Unlikely Outcomes

In a piece at the New York Times Nate Cohn reviews some of the possible outcomes in the midterm elections. I recommend you read the whole thing but here is the kernel of his piece:

The possibility that the Kavanaugh nomination is helping Republicans in Republican-leaning areas is important because the fight for control of both the House and the Senate will be determined largely in Republican-leaning areas. This simple fact has always been the G.O.P.’s biggest advantage. If the electorate is polarized along the lines of recent presidential elections, as it was during the Obama presidency, Republicans could hold down their losses considerably.

Democrats have been considered clear favorites in the fight for House control because polls and special election results have made it seem that the electorate wouldn’t be so polarized, allowing them to compete in many Republican-leaning districts. But if Democrats can’t break through and actually carry the many Republican-leaning districts they’ve put into play, Republicans could stay highly competitive in the fight for House control and even survive a wave election.

A lot of the commentary including mine has focused on the likely outcomes and Mr. Cohn’s is no exception. The greatest likelihoods are either that the Democrats eke out a narrow victory in the House and fail to take the Senate (which I’ve been predicting for some time), the Democrats receive a narrow House majority and an even narrower majority in the Senate, or that Democrats fall short of taking control of either house of Congress.

Let’s consider some of the less likely alternatives.

The Democrats pick up large majorities in both houses of Congress

For Democrats to pick up as large a majority in the House as the Republicans have now they’d need to net 50 seats or more. That has happened twice in midterm elections in the post-war period and in both cases it was the Republicans who accomplished the feat. It’s not beyond the realm of possibility but it’s very unlikely.

The Republicans pick up seats in both houses of Congress

By my reckoning the president’s party picking up seats in both houses has happened exactly once since the end of World War II—in 2002—and again it was the Republicans who did it. Given the present polls and President Trump’s approval rating, I think this is quite unlikely. At the time of the 2002 midterms President Bush’s approval rating was 68%, something hard to imagine now.

The Democrats pick up seats in the House and lose seats in the Senate

The president’s party losing seats in the House and picking them up in the Senate has happened three times in the post-war period: in 1962, 1970, and 1982. This is not an outcome that Democrats should wish for. In each case the House gains were small—not nearly enough for a majority—and Senate gains would strengthen the Republicans’ hand. IMO this particular outcome is nearly as likely as the likely outcomes of the prevailing wisdom.

2 comments

Healing Chicago’s Wounds

In their editorial following the Van Dyke verdict the editors of the Chicago Tribune touch on several of the same themes I did in my reaction piece:

On the night of the shooting, a police union spokesman at the scene fed reporters a false narrative in which Van Dyke fired in self-defense after McDonald lunged at him with a knife. The Police Department’s official statement did not correct the falsehoods. Van Dyke’s fellow officers closed ranks, coordinating their stories to protect him. Three of them now face criminal charges for conspiring to provide “virtually identical false information,” according to prosecutors.

The video told a different story. And it revealed some outrageous malfeasance. Questions about the lack of sound with the images led to the discovery that many officers were routinely disabling their vehicles’ cameras or audio — at least five other cameras had recorded video at the scene, all without sound. The Cook County state’s attorney’s office acknowledged that video supplied by police in other criminal cases rarely included audio. Neither prosecutors nor police supervisors had bothered to find out why.

We’re recounting all of this as a reminder that McDonald’s death exposed much more than what Mayor Rahm Emanuel first tried to present as a problem with “one individual.” It revealed systemic failures in the Police Department, from top to bottom. It showed the complicity of generations of politicians who were eager to look the other way.

Sustained outrage over McDonald’s death has forced the city to acknowledge those failures and work in earnest to address them. Real progress has been made, but there is still a long way to go before Chicagoans are confident that police officers are being held accountable for their actions.

While the verdict may begin the healing of Chicago’s wounds, it’s only the first of what must be many steps. The personnel, recruitment, training, and assignment strategies of the Chicago Police Department need to be changed. None of those can be effected with the present union representing the police officers. It should be decertified. I don’t object to police officers having union representation but I do object to union representation that makes it impossible to discipline the police force. As the editors point out, what has been revealed is a systemic problem not one of a few individuals. It’s not just a few apples; it’s the barrel.

I don’t believe that any regular Democrat will make the moves necessary. Can you imagine Bill Daley or Gerry Chico going toe-to-toe with the FOP? They will not alienate people whose support they need to maintain Democratic hegemony in Chicago. They’ll use the same strategy the late Mayor Daley did in negotiating with public employees’ unions. He’d go into a closed door meeting, give them whatever they wanted, and then announce victory.

