Take the Cannoli

At Roll Call Walter Shapiro urges the Congressional Democrats to do a deal with the Trump Administration—security for the “DREAMers” in exchange for partial funding of Trump’s wall:

Ever since the Soviets erected in 1961 a barrier separating East and West Berlin, walls have been associated with totalitarian countries rather than confident democracies. And the Trumpian vision of a beautiful solar-powered wall (presumably with Ivanka’s boutiques at the base) doesn’t make the image any prettier.

But if congressional Democrats can win lifelong legal protection for the nearly 800,000 Dreamers in exchange for, say, a $10 billion down payment on the wall, it would be a deal worth making. Sure, the $10 billion would be wasted. But that’s chump change compared to the nearly $1 trillion in giveaways already embedded in the GOP tax bill.

Yes, Trump would chortle that he won the most glorious victory since Gen. George Patton crossed the Rhine. Trump’s triumphalism would be difficult to take. Far worse, though, would be immigration roundups of the Dreamers if Trump petulantly refused to extend the executive order beyond March 5.

There’s an additional complication for Democrats: politically they’re on the wrong side of the argument. A recent poll found the following opinions on immigration:

Some 57 percent of likely midterm voters favored ending the ability of new citizens to sponsor extended family members for immigration if Congress offers a path to citizenship for young adult illegal immigrants. Some 32 percent said they support continued chain migration.

By a margin of 57 percent to 23 percent, respondents also said a bill granting legal status to young adult illegal immigrants should include a provision requiring employers to use the E-Verify system to confirm the legal status of workers.

The smart, substantive, and politically superior move would be serious workplace enforcment rather than a wall. A wall is only as good as its weakest ICE agent. Workplace enforcement would address the issue and impel businesses and government to enter into a realistic discussion of the issues.

13 comments

We Have No Allies

I don’t believe that the editors of the Wall Street Journal have fairly characterized the problems that could be created by the U. S.’s imposition of sanctions against Pakistan:

Aid is only one part of the leverage the U.S. can use to persuade Pakistan to change. An interagency policy review is considering the more potent step of rescinding Pakistan’s status as a major non-NATO ally. That would have serious consequences for the country’s military as it would lose access to U.S. military equipment, training and intelligence-sharing.

The U.S. could even designate Pakistan a state sponsor of terrorism, which would bring sanctions. Already the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, a multilateral organization, has warned Pakistan it could be placed on a watch list for failing to stop terrorism funding.

Such steps are not to be taken lightly. The U.S. relies on Pakistani ports and roads to move heavy equipment in and out of Afghanistan, and rising U.S. tensions with Russia and Iran make alternate routes through Central Asia unfeasible. China gives Islamabad unconditional support and has promised to invest $57 billion in Pakistan’s infrastructure. If it is forced to rely more on Beijing, Islamabad might give the People’s Liberation Army Navy greater access to the Gwadar Port and other strategic advantages.

“Heavy equipment” is a misstatement. The U. S. moves the munitions they need to prosecute the war in Afghanistan via air. Everything else including food and, importantly, fuel is transported by ground transport through Pakistan. For that privilege we pay the Pakistanis—presumably part of the “aid” we supply. It’s actually a pay-off for right of way.

Additionally, Pakistan is so fragile that throwing a spanner into the works presents dangers we would probably prefer not to face. Pakistan’s Inter-Service Intelligence Agency, considered by many the best intelligence service in the world, is known to support terrorists, have close ties with Islamist groups, and provides them with support. Overthrowing the present Pakistani government, such as it is, risks putting Pakistan’s nuclear weapons (probably the third largest nuclear arsenal in the world) in the hands of those groups.

The sad reality is that we can either prosecute a war in Afghanistan or antagonize the Pakistanis. We can’t do both.

Welcome to the world of the 21st century. We have no allies. We have clients, rivals, and enemies. We’ve got to choose very carefully whom we can afford to antagonize and how much we can afford to antagonize them.

2 comments

Synecdoche


A synecdoche is a rhetorical device by which a part of something actually refers to the whole. An everyday example of synecdoche is using “boots” to mean military forces. When one is concerned about “boots on the ground” it does not mean that the image in the graphic above disturbs them but rather the prospect of stationing soldiers in some particular place.

