Giving Rather Than Getting

In her latest Washington Post column Megan McArdle makes a charmingly naive claim:

Blue-state taxpayers may finally have to confront the full cost of the government they want. And Democrats will finally have to confront the tension between what those voters want government to do and what they’re willing to pay for.

That reckoning is long overdue.

and

Blue-state professionals have enjoyed a disproportionate share of the prosperity gains over the past few decades; if they want a bigger government, they’ll have to give up those gains to fund it. But thus far, Democrats haven’t managed to convince these voters that providing lavish government to every state means that they need to be taxed like a Rockefeller — or even like a Dane.

I’ve mentioned this anecdote before. Back at the turn of the 20th century there was a chap named Elbert Hubbard. He and his wife died when the Lusitania was sunk. He was a successful entrepeneur and best-selling author who wrote the famous motivational A Message to Garcia. He founded a utopian community on a creative plan: the inhabitants were craftsmen who owned shares in the community’s profits, earned from selling the works created by the shareholders in the community, or derived them from the earned value of what they created. When asked by an interviewer whether he was a socialist, he responded “When 51% of the people want to give rather than get, I’ll be a socialist.”

There is presently precious little evidence that those who earn 51% of the income (we’re nothing like as egalitarian as Hubbard’s comment presupposed) want to give. High tax states, particularly high tax states without amenities like beautiful mountain vistas and benign climates, are finding that their erstwhile citizens would rather switch than fight—they’re leaving for places with lower taxes like Texas and Florida. The total effective tax rate Americans have been willing to pay has been remarkably stable for a very long time even as what government at all levels has disbursed has risen.

Just about anyone who earns more than $80,000 per year, the top quintile of income earners, is the beneficiary of government or some sort of government-sponsored market intervention. They’re government employees (firefighters, police officers, teachers), protected by occupational licenses or have their goods or services exempted from competition, foreign and domestic, by a variety of means like copyrights and patents.

The bill hasn’t come due yet but it will. Eventually the increase in interest payments will exceed the increases that can be realized by raising taxes. Raising marginal rates isn’t enough—you’ve to increase effective rates to derive additional revenue. That’s when the wheel will hit the road. I’m guessing that those with the money won’t be beneficent to dispense with it. They haven’t been so far.

0 comments

More Great-Great-Grandfathers

Since I’ve told you about a couple of my great-great-grandfathers, I may as well fill you in on the rest of them. My great-great-grandfather Schuler arrived in the United States shortly after the Civil War ended, just one step ahead of the sheriff. He’d lost the family’s money playing jass, a pinochle-like game peculiar to Switzerland. That’s even more serious than it sounds. Due to Switzerland’s peculiar method of social organization that meant that he didn’t just lose his own money but his brothers’, sisters’, and childrens’. Quite a disaster. Otherwise his life was fairly unremarkable. He made his way up the river from New Orleans, finally settling outside Louisville.

I know nothing about my great-great-grandfathers Fisher or Bader. I’m just about to hire a professional genealogist to research them for me.

My great-great-grandfather Schneider died of TB, too, also at age 33.

My great-great-grandfather Blanchard was born in Clinton County, New York, and moved to Buffalo where he lived for the rest of his life. He was an engineer.

My great-great-grandfather McCoy lived in Pittsburgh for a while, then moved the family to St. Louis. He served in a militia during the Civil War. Didn’t see any action as best as I can tell.

And that’s all of my great-great-grandfathers. The oldest was born in the 1820s, the youngest in the 1850s. They were a pretty colorful bunch.

0 comments

Flying Sucks

Not long after a woman was killed by being partly sucked out of an aircraft window, it’s happened again, this time on a Sichuan Airlines craft. NBC reports:

BEIJING — The cockpit was in chaos.

About an hour into a Sichuan Airlines flight headed from southwestern China to Tibet on Monday morning, the pilot heard a piercing sound, and then the windshield inexplicably shattered. Captain Liu Chuanjian found himself in a turbulent struggle to maintain control of a plane full of 119 passengers.

He turned to his co-pilot only to see “half his body suspended out of the window,” he said. “Fortunately, he was wearing a seat belt.”

Liu described the terror at 30,000 feet during a taped interview with the Chengdu Business News, while Sichuan Airlines thanked him and the crew in a statement for their life-saving actions. No one was killed.

What in the heck is going on? Coincidence? The large number of flights makes incidents like this inevitable? Omni-present smartphones make covering stuff like this up impossible? They’re flying differently? Faulty maintenance? What?