4 comments

We Don’t Need the Russians

There is no lack of bitter complaint or recrimination following the confirmation of President Trump’s appointee, Brett Kavanaugh, to the Supreme Court yesterday by a 50-48 vote. A single Democrat, Joe Manchin of West Virginia voted for Kavanaugh’s confirmation. One Republican, Alaska’s Lisa Murkowski, abstained. The editors of the New York Times declaim:

The degrading spectacle of Judge Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation process is behind us; the degrading era of his service on the Supreme Court lies ahead. If senators vote as expected on Saturday, Judge Kavanaugh, with a razor-thin victory on an almost strict party-line Senate vote, will be sworn in as the newest associate justice of the Supreme Court as early as next week.

Credible accusations of sexual assault, lies told under oath, explicitly partisan attacks on the senators trying to assess his fitness to serve: None of it was enough to give Republican leaders more than momentary pause in their campaign to seize decisive control of the Supreme Court.

while the editors of the Washington Post strike a more reasoned note:

THE SENATE voted Saturday to confirm Brett M. Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court, after one of the most contentious nomination battles in history and by the slimmest margin for a justice in the modern era. Now, difficult as this seems, it will be up to the new justice to seek to reassure a country riven over his selection that he has the temperament and judgment to do the job; as important, it will be up to the court as a whole to demonstrate that it is not just another partisan institution. And it will be up to those who opposed his confirmation, including this page, to evaluate Mr. Kavanaugh fairly in his new position.

Many Americans believe, with reason, that the GOP-majority Senate muscled the Kavanaugh nomination through in its drive to install a reliable fifth conservative vote. Now, an increasingly dysfunctional Congress and a wayward presidency threaten to place more demands on this new court to address major social problems and perhaps even defuse threats to the nation’s constitutional order. Meantime, a cemented conservative majority will face temptations to wreak major changes in the law. As they confront these challenges, the justices must act as the careful, restrained jurists they claim to be, not the partisans in robes many fear.

Democrats are right to complain that Republicans blocked the appointment of President Obama’s appointee, Merrick Garland. But it ain’t beanbag and they are wrong to argue, as they persistently have, that two wrongs make a right. It would be easier to take their bitterness more seriously if they hadn’t drummed up charge after charge against appointees by Republican presidents, if they had not treated Christine Blasey Ford as shabbily as they have, and if they didn’t defend their own accused of much worse offenses than those of which now Supreme Court Justice Kavanaugh was accused by Dr. Ford.

In my view President Trump should have withdrawn his appointment of Brett Kavanaugh and appointed someone else in his place whom the Senate could have quickly moved to confirm. That would have been terribly unfair to Judge Kavanaugh but it might have avoided what is now an open sore, likely to fester over the course of a generation.

The new tack of the Democrats appears to be to complain about the terrible unfairness of our present electoral system, conveniently forgetting that Bill Clinton was elected twice by minorities of the electorate and to delegitimize the Supreme Court. Perhaps the best outcome of this whole sorry chapter would be if Democrats were to suddenly rediscover federalism.

We don’t need the Russians to challenge the legitimacy of our system. We’re doing a fine job without them.

9 comments

The Worst Job in Politics

At Politico Theodoric Meyer wonders why anyone would seek to become governor of Illinois:

Illinois — the sixth-biggest state, by population — has seen its credit rating cut to near-junk status in the decade since the financial crisis. Its bonds are now considered as risky as those of Russia and Romania. Its pension system is in worse shape than that of almost any other state. Springfield, the state capital, has grown so paralyzed that Illinois’ own governor compared the state to “a banana republic.” And a bitter standoff between Rauner, a Republican, and Democrats in the state Legislature has left Illinois more than $7 billion in unpaid bills and a sense among the state’s residents and creditors that Illinois might not be governable anymore.

“The state is on the edge of financial collapse,” says Laurence Msall, president of the Civic Federation, a good-government nonprofit in Chicago. What scares budget experts the most is that Illinois is facing a fiscal crisis even as the national economy, and the state’s, is roaring ahead. The unemployment rate in Illinois is 4.1 percent. “If there’s a hiccup in the economy, if there is something that’s unexpected, Illinois does not have reserves to basically weather any economic downturn at this point,” Msall says.

