At Roll Call Walter Shapiro urges the Congressional Democrats to do a deal with the Trump Administration—security for the “DREAMers” in exchange for partial funding of Trump’s wall:
Ever since the Soviets erected in 1961 a barrier separating East and West Berlin, walls have been associated with totalitarian countries rather than confident democracies. And the Trumpian vision of a beautiful solar-powered wall (presumably with Ivanka’s boutiques at the base) doesn’t make the image any prettier.
But if congressional Democrats can win lifelong legal protection for the nearly 800,000 Dreamers in exchange for, say, a $10 billion down payment on the wall, it would be a deal worth making. Sure, the $10 billion would be wasted. But that’s chump change compared to the nearly $1 trillion in giveaways already embedded in the GOP tax bill.
Yes, Trump would chortle that he won the most glorious victory since Gen. George Patton crossed the Rhine. Trump’s triumphalism would be difficult to take. Far worse, though, would be immigration roundups of the Dreamers if Trump petulantly refused to extend the executive order beyond March 5.
There’s an additional complication for Democrats: politically they’re on the wrong side of the argument. A recent poll found the following opinions on immigration:
Some 57 percent of likely midterm voters favored ending the ability of new citizens to sponsor extended family members for immigration if Congress offers a path to citizenship for young adult illegal immigrants. Some 32 percent said they support continued chain migration.
By a margin of 57 percent to 23 percent, respondents also said a bill granting legal status to young adult illegal immigrants should include a provision requiring employers to use the E-Verify system to confirm the legal status of workers.
The smart, substantive, and politically superior move would be serious workplace enforcment rather than a wall. A wall is only as good as its weakest ICE agent. Workplace enforcement would address the issue and impel businesses and government to enter into a realistic discussion of the issues.







