Bad Leadership

The editors of the Wall Street Journal chortle over the prospect of Donald Trump appointing another Supreme Court Justice:

Schadenfreude is overrated, but it is amusing to see Democrats apoplectic that Republicans might confirm a Supreme Court Justice with 51 Senate votes. Let’s review the tape on the Sage of Searchlight, Nevada, because Harry Reid made this moment possible by blowing up the filibuster for judicial nominees.

Democrats are in various stages of grief about the retirement of Justice Anthony Kennedy but the prevailing mood is rage. Democrats are insisting that the Senate not confirm a replacement until after the November election. The left is still furious that GOP Leader Mitch McConnell barred until after the 2016 election a vote on Merrick Garland, President Obama’s nominee to replace Antonin Scalia. They think Mr. McConnell should be “consistent” now.

But that Court opening came amid a presidential election, when Americans decide who will determine the direction of the courts for four years. No less than a quarter of Donald Trump’s voters said their reason was the Supreme Court. Hillary Clinton would have had her pick of nominees, and Mr. Garland or a more radical jurist would be on the Court. The real Democratic grievance as ever should be with Mrs. Clinton for losing.

Supreme Court confirmations ahead of a midterm election are routine. The Senate confirmed Justice Elena Kagan in August 2010, Justice Samuel Alito in 2006, Justice Stephen Breyer in 1994, and David Souter a month before midterms in 1990. The Great Scalia was confirmed in September 1986.

If Democrats are unable to stop Republicans from confirming a new Justice, they can also thank Mr. Reid. In 2013 the Democratic Majority Leader changed Senate rules on a party-line vote and ended the filibuster on appellate court and executive nominees. That allowed Democrats to pack the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals and win some favorable rulings on Mr. Obama’s regulatory agenda.

I wish that, rather than blaming Republicans, more Democrats would point the finger where it belongs: bad Democratic leadership particularly in the Congress. The list of particulars is enormous including not just Harry Reid’s decision to curtail the filibuster on presidential appointments but the decision to pass major social legislation on a straight party-line vote, an inadequate and politically motivated stimulus package, and enacting the largest tax increase on working people in the history of the republic.. Blame the Democratic leadership, too, both for Hillary Clinton’s nomination and her loss.

These are among the reasons that I consider the Pelosi-Reid Congress the worst of my lifetime. The Democrats have been saved somewhat by bad Republican leadership both on the part of the Boehner-McConnell Congress and then the Ryan-McConnell Congress.

That leadership will ultimately be replaced. Time is not on its side. I hope that Democrats don’t decide to replace it by bringing Chavismo to the United States. It’s been so successful in Venezuela.

3 comments

Dial It Back

Turn down the temperature. Control your anger. That goes for everybody.

There are a lot of crazy people out there.

4 comments

The Cold Equations, Again

Something that I don’t believe that most people realize is that a family can come into the United States illegally on Sunday and, in most if not all states, register their kids at a public school on Monday. In Illinois the average cost per elementary school student is about $12,000.

It is estimated that there are over 40,000 school age children in Illinois who have entered the U. S. illegally. That represents a cost of around a half billion per year that the state and local governments just can’t afford.

Illinois is strapped. We don’t have the money to sustain that sort of expense.

24 comments

The Seat-By-Seat Races

I want to commend to your attention Kyle Kondik’s post at Larry Sabato’s Crystal Ball, analyzing the House races one by one. Here’s the short version. Which party will hold the House in 2019 is presently too close to call:

Today’s seven ratings changes are all toward the Democrats, and the overall ratings now show 208 seats at least leaning to the Republicans, 199 at least leaning to the Democrats, and 28 Toss-ups. To win the House under the current ratings, Democrats would have to win two-thirds of the Toss-ups. In the event of a good Democratic environment in the fall, that would not be unreasonable to expect.

If the Democrats run good campaigns and don’t go out of their way to make any mistakes, they have a good chance of taking the House.

2 comments

Janus in Illinois

The editors of the Chicago Tribune react to the Supreme Court’s decision in Janus v. AFSCME:

We’re intrigued — and hopeful — about the implications of Janus v. AFSCME Council 31. If government workers don’t have to contribute, maybe this begins a reckoning for the political class of Illinois. We’re not great fans of that symbiosis between one party and the public’s workforce. Unions have a vested interest in the taxing-and-spending status quo in Illinois, which in fiscal terms is a disaster. Democrats have been too happy to go along for the ride, saddling taxpayers with enormous public debts. The results for this state and its economy are political gridlock and disappointment: Illinois has weak job growth, a bleak credit rating and a $130 billion hole in the state’s pension funds. Those are largely byproducts of the hand-holding between unions and Dems.