He barely scratches the surface of Illinois’s problems. Not the least problem is that the state is effectively ruled by a man, sometimes called the “most corrupt politician in American politics”, who only needs to get 10,000 votes to stay in office.

A month from now multi-billionaire J. B. Pritzker will likely be elected Illinois’s next governor over incumbent billionaire Bruce Rauner. Pritzker is running on a tax and spend platform, most of the provisions of which are either violations of the U. S. constitution, the Illinois constitution, or impossible to get through the state legislature. It is fantasy as a substitute for policy. The legislature stands four square against any measure which might actually solve Illinois’s problems. Worst job, indeed.

5 comments

No Way Out

At RealClearPolitics Nancy Jacobson of No Labels wonders how we can dig our way out of the pit of partisan politics we have dug for ourselves:

There is one clear way to signal this change, establishing a beacon for the clear majority of Americans aghast at the current state of our politics. We need a unity ticket. We need a major party’s presidential nominee to select as his or her running mate a person from the other party. We need the two of them — two leaders who may not agree on every issue, but agree that America is worth the compromise our democracy demands — to stand in stark contrast to those who would keep pushing the country further along its disastrous current trajectory. As people working through the group No Labels have begun to argue, nothing would signal that enough is enough as powerfully as a Democrat and Republic running on the same party ticket.

I think she’s dreaming. Many explanations for our present situation have been proposed:

  1. Russian meddling
  2. Chinese meddling
  3. It’s all the Republicans’ fault.
  4. It’s all the Democrats’ fault.
  5. It’s the outcome of a bipartisan consensus among elected officials to pursue goals not favored by most Americans using means not favored by most Americans.

I lean towards #5 and there’s no clear remedy for it short of a broad reaction against incumbents, something not yet in evidence. Does it make any difference which candidate you vote for when either will inevitably support endless war? Or crony capitalism?

2 comments

Why Not Direct Democracy?

As I read this jeremiad on how unfair our present national electoral system is by Kathy Gill at The Moderate Voice:

Yet in a very real sense, that 51-49 vote on Friday represented the tyranny of the minority, just like the committee vote that preceded it.

Those 51 senators represent only 44% of the U.S. population.

The 49 opposition senators (46 Democrats, two Independents, one Republican) represent 56% of the U.S. population.

On the Senate Judiciary Committee, all Republican members are men; 51% of the U.S. population is female. Most women in America, according to polls, oppose Kavanaugh’s nomination.

Tyranny of the minority.

it occurred to me how narrow the analysis was. Why are party and gender the only things that matter in electoral politics? Why does party matter at all? I don’t think that Ms. Gill realizes how ironic her use of a quote from James Madison was. Madison thought that political parties as such were problematic.

The Democratic Party is already majority minority or very nearly so but that’s not reflected among the Democratic House representative or senators. If it were there would be many more black and Hispanic representatives and senators than at present. If you’re going to argue for proportional representation, proportion of what? Total population, legally resident population, voting age population, eligible voters, registered voters, voters? In a country where the majority of those registered to vote can’t be bothered to do so, it’s hard to sympathize.

Switzerland approximates direct democracy. Every matter of significance is put to a popular vote but Switzerland is small. Would such a system work in the U. S.? Why is representative democracy sacrosanct?

As I have tried to make clear over the years, I favor federalism, subsidiarity, and a federal government limited to its enumerated powers. “Subsidiarity” means that government action and authority resides at the lowest practicable level. In the U. S. that would require an enormous devolution of power back to state and local governments. The irony of holding those views and residing in the state of Illinois is not lost on me. I believe that our present system infantilizes state governments until we get, well, Illinois. An epitome of what I believe is that I think that banks should not be able to operate across state lines and that they should be regulated by states.

9 comments

One Month Out

One month before the midterm elections the analysis of the likely outcome of the elections from one of the best sources of which I’m aware, Larry Sabato’s Crystal Ball at the University of Virginia summarizes the state of the House:

Our best guess in the House right now remains a Democratic net gain in the low-to-mid 30s, with enough uncertainty that we would not rule out the Democratic gains sputtering out short of the 23-seat net gain they need.

and Senate:

As we noted last week, Democrats need to win 80% of all the Senate races this year (28 of 35) to win the Senate, something a party has accomplished only twice before in more than a century of Senate popular elections. We remain skeptical of their ability to do so but we won’t rule it out either.

