Those Busy Agents

I see that Mark Tapscott has stumbled across the same point I made yesterday:

FBI counterintelligence agent Peter Strzok and his lover, bureau lawyer Lisa Page, sent each other an estimated 50,000 text messages during a five-month period in 2016 and 2017 that are now “lost.”

To put 50,000 texts in five months into perspective, consider this:

  • There are 12,960,000 seconds in five 30-day months.
  • The number 12,960,000 divided by 50,000 equals a new text message every 259.2 seconds.
  • This means Strzok and Page texted each other about every 4.32 minutes.
  • That’s every day of every week of every month for five months!

Investigators might wonder how Strzok and Page found time to do anything else — like participating in special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation of allegations President Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign colluded with Russian interests to defeat Democrat Hillary Clinton.

To which I’d add that they must have been completely unsupervised for the entire period. Anything remotely resembling management would’v’e noticed how many texts they were sending and put an end to it.

8 comments

Actually, We Have Always Been At War With Eastasia

I found Niall Ferguson’s op-ed in Global Times interesting if not particularly informative. In it he questions the “liberal international order”:

The phrase international order reminds me of the phrase Western civilization. As Indian independence icon Mahatma Gandhi wittily replied when asked about Western civilization, “It would be a good idea.” The notion that international order exists or has ever existed seems highly questionable to me. The notion of a liberal international order is even more questionable because it is neither liberal, nor international, nor very orderly.

It is often claimed by political scientists that the liberal international order came into existence in 1945. The argument goes that American and British statesmen, having learned from the terrible mistakes of the 1930s and 1940s, decided to make the world anew by creating a series of remarkable international institutions: the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund and later the World Bank. According to this narrative, Donald Trump’s election as US president in 2016 was a wrecking ball directed at the liberal international order created by the generation of 1945.

Yet this is a fairy tale. For one thing, there was nothing very liberal about the economic order that was established in 1945. It was devised by people – notably John Maynard Keynes – who had repudiated classical liberal economics and believed that international trade should be limited and capital movements controlled.

What has actually existed is different countries with different interests pursuing those interests with the differing tools they have at their disposal. Brussels is delusional and those who believe otherwise are primarily playing into the hands of those in whose interests it was primarily conceived, i.e. Germany.

The circumstances are different today than they were 70 years ago when the “international order” was put into place. Some countries, e.g. China, have much more powerful tools at their disposal than they did when that order came into being. Others, e.g. the Arab countries of the Middle East, were practically invisible 70 years ago—they were so small and poor. I read Dr. Ferguson as urging the great powers—presently including the United States, China, Russia, Britain, and France and, possibly, India but in the future who know?—to eschew great power war and cooperate when it’s in their interests.

IMO that’s the right advice but it would help if politicians in China and the U. S. in particular didn’t think that great power was inevitable and persist in trying to foment it.

2 comments

The Feds Have the Atom Bomb

At RealClearMarkets Alex Pollock has a primer on the federal government’s ban on holding gold (that ended in 1974). If you’re not aware of the history, you might find it interesting.

Bitcoin enthusiasts, take heed! It is impossible to get beyond the government’s reach.

The title of this post is a reference to Earl Long’s remark about the futility of resisting the federal government’s enforcement of the civil rights of blacks in the South of the 1960s.

0 comments

The Higher Education Lie

There’s more evidence of the point I’ve been making for some time, i.e. that the benefits of higher education for most people are greatly exaggerated. From the Foundation for Economic Education:

There has been mounting evidence that the financial payoff from the traditional bachelor’s degree is declining, particularly for men. For example, the Census Bureau data suggest that from 2005 to 2016, the average earnings differential for male workers holding bachelor’s degrees compared with those holding high school diplomas fell from $39,440 to $37,653 (in 2016 dollars)—at a time when college costs were rising.

Other evidence from the New York Federal Reserve Bank confirms that a large portion of college graduates are underemployed, working jobs traditionally held by high school graduates.

