

Barack Obama’s presidency was supposed to mark a great leap forward for the United States. But, as Omar El Akkad discovered as he travelled across America this year, the election of Donald J. Trump has turned the country against itself.

Barack Obama’s election to the presidency demonstrated that the United States had changed since the 1950s, a great improvement. The manner in which Mr. Obama’a term of office unfolded demonstrated little or no respect for a majority of the country. Congressional Democrats and President Obama were not forced into that position. They chose it and blamed it on their political opponents, transparently abetted by a servile press.

Or this from Mr. El Akkad himself:

For the past four years, I have lived in America, but America does not belong to me. Here, I am part of a minority that constitutes the majority of the world: I am a person of colour. I am an immigrant in a country that purports to be a melting pot but is in reality a crucible, a vessel of fierce and fiercely luminous burning.

There’s so much wrong with that paragraph it’s hard to know where to start. First, “melting pot” and “crucible” are synonyms. He’s trying to draw a contrast where none exists.

Second, that “America does not belong to me” is at it should be. If I were to visit Egypt or Qatar, they would not “belong to me”. Becoming an American means adopting certain beliefs. As Chesterton put it America is a country founded on a creed. I do not find a single piece of evidence in the piece that Mr. has adopted the beliefs that at least used to be commonplace among Americans, at least aspirationally. These beliefs include self-reliance, believing that “sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me”, and that individual conduct matters more than group identity.

Perhaps being an American is obsolete. Perhaps the country belongs to no one any more.

He seems to find protest a troubling sign. That’s a misconception shared by many non-Americans. Self-criticism, including vehement self-criticism, has been distinctive of the United States for the last two hundred years, something practically unique in the world. It’s not a sign of weakness but rather a sign of strength.

My concerns about the United States are different from Mr. Akkad’s. What I see is a loss of confidence in our country’s virtue, a desire to punish the United States, a thirst for riches rather than a love of freedom, and a longing need for an aristocracy rather than self-reliance. There are just too many people who want too many different, conflicting things.

30 comments

Malice

Glenn Greenwald remarks on the latest self-immolation by the major news outlets:

FRIDAY WAS ONE of the most embarrassing days for the U.S. media in quite a long time. The humiliation orgy was kicked off by CNN, with MSNBC and CBS close behind, with countless pundits, commentators and operatives joining the party throughout the day. By the end of the day, it was clear that several of the nation’s largest and most influential news outlets had spread an explosive but completely false news story to millions of people, while refusing to provide any explanation of how it happened.

The spectacle began on Friday morning at 11:00 am EST, when the Most Trusted Name in News™ spent 12 straight minutes on air flamboyantly hyping an exclusive bombshell report that seemed to prove that WikiLeaks, last September, had secretly offered the Trump campaign, even Donald Trump himself, special access to the DNC emails before they were published on the internet. As CNN sees the world, this would prove collusion between the Trump family and WikiLeaks and, more importantly, between Trump and Russia, since the U.S. intelligence community regards WikiLeaks as an “arm of Russian intelligence,” and therefore, so does the U.S. media.

This entire revelation was based on an email which CNN strongly implied it had exclusively obtained and had in its possession. The email was sent by someone named “Michael J. Erickson” – someone nobody had heard of previously and whom CNN could not identify – to Donald Trump, Jr., offering a decryption key and access to DNC emails that WikiLeaks had “uploaded.” The email was a smoking gun, in CNN’s extremely excited mind, because it was dated September 4 – ten days before WikiLeaks began promoting access to those emails online – and thus proved that the Trump family was being offered special, unique access to the DNC archive: likely by WikiLeaks and the Kremlin.

It’s impossible to convey with words what a spectacularly devastating scoop CNN believed it had, so it’s necessary to watch it for yourself to see the tone of excitement, breathlessness and gravity the network conveyed as they clearly believed they were delivering a near-fatal blow on the Trump/Russia collusion story…

There was just one small problem with this story: it was fundamentally false, in the most embarrassing way possible. Hours after CNN broadcast its story – and then hyped it over and over and over – the Washington Post reported that CNN got the key fact of the story wrong.

Read the whole thing.

There’s a simple explanation for such. CNN and other major media outlets’ hatred for Trump is such that they aren’t even bothering to verify stories through reliable sources any more and are publishing them as facts. They are playing a very dangerous game. That is practically the definition of malice under the law.

The Trump Administration is a target-rich environment. Why publish stories from anonymous or all but anonymous sources? We need a solid, professional, fair, unbiased news media. Unfortunately, that isn’t the one we have.

23 comments