I don’t object to public employees receiving fair wages for their efforts. I do disagree with recycling union dues into political contributions which are then transmogrified into raises for public employees. Nearly everyone wants more money. There needs to be some way of limiting public employee wage demands to what the communities they purport to serve can afford to pay and right now in Illinois that is absent in the corrupt arrangement between public employee unions and elected officials.

6 comments

Winners and Losers

At the Wall Street Journal James Freeman notes:

The number of job openings in the United States is at an all-time high, and a new report due out today shows American businesses of all sizes trying to find the workers they need to meet the demands of a rising economy. ManpowerGroup surveyed more than 2,000 U.S. employers and finds that 46% report difficulty filling jobs. “Skilled trade workers, sales representatives and drivers remain the hardest roles to fill,” according to the Milwaukee-based staffing company.

“Most of the jobs where demand is growing are mid-skilled roles such as electricians, welders and mechanics that require training, yet not always a four-year college degree,” reports Manpower Group, adding:

Although unemployment remains low, there are millions of workers on the edge of the U.S. labor market. Companies are bringing in workers from the sidelines to fill talent gaps and 40% are looking at different talent pools for skills including boomerang retirees, long-term unemployed or returning parents and part-timers.

Over the period of the last several decades public funding for vocational training has plummeted while funding for higher education has soared. That didn’t reflect demand. It reflected the prejudice of lawmakers, mostly lawyers themselves, in favor of people like themselves.

Big money for higher education while eliminating vocational training from public high schools is an egregious instance of picking winners and losers. People who go to college are winners; everybody else is a loser.

But at least half of Americans and possibly as many as two-thirds simply aren’t college material. They aren’t interested in what college has to offer; they aren’t prepared for what they will need to do in college; they don’t have the skills or abilities to succeed.

Additionally, you need to look deeper into those “Help Wanted” ads. Employers aren’t just looking for skills; they’re looking for five or seven or ten years of experience but not fifteen or twenty. You can train someone to be a welder or an electrician but you can’t put someone through a few weeks or months of training and have them emerge with five years of experience in their newly-learned skill.

Human beings aren’t like drill presses or welding stations. You can’t just bring them online when you need them and put them on the shelf when you don’t.

4 comments

The WSJ on Kennedy’s Departure

Although I think that they’re far too kind to Justice Kennedy, I agree with this observation on the part of the editors of the Wall Street Journal about his departure:

As for the Court after Justice Kennedy, we doubt it will overturn his precedents on abortion or gay marriage. Even with a new conservative Justice, Chief Justice Roberts remains a legal and political wild card, and we use those words advisedly. He will certainly not want the Court to overturn the gay marriage case so soon after it was decided, lest it make the Justices seem too political.

As for Roe v. Wade, the abortion case was a legal travesty and should be overturned. But the Court has upheld its core right so many times that the Chief Justice and perhaps even the other conservatives aren’t likely to overrule stare decisis on a 5-4 vote. The likelier judicial path would be to allow the states modestly more room to regulate abortion while preserving the right.

Our point is that replacing Justice Kennedy should not be the legal war to end all wars. A single Justice will not turn the Court sharply to the right, and Republican Senators should not be intimidated by hyperbolic Democratic claims designed to fire up their voters for the November election.

Trump-hatred and the longing of Democrats for revenge for the Republicans’ slight of President Obama are powerful forces and continue to rankle. Sadly, I don’t think that the editors’ advice will be heeded.

5 comments

The Law Should Prevail

At the Washington Post Sarah Turberville and Anthony Marcum point out something I have noted and documented multiple times:

The ratio is staggering. According to the Supreme Court Database, since 2000 a unanimous decision has been more likely than any other result — averaging 36 percent of all decisions. Even when the court did not reach a unanimous judgment, the justices often secured overwhelming majorities, with 7-2 or 8-1 judgments making up roughly 15 percent of decisions. The 5-4 decisions, by comparison, occurred in only 19 percent of cases.

or, said another way, the emphasis on the 5-4 decisions misrepresents what the Supreme Court is doing. In by far the greater number of cases the law is actually pretty clear.

