Virtuous Cycle

At Arc Digital Julian Adorney argues for the creation of a virtuous cycle:

But for the past two decades, partisan hatred has been on the rise. Social psychologist Jonathan Haidt and political scientist Sam Abrams point to one cause: “rule changes and culture changes in Congress made it harder to maintain cross-party friendships.” With the decline of these friendships, civility in Washington has frayed.

In the Trump era, that hostile, partisan atmosphere describes the whole country. The lack of civility threatens to push us further away from a unified nation into two warring camps.

There is another way. Sometimes in a conflict, one party will offer the other an olive branch. Kindness, like hostility, is reciprocated. This can trigger a benevolent cycle, as one party de-escalates and apologizes, prompting the other party to do the same, until civility and goodwill are restored. But someone has to take the first step.

to oppose escalating incivility. Requite evil with good. I think that such a thing is only possible in a Kantian ethical system; it’s practically incomprehensible to instrumentalists.

IMO one of the factors in the rising political temperature is suburbanism. Civility is by definition the qualities or habits needed to live in a city. When most of the people live in the suburbs they may never have developed the skills necessary to be civil. They think it’s optional.

11 comments

Where the Parasites Are

The argument that Tyler Cowen is trying to make in his piece at Bloomberg:

Following the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, there have been many calls for reexamining the U.S.-Saudi relationship, even for imposing sanctions. As an economist, I understand there are diplomatic fine points to this relationship that lie beyond my expertise, but still: It is worth reviewing the economic and exchange-based reasons why U.S.-Saudi relations have been so robust.

First, trade between the U.S. and Saudi Arabia is currently about $24 billion per year. You might think that the U.S. is now energy-independent, but many U.S. allies, most notably Japan, rely on oil imports. Part of the larger U.S. foreign policy stance is promising those allies freedom from major supply disruptions.

appears to be that the relationship between the U. S. and Saudi Arabia is a commensal one. I don’t think he succeeds but I do give him credit for articulating a different argument pretty well. The U. S. is afflicted by many parasites and the parasites have a commensal relationship with one another.

My conclusion from that is not only do we need to revisit our alliances we need to start making more demands of our presumed allies.

BTW $24 billion is on the order of .1% of GDP. Our economy grows more than that in a month.

0 comments

What to Do?

What do you do when you’re a state without income taxes but also want more revenue? You impose a carbon tax as the legislature of the State of Washington has done. The editors of the Wall Street Journal complain:

Washington’s tax might reduce global emissions by all of 0.02% in 2035, and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change recently estimated a global carbon price of between $135 and $5,500 per ton would be necessary to forestall a climate apocalypse. This level of taxation would be a political nonstarter anywhere.

But if the Washington referendum passes, liberals will be emboldened to push carbon copies in other states and Congress. Some on the right advocate a national carbon tax along with a supposed “dividend” for taxpayers, but here all revenue is for Olympia politicians. The story in Washington shows that liberals care more about increasing tax revenue to spend than they do about reducing emissions.

Washington’s carbon tax is not only regressive but ineffectual both because it is so low and because carbon emissions increase geometrically with income.

Here’s a modest proposal. Impose a $10,000 per ton carbon tax, prebated on a varying scale based on income up to $300,000. That wouldn’t be nearly as regressive, would have the potential of generating a lot more revenue, and might actually reduce carbon emissions.

12 comments

It Isn’t “Americans”, Mr. Kagan

The only question I have about Robert Kagan’s latest Washington Post column is where was this column when the WaPo was hailing Mohamed bin Salman as a reformer?

Many Americans have an odd fascination with the idea of the reforming autocrat, the strongman who can “modernize” and lead his nation out of its backward and benighted past. This was the hope for Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia, a hope now somewhat diminished by the hit he appears to have ordered against Post contributing columnist Jamal Khashoggi in Turkey.

Sympathetic Americans saw Mohammed, or MBS, as he is known, as a transformational figure seeking to reform Saudi Arabia’s one-commodity economy and to reconcile Islam and modernity. If doing so required more not less dictatorial control, if it entailed locking up not only fellow members of the royal family but also women’s rights activists, moderate religious figures and even young economists raising questions about the dubious figures contained in his “Vision 2030” program, then so be it. Only a “revolution from above” held any promise of reforming that traditionalist, hidebound society. You know — omelets, eggs.

He’s being overly kind and insufficiently specific. It wasn’t Americans broadly who exhibited an “odd fascination” with MBS. I don’t recall any dinner table conversations to the effect of “Boy, what a great reformer that MBS is!”
To the contrary tt was Mr. Kagan’s editors and those of the other major media outlets as well as his columnist peers. Why are they so attracted to dictators? I can only speculate. I can’t remember who made the observation but it’s apt. They don’t want to live under an authoritarian system but they do want to run one. The lesson here is that we are ill-served by our pundits.

Mr. Kagan, the first step on the road to recovery is acknowledging you have a problem. It’s clear that you and your peers have a problem. When does the acknowledgement come?

1 comment

Choosing

This afternoon my wife and I reviewed our sample ballot for the November elections and, frankly, that process makes our choices look even less appealing.

I still haven’t decided for whom I will vote for governor. I don’t think that Rauner can do anything to help the state and I don’t think that Pritzker will do anything to help the state. Otherwise I’m splitting my votes for statewide office between Republicans and Democrats, doing my best to choose the lesser evil.

