First Earn Billions

Here’s my advice for Dr. Pollack. From his New York Times op-ed:

How much does Mr. Bezos plan to spend on this gonzo space adventure? He said he would start with $1 billion a year. He has every right to do that. I fear that he will go further and shoot much of his fortune into space. That would squander a staggering opportunity to serve humanity.

How big is this opportunity? Ignoring inflation, let’s assume that the annual investment returns to his fortune are about 5 percent. He can spend more than $6 billion every year, pretty much indefinitely. Consider a few obvious ways this money could help people here on Planet Earth…

If Dr. Pollack is genuinely committed to the projects he goes on to describe, he should first earn billions of his own. Then he can devote them to whatever causes he values. There’s an old wisecrack: it’s a difference of opinion that makes a horserace.

Among economists there’s another catchphrase: don’t compare utility functions. What’s worth a billion to Dr. Pollack (who doesn’t have one) may not be worth a billion to Jeff Bezos (who does). There are reasons to question his judgment. Exhibit 1: the Washington Post.

However, he has billions and it’s his prerogative to spend them however he cares to and it’s equally his prerogative to have a different opinion of what’s worthwhile than Dr. Pollack.

1 comment

Will Gina Haspel Be Confirmed?

Who’s right? The editors of the Chicago Tribune:

As part of the nomination process, Haspel does have to answer for her actions. On Wednesday, she testified publicly before the Senate intelligence committee and addressed key questions about the CIA and torture. The hearing produced no startling revelations about her. Haspel stated that, if confirmed, she would not restart the now-repudiated detention and interrogation program. “I would not allow the CIA to undertake activity that I thought was immoral, even if it was technically legal,” she said.

And what if Haspel were ordered to waterboard a terrorism suspect? We ask because, at various times, Trump has sounded like a fan of “tough” interrogations. But Haspel made clear to the panel she wouldn’t allow the CIA to again embrace what was a desperation tactic.

Spycraft is exotic, at least as portrayed in paperbacks. It’s a coldblooded business that exists to help keep America safe. There are untidy aspects to the profession.

Haspel, who would be the first CIA director in five decades to come into the job after a career in clandestine operations, is also a proven administrator. The Senate should confirm her.

or John McCain:

I believe Gina Haspel is a patriot who loves our country and has devoted her professional life to its service and defense. However, Ms. Haspel’s role in overseeing the use of torture by Americans is disturbing. Her refusal to acknowledge torture’s immorality is disqualifying. I believe the Senate should exercise its duty of advice and consent and reject this nomination.

I don’t agree with Sen. McCain often but on this I’m inclined to agree with him. What do you think?

14 comments

Literally Hysterical

I wish that more people, journalists in particular, would take Matthew Walther’s words in The Week to heart:

Trump is shutting journalists out and complaining about them because they decided before his first day in office that his presidency was a disaster. The press is probably going to be proven correct about this, but reporters should spare us the faux-naïve surprise when he responds to their diurnal insistence that he is a fascist demagogue by making very tame jokes at their expense on Twitter. It’s not a frighteningly nihilistic assault on the freedom of the press or the nature of truth itself when he says that negative stories are “fake”: This is what politicians have always done, from John Adams to Bill Clinton. The same White House press briefings that they care so much about covering exist for the sole purpose of informing them that the administration is, weirdly, always right.

Trump will probably never love them. They won’t fawn on him as they did on President Obama or Secretary Clinton. But he might stop jerking their collective chain if they stopped going into hysterics every time he did so and it stopped being fun.

6 comments

How Anti-Populist Can the Congress Be?

I feel moved to respond in the negative to David Harsanyi’s remarks at The Federalist:

It’s strange that a president who had such a transformative effect on our national discourse will leave such a negligible policy legacy. But Barack Obama, whose imperial term changed the way Americans interact and in some ways paved the way for the Trump presidency, is now watching his much-celebrated and mythologized two-term legacy be systematically demolished. This, in many ways, tells us that American governance still works.

First, it’s not at all strange. I can only think of the words in Matthew:

Therefore whosoever heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, which built his house upon a rock:

And the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell not: for it was founded upon a rock.

And every one that heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them not, shall be likened unto a foolish man, which built his house upon the sand:

And the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell: and great was the fall of it.

When your actions are based on narrow majorities, executive orders, and, in some cases, contrary to the will of the people, seeing your legacy vanish like the house built on sand isn’t strange at all. It’s to be expected.

However, I also don’t believe that what we’re seeing shows that “American governance still works”. We have had three consecutive presidential elections in which the people were rather clearly calling for change. The Congress is delivering more of the same.

