Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
ABC Tulsa reports that Oklahoma teachers are coordinating a statewide strike:
MOORE, Okla. (KTUL) — Oklahoma teachers are fed up with state lawmakers. A public school teacher in Stillwater created the Facebook group “Oklahoma Teacher Walkout – The Time is Now!” two days ago, and it has already gained more than 20,000 members.
Today, teachers gathered in Moore to discuss the possible statewide strike.
“Frustration levels are high, so a strike is not a touchy word anymore,” said Molly Jaynes, a teacher in Oklahoma City.
You have to dig a bit for it but the issue is pay and I’m with the teachers on this one. They aren’t paid enough. Pay for a teacher in Oklahoma starts at $37,000 and tops out at $46,000 at the highest lane and seniority. Median household income in Oklahoma is $43,000. That means that most teachers in Oklahoma earn below median income. That’s not right. Plumbers in Oklahoma have a median income around the state’s median and can earn as much as $75,000.
For comparison purposes the starting pay for a Chicago teacher is over $50,000 a year and the median income is around $80,000. That’s for a nine month job in a city with a median household income of around $47,000 a year.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
Man working running social media accounts for a large company “Likes” a tweet mentioning the company. China doesn’t like the tweet and complains. Man is fired. The tweet mentioned Tibet as a separate country rather than as part of China. The Wall Street Journal reports:
Chinese authorities cited advertising violations in several of the recent cases including Marriott’s. Marriott emailed a survey to rewards-program members asking them to specify their home country. The options included Tibet, Macau and Hong Kong—all part of China—and Taiwan, which is claimed by China but has its own government. The survey was prepared by a longtime Canadian vendor.
Chinese social media began lighting up with outrage over Marriott’s survey on Jan. 9. The next day, Mr. Jones was on the night shift handling the Marriott Rewards Twitter account, a job that required him to engage with the public on Twitter.
Mr. Jones said his team noticed calls on Twitter to boycott Marriott but hadn’t been briefed on what was happening.
That night, a tweet from a Tibetan separatist group praising Marriott for listing Tibet as a country in its survey was liked by Marriott’s official Rewards account.
Mr. Jones said he typically reviewed up to 300 tweets a shift and doesn’t recall liking that one, although he concedes he probably did.
On Jan. 11, the Shanghai Municipal Tourism Administration said it questioned Marriott representatives over the matter and ordered the company to publicly apologize and “seriously deal with the people responsible.â€
Marriott was also forced to suspend online booking services for one week in Greater China, its largest market outside North America with nearly 300 hotels. Following the episode, Marriott said it terminated its contract with the Canadian vendor.
Mr. Jones said he was fired after a Marriott human-resources director interviewed him about the incident.
It’s the sort of thing that would make me want to boycott Marriott.
The official position of the U. S. government is that Tibet is a part of China but they hedge by expressing a desire for the matter to be handled democratically and amicably by the government of China and the people of Tibet. If you move enough Han Chinese into Tibet, you can certainly make it de facto a part of China. The same could be said of Zimbabwe.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
The New York Times has a profile of Illinois 3rd Congressional District Congressman Dan Lipinski, who’s facing significant primary opposition from the left in his quest for yet another term:
In California, party activists at the state Democratic Convention last week rejected Senator Dianne Feinstein, a moderate lawmaker, refusing to formally bless her re-election. In Texas, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee opened fire on a progressive candidate, Laura Moser, posting negative research to blunt her rise in fear that a victory by her in Tuesday’s primary race could doom the party’s bid for a suburban Houston district in November.
But the battle to define the party is playing out most vividly in overwhelmingly safe House districts around cities like Boston, Chicago and New York, where younger liberals, often women, people of color or both, are confronting men who are products of a clubhouse politics where fealty to the organization was paramount.
And no lawmakers may be more vulnerable to the rising left than Mr. Lipinski and, in Massachusetts, Representative Michael E. Capuano, a far more liberal Democrat who is nevertheless confronting a restless electorate in his Boston-based district.