Let me summarize it this way. It is possible that the Democrats will take both the House and the Senate. It is possible that the Republicans will eke out a victory and continue to hold both the House and the Senate. It is likely that the Democrats will narrowly take control of the House while the Republicans continue to control the Senate. Which is about what I said six months ago.

If the elections actually turn on who shows up to vote and in what numbers, judging from the polling data the Democrats have made a strategic error. Back in July the Democrats were favored in the “enthusiasm gap” by a comfortable 14 points (the prevailing wisdom is that if the Democrats are up by 7 points or more, they win). Now they’re up by 1 point, well within the margin of error meaning Republicans might actually be more motivated than Democrats at this point.

7 comments

Laquan McDonald’s Killer Convicted

The Chicago Tribune reports that the police officer who shot and killed Laquan McDonald, the events captured on video, has been convicted of 2nd degree murder:

A Cook County jury convicted Chicago police Officer Jason Van Dyke of second-degree murder in the shooting of Laquan McDonald.

The eight-woman, four-man jury deliberated about 7 ½ hours over two days before reaching its verdict.1:59 p.m. Van Dyke also convicted of 16 counts of aggravated battery

The jury also convicted Van Dyke of all 16 counts of aggravated battery — one for every shot he fired at Laquan McDonald.

He was acquitted on the single charge of official misconduct.

When my wife asked me my opinion of the case a few days ago, I responded that if Van Dyke were not to be convicted it would be proof positive that a Chicago police officer couldn’t be convicted of anything in a Cook County court. Perhaps this conviction will begin healing some of the ill feelings between the Chicago police and the communities on the South and West sides of the city. I’m not optimistic but you can always hope.

4 comments

IQ <> Success

At Nautilus Dean Keith Simonton explains something I’ve remarked on many times. IQ is a weak predictor of success in life:

The relation between IQ and achieved eminence is not huge or even large. Most statisticians would classify it as a “moderate” relationship. In practical terms, that means that there’s ample room for exceptions at either end. The highly eminent can have IQs lower than average and supremely high IQs can be associated with relative obscurity. I’ve already given three examples of the former, so who illustrates the latter? How about Paolo Sarpi, the Venetian historian? Although his estimated IQ was as high as 195, making him one of the very brightest among the 301, his eminence ranking put him in the lower 20 percent, that is, 242nd!

A more contemporary example is Marilyn vos Savant, who was once listed in the Guinness Book of World Records as having the highest recorded IQ. Reportedly, she had taken a revised version of the Stanford-Binet when she was just 10 years old, and got a perfect score! Although there’s some debate about how best to translate that performance into a precise IQ estimate, it is certainly arguable that she is more intelligent than the brightest Termite and any member of Cox’s 301. Yet what is her main accomplishment? Becoming famous for her super-high IQ!

It always amuses me how the fans of certain politicians put so much stock in the high IQs of their idols. They’re confusing IQ and accomplishment. Everything we know about Barack Obama or Bill Clinton tells us that their IQs are between median and one standard deviation above normal—completely ordinary members of the professional class. But there are other kinds of smarts than IQ, notably socio-emotional development which includes the ability to get people to do what you want. Bill Clinton in particular has that ability in spades. That’s a genius of sorts but it has little relationship with IQ.

8 comments

Mug’s Game

I see that others are pointing out that reducing carbon emissions is a mug’s game. At RealClearEnergy Beau Rothschild articulates the case for carbon capture:

Next month, United Nations scientists are set to report that we can no longer win the battle against climate change by reducing carbon emissions: we have to start draining those emissions from the air. This conclusion simply adds to a growing scientific consensus that carbon removal technologies that actively remove CO2 already in circulation can be delayed no longer. Thus far, the U.S. government has only shown lukewarm support for these technologies, but America has as much to gain as anyone from their mass adoption. It’s time for President Donald J. Trump and his administration to take a second look at this issue to put America first in carbon capture technology.

The UN report is hardly surprising given the problems that have blighted the Paris climate agreement. Trump, of course, has already pulled out, and many other countries are showing indifference; a report earlier this year ranked three-quarters of EU member-states “poor” in their attempts to meet their Paris obligations. A recent meeting, supposed to lay down a set of rules for the agreement’s implementation, ended in deadlock – the latest in a series of tetchy summits that have exposed political fault lines in the accord.

He goes on to touch on various technologies for accomplishing this from planting trees to carbon capture and storage systems. In the past I’ve mentioned artificial trees. As he notes, the places to install these devices are coal-fired power plants.

9 comments