On occasion being a Congressman can be a tough job. Most of the time you can just vote as you care to or, more precisely, as the party leadership tells you to. But every so often you need to swallow and just vote the way your constituents want you to. The Congress, confident in its own elite status, has been refusing to do that for some time. I don’t know if they realize the risks they’re taking.

1 comment

After the Deal

The media are still fulminating about President Trump’s abrogation of the Iran deal. You might think the rescinding of an executive order by another presidential ukase might encourage reflection among Democrats about the wisdom the strategy and, indeed, the 50%+1 strategy that seems to be becoming the norm in Congress but I doubt it will. Our system of government is constructed in such a way as to require collaboration and compromise, no matter how detested or wrong your interlocutors may be. That was my main complaint about the Pelosi-Reid Congress. Prior to their guidance the Congress had never enacted a major piece of social legislation on a party-line basis. Après moi le déluge. We will see more of it.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal say that Trump’s action was only possible because President Obama failed to cultivate support for the Iran deal at home:

Mr. Obama issued his own broadside Tuesday against withdrawal, but then he made it easier for Mr. Trump by never winning domestic support for the deal. He refused to submit it for Senate approval as a treaty, which would have had the force of law. Mr. Trump is walking away from Mr. Obama’s personal commitment to Iran, not an American commitment.

That was my major criticism of President Obama. He had no patience with the politicking necessary to accomplish what you want under our system. He was too convinced of his own rightness and thought that when he was right he should just be obeyed. That is not our system, either.

Now that the Iran deal is dead from the American side, what next? The Iranians shelled Israeli military sites in Syria, something they’re legally entitled to do. The Israelis responded by shelling Iranian military sites in Syria, something they’re not legally entitled to do (the legal response would have been to withdraw from what is internationally recognized as Syrian territory). I think the Iranian action was ill-considered and the Israeli riposte understandable but it’s a very dangerous situation. To my eye the United States is being drawn step by step into a major Middle Eastern war, the likes of which has not been seen before.

I guess we’ll need to see what the Europeans, Russians, and Chinese do. Maybe Trump-Bolton truculence will be effective in extracting more concessions from Iran but somehow I doubt it.

19 comments

Dumping the Deal

I probably should write something on President Trump’s abandoning the deal cut by President Obama with Iran. The editors of the Wall Street Journal declaim:

The Obama Administration spent years negotiating a lopsided pact that gave Tehran $100 billion of sanctions relief and a chance to revive its nuclear-weapons program after a 15-year waiting period. Instead of cutting off “all of Iran’s pathways to a bomb” as Mr. Obama claimed, the deal delayed the country’s entry into the nuclear club and gave the mullahs cash to fund their Middle East adventurism.

I was skeptical of the deal negotiated by the Obama Administration because I thought it rested on intellectually shaky grounds, was probably not as good a deal as could have been negotiated, and, at least to my eye, seemed to take the position that any deal was better than no deal.

In what may seem a paradox to some I’m equally if not more skeptical of Trump’s abrogation of the deal. Think of it this way. You cut a deal with someone. You give them $10 and every day for 15 years they give you a token. How much is the token worth? You don’t know. It might be worth nothing; it might be worth a billion dollars. You’ve already given them the $10. The benefits if there are benefits simply accrue over time.

The $100 billion was already doled out and I don’t think that President Trump has made the case that leaving the deal in place is doing us any harm. If there are benefits, they will only accrue over time. What have we gained by abandoning the deal? It isn’t more security or peace of mind or a freer hand.

7 comments

Where Do We Get Such Men?

In his Wall Street Journal column Holman Jenkins attributes the manifest low moral character of New York politicians to one-party rule:

Unmentioned is how New York’s one-note political culture brings exactly this result on itself. There are no complexities, no ambiguities, no conflicting views to consider or conciliate. Just adopt the catechism and go. This is the formula for a career in New York politics. As the paper’s editorial page demonstrates on a daily basis, hardly is there even a limit on the amount of self-righteousness that will be tolerated as long as you internalize the correct checklist of things to be self-righteous about.

It’s an environment abnormally conducive to persons who lack real political instincts, talents and convictions, who make their way by being more loudly conformist than the next guy. Mr. Schneiderman tweeted Monday that, while he never assaulted anyone, “in the privacy of intimate relationships, I have engaged in role-playing.” Where do we get such men? Their role-playing, paint-by-numbers political careers are a product of New York’s warped one-party politics.

I think he’s giving too much credit to Republicans and to the two party system. Yesterday I mentioned that four of the last eight Illinois governors (three Democrats, one Republican) have done time in prison after serving their terms of office as governor and two of the last four (one Democrat, one Republican).