When you take other factors into account, like opportunity costs and indebtedness, the presumed benefit of higher education narrows even farther.

I have always believed that the benefit of higher education depended too much on a fairly narrow group of very highly compensated professionals and that when those were excluded from the calculations and the other factors mentioned above taken into account there was little if any benefit to higher education for most people. The recent findings may reflect slowing earnings for professionals.

Not everyone is destined to be a physician or a lawyer working for a large law firm. We need a better balance between higher education and what used to be called “vocational training”. When baccalaureates are flipping burgers while companies are begging for people who can weld suggests there’s something seriously wrong.

1 comment

Belaboring the Point

  1. I thought that continuing to wage war illegally without end with no achievable goals in Syria was wrong under Obama and I think it’s wrong under Trump.
  2. I thought that invading and occupying Afghanistan was foolish back in 2001. We would have been better off punishing the Taliban and coming to a modus vivendi with them. Whether that was possible 15 years ago or not, it’s impossible now. It’s like that old toy called “Chinese handcuffs”. The harder we pull the tighter it holds.
0 comments

Morality Is Hard

I searched E. J. Dionne’s Washington Post column for a moral argument in support of action on DACA in vain. Here’s what I found:

Democrats were moved to force the “dreamers” issue not just by the demands of liberals but also by the requirements of sheer decency. There was additional fury at Trump for blowing up a DACA agreement negotiated painstakingly by Sens. Lindsey O. Graham (R-S.C.), Richard J. Durbin (D-Ill.) and others. Most Democrats therefore felt they had to reject a budget deal without a dreamers fix, even if shutdowns are hardly an ideal strategy for the party that respects the work government does.

It’s not much of an argument. Is it decent to ignore the problems of native-born Americans, overwhelmed by your concerns for people who are in this country illegally? It’s too much to expect of politicians that they be outraged at everything all at the same time. Basically, I think he’s confusing “niceness” with morality or decency.

19 comments

Poverty in America

In today’s New York Times Angus Deaton takes note of genuine poverty in the United States:

Surely no one in the United States today is as poor as a poor person in Ethiopia or Nepal? As it happens, making such comparisons has recently become much easier. The World Bank decided in October to include high-income countries in its global estimates of people living in poverty. We can now make direct comparisons between the United States and poor countries.

Properly interpreted, the numbers suggest that the United Nations has a point — and the United States has an urgent problem. They also suggest that we might rethink how we assist the poor through our own giving.

According to the World Bank, 769 million people lived on less than $1.90 a day in 2013; they are the world’s very poorest. Of these, 3.2 million live in the United States, and 3.3 million in other high-income countries (most in Italy, Japan and Spain).

This is a subject about which I’ve written before. You’ve got to dig through the article a bit but most of the genuinely poor are people living on Indian reservations, rural blacks, particularly in the Mississippi delta, and rural whites, particularly in Appalachia. Most of those who are thought of as the poor, the urban poor, are only relatively poor. They aren’t subsisting on the grind, absolute poverty you see in the place noted above.

These are the people most in need of help and most deserving of our charity and concern. We’ll never reach them using the tools we’re presently applying like Medicaid, HUD housing assistance programs, TANF, or WIC. Those programs do the most good for the urban poor.

0 comments

What Accountability?

Lou Anna Simon, the president of Michigan State University, has stepped down in the wake of the Larry Nassar’s receiving a sentence of 175 years in prison on charges of sexual abuse of those in his care. USA Today reports:

Michigan State University President Lou Anna Simon will step down as leader of MSU, the school announced late Wednesday.

“As tragedies are politicized, blame is inevitable,” she said in statement. “As president, it is only natural that I am the focus of this anger. I understand, and that is why I have limited my personal statements. Throughout my career, I have worked very hard to put Team MSU first. Throughout my career, I have consistently and persistently spoken and worked on behalf of Team MSU. I have tried to make it not about me. I urge those who have supported my work to understand that I cannot make it about me now. Therefore, I am tendering my resignation as president according to the terms of my employment agreement.”