What is missing from the discussion is that there are only two reasons that cases make it to the Supreme Court at all. Either lower courts have erred, including by ideological bias, or the parties involved aren’t satisfied with the law, want an outcome that can’t be supported by the law, and want the Supreme Court to give it to them.

In such cases we should not rejoice when the Supreme Court gives it to them. The law should prevail. Making an end run around the law through the Supreme Court creates lasting societal rifts and these build, one on the other.

2 comments

Law, Politics, and Outcomes

I think that Ilya Shapiro says what needed to be said about Justice Anthony Kennedy on the occasion of the announcement of his retirement in his op-ed in the Washington Post:

Even if you generally liked how Justice Anthony M. Kennedy voted, you had to scratch your head at how he got there. I should know; during his time on the bench, he agreed with the Cato Institute more than any other justice did. Cato was the only organization in the country, for example, to file briefs supporting the side that got Kennedy’s vote in virtually all the big cases: District of Columbia v. Heller ( Second Amendment), Citizens United vs. Federal Election Commission ( campaign finance), Shelby County v. Holder ( voting rights), United States v. Windsor (Defense of Marriage Act), National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius ( Obamacare), Obergefell v. Hodges (same-sex marriage) and this term’s Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission ( free exercise clause ).

But that didn’t make him any less frustrating to libertarians — at least those of us who care about the rule of law rather than simply achieving what we consider to be good policy results.

Take his celebrated opinion in Obergefell in 2015. What should have been an easy case about the propriety of certain marriage-licensing schemes under an equal protection clause that says the government can’t treat people differently for no good reason, instead became yet another opportunity to wax poetic about the meaning of life. The rule of Obergefell seems to be that you take a scoop of due process and a cup of equal protection, wrap them in some dignity, and then enjoy the waves of adulation.

That’s not law.

Particularly in a common law system like ours, the destination is not the only important thing. How you get there is vitally important, even more important than the outcome.

As I noted yesterday, Justice Kennedy is a very conservative justice with strong libertarian leanings who votes from his political convictions and backs the law out of it. He has not been a good judge. A good judge’s opinions comport with the law regardless of his or her political views.

Any wailing and gnashing of teeth about Trump’s appointing a conservative justice to replace Kennedy upsetting the balance of the court is greatly exaggerated. It would preserve the balance of the court except in cases where Kennedy’s sexual libertarian streak would have guided him.

Let’s hope for a justice who follows the law over his or her heart. That’s what good judges do.

3 comments

Kennedy to Retire

This isn’t a news blog but this particular news item is of sufficient significance I felt I needed to post on it. Supreme Court Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy today announced that he would be retiring, effective July 31. From NBC News:

WASHINGTON — Supreme Court Justice Anthony M. Kennedy announced Wednesday that he will retire at the end of next month, preparing the way for the most significant change in the court’s makeup in half a century.

The vacancy will allow President Donald Trump to make the U.S. Supreme court a solidly conservative body for years, if not generations, to come — a towering legacy of his time in office.

Trump said Wednesday shortly after Kennedy’s announcement that a search for his replacement would begin immediately and he thanked the justice for his service.

A spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said he saw no reason why a new justice couldn’t be confirmed before the midterm elections in November. McConnell himself said on the Senate floor that the vote to confirm Kennedy’s successor would take place “this fall.”

Here are some predictions on the outcome of this development:

  • Trump will appoint a reasonably conservative justice to replace Kennedy
  • Democrats will start making rumblings about blocking the appointment as Republicans blocked Merrick Garland’s appointment by Obama
  • As the midterm elections near and the obstructionist move actually starts looking as though it will hurt their prospects in November, the Democratic leadership will back off and Trump’s appointment will be confirmed before the election.

Several observations. First, I think that Justice Kennedy is actually a pretty conservative jurist. He is, however, a sexual libertarian and that makes what is otherwise a pretty conservative record seem more progressive.

Second, the Supreme Court is about to become more conservative. That will undoubtedly make Ruth Bader Ginburg, Sonya Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan feel more embattled. What the consequences of that might be I have no idea.

Finally, President Obama really should have persuaded Ruth Bader Ginsburg to retire in 2015. There is an increasingly strong risk that Donald Trump will appoint three or more Supreme Court justices.

14 comments