Mr. Lipinski, opposed to abortion and uneasy with gay rights, is locked in a bitter campaign with Ms. Newman, a former marketing consultant who has backing from powerful liberal groups such as Naral Pro-Choice America and the Human Rights Campaign.
There are some significant omissions from the profile. Lipinski has a PhD in political science from Duke and taught at Notre Dame and University of Tennessee before ascending to take his dad’s, long-time Congressman Bill Lipinski’s, seat in Congress in a political deal that stank to high heaven. I wrote against him when he first ran for office, essentially on the grounds that I hate political dynasties. I don’t think they’re conducive to republican let alone democratic government.
How much has the 3rd District since his dad represented it 15 years ago? That’s what the primary will determine. I would caution coastal progressives that being a Democrat in Chicago does not necessarily mean the same thing that it does in Manhattan or Boston or San Francisco and that it’s possible to win the primary but lose in the general election. It’s been a safe seat for Lipinski but there’s no guarantee that it will be for Ms. Newman.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
Here’s the meat of Matthew Karnitschnig’s post at Politico EU:
The movement’s founding ideals — a generous welfare state with universal health, education, pensions — have long been realized, helping to lift generations of Europeans out of the proletariat into the middle class. In many countries today, the average social democrat is just as likely to have a white collar as a blue one.
What’s more, technology has forever altered the nature of employment. The days of back-breaking assembly-line work are long gone. And the large industrial labor unions — once social democracy’s core constituency — have faded, leaving the movement’s leaders to chase the prosperous middle class.
As a result, social democracy has lost its raison d’être. In the German campaign, the party struggled to find a central theme, finally settling on the issue of “justice.†To many on the movement’s left, the slogan sounded like mockery.
Like the U. S. political system and its once upon a time thriving egalitarian economy, social democracy in Europe depended on its remaining a sort of island in relative isolation from the rest of the world. Tear down the walls and you tear down the systems that depended on those walls.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
The Academy Awards are an artifact of the studio system. They were created not just as a party that the motion picture industry threw for itself but to promote motion pictures. The studios controlled the format, what the actors wore, what they said, and, to a large degree, who won. Unpopular, controversial, or unknown motion pictures or performers rarely if ever won. By the time the old studio system collapsed a half century ago, the Academy Awards had become a business of their own.
I predict that this year’s ceremony will be a surreal combination of posturing, pandering, patronization, and enormously self-absorbed and will be widely unwatched, like the Olympics possibly the least-watched ceremony in years. I also predict that, unlike the Academy Awards of the great days of Hollywood in which It Happened On Night, Gone With the Wind, or Casablanca—all movies that continue to be watched and enjoyed today—were honored, this year’s winners will be ephemeral and largely forgotten in a few years.
It’s high time that, also like the Olympics, the Academy Awards ceremony go the way of the old studio system that gave birth to it.
I also predict that my wife will object strongly to this post.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
At the National Interest Salvatore Babones writes:
The real problem is that other countries—including allies like Canada and the European Union—have responded to years of Chinese dumping by subsidizing their own industries and imposing broad tariffs on Chinese steel. American antidumping measures have traditionally been more narrowly focused. In a sense, Trump is only catching up with what the rest of the world is doing already.
The simple fact is that the world produces much more steel and aluminum than it needs. A global shakeout is inevitable, and every country wants to make sure that its own industries are the ones that survive. The only question is: who will blink first? If one country has done a lot of blinking over the last twenty years, it’s the United States, as the Commerce Department report amply documents. Embracing a free-market approach, being reluctant to provide subsidies, applying very selective tariffs and never even thinking about nationalizing its strategic industries, the United States has consistently ceded market share to its statist rivals overseas. The Trump tariffs bluntly but effectively draw a line under twenty years of creeping retreat.
We will continue to have a steel industry in the United States. Our national defense posture requires it unless you think that we’re going to import steel from enemies in a prospective war. Maintaining a steel industry in the face of global overcapacity will either require titanic subsidies at a level we’ve never seen before or some level in another form of protectionism. You can’t just turn the furnaces off and then turn them on when you suddenly find yourself in need of more steel.