Since the only contested countywide race if for County Assessor, I won’t vote for the other county offices and I’m still undecided about Assessor.

I’ll vote for Mike Quigley. He’s acceptable as our Congressional representative but I may feel differently in 2020, thinking he’s served long enough. I’ll probably vote against incumbents for state legislature.

5 comments

∃ A ⇏ ∀ A

The title of this post says it all. I’ve been meaning to mention this for a long time.

5 comments

Refugees

The picture on the left is of Jewish refugees from Europe in the 1930s. The picture on the right is of people in the “caravan” from Guatemala today.

14 comments

The Wonders of Modern Medicine

The key passage in the post at RealClearHealth by Marshall S. Runge, “The Wonders of Modern Medicine Come at a Cost” is this one:

Medicine is not like other aspects of our technological age, where everything from cell phones to PCs inevitably get better and cheaper. One reason is that therapies like CAR-T represent the trend in medical innovation toward targeting smaller groups of patients with relatively rare conditions. This is the exact opposite of the newest gadget aimed at a mass market. And in most cases, expensive, novel therapies are adopted earlier and to a greater extent in the United States than in many countries. In essence, we are taking the economic risk to implement medical breakthroughs when costs are highest.

That caused me to think of a couple of other articles I’d read recently, the first predicting that by 2040 life expectancies in the U. S. will have increased less than 1% from now, the other than by 2040 real health care spending in the U. S. will have doubled.

The greatest wonder of modern medicine is that we continue to be so complacent with paying so much for such meager results.

10 comments

The Limits of Control

There is a story that goes back a millennium about how King Canute commanded that his throne be brought to the seashore where the king commanded the tide to halt so as not to wet his feet and robes, knowing full well commanding the elements was beyond his power:

“Might I stay the sun above us, good sir Bishop?” Canute cried;
“Could I bid the silver moon to pause upon her heavenly ride?
If the moon obeys my orders, sure I can command the tide.

“Will the advancing waves obey me, Bishop, if I make the sign?”
Said the Bishop, bowing lowly, “Land and sea, my lord, are thine.”
Canute turned towards the ocean–“Back!” he said, “thou foaming brine.

“From the sacred shore I stand on, I command thee to retreat;
Venture not, thou stormy rebel, to approach thy master’s seat:
Ocean, be thou still! I bid thee come not nearer to my feet!”

But the sullen ocean answered with a louder, deeper roar,
And the rapid waves drew nearer, falling sounding on the shore;
Back the Keeper and the Bishop, back the king and courtiers bore.

And he sternly bade them never more to kneel to human clay,
But alone to praise and worship That which earth and seas obey:
And his golden crown of empire never wore he from that day.
King Canute is dead and gone: Parasites exist alway.

I am frequently baffled that people don’t understand how limited government is. Wouldn’t it be great if everyone earned at least $30,000 per year? Sure it would but you can’t mandate it. If you did here’s what would happen:

  • Some people would be better off
  • Some people would lose their jobs
  • Some businesses would go out of business and all of their erstwhile employees would lose their jobs
  • Other businesses would invest in equipment to make it possible for them to get rid of more of their employees

or, as Amazon has recently learned, it would not only ensure that its employees earning less than $30,000 per year got that but it would make its employees who are already earning $30,000 per year unhappy that they were being paid at the same rate as people who used to earn less.

Or it might have the results that Jim Epstein points out at Reason.com—it might produce a black market:

“We used to do the same thing with 25 people, and now I’m doing it with two,” says Belinsky.

By making cheap labor illegal, the $15 minimum wage made it possible for Belinsky to downgrade his service. “Before if I go exterior, my competition would say, ‘ah, he went exterior and I’m still full-service so I’ll take all his customers,'” Belinsky says. “That never gave me a chance to go exterior. Now everybody is forced to go exterior because of this crazy law and the minimum wage $15 per hour. It evened out the field.”

“These workers have few options and little power, RWDSU President Stuart Applebaum said in his December 2014 speech. “They live in the shadows.”

The irony is that progressives have pushed the car wash workers further into the shadows.

The $15 minimum wage amounts to government prohibition of low-wage work. And yet just making something illegal won’t stop able-bodied men with few alternatives from meeting a market demand for their services.

Since many legitimate car washes can no longer hire them, workers are going to the streets, where it’s all cash, no tax, no unions, no workers comp, no insurance, and certainly no wage floors.

“The economy has led us to this situation to have to work washing cars in the street,” says Fausto, an illegal car wash worker who asked that we only use his first name. He’s part of a three-man operation washing cars on the curb out of a van for about $15 a pop.

We don’t need a $15 per hour minimum wage. We need more jobs that pay more than minimum wage and more workers who are capable of filling jobs that pay more than minimum wage. Some of that can be accomplished with training if the workers are trained in the right skills. But some of it means that we need to control immigration.

6 comments

As You Sow

What I think Mark Penn is missing in his piece at The Hill tut-tutting over how illiberal the Democrats are becoming is the role he played in the process. He was instrumental in maintaining Bill Clinton’s popularity and ensuring that Hillary Clinton was some sort of feminist icon when the reality was that she was anything but and remained a viable presidential contender herself.

You don’t get to be cynical in your 30s and then suddenly discover the value of our institutions in your 60s. They had value 25 years ago, too, Mark. If you don’t like having a low character as president you should have thought of it then.

6 comments