She made the announcement hours after a judge sentenced Larry Nassar to 40 to 175 years in prison as part of a plea deal on seven counts of first-degree criminal sexual conduct involving more than 156 girls and women over more than two decades.

Note the careful wording. Whatever happened to “the buck stops here”? She’s not taking personal responsibility. She’s portraying herself as a victim.

At SI.com Charles Pearce temperately declaims:

Burn it all down. That is the calm and reasoned conclusion to which I have come as one horror story after another unspooled in the courtroom. Nobody employed in the upper echelons at USA Gymnastics, or at the United States Olympic Committee, or at Michigan State University should still have a job. If accessorial or conspiracy charges plausibly can be lodged against those people, they should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. Those people should come out of civil courts wearing barrels. Their descendants should be answering motions in the 22nd Century. In fact, I can argue convincingly that none of those three institutions should continue to exist in its current form. USA Gymnastics and the USOC should lose their non-profit status forthwith. Michigan State should lose its status within the NCAA for at least five years. American gymnastics is no longer a sport. It’s a conspiracy of pedophiles and their enablers.

Ms. Simon’s base pay is $750,000 per year. She recently received a raise after Nassar had already been sentenced to 60 years for possession of child pornography some months ago. The Detroit News reported one dissenter’s reaction:

“What kind of institution gives a raise to someone who presided over the molestation of hundreds of little girls?” said John Manly, a California-based attorney representing 106 young women in civil lawsuits against Nassar, MSU, USA Gymnastics, Gedderts’ Twistars USA Gymnastics Club and, in some cases, the U.S. Olympic Committee. “The short answer: One that is run by people who are morally depraved.”

Michigan State’s Athletic Director Mark Hollis’s base pay is $688,000 per year. What their pensions must be I can only imagine.

If we dug into all of this more intensively, I believe what we would discover is that Ms. Simon and Mr. Hollis are primarily fund raisers and all of the coaches and other officials at Michigan State have little fiefdoms with practically no scrutiny. As long as the money keeps pouring in.

And what I believe this tells us is that not just Michigan State but higher education more generally not to mention higher level athletics are thoroughly corrupt. The very least we could expect from the very high wages those at the top are receiving is some level of accountability.

With great power goes no responsibility. But the pay and benefits are great.

Update

The editors of the New York Times jump into the scrum:

The resignation on Wednesday of Lou Anna Simon, the president of Michigan State, where Dr. Nassar’s medical practice was based, was overdue. Though Michigan State has denied covering up Dr. Nassar’s crimes, reporting by The Detroit News found that 14 university officials were told of Dr. Nassar’s sexual misconduct in the two decades before he was arrested, and that at least eight women had reported his actions. Michigan State continued to allow Dr. Nassar to see patients for 16 months while he was under criminal investigation after a 2014 allegation of sexual assault by a patient.

The money kept pouring in. Everybody continue to get paid. Nobody cared.

They continue:

The athletic trainers, assistant coaches, university police officers and other school officials who let Dr. Nassar’s abuse go on should also step down. The N.C.A.A., which is investigating the matter, should consider sanctions against Michigan State, including banning it from postseason play for some period, as it did Penn State’s football program after the former assistant coach Jerry Sandusky was convicted of molesting children over a period of 15 years.

People in positions of responsibility need to be held accountable for what happens in the areas for which they are responsible, not just when atrocities are revealed but 365 days a year every year.

4 comments

The Stupidity of Limited Strikes

Noting the litany of those calling for a punitive strike against North Korea, at Foreign Policy Luke O’Brien provides a convincing analysis of just how foolhardy that would be:

If the United States keeps operating under flawed assumptions about the North, it could lead to a strike that, at best, will not end North Korea’s WMD program and, at worst, might provoke an escalation that results in the first battlefield use of nuclear weapons since 1945. The in-between possibilities are equally unattractive: limited retaliations that threaten the United States and its allies, and target civilians and military alike? A wider war on the Korean peninsula? No war, but allies that are forced to re-evaluate their own security relationships in the wake of a massive U.S. miscalculation? None of these can be said to be in the United States’ best interest.