But let me highlight another aspect of this. The members of the so-called “creative class” can’t oppose the continuation of every job that more ordinary people can do on a variety of grounds and pretexts, whether economic, environmental, or other without being prepared to support those people out of their own pockets, something that so far they’ve shown no willingness to do. That’s not merely hypocritical, it’s predatory. These contemporary Eloi won’t be allowed to put their Morlocks underground or otherwise put them out of sight. That’s science fiction.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
Judging by the reactions of economists I’m seeing I think a new definition of trade war is emerging. When trade barriers protect your job it’s trade war and when they protect my job they’re prudent restrictions.
Dave Schuler
March 4, 2018
There’s a fun article at Aeon examining whether Homo erectus spoke:
The genus Homo rules the Earth because it possesses language. But how and when did we build this kingdom of speech? And who is ‘we’? After all, Homo sapiens is just one of several species of humans that have walked the Earth. Does ‘we’ refer to our genus, Homo, or to our species, sapiens?
To discover the answers to these questions, we need to travel back in time at least 1.9 million years ago to the birth of Homo erectus, as they emerged from the ancient process of primate evolution. Erectus had nearly double the brain size of any previous hominin, walked habitually upright, were superb hunters, travelled the world, and sailed to ocean islands. And somewhere along the way they got language. Yes, erectus. Not Neanderthals. Not sapiens. And if erectus invented language, this means that Neanderthals, born more than a million years later, entered a world already linguistic.
I wish there were more rigorous definitions of genus and species. The prevailing general definition of species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and the offspring be fertile. What then to make of the statement that humans (Homo sapiens) interbred with Neanderthals and Denisovans? Either they were all subspecies of the same species and the correct designation of Neanderthal would be Homo sapiens neanderthalensis and our subspecies Homo sapiens sapiens or the definition of species is wrong (or there’s some undiscovered predecessor species that had the characteristics common to all three).
My opinion is that we, Neanderthal, the Denisovans, and probably erectus were all members of the same species. I would change Plato’s academy’s definition of human being to “furless featherless biped with flat nails that speaks“.
Dave Schuler
March 3, 2018
And sure enough the editors of the New York Times are whining about trade war:
The steel and aluminum tariffs might, on their own, have only a small impact on the economy. But the greater fear many experts have is that Mr. Trump is just getting started and will impose new tariffs on a host of other imports, sending the United States into a much broader trade war, the likes of which the world hasn’t seen since the Great Depression. That would have a large and devastating economic impact, in the United States and around the globe.
as are the editors of the Washington Post:
The key is to exempt close treaty allies such as Canada, Japan, Korea and Germany from the new tariffs. Not only is there no national security risk from importing their steel and aluminum, there would also be national security harm from weakening them economically and alienating them diplomatically. And Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross’s original proposal included a proviso allowing certain exemptions, based on “an overriding economic or security interest of the United States †or, in the case of aluminum, on “their willingness to work with the United States to address global excess capacity.â€
China, South Korea, Vietnam, India, Brazil, and the Bolivarian countries of South America all subsidize their steel production. That results in substantial overproduction of steel and dumping which pushes U. S.-produced steel out of international markets. Most of the overproduction is on the part of the Asian countries where production has skyrocketed. This has been going on for years, in some case decades.
Imposing countervailing tariffs against these countries has been an available option for years. We’ve just elected not to exercise them and the consequence has been the ongoing hollowing out of the U. S. steel industry and the loss of U. S. jobs.
U. S. and European steel production have been stable for decades. The best case scenario would be for all of these countries to end their subsidies. Imposing tariffs is a distant second best but it’s better than sitting there fat, dumb, and unhappy. Other countries’ policies are harming the United States and its people. Isn’t that the definition of war?
Dave Schuler
March 3, 2018
I can’t help but be amused at the flurry of articles crying “trade war” (here, here, and here). When our trading partners engage in non-competitive activities it’s trade; when we do it’s war.
Most of China’s steel mills making most of China’s steel are government owned. They are heavily subsidized as are the government-owned coal mines that feed the furnaces that produce the steel and that produce so much of China’s particulate air pollution.
We’ve been in a trade war with China for 30 years. We just haven’t been shooting back.