3 comments

Is It the B-Schools?

I think that John Benjamin’s attack on business schools in The New Republic is misplaced or at least inadequate. He’s critical of them because a) they don’t consider broader societal implications and b) they’re a monoculture:

But in truth, MBA programs are not the open forums advertised in admissions brochures. Behind this façade, they are ideological institutions committed to a strict blend of social liberalism and economic conservatism. Though this fusion may be the favorite of American elites—the kinds of people who might repeat that tired line “I’m socially liberal but fiscally conservative”—it takes a strange form in business school. Elite business schooling is tailored to promote two types of solutions to the big problems that arise in society: either greater innovation or freer markets. Proposals other than what’s essentially more business are brushed aside, or else patched over with a type of liberal politics that’s heavy on rhetorical flair but light on relevance outside privileged circles.

It is in this closed ideological loop that we wannabe masters of the universe often struggle to think clearly about the common good or what it takes to achieve it. Today’s MBA programs, insofar as they churn out graduates riveted to this worldview, limit the vision of future leaders at a time when public dissatisfaction with business and its institutions makes our complacency a danger.

I wonder what profession or sector would meet the standards Mr. Benjamin holds up? Do physicians routinely consider the global social implications of treating Patient A as opposed to Patient B? I know what an old boss of mine would say. “If I consider the global social implications, next quarter some other guy is going to be sitting in this chair who looks at the corporate earnings implications.”

My own criticism would be somewhat more basic and, in some ways, more realizeable. I’m not convinced that the strategies that would be effective for managing an automobile manufacturing company are the same as would be effective for an insurance company as would be the same for a software development company. IMO understanding the industry you’re working in is vital to making a good decision—decisions can’t be abstracted from circumstances.

The one area in which they can is finance and that’s why there’s a powerful temptation to turn every company into a financial holding company.

5 comments

Performing As Expected

At Law and Liberty James Wallner provides a succinct description of our present Congressional non-performance:

In theory, polarization makes it harder for senators to compromise by increasing the distance between the two parties. Senators agree on less and less as that gap widens and, as a consequence, the majority goes to greater lengths to avoid negotiating with the minority. Gridlock results when the gap becomes unbridgeable. At that point, the majority is left with no other choice but to eliminate the minority’s ability to obstruct if it wants to pass its agenda.

But in reality, the problem underlying Congress’s present dysfunction is a lack of effort, not polarization. That is, the Senate is mired in gridlock because its members are unwilling to expend the effort required to legislate successfully in a polarized environment.

He’s letting the House off too easily. The House has been inactive, too, and they don’t even have the excuse of the filibuster to blame. The House just isn’t working as hard as it used to.

I would say that the Congress is performing just about as expected. The notion that the Senate is where heated legislation goes to cool probably wasn’t said by Washington but it’s true nonetheless. When you add to that that the voters are less likely to penalize an incumbent for doing nothing than for acting against their wishes and that incumbents tend to get re-elected, House nonfeasance is perfectly understandable.

My solution to that has been to make serving in the Congress less of a sinecure, to increase substantially the number of members of the House, and to pay them a lot less. Don’t expect incumbents to support anything that would actually reform the Congress.

0 comments

What Enforcement Requires

At Outside the Beltway James Joyner laments the measures that have been taken to enforce our immigration laws:

Defense One reports “The Border Patrol’s ‘Constitution-Free’ Zone Is Probably Larger Than You Think.” Considering that I didn’t realize we had a Constitution-free zone, they’re certainly right.

[…]

I’ve long known, of course, that borders are essentially Constitution-free zones. I lived in El Paso for eighteen months and crossed into Juarez on a few occasions. Studying Constitutional Law as an undergraduate, I learned that the Supreme Court had, not unreasonably, ruled that pretty much all searches conducted at our borders were “reasonable” under the 4th Amendment.

[…]

Essentially, for the purposes of border enforcement, we’ve redefined “probable cause” as “looks Hispanic.” Combined with longstanding SCOTUS rulings that people in motor vehicles have essentially no expectation of privacy, this makes much of the country “Constitution-free.”

but towards the end of his post he gets to the crux of the matter:

In fairness, we’re a continental nation with a two thousand mile-long border with a developing nation.

I like to work from premises, identify objectives based on them, and then identify ways and means for accomplishing those objectives. James’s post presents an opportunity for me to return to themes common here. Here are my premises:

  1. American nationals have a right to live here.
  2. Mexican nationals don’t except as provided by law.
  3. Most Mexican nationals who come here don’t particularly want to live here; they come to work.

