Rule by 50%+1

I think the editors of the Wall Street Journal are asking the wrong question in considering the completely partisan nature of the tax reform bill making its way through Congress:

Part of the explanation is ideological. The Democrats as a party moved sharply left during the Obama years—on economics nearly as much as on identity politics. They have made income inequality their main economic priority rather than growth, and the fact that the slow-growing Obama economy increased inequality hasn’t changed that obsession.

One result is that there isn’t a pro-business Democrat left in the Senate, except perhaps on energy policy in fossil-fuel states like West Virginia and North Dakota. Democrats are now the party of Thomas Piketty, the French economist who thinks tax rates should return to pre-Kennedy levels to reduce inequality.

Democratic economists who might have offered an alternative view have no choice but to go along if they ever want to serve in another Democratic administration. They all saw what Elizabeth Warren and the Democratic left did to block Larry Summers from getting the job of Federal Reserve Chairman.

The other explanation is the political calculation that opposition will help Democrats retake the House and Senate in the 2018 midterm elections. President Trump is unpopular, and they figure his polarizing behavior will drive enough Democrats in the polls to save Senate incumbents even in states that Mr. Trump carried in 2016. Heidi Heitkamp (North Dakota), Joe Donnelly (Indiana) and Claire McCaskill (Missouri) figure that the safer play is to oppose all things Trump and mobilize the base vote.

Perhaps they should be asking what sort of tax reform would garner Democratic support? They appear to be assuming that Democrats would oppose any tax reform on partisan grounds. That closely parallels the situation with the Affordable Care Act.

Our government isn’t supposed to work this way. Congress is supposed to forge consensus, build coalitions, and make compromises. Government by 50%+1 of both houses of the Congress may be comforting for the winners but it also consolidates and embitters opposition. It’s no way to govern a country as large and diverse as the United States.

15 comments

Modern Totalitarians

Today’s editorial from the Washington Post on China’s technological surveillance state has one serious deficiency:

STEP BY STEP, China has been rolling out surveillance technology that is remarkably intrusive, comprehensive and ubiquitous. Eager to exploit gains in technology, Beijing seems little concerned about human rights or privacy violations.

On Dec. 10, the BBC reported that China seeks to build the world’s largest camera surveillance network, with 170 million closed-circuit cameras installed and an estimated 400 million new ones coming in the next three years. In the city of Guiyang in southwest China, correspondent John Sudworth agreed to add a photograph of his face to the database of the local public security bureau and have it flagged as a “suspect” in an experiment to see how long he could walk freely on the streets before the police could find him. He got out of his car close to the city center and walked toward a bus station. The exercise took just seven minutes.

Meanwhile, Human Rights Watch reported on Dec. 13 that Chinese authorities have been collecting DNA samples, blood types, fingerprints and iris scans, in some cases possibly without informing people, from a large swath of the population in the restive Xinjiang province in far northwestern China. Ethnic Uighurs in Xinjiang have long complained about repression and discrimination at the hands of the Chinese government; resentment has sometimes turned violent. According to Human Rights Watch, in a procedure rolled out this year, the authorities there are collecting the DNA and blood-type information under the cover of a “free annual physical exams program called Physicals for All.”

It is completely lacking in practical recommendations. What the evidence suggests is that the Chinese authorities would like to be totalitarians but don’t want to appear to want to be totalitarians.

In my view the Chinese people are entitled to have any sort of society they care to have and we’re entitled both to disapprove of it and to not have anything to do with them, taking the additional step of penalizing companies that assist the Chinese authorities in their plans.

We should also be asking whether our own government is seeking the same kind of intelligence on us? How about American companies? Do we really want that? Whose data is it, anyway?

6 comments

The Choice

There’s an interesting post at Quillette on how anthropologists came to romanticize hunter-gather societies:

The picture you get from reading articles in publications like the New Yorker and the Guardian, or from anthropologists like Douglas Fry and James Suzman, is often quite different from what a deep dive into the ethnographic record reveals. The excessive reliance on a single paper published 50 years ago has contributed to some severe misconceptions about hunter-gatherer ‘affluence,’ and their relative freedom from scarcity and disease. There is a tendency to downplay the benefits of modern medicine, institutions, and infrastructure – as well as the very real costs of not having access to them – in these discussions. And, despite what some may wish to believe, the hunter-gatherer way of life is not a solution to the social problems found in modern nation states.

The gist of it is that the human species has not been engaged in a 10,000 year old mistake. The lives of hunter-gathers tended to be, in Hobbes’s memorable phrase, “nasty, brutish, and short”. The only way in which hunter-gatherer societies could be construed as preferable to a sedentary habit is if you preferred for your children to die in infancy, you’d like to die of old age in your 20s, and you didn’t mind being always watchful for your neighbor trying to murder you.

The practice of a sedentary habit and agriculture was better than being a nomadic hunter-gatherer and industrialization was better than an almost entirely agrarian society. For the last 10,000 years people have successively chosen the better alternative, the one that led to longer, healthier, less precarious lives. Will post-industrialism prove to be better than industrialism? We can only guess.

9 comments

10 Most Significant World Events of 2017

It’s a big time of year for “top ten” lists. At RealClearDefense James M. Lindsay presents the Council on Foreign Relations’s list of ten most significant world events:

  1. Robert Mugabe’s Ouster
  2. Britain Triggers Article 50 (official beginning of divorce from EU)
  3. The Rohingya Crisis
  4. The Fall of Mosul
  5. Mohammad bin Salman Remakes Saudi Arabia
  6. Global Growth Picks Up
  7. The Globe Continues to Warm
  8. North Korea Defies the World
  9. Xi Jinping’s “Extraordinary Elevation
  10. Donald Trump Champions America First

Is he right? Wrong? Is there something that he’s missed?

I note that Time’s “Most Important…” is conspicuously missing from that list. And not a word about Meghan Markle.

7 comments

Statistics to Conjure With

I found these statistics in Stephen Moore’s Wall Street Journal op-ed on the future of retail startling:

By his estimate, the U.S. has at least 50% more retail space per person than Canada—and Canada’s figure is 50% higher than Germany’s. “It’s Germany that has it about right,” he concludes—which would mean the optimal amount of retail space is less than half the current American total. “I’ve traveled all over the country,” Mr. Freeman says. “The challenge is to find a place where retail isn’t overbuilt.” If he’s right, a severe real-estate contraction is coming, and weak stores and malls will get eaten alive. Can Macy’s survive? Probably not: “They are run by bean counters”—lawyers and accountants, not entrepreneurs.

There are some things in the op-ed that I agree with, for example this:

Somewhat counterintuitively, he argues that e-commerce is “not our enemy” but is becoming complementary to retail. Here’s his challenge to anyone who thinks digital sales are set to crush the old analog kind: “Explain Blue Nile. They were one of the first to sell online jewelry. Blue Nile comes in and blows the door off as one of our most successful stores. Who else? Apple! You can buy your phone online, and they can ship it to your house. But the Apple Store almost everywhere does giant business. Microsoft—same thing. Peloton is another one. They make exercise equipment and have just opened a store next to Nordstrom, highest sales in the country. They’re killin’ it.”

With a twinkle in his eyes, he tells the story of Bellevue Square’s 1,800-square-foot Tesla showroom. Tesla is largely an internet-based company, but it helped produce one of the biggest days in the mall’s history when Mr. Freeman says it sold close to $16 million worth of cars in 12 hours. “There were lines 10 blocks long, and the average person waited five hours,” he recalls, “the way people used to wait outside stores on Black Friday. There was even a sign in front of the store that read ‘limit of two cars per customer.’ ”

If that isn’t enough, he adds: “Guess what’s one of our most successful stores we just opened up three months ago? Amazon. They already mastered online book sales. Why are they creating a physical presence? Because they know they need to connect and fuse with you as a consumer.” That’s what he means by emotional fulfillment.

However, I don’t agree with one thing the op-ed claims. I don’t think it’s the “age of Amazon”. In fact I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if Amazon announced its intention of getting out of retail in five years. It isn’t making money in retail. It is in web services. Amazon’s stock has exploded in the last two years. How long can the company maintain that pace? Will its investors accept a company whose stock price doesn’t increase, that doesn’t show profits, and that doesn’t pay dividends?

I think we’re in the age of Walmart and Walmart will be the ultimate victor in the online retail space.

However, back to those statistics. Can the United States really prosper on the basic of personal consumption expenditures? Or, as I believe, do we really need to rebalance our economy in favor of business investment? Businesses used to invest a lot more with a lot less sales than they do now. The change is not due to phlegmatic personal consumption. It’s due to a decline in entrepeneurship among American managers.

6 comments

Parkinson’s Other Law

Many people are aware of Parkinson’s Law: work expands to fill the time allotted to its completion. Not as many are aware of C. Northcote Parkinson’s other law: once any large organization has completed its grand new headquarters, it marks the peak of its influence and power. It’s all downhill from there. That’s what I think of when anybody mentions Apple Park, as Rob Pegoraro does in his Washington Post op-ed:

Apple Park certainly sounds like a pleasant place to work, if not to have worked on. Journalists who have visited it — I haven’t — have said as much.

But if the company wanted to craft a target for resentment among its loyal customers, it could not have done much better than to put this circle of glass and metal on the map.

At his talk in Washington, Ive made a case that by putting designers across multiple disciplines in the same space, Apple Park will yield better products down the line. (Possibly years down the line: The Apple Watch, designed with zero input from Steve Jobs, shipped almost three years after Jobs’s death in October 2011.)

“I can’t imagine another time in the future where we get to try and make something that is for us,” he said. “Not to be indulgent in a sort of ghastly, selfish way; we made it for us, to try to help us do better.”

But the Apple customers of today can’t caress Apple Park’s wood paneling, stride uninterrupted through its threshold-free doorways or treat themselves to a non-soggy pizza at one of its desks courtesy of that patented pizza box.

Maybe Apple’s management will prove me wrong and Apple’s mystique isn’t synonymous with Steve Jobs. Nothing the company is doing has persuaded me otherwise.

1 comment

Prediction

Actually, predictions. The tax bill will be enacted and signed into law. It won’t be as good as the Republicans and the Trump Administration have been claiming and it won’t be as bad as the Democrats have complained it is.

The entire incident is remarkably similar to the Affordable Care Act. A major policy will be enacted under strictly partisan lines. It addresses a problem in serious need of attention. A flawed bill is enacted but it’s one that can be claimed accomplishes the task, in this case tax reform. It doesn’t accomplish the reform we really need. It isn’t as good as its proponents claim or as bad as its opponents do. It will be a political football for years to come.

10 comments

What Actually Doesn’t Work

While I realize that every post can’t be about everything, I don’t think it’s too much to ask for an article titled “What Will ‘Actually Solve’ Terrorism Problem?”, like this one at Breaking Defense by James Kitfield to present some proposals for actually solving the terrorism problem. Instead it lists a few things that don’t work including torture and decapitation strikes. To those I would add overthrowing the governments of countries that are probable homes for terrorist groups and losing track of immigrants from those countries when they’re in the United States.

I don’t honestly know what would work. The only things I can think of are mass exterminations and bottling the populations of countries producing terrorist groups up until the fever passes. I reject the former as immoral and consider the latter a much more humane solution. It wouldn’t solve the problems of the countries being bottled up but it would solve ours. That appears to be more than Americans or at least American elites will stomach so I guess we’re stuck with terrorism for the foreseeable future.

6 comments

Mexico’s Future

At the Center for Strategic & International Studies Richard Miles underscores what I’ve been saying for some time and summarizes it succinctly in his opening paragraph:

Lower birth rates and freer markets have led to a sustained drop in Mexicans moving north to find work, developments that will reshape the immigration debate in the United States. Meanwhile, the passage of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 1994, combined with Mexico’s entry the same year into the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) has transformed its economy and slowly made its citizens better off. By 2055, Mexico will be smaller, wealthier, and with citizens less prone to leave their country. These fundamental trends may be thwarted by changes of government policies in the United States and Mexico, but they are unlikely to stop for the remainder of the twenty-first century.

and the graph at the top of the page illustrates the demographic forces that will promote those changes. It also explains why I’m not particularly worried about Mexican immigration.

I am, however, concerned about the rule of law and business models that assume a continuing supply of low-level workers. The studies most cited to demonstrate that Mexicans-Americans do eventually assimilate also found that assimilation is taking much longer than previous cohorts of immigrants.

The next cohort of immigrants will present new and more difficult problems. Look to the Somalis for a vision of things to come. As a community their unemployment rate is still a multiple of the general unemployment rate. Compare that with the unemployment rate of the Mexican immigrants. There are costs that are not worth bearing just so that somebody can say “Do you want fries with that?” in strongly accented English.

One factor not mentioned in the piece: when a significant fraction of the emigrants are women of child-bearing age, it tends to depress the birth rate. Expect Mexico to want to keep its young people at home in the coming years.

3 comments

Disney and Fox

I really don’t have a great deal to say about the proposed Disney and Fox merger other than to express my opinion that we should be breaking up horizontally integrated monopolies rather than creating them.

I also think that the cost of the deformation of copyright law that Disney bought and paid for back in 1999 should be that the company should be barred from the distribution business entirely. Under the Constitution copyrights must be for limited terms and if you can extend a copyright after the fact there’s no barrier to their terms being unlimited.

7 comments