I don’t believe that the low character of politicians in New York or in Illinois is due to one party rule. I think it’s due to re-electing professional politicians for purely partisan or ideological reasons time after time after time. When you elect people because they’re on your side rather than because they’re the right sort of people or, worse, you infer that they’re the right sort of people because of their partisan or ideological affiliations, you’ll inevitably wind up with a bunch of self-serving moral midgets in office.

5 comments

Groveling to Power

An op-ed at the Washington Post by Ted Genoways touches on a subject I’ve addressed in the past, how our present copyright law suppresses works and creativity to the benefit of a few wealthy corporations:

Under the original Copyright Act of 1790, a work could be protected for 14 years, renewable for another 14-year term if the work’s author was still alive. In time, the maximum copyright grew from 28 years to 56 years and then to 75 years. In 1998, Sonny Bono championed an extension that would protect works created after 1978 for 70 years after the death of the author and the copyright of works created after 1922 to as long as 120 years.

This worked out great for Disney — which, not coincidentally, was founded in 1923 — but less so for the reputations of authors who produced important work between the 1920s and 1950s. Because copyright law became such a tangle, many of these works have truly languished. Here, Hurston is the rule rather than the exception. I have a file that I’ve kept over the years of significant unpublished works by well-known writers from the era: William Faulkner, Langston Hughes, William Carlos Williams, Hart Crane, Sherwood Anderson and Weldon Kees, among others. The works aren’t really “lost,” of course, but they are tied up in a legal limbo. Because of the literary reputations of those writers, their unpublished works will eventually see the light of day — whenever their heirs decide that the royalties are spreading a little too thin and there’s money to be made from new works. But other important writers who are little-known or unknown will remain so because they don’t have easily identifiable heirs — or, worse, because self-interested, or even uninterested executors, control their estates.

We should return to the Copyright Act of 1790 or, given the extremely short attention spans that prevail today, reduce the 14 years to 10.

The purpose of the copyright is to reward creators not to ensure the holdings of Disney stockholders. A return to the original purpose of the copyright is long overdue.

2 comments

Returning to Grand Rapids

In the Washington Post Jared Berstein and Somin Park have a very good op-ed about the measures that would actually promote U. S. manufacturing. Their claim is that tax policy is not nearly as important as other supportive policies and they use Grand Rapids as an example:

Here’s what Grand Rapids did:

  • Michigan devotes more resources than the average state to customized job training programs.
  • The local economic-development organization has invested great effort in developing clusters of related manufacturing industries that can work together to identify and solve common problems (e.g., skill needs).
  • The local area has a high-profile initiative, Talent 2025, which is trying to improve the area’s skills development from early childhood through adulthood.
  • Extensive infrastructure investments have been made in downtown Grand Rapids.
  • Local business interests put up funds for extensive subsidies that helped attract the medical school of Michigan State University to locate in Grand Rapids.

The bottom line is this: Before we accept the diagnosis that U.S. manufacturing is toast, there’s way more to do.

While I agree that there are all sorts of measures that could and should be taken by state and local governments to maintain manufacturing employment, IMO they’re conflating two very different things: federal taxes on the one hand and state local taxes on the other. Isn’t is possible that lowering federal taxes, particularly on businesses, could provide the headroom to allow state and local governments to collect additional tax revenue which could be used for the other measures they favor? That’s something that never seems to occur to them.

Additionally, I wish the op-ed (and the underlying paper on which they rely) did more to quantify the effects of the individual actions.

Finally, while Michigan’s tax policies have been pretty stable over the last decade, Illinois has raised taxes multiple times and actually collects more taxes per capita than Michigan does and has higher tax rates of every kind except for their personal income tax (Michigan has a higher individual deduction; I haven’t done the spadework to determine which state actually collects more personal income tax from its citizens). My point is that state and local policies need to be targeted at maintaining manufacturing employment. What are the forces that led Grand Rapids to do that while Chicago didn’t?

4 comments

Insufficient Othering

Is there any way to convince Tom Friedman to stop making false equivalences between the U. S. and China? His most recent New York Times column is practically a catalog of such equivalences. Is self-censorship for political reasons really the same thing as holding your tongue lest you be thrown into prison? When was the last time the U. S. murdered 50 million of its own citizens? The Chinese regime has done so within living memory. There is no effective rule of law in China. Nearly every day there’s news of checks on presidential power by the courts or the Congress in the United States. President Xi has just been made president-for-life.

The Chinese regime is genuinely different from our would-be aristocracy. For one thing China’s rulers don’t just imagine themselves to be elite as ours do. They are elite. I don’t think any productive purpose is served by attempting to diminish just how different China is from the United States.

1 comment