The objective, obviously enough, is to enforce our rights. That’s how I arrived at what I’ve suggested many times here. Rather than focusing on border control we should emulate our Canadian neighbors and put serious workplace enforcement regulations in place. As a balance to that we should issue a lot more work visas to Mexican nationals than we presently do although I recognize that’s more of a bone of contention.

I also think that need to stop patronizing Mexico. It’s no longer a poor country. It’s a middle income country with a lot of poor people in it. It’s quite capable of dealing with its own problems. We need to stop allowing its aristocracy to offload their problems onto us.

Immigration involves both push forces and pull forces. Historically, for Mexico the push forces have included population, demographics, social factors, and economics. Pull forces have been social and economic. Both the push forces and pull forces are weakening. Translated, that means that we should expect immigration from Mexico to slow which is precisely what has been happening.

4 comments

Rewriting the Rule Book

In the Wall Street Journal Walter Russell Mead has a lengthy analysis of President Trump’s strategy with respect to Iran. Here’s a generous slice of it:

America’s withdrawal from the Iran deal and relocation of its Israeli embassy to Jerusalem send an unmistakable signal about the emerging Trump foreign policy: The administration wants to enlarge American power rather than adjust to decline. For now at least, the Middle East is the centerpiece of this new assertiveness.

For President Obama, Iran’s rise was an unavoidable fact. Confronting Iran meant risking a war even bigger and uglier than the one in Iraq. Mr. Obama wasn’t only personally opposed to such a war, he believed that neither Congress nor public opinion would sustain it. The era in which the U.S. could dominate the Middle East was over; the wisest course was to negotiate an arrangement that would protect core U.S. interests and cover for an American withdrawal.

The Iran deal, President Obama and his supporters believe, accomplished all that and more. By taking the nuclear issue off the table, at least for the time being, the agreement averted the danger of a U.S.-Iranian military confrontation. Moreover, it weakened hard-liners inside Iran by undermining their core argument that Iran faced an external threat requiring permanent social mobilization even as it strengthened moderates by tying the country ever more closely to the world economy. If supported by the West, the Obama administration believed, moderates would gradually consign the Islamists to the political fringes.

From this perspective, the deal was a masterstroke of diplomacy. Its supporters now fear that Iranian and American hard-liners, energized by the failure of their more accommodating rivals, will steer the countries toward a policy of confrontation ending in war—and that the result of this war will be to accelerate rather than retard American decline in the Middle East and beyond.

President Trump’s approach is different. His instincts tell him that most Americans are anything but eager for a “post-American” world. Mr. Trump’s supporters don’t want long wars, but neither are they amenable to a stoic acceptance of national decline. As to the wisdom of accommodating Iran, Team Trump believes that empowering Iran is more likely to strengthen the hard-liners than the moderates. As Franklin Roosevelt once put it in a fireside chat, “No man can tame a tiger into a kitten by stroking it.”

I have a number of bones of contention with that analysis. First, can anyone provide a post-revolution example of Iran’s having attacked another country? Militarily I mean not rhetorically or covertly. More specifically, can anyone provide a post-revolution example of Iran’s having attacked the U. S.? I don’t think there are any. In that context how can Iran be deemed a threat to the U. S.? There’s a somewhat better argument that Iran is a threat to Israel or even to Saudi Arabia. Even that’s a stretch. Iran is a risk not a threat and wishing to live in a risk-free world is unrealistic. When backed up by military force it is malignant.

Second, isn’t it just barely possible that the perceived decline in U. S. power is associated with our trading soft power for hard? Judging by the number and size of our military interventions over the last 25 years, American power is at its zenith not its nadir. That we haven’t realized our strategic goals from these interventions isn’t because we haven’t employed enough force but because we’re trying to turn a screw with a hammer.

Third, let’s consider this a little more more closely:

Mr. Obama wasn’t only personally opposed to such a war, he believed that neither Congress nor public opinion would sustain it.

I see little evidence that the American people have become pacifists but I see lots of evidence that, confronted with no direct threat, the American people aren’t interested in deploying force to accomplish goals in which they have no particular stake. Costs with few benefits.

I realize it’s a revolutionary thought but what if, rather than pursuing German or Saudi interests, we considered pursuing our own? Ending sanctions against Iran is a German interest; beating the Iranians down a Saudi and an Israeli. They cannot be pursued simultaneously.