Is it possible that putatively literate people do not understand this device?

4 comments

Doing Their Jobs


Former Fed governor Narayana Kocherlakota begins his critique of the Federal Reserve’s Board of Governors at Bloomberg View with this scathing indictment:

In the first 18 years of the new millennium, the U.S. economy has fared much worse than it could have. If the Federal Reserve wants to improve that performance, it should consider changing the way it manages growth and inflation.

He goes on to complain about the Fed’s handling of inflation, the distribution of income in which the Fed are been one of the main culprits, median incomes, and median net worth.

The graph above illustrates how poorly the U. S. economy has performed over the last 17 years. Let me translate it for you: the U. S. economy has underperformed relative to potential every year of the present millennium other than 2005-2006 and that notional success was the consequence of a disastrous housing bubble. He calls for an “attitude adjustment” of the Fed without specifying what that would entail.

What I think should concern us more is possibility that the results the Fed has realized may reflect that they’re doing their jobs as they understand them and that is to ensure that the ultra-rich become ultra-richer.

My suggestion is shoemaker stick to thy last. The Fed should stop trying to manage the economy, a task I believe is beyond its abilities, and shoulder their primary responsibility of regulating the banks. Here’s a statistic not cited by Dr. Kocherlakota: the number of commercial banks in the U. S. is just about half what it was in January of 2000. If rather than shuttering small banks and selling their assets at fire sale prices to the megabanks, maybe the Fed governors should think about regulating those big banks. While regulating small banks may keep you busy, regulating big banks may well be impossible.

2 comments

Do Your Data Belong to You?

I know that my views on this subject are more like those of Europeans than of Americans. It’s interesting to see the notion that companies like Google and Facebook don’t own the data they collect about you gaining traction. At Bloomberg View Kara Alaimo declaims:

Many people think that it’s an invasion of privacy for companies to gather sensitive data — such as information about our relationships and medical history — and exploit it for commercial purposes. It could also widen social divisions. For example, Facebook determines our political beliefs based upon the pages we like and preferences we list on our profiles. If algorithms peg us as conservative or liberal and we’re targeted with ads accordingly, we may end up never understanding what people of other political persuasions think. Internet activist and author Eli Pariser has argued that America is so politically polarized in part because social media sites leave us in “filter bubbles.” Targeted political advertising could have the same effect.

That’s part of the reason why, in May, a new regulation will go into effect into the European Union giving citizens the “right to object” to “processing of personal data” about them for marketing and other purposes. As Andrus Ansip, the European Commission vice president for the digital single market, tweeted, “Should I not be asked before my emails are accessed and used? Don’t you think the same?” The new law overcame serious opposition from the advertising industry, whose representatives argue that it will disrupt ad revenues needed by the media. Experts say that websites will have to provide more valuable content to users as an incentive for readers to allow them to use their data.

I wonder how long it will be before there’s a more general recognition of how fragile the business models of the Internet titans are? Nobody has a right to a business model. Business models aren’t assets; they’re risks.

0 comments

Beginning of Year Blahs

I can only speculate that the entire journalistic profession is on vacation. Massive demonstrations continue in Iran. The French are outraged by violence directed at police officers. The Bitcoin bubble is reaching alarming proportions. The numbers tell me that the U. S. economy is swell but it doesn’t feel swell. North Korea’s nuclear weapons development program is proceeding apace. It’s not as though there isn’t any news. It’s just that nobody has much new to say about the news.

14 comments

Backgrounder on Iranian Demonstrations (Updated)

There’s an interesting backgrounder on the Iranian demonstrations in the comments of Pat Lang’s blog. Here’s a snippet:

I think this could be a bigger challenge than 2009 protests, which only encompassed Tehran but not other Iranian cities.

Government, without a doubt, would be worried about a repeat of Arab Spring. although I personally do not see any chance of that.

Last December 21, during the Yalda Celebration, 210 or so party goers were arrested by the police for engaging in immoral acts; such as dancing in mixed company etc.

At the time, I thought that the Iranian security forces seem to have too much time on their hands, arresting young people having a good time. Now, of course, they have too much on their plates for a change.

I do not expect this to bring down the government or the system, but I do expect it to weaken the hizbollahis and strengthen the political and cultural position of middle-of-the-road Iranians.

Read the whole thing. The author has an ear to the ground.

Update

Hossein Derakhshan’s Twitter feed is another good source.

0 comments

What Does “Support” Mean?

I wish I knew what the editors of the Washington Post meant by “support” when they say “the West should support the protesters in Iran”:

At the same time, Mr. Trump should avoid acts that would undercut the protests and empower the regime’s hard-liners. Foremost among these would be a renunciation of the 2015 nuclear accord. That would divide the United States from European governments when they should be coordinating their response to the uprising, and it would give the regime an external threat against which to rally. Reform of the nuclear accord can wait. Now is the time for Mr. Trump to focus on supporting the people of Iran.

I think the best thing that Western politicians and journalists can do to “support” the protesters is maintain a low profile. Any statement, any insertion of the West into the protests may be construed as Western interference in the internal affairs of Iran. That is, after all, the origin myth of the present mullahocracy: heroic Iranians overthrew the Shah’s regime which had been put in place by the Americans who overthrew the democratically-elected Mossadegh government. Let’s not give patriotic Iranians reasons to oppose the protests.

1 comment

This Is Not the Revolution You’re Looking For

I genuinely wish that Western writers would not expound on the demonstrations going on in Iran as Terry Glavin does in MacLean’s:

The Iranian uprising that began last Thursday in Mashhad, Iran’s second largest city, was initially reported as an isolated protest over food prices and unemployment. By Sunday, the entire country was heaving in convulsions. Tens of thousands of people had poured into the streets of at least two dozen Iranian cities and towns, upturning police vehicles and setting government offices ablaze. The Khomeinist regime has been shaken to its foundations. Hundreds of people have been arrested. At least 12 people are dead.

By Monday morning, state broadcasters were reporting that security forces had prevented armed protesters from seizing military bases and police stations. President Hassan Rouhani was threatening a crackdown, but the rebellion continues. Nothing quite like it has happened since the Khomeinists seized power from the decrepit Mohammad Reza Shah, the last ruler of the Pahlavi dynasty, in 1979.

Unlike the massive protests that erupted after Mahmoud Ahmedinejad came out on top in the sham presidential elections of 2009, the unrest this time around is not largely confined to Tehran, Iran’s capital. It’s coming from everywhere. And unlike the 1999 uprising, the tumult of the past four days is not a student revolt. It’s an eruption that has arisen from the Khomeinist heartlands. Even in Qom, the Shia holy city, throngs of protesters last Friday were shouting ‘Khamenei, leave the country.” Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is Iran’s doddering Supreme Leader. In Iran’s criminal code, disparaging Khamenei in that way is a crime punishable by death.

I believe he’s mistaken in thinking that these demonstrations are an incipient revolution. He’s forgetting that the mullahs are successful revolutionaries. They won’t hesitate to use force in putting down demonstrators including mass executions and they have the loyal followers, the Revolutionary Guard and paid mercenaries, the basiji, to do it with. They have no Plan B.

The Khomeinists organized and planned their revolution for decades and they were bloody-minded enough to carry it out. The Shah wasn’t willing to kill enough of his own people to stay in power.

The demonstrations are indications of dissatisfaction not incipient revolution. Overthrowing the mullahs will require a lot more than dissatisfaction.

0 comments

A Self-Defeating Feminism

Yesterday evening my wife and I watched Moana, streaming on Netflix. After watching it my wife asked me what I thought of it. I said I thought it was an astonishing technical achievement and very affecting but I had reservations about the portrayals of men. Without exception every male was portrayed as timorous, pompous, a buffoon, an idiot, or all four while every female was portrayed as courageous or at worst misunderstood.

I have no problem with the occasional male villain but I do with the systematic demeaning of men. If that’s Disney’s marketing plan, I think they should rethink it. For one thing timorous, pompous, buffoonish, or idiotic men will do women no good.

14 comments