Most of all, we don’t have to take these risks at all. If the perception of Kim Jong Un is one of a rogue and irrational actor, then striking now is far more prudent because deterrence likely will not hold. Of course, everything we see indicates that Kim is rational. North Korea is absolutely deterrable. And since it is, striking based on a misplaced trust in our own power is a dangerous — and unnecessary — risk.

And that’s without even a hint that such a course of action might well draw China or Russia into the conflict. I genuinely don’t know what these people are thinking.

Something that should be considered more seriously is just how fragile the Kim regime is. Politically, it cannot accept a limited attack without striking back any better than it could tolerate a U. S. invasion. The very forces that are driving the Kim regime to seek nuclear weapons refute the notion that a limited strike could be effective.

3 comments

Thinking About Immigration

I’ve mentioned before that I rarely read articles in the National Review. They’re generally just too much for me. However, in the light of my post of yesterday I found the title of Jason Lee Steorts’s piece, “What Is Our Responsibility for the Undocumented Population?” suggested it was probably relevant to it so I checked it out. Imagine my delight to find that his position, as reflected in the following paragraph, approximates my own:

I think that immigrants to the United States should learn English for their own good and for the sake of social cohesion, and that we should be patient and helpful while they do so. I think that illegal immigration is undesirable and to be prevented, through means that do not destroy the lives of the peaceable illegal immigrants we have already allowed to settle here. I think that practical indifference to illegal immigration, often motivated by the best of intentions, has created a huge limbo population that is highly vulnerable to populist predations and partisan manipulation. I think that assimilation — defined in terms of assent to the Declaration of Independence rather than adoption of cultural contingencies — is necessary and good. I think that our immigration priorities should be broadly “merit-based,” in part to help ensure that those who come can lead dignified lives; but I also think that not all skills are designable with credentials, that the willingness to immigrate to a skilled, prosperous country is itself the manifestation of a skill of character, and that what looks to us winners of the birth lottery like an undignified life might be vastly preferable to penury and disease and unpredictable, unavoidable, unimaginable crime in a developing country. I think it is often better for refugees to resettle in countries similar to the one they fled, provided they are safe there, but that this is not an excuse to refuse giving whatever help we uniquely can; and if you say that it’s unfair to help some people if we can’t help all of them, I’ll have to quote the story about the starfishes on the beach at you.

He characterizes the italicized portions as “anathema” to many of the right. For all I know that may be the case.

I said “approximates” which means that the views are not identical to my own. I would add the following observations:

  • I think that the slow growth or actual decline in wages among those without high school educations suggests that the United States does not, in fact, have a great or rising demand for workers without educations, particularly those who cannot speak English.
  • I think that a large number of immigrants from a single country is itself an impediment to assimilation.
  • I think that very few of today’s immigrants “assent to the Declaration of Independence” and most are just looking for a raise. A small number are looking for a handout or prey.
  • Failing to take affirmative steps to learn English suggests a lack of commitment if not a lack of assent and is likely to consign those who make that choice to permanent status as second class citizens.
  • I think that consigning a large percentage of the population to a status as second class citizens is not an act of virtue.
  • I think that we have a much, much greater obligation to native-born blacks, the descendants of slaves, than we do to illegal immigrants and whatever obligation we have to illegal immigrants we are unable or unwilling to honor both obligations.

Finally, the “one size fits all” approach to immigration we presently apply is particularly unsuited to the United States. We actually should have two immigration policies: one for Mexico and one for all other countries of origin. We should have a guest worker program that allows substantially more Mexicans to work here than is presently the case.

I should note that I wouldn’t be concerned about immigration at all if we were presently managing immigration. We aren’t so I am.

7 comments