11 comments

Why Is One Not Like the Others?

Health economist Austin Frakt expresses puzzlement in his latest op-ed in the New York Times. Why does the United States pay more for health care than other OECD countries without benefits to life expectancy comparable to those in other OECD countries?

“Medical care is one of the less important determinants of life expectancy,” said Joseph Newhouse, a health economist at Harvard. “Socioeconomic status and other social factors exert larger influences on longevity.”

For spending, many experts point to differences in public policy on health care financing. “Other countries have been able to put limits on health care prices and spending” with government policies, said Paul Starr, professor of sociology and public affairs at Princeton. The United States has relied more on market forces, which have been less effective.

“Confronted with fiscal pressures, as the share of G.D.P. absorbed by health care spending began to get serious, other nations had mechanisms to hold down spending,” said Henry Aaron, a health economist with the Brookings Institution. “We didn’t.”

One result: Prices for health care goods and services are much higher in the United States. Gerard Anderson, a professor at Johns Hopkins and a lead author of a Health Affairs study on the subject, emphasized this point. “The differential between what the U.S. and other industrialized countries pay for prescriptions and for hospital and physician services continues to widen over time,” he said. Other studies also support this idea. However, by some measures, growth in the amount of health care consumed has also been a factor.

Possible explanations are low levels of competition in the health care sector, higher insurance administrative costs, a more diverse population, and the lack of universal coverage are all considered. None really explains the difference between the U. S. and other OECD countries and in particular why improvements in life expectancy slowed in the U. S. while health care spending didn’t.

In the end we’re left with a mystery. Are Americans just worse patients? That’s an explanation frequently given by health care providers. Is it possible that you get what you pay for? At least that’s the best case scenario. In the U. S. we pay for procedures. Increased intervention isn’t always associated with improved outcomes but increased costs are.

2 comments

No Physicist Left Behind

Here’s a potential explanation for the plea for more students in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. From Heather Mac Donald at City Journal:

Identity politics has engulfed the humanities and social sciences on American campuses; now it is taking over the hard sciences. The STEM fields—science, technology, engineering, and math—are under attack for being insufficiently “diverse.” The pressure to increase the representation of females, blacks, and Hispanics comes from the federal government, university administrators, and scientific societies themselves. That pressure is changing how science is taught and how scientific qualifications are evaluated. The results will be disastrous for scientific innovation and for American competitiveness.

A scientist at UCLA reports: “All across the country the big question now in STEM is: how can we promote more women and minorities by ‘changing’ (i.e., lowering) the requirements we had previously set for graduate level study?” Mathematical problem-solving is being deemphasized in favor of more qualitative group projects; the pace of undergraduate physics education is being slowed down so that no one gets left behind.

Apparently, having absorbed the humanities, diversity advocates wept because there were no more worlds to conquer.

Actually, it makes perfect sense. When you believe that everything including the laws of physics are social constructs, you’ll want to push engineering and the sciences in your own preferred direction.

Scientists and engineers are no more immune to prejudices, preferences, priorities, and agendas than any other human being. The challenge for engineering and the sciences is less in capitalizing on these differing points of view than in subordinating them through the vigorous and vigilant application of the scientific method. Objectivity is not impossible; it is difficult.

Here’s a question for you. Is the movie Hidden Figures about how racism and sexism suppressed black women capable of making great contributions to the space program? Or is it a parable of how concentrating on good work let those women make their contributions? Is it more important to do the work or get the credit?

8 comments

Another Great-Great-Grandfather

As a counter-balance to the story of my great-great-grandfather Charles Wagner, I thought I’d tell you a little about another of my great-great-grandfathers, Edward Flanagan. I find this episode from his life oddly emblematic of the difference between my father’s family and my mother’s.

Like Charles Wagner, Edward Flanagan volunteered to serve the Union during the Civil War. At 14 he joined a unit in Missouri. Then, hearing that a unit in Illinois paid more, he crossed the river and joined the Illinois unit, serving with that unit for a time. He doesn’t appear in any unit records. I only know about this because later in life he applied for a pension as a Union veteran. The War Department turned him down on the grounds that he had never been properly mustered in to any unit. However, they were kind enough rescind his status of deserter from the first unit with which he served.

He led an interesting but hard life which I think I’ve recounted elsewhere. He was tall, rangy and good-looking and, honestly, I wish I looked more like that side of the family.

2 comments