British Traditions and American Engineering

I read one of my all-time favorite wisecracks in a newspaper op-ed by a Canadian writer many years ago. The author lamented “We could have had it all—British traditions, French cuisine, and American engineering. We ended up with American traditions, French engineering, and British cuisine.” It was in that context that I read this piece by Sir Roger Scruton at the Library of Law and Liberty, “Tradition, Culture, and Citizenship”:

The concepts of tradition, culture, and citizenship have this in common – they are summoned to protect our political inheritance against the disintegrative forces to which it is now exposed. They are tenuous, fragile, subject to many interpretations, and bend or break when we place too much weight on them. But they are among the important assets we have, when it comes to opposing the view of society as simply a power struggle between groups, who have no other end than to gain the ascendancy over their rivals. That view of society, as a power struggle, whose aim is domination or the escape from it, has been an intellectual commonplace from Marx to Foucault and beyond. Its falsehood is best displayed by examining the three concepts that form the topic of this article.

He goes on to distinguish between what he calls “shallow traditions” on the one hand and “deep traditions” on the other. “Shallow traditions” are things like Christmas trees, highland dress (if you’re English), and ceremonies of lessons and carols at Christmastime. “Deep traditions” include the common law, belief in individual responsibility, and citizenship (defined as the “active participation in the business of government”). I would include the English language itself among deep traditions.

I had two reactions to the essay. First, I think that, like many Brits, Sir Roger underestimates the tremendous differences between England and the United States. The second was G. K. Chesterton’s observation that America is a country founded on a creed. I’m less optimistic than Sir Roger is that when the creed itself is rejected that there can be anything left to recover.

7 comments

Why Is a Raven Like a Writing Desk?

I have a considerable amount of sympathy with the views expressed by Greg Kaufmann in his post at Talk Poverty criticizing the incipient tax reform:

It doesn’t seem to matter that our antipoverty programs cut poverty in half—that poverty would have been as high as nearly 30 percent in recent years without them; or that girls who had access to food stamps (SNAP) saw increases in their economic self-sufficiency as adults—including less welfare participation—compared to their disadvantaged peers who didn’t have access; or that a little assistance for children up to age 5 is associated with boosted educational performance, and increased work and earnings as adults; or that children under 13 who were able to use a housing voucher to move to a low-poverty neighborhood were 32 percent more likely to attend college and earned 31 percent more annually as young adults, compared to their peers in families that didn’t receive a voucher. Or even that expansion of Medicaid eligibility has reduced infant mortality and childhood deaths, and that children eligible for Medicaid are more likely to go on to graduate college.

I think that the U. S. needs a “safety net”, as it’s called and I think that most Americans would agree. The areas of dispute are how extensive that safety net should be and how we can pay for it. If you define “safety net” as just the six major means-tested public assistance programs (Medicaid, SNAP, housing assistance, SSI, TANF, and general assistance), about 20% of Americans receive benefits from one or more of them. To some, presumably including Mr. Kaufmann, that isn’t nearly enough. To some it is far too many.

If you extend the notion of “safety net” to what are referred to as “entitlements”, another 20% of Americans receive benefits from just two of them, Medicare and SSRI, for a total of something like 40%.

Is there any practical way to reduce the amount of money being spent on these programs without reducing what we’re paying for health care? If there is, I don’t see it.

Rather than dwelling on the things about which we disagree, let’s try to forge some agreement. The extent of government benefits and how much we should be spending on them seems like a pretty good place to start.

7 comments

Will, Hoffer, and the Escalation of Outrage

Geoge Will’s column today contains the best sentence he’s written in years:

Most of the nonstop noise emanating from the White House is white noise — audible wallpaper, there but unnoticed.

He goes on to consider the overheated remarks about the tax reform bill making its way through the Congress:

The 1986 tax reform radically simplified the tax code. Since then, the code has acquired more than 15,000 new wrinkles. The 2017 tax legislation might — this is difficult to measure — have managed the minor miracle of making the 70,000-page code more complicated. On a scale of importance from one (negligible) to 10 (stupendous), the legislation might be a three. Never mind. Cue the Cassandras. This tax cut of less than 1 percent of the next decade’s projected GDP is “the worst bill in the history of the United States Congress” (House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi). It “will result in 10,000 extra deaths per year” and “our country will be living on a shoestring for decades” ( former treasury secretary Lawrence H. Summers).

which is precisely why I’m confident that the bill won’t be as bad as its critics have been declaiming. Mr. Will considers the reactions in the light of one of Eric Hoffer’s apothegms:

The intellectual cannot operate at room temperature.

a characterization of the public intellectuals of the late 60s and early 70s. Another celebrity of that period might have said that in the future, the future we’re living in, everybody will be outraged for fifteen minutes.

That’s the problem with the deluge news, commentary, trivia, and drivel with which we’re continuously inundated these days. You’ve got to express inordinate outrage merely to be heard above the din and that sort of outrage crowds out considered thought.

It presents a mighty temptation to stop listening to the news, close Facebook, and delete your Twitter account. Franklin would have loved it but I wonder what Jefferson would have thought of it. Can there be an informed electorate these days?

15 comments

What Do I Want from the Democrats?

As I frequently feel the need to point out, I’m a Democrat. Since I’m neither a progressive nor a machine Democrat, people seem to find that confusing but it does raise the question what do I want from the Democrats?

First and foremost I want clean, honest government. We don’t presently have that either here in the state of Illinois or at the national level.

I want a United States that is at peace with the world.

I want Democrats to stop drawing dichotomies between “corporations” which they presumably don’t like on the one hand and “people” which they presumably do on the other. This very morning I read an op-ed by Ron Wyden in which he drew that very dichotomy. The reality of life in the 21st century is that a very large percentage of Americans work for corporations. They depend on them for their livelihoods. While it’s reasonable to want better corporations, disparaging them is a self-destructive error.

I want a lot of other things, too, but that’s a start.

I guess some people view my even raising these issues as misguided or disloyal. I see it as the higher loyalty.

32 comments

Moving Forward on DACA

I agree with Josh Smith’s point in his post at RealClearPolicy—DACA needs to be enacted into law:

DACA is an executive action issued by the Obama administration in 2012 that protects immigrants who came to the United States as children from deportation and grants them eligibility to work. Its requirements are stringent: DACA recipients must be enrolled in school, the military, or have received a high school diploma or honorable discharge. Moreover, they must pass a background check from the Department of Homeland Security.

The executive action was likely unconstitutional.

Some form of legislative solution is overwhelmingly popular, both among Americans generally and among lawmakers. What’s impeding it? I can only think of two things: the opposition of the most extreme anti-immigration branch of the Republican Party and the incessant demand to bundle DACA with a more general amnesty, a topic into which Mr. Smith, too, veers.

Just enact DACA into law and enforce it. Leave it at that.

12 comments

The WSJ, the Democrats, and Taxes

Here’s the editors of the Wall Street Journal’s take on the Democratic reaction to the tax reform bill working its way through the Congress:

Republicans are poised this week to cut taxes for most American workers and businesses, fulfilling a core campaign promise. But before the House and Senate vote, it’s worth noting that they may do so without a single Democrat in support. How has the party of the Kennedy tax cuts of the 1960s and the co-writers of the Reagan reform in the 1980s become implacably opposed to pro-growth tax policy?

A little history shows how remarkable this is. The Kennedy marginal tax-rate cuts were pushed by White House economist Walter Heller and powered the economic expansion for another half-decade. In the 1981 tax debate, William Brodhead of Michigan and other Ways and Means Democrats offered an amendment that cut the top rate on investment income to 50% from 70% in the first year.

The 1986 tax reform was driven as much by Democrats as by Ronald Reagan. Dick Gephardt and Dan Rostenkowski helped move it through the House, and Bill Bradley was a leading architect in the Senate. Thirty-three Democrats voted for the bill that passed the Senate 74-23 and cut the top marginal income tax rate to 28%.

Bill Clinton raised taxes in 1993, but after his re-election he compromised with Newt Gingrich in 1997 to cut the capital-gains tax rate to 20% from 28%. That drove investment and growth through the rest of the decade. Even as recently as 2001, a dozen Democrats in the Senate and 28 in the House compromised with George W. Bush to cut the top income-tax rate to 35%.

Yet this year not a single Senate Democrat seems willing to vote to cut the top rate a mere 2.6-percentage points to 37% or reform a corporate tax code that Democrats have long recognized is anti-competitive. Had they engaged with Republicans to provide 60 votes, they surely could have influenced the bill.

They might have saved most of the state-and-local tax deduction that helps Democratic states keep taxes high. Now Democrats in New Jersey and California are left to moan that perhaps they’ll have to stop raising taxes on high-earners. Or perhaps Democrats could also have proposed eliminating the corporate tax in return for a long-time progressive priority like a carbon tax. Instead they chose total resistance, and policy irrelevance.

Part of the explanation is ideological. The Democrats as a party moved sharply left during the Obama years—on economics nearly as much as on identity politics. They have made income inequality their main economic priority rather than growth, and the fact that the slow-growing Obama economy increased inequality hasn’t changed that obsession.

One result is that there isn’t a pro-business Democrat left in the Senate, except perhaps on energy policy in fossil-fuel states like West Virginia and North Dakota. Democrats are now the party of Thomas Piketty, the French economist who thinks tax rates should return to pre-Kennedy levels to reduce inequality.

Democratic economists who might have offered an alternative view have no choice but to go along if they ever want to serve in another Democratic administration. They all saw what Elizabeth Warren and the Democratic left did to block Larry Summers from getting the job of Federal Reserve Chairman.

The other explanation is the political calculation that opposition will help Democrats retake the House and Senate in the 2018 midterm elections. President Trump is unpopular, and they figure his polarizing behavior will drive enough Democrats in the polls to save Senate incumbents even in states that Mr. Trump carried in 2016. Heidi Heitkamp (North Dakota), Joe Donnelly (Indiana) and Claire McCaskill (Missouri) figure that the safer play is to oppose all things Trump and mobilize the base vote.

Perhaps that bet will pay off, but then they are also betting that tax reform will fail to increase growth and wages. If it does succeed in spurring the economy, they will have had no stake in that success. Republicans will surely point that out, especially if the popularity of the tax bill rises once voters see the results in higher after-tax income.

Whatever the political results next year, this Democratic left turn isn’t good for the country. The U.S. has historically prospered when there is a growth wing in both major political parties. A Democratic growth wing is all the more important because the GOP is developing an income-redistribution wing led by Florida Senator Marco Rubio that has watered down the growth elements of this tax reform and almost scuttled it.

After the slowest expansion in decades and tepid wage growth, Americans should want this tax reform to succeed and it’s a shame Democrats are rooting for failure.

I think that some of their claims are false, e.g.:

Democrats are now the party of Thomas Piketty, the French economist who thinks tax rates should return to pre-Kennedy levels to reduce inequality.

while some are surely exaggerated:

They have made income inequality their main economic priority rather than growth, and the fact that the slow-growing Obama economy increased inequality hasn’t changed that obsession.

However, I agree with this:

The U.S. has historically prospered when there is a growth wing in both major political parties. A Democratic growth wing is all the more important because the GOP is developing an income-redistribution wing led by Florida Senator Marco Rubio that has watered down the growth elements of this tax reform and almost scuttled it.

specifically, that we need a pro-growth Democratic Party. My take is that too many Democrats have decided that more growth isn’t possible or, worse, desirable and they want to position the party as the party of dividing the spoils.

More than anything else what has driven income inequality in the United States is bad tax policy, particularly the Clinton era revision to the treatment of stock options. Until that’s dealt with no adjustment of marginal rates on the personal income tax will do a darned thing about income inequality.

24 comments

Redirecting the Conversation

Back in May a ransomware attack struck nearly a quarter million computers around the world. It was dubbed “WannyCry”. Fortunately, no one died although, since British National Health was heavily affected, it had that potential. It seems to me that if this, from a Wall Street Journal op-ed by Thomas Bossert, is true:

Cybersecurity isn’t easy, but simple principles still apply. Accountability is one, cooperation another. They are the cornerstones of security and resilience in any society. In furtherance of both, and after careful investigation, the U.S. today publicly attributes the massive “WannaCry” cyberattack to North Korea.

The attack spread indiscriminately across the world in May. It encrypted and rendered useless hundreds of thousands of computers in hospitals, schools, businesses and homes. While victims received ransom demands, paying did not unlock their computers. It was cowardly, costly and careless. The attack was widespread and cost billions, and North Korea is directly responsible.

We do not make this allegation lightly. It is based on evidence. We are not alone with our findings, either. Other governments and private companies agree. The United Kingdom attributes the attack to North Korea, and Microsoft traced the attack to cyber affiliates of the North Korean government.

The consequences and repercussions of WannaCry were beyond economic. The malicious software hit computers in the U.K.’s health-care sector particularly hard, compromising systems that perform critical work. These disruptions put lives at risk.

at the very least it should redirect the conversation on North Korea. IMO it strongly suggests that North Korea is not deterrable, it will do what it cares to when it cares to, and there’s little that can be done about it as long as the Kim regime is in charge.

6 comments

When You Quote Robert McNamara

Aussie analyst Benjamin Schreer concludes his critique of American policy on Afghanistan at RealClearDefense by quoting Robert McNamara:

I deeply regret that I did not force a probing debate about whether it would ever be possible to forge a winning military effort on a foundation of political quicksand. It became clear then, and I believe is clear today, that military force—especially when wielded by an outside power—cannot bring order in a country that cannot govern itself.

We are presently in Afghanistan because no president has been able to bring himself to be characterized forever after as “the president who lost Afghanistan to the Taliban”. The inherent contradiction of being logistically dependent on a Pakistan that’s in collaboration with the Taliban does not appear to have occurred to anyone.

Not only can Afghanistan not govern itself, it does not have the financial ability to support a military capable of ousting the Taliban who are, after all, Afghans. I’m also beginning to wonder if military force wielded by an “outside power” incapable of governing itself can form the foundation of a “winning military effort”.

Not to mention that when you feel the need to quote Robert McNamara, you’re in real trouble.

18 comments

View from Abroad

In the comments section of a post at naked capitalism a foreign commenter summarizes U. S. politics pretty succinctly anno Domini 2017:

If you stand a reasonable, moderate candidate against a raging nut job, then the majority of the times the moderate will win. If you stand a vile, corrupt candidate up against a raging nut job, then there is an even chance that the raging nut job will win.

I certainly hope that’s the case. It actually might be the best case scenario. At this point I’m not entirely sure.

4 comments

Moral Hazard in Health Care

As Yogi Berra once put in theory there’s no difference between practice and theory; in practice there is. At the Sacramento Bee Dan Walters looks at the bottom line on universal health care for California:

A Senate Appropriations Committee analysis pegs costs of universal coverage at $400 billion a year, but suggests that half could be covered by redirection of existing federal, state and local government health care spending.

It added that “about $200 billion in additional taxes would be needed to pay for the remainder,” but also noted that half or more of that burden could be offset by eliminating direct health care costs now borne by consumers and their employers.

To put that in perspective, even $100 billion in new taxes would be the equivalent of a one-third increase in the $300 billion a year now levied by state and local governments.

In theory – one advanced by advocates – the two-thirds “supermajorities” in the Legislature and the governor could levy new taxes of that magnitude.

In practice, however, even if the supermajorities survive the recent spate of sexual harassment resignations and next year’s elections, there’s virtually no chance of such a vote.

For California’s plan to be truly universal, as Mr. Walters goes on to point out, it must cover illegal immigrants. I think that California’s remaining a sanctuary state and having universal health care is a fantasy. There is no way such a system could ever be stable and there is no way for Californians to pay for a system in which the costs are completely out of control. Every parent everywhere in the world with a sick kid would be moving heaven and earth to get to California to avail themselves of free health care.

Meanwhile here in Illinois one of the Democrats seeking to replace Gov. Bruce Rauner after the next gubernatorial election is running on a platform of a single-payer plan for the state of Illinois. Even states much more solvent than Illinois have rejected the idea as unaffordable. Illinois is bankrupt in all but name. How in the heck can a state that can’t even afford to maintain its roads pay the pensions it’s promised going to implement a single-